BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Rail

Signals and train control

This work keeps trains apart and within safe speeds: track circuits detect where trains are, interlockings stop conflicting routes from being set, and train protection systems brake a train whose driver misses a limit.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1872 to 2020.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1872

    A circuit that fails safe

    William Robinson's US patent of 20 August 1872 covered the closed track circuit: current runs through the rails to a relay that holds a signal at clear, and a train's wheels cut the relay's power, as do a broken rail or a dead battery, so a fault shows as danger. He had built his first installation on the Philadelphia & Erie Railroad at Kinzua, Pennsylvania, in 1870.

    jonroma.net

    Credit

    William Robinson; the Philadelphia & Erie Railroad, by signaling historian Jon Roma's account

  2. 1988

    Clapham Junction: a stray wire

    On 12 December 1988 three trains collided near Clapham Junction, London, killing 35 people, after faulty wiring work done on 27 November let a signal show clear for an occupied line. Anthony Hidden's inquiry made 93 recommendations, and the transport secretary told Parliament the fault "could and should have been discovered through routine checks, but the wiring was not checked".

    LessonSignal work is only as safe as the test that follows it.

    api.parliament.uk

    Credit

    the Hidden inquiry

  3. 1998

    Proof instead of testing

    The safety software of Paris Métro Line 14, a driverless line that opened in October 1998, was written with the B method, in which a program is proved mathematically to meet its specification. Its 110,000 lines of B models became 86,000 lines of Ada code, and authors from ClearSy, a B-method firm, report that no bugs were found after the proof was complete, in testing or in service.

    arxiv.org

    Credit

    Matra Transport and the RATP, Paris's transit operator

  4. 2006

    Signals move into the cab

    Under ETCS Level 2, the European train control system, a train receives its permission to move by radio and shows it to the driver in the cab, so signals beside the track are not needed. In August 2006 Alstom said it had equipped Italy's Rome–Naples high-speed line with Level 2 first, and that Switzerland's Mattstetten–Rothrist line was the largest Level 2 line in operation.

    alstom.com

    Credit

    RFI in Italy; SBB in Switzerland; Alstom

  5. 2019

    Driverless heavy-haul trains

    Rio Tinto's AutoHaul system ran its first driverless ore train in July 2018, three locomotives carrying about 28,000 tonnes over 280 km from Tom Price to Cape Lambert in Western Australia, and was fully operational in June 2019. The company says it had run more than 33 million km by 2023, with more than 98% of trips reaching their destination.

    progressiverailroading.com

    Credit

    Rio Tinto; Hitachi Rail

  6. 2020

    Automatic braking on US lines

    Positive train control (PTC) is designed to stop a train automatically before a collision with another train, a derailment from overspeed, a move through a switch set the wrong way, or entry into a work zone. Required by the Rail Safety Improvement Act of 2008, it was running on all 57,536 required route miles by 29 December 2020, the FRA said; the AAR says the large freight railroads spent nearly $11.5 billion on it.

    ttnews.comaar.org

    Credit

    US Congress; the FRA; the railroads

Watch for

  1. Signal sighting from a desk

    Signal sighting is the check that drivers can see and read each signal in time. One Big Circle says its AIVR platform does this from forward-facing video filmed on trains in service, so engineers need not stand beside the line, and that signals across the UK have been "automatically detected, classified, and mapped".

    Achieved whenNetwork Rail or RSSB, the industry's standards body, accepts remote sighting in its standards, or an independent comparison with on-site sighting is published.

    railway-news.com

    Claimed by

    One Big Circle, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Read relay drawings by machine

    Older interlockings are built from relays, and their record is a set of circuit drawings. Build a tool that reads scanned relay circuit drawings, turns each sheet into a netlist (a list of every connection), and reports every difference between two versions of a sheet. Test it on sheets drawn for the purpose to a signaling convention, with changes seeded at known places, and on historic drawings from public archives.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Check the read-back

    On lines without signals, a dispatcher often gives a crew permission to use a stretch of track by reading out a written form, in North America a track warrant, which the crew must repeat back word for word. Build a tool that listens to such an exchange and flags any difference between what was said and what was repeated. Test it on role-played exchanges recorded on phones with volunteers, with errors seeded at known places and radio noise added afterward. No live radio is used.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Read relay drawings by machine

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Older interlockings are built from relays, and their record is a set of circuit drawings. Build a tool that reads scanned relay circuit drawings, turns each sheet into a netlist (a list of every connection), and reports every difference between two versions of a sheet. Test it on sheets drawn for the purpose to a signaling convention, with changes seeded at known places, and on historic drawings from public archives.

Why it is still open

After the 2017 collision at London Waterloo, the Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) found two versions of the maintenance drawings for the same points in the relay room, and wires missing from the interlocking drawings that testers' checks "should have identified". SINA, an open-source tool from January 2026 that turns circuit drawings into netlists and scored 96.47% on its own test, was built for electronic schematics; this research found no tool or public test set for railway relay drawings.

era.europa.euarxiv.org

Built with what exists

SINA; a vision-language model to read relay and contact labels (see the Note "Three working devices"); KiCad, an open circuit-drawing editor, to draw test sheets; scans of historic signaling drawings from public archives.

  1. First step

    Draw ten relay sheets in KiCad, seed five changes in each, print and scan them, and run SINA on the scans.

  2. Done looks like

    A public test set of at least 200 drawing pairs with at least 500 seeded differences (a wire added, removed or moved; a contact changed), and a published table of differences found and false differences reported, with 20 sheets checked by a signaling engineer.

Open 02 · the brief

Check the read-back

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

On lines without signals, a dispatcher often gives a crew permission to use a stretch of track by reading out a written form, in North America a track warrant, which the crew must repeat back word for word. Build a tool that listens to such an exchange and flags any difference between what was said and what was repeated. Test it on role-played exchanges recorded on phones with volunteers, with errors seeded at known places and radio noise added afterward. No live radio is used.

Why it is still open

An RSSB proof of concept used speech recognition and language models to check staff's adherence to safety-critical communication rules, as a monitoring tool after the fact. This research found no tool that checks read-backs and no public test set of railway radio exchanges.

rssb.co.uk

Built with what exists

A speech-to-text model such as ElevenLabs Scribe v3 (see the Note "Fewer word errors") or an open model run locally (see the Note "A first stable number for local AI"); a small language model taught to compare the two versions (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune"); a track-warrant form copied from a published operating rulebook.

  1. First step

    Write 50 track-warrant scripts with seeded errors, record them with two volunteers on phones, and transcribe them.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 recorded exchanges from at least 20 speakers, about one in five with a seeded error, under an open license, and a published table of the share of seeded errors caught and of correct read-backs wrongly flagged, at three noise levels.