Industries / Mining and materials / Chemicals and petrochemicals / Specialty chemicals / Paint and coatings
Formulation
Formulation is choosing a paint's ingredients and their amounts (binder, pigment, water or solvent, and small doses of additives such as thickeners, driers and preservatives) so that it flows, covers, dries and lasts as it should.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1937 to 2024.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1937
Zinc dust in liquid glass
Victor Nightingall, an inventor working in a shed in suburban Melbourne, made a coating of zinc powder in sodium silicate, a liquid glass, and applied for an Australian patent on 20 March 1937; the Australasian Corrosion Association (ACA) calls it the first inorganic zinc coating. It was chosen for the 360 km Morgan to Whyalla water pipeline in South Australia, planned at the outbreak of the Second World War, when most steel was protected with oil-based coatings that had to be renewed every few years; the ACA said in 2019 that the pipeline's original coating was still in very good condition 70 years after it was applied. In 1949 Charles Munger of Ameron licensed it for the United States as Dimetcote, and self-curing water-borne versions were on sale by the 1960s.
corrosion.com.aupatentimages.storage.googleapis.comcorrosion.com.au
Credit
Victor Nightingall; Charles Munger and Ameron
1949
A limit for pigment
W. K. Asbeck and Maurice Van Loo published "Critical pigment volume relationships" in Industrial & Engineering Chemistry in July 1949. The critical pigment volume concentration (CPVC) is the share of a dry film's volume taken by pigment at which there is just enough binder to fill the gaps between tightly packed pigment particles; above it, the film holds air pockets around the particles. Formulators still describe a paint by the ratio of its pigment volume concentration to its CPVC, which separates continuous films from porous ones, as a 2020 study of epoxy coatings sets out.
Credit
W. K. Asbeck and Maurice Van Loo
1980s
Thickeners that link particles
Associative thickeners are water-soluble polymers with water-repelling ends that stick to the plastic particles in latex paint and join them into a loose network. Writing for a 2001 symposium, Edward Kostansek of Rohm and Haas said that over the previous two decades they had become a very useful tool for latex paints, giving less spatter, better flow and leveling, hiding and gloss than older thickeners such as hydroxyethyl cellulose, which thicken by the sheer size of their molecules.
LessonBecause these thickeners interact with almost every other ingredient, Kostansek wrote, they forced a significant amount of reformulation: an additive that works through the other ingredients changes the whole recipe.
Credit
Rohm and Haas among other makers; the account opened is Kostansek's
1990
Mercury taken out
Until 1990 about a third of US interior latex paints were kept from spoiling in the can with mercury compounds such as phenylmercuric acetate, by the count of a 1993 CDC study. In August 1989 a 4-year-old boy in Michigan developed acrodynia, a form of mercury poisoning, after his home was painted; the paint held 930 to 955 ppm mercury, against the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) limit of 300 ppm for interior paint. A CDC study of 74 people in 19 recently painted homes found more mercury in their urine than in people from unpainted homes. Under a voluntary agreement with EPA, makers stopped adding mercury to interior latex paint after 20 August 1990, and sales of the preservative for exterior latex paint ended in September 1991.
LessonA later study found potentially hazardous exposure even in homes painted with paint holding less than 200 mg/L, below the legal limit, so a limit on what goes into the can has to be checked against what people breathe after painting.
Credit
Michigan Department of Public Health; Agocs, Etzel and colleagues at CDC; EPA, the National Paint and Coatings Association and the preservative's makers
2024
Lead paint laws spread
The World Health Organization (WHO) says that as of January 2024, 48% of countries had legally binding controls on lead paint, up from 43% at the end of 2021. WHO and the UN Environment Programme lead the Global Alliance to Eliminate Lead Paint, which urges every country to pass such a law, and WHO calls lead paint a major source of lead exposure worldwide.
Credit
WHO and UNEP, Global Alliance to Eliminate Lead Paint; the governments that passed the laws
Watch for
AI-shortened clearcoat
PPG says AI let its car-refinish chemists explore more formulation options and unconventional approaches, and that this significantly shortened development of a clearcoat for collision repair that bakes in five minutes at 140 °F (60 °C) or air-dries in under an hour. PPG says it checks the AI's suggestions in lab and real-world tests; no development times or baseline are given.
Achieved whenPPG or an outside party publishes development times for comparable products made with and without the tool.
Claimed by
Nicole Sinclair, PPG Automotive Refinish, June 2026
AI rates painters' comments
Dow chemists filmed a painter applying paints made with different rheology modifiers, the thickeners that set how paint flows, to drywall: about 160 videos of two to five minutes. A large language model rated the painter's spoken comments by category in place of researchers watching every video. Dow says one expert reviewed the result and agreed, and that the method saves time and reduces subjectivity; it gives no accuracy figures.
Achieved whenthe model's ratings are compared with those of several trained people on the same videos and the agreement is published.
Claimed by
Alicia Liew, Sunny Wang and Ericka Killian, Dow, January 2026
Open
01
Cobalt-free driers, compared
A public test, under the same conditions, of every cobalt-free drier on sale. Driers are metal compounds that speed the reaction with air that hardens alkyd paint, and cobalt has long been the standard. Run each in the same two alkyd paints, one solvent-borne and one water-borne, at three doses, with a cobalt drier as the reference, and measure the drying stages, hardness as it develops, yellowing in the dark and drying at 10 °C.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A formulation exam for AI
A public set of 300 paint formulation questions with checked answers, each tied to a published source (which thickener cuts spatter, what happens above the CPVC, why a water-based primer leaves rust spots, how to restore hiding after cutting titanium dioxide), and a scorecard for general AI models and for the formulation assistants paint makers are starting to use.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Cobalt-free driers, compared
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test, under the same conditions, of every cobalt-free drier on sale. Driers are metal compounds that speed the reaction with air that hardens alkyd paint, and cobalt has long been the standard. Run each in the same two alkyd paints, one solvent-borne and one water-borne, at three doses, with a cobalt drier as the reference, and measure the drying stages, hardness as it develops, yellowing in the dark and drying at 10 °C.
Why it is still open
DIC, a drier maker, writes that the European Chemicals Agency labels cobalt 2-ethylhexanoate, a common cobalt drier, as toxic to reproduction (category 1B) from November 2023, and that few manganese driers match cobalt; the drying times it reports for its own manganese drier are its own. Published comparisons are small. TNO tested one iron and two manganese driers in a solvent-borne alkyd in 2016, and a 2021 study by Sansonetti and colleagues in Latvia compared one cobalt, one iron and one manganese drier by infrared spectroscopy and found the cobalt film formed fastest. A 2019 review by Simpson, Maaijen, Roelofsen and Hage describes the iron and manganese catalysts developed to replace cobalt but runs no common test of them. Searches for this file found no public comparison covering the driers sold today.
Built with what exists
Drier samples, which makers supply to formulators; a commercial long-oil alkyd and an alkyd emulsion; a mechanical drying-time recorder (ASTM D5895); a König pendulum hardness tester; a spectrophotometer for the yellowness index (ASTM E313); a wine cooler or climate cabinet held at 10 °C; a fume hood for the solvent-borne paint.
First step
Ask five drier makers for samples and recommended doses, and run the cobalt reference and one alternative in the water-borne alkyd to learn to read the recorder tracks.
Done looks like
At least eight cobalt-free driers, each at three doses in both paints, three films per condition; set-to-touch, tack-free and dry-through times at 23 °C and 10 °C, König hardness at 1, 7 and 28 days, and yellowness after four weeks in the dark, published with the raw recorder images under an open license.
Open 02 · the brief
A formulation exam for AI
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public set of 300 paint formulation questions with checked answers, each tied to a published source (which thickener cuts spatter, what happens above the CPVC, why a water-based primer leaves rust spots, how to restore hiding after cutting titanium dioxide), and a scorecard for general AI models and for the formulation assistants paint makers are starting to use.
Why it is still open
PPG says AI shortened its development of a clearcoat, and Nippon Paint and the University of Tokyo are building an AI platform from Nippon Paint's research records, a project with no published results. Neither has published how often such tools are right. The nearest public benchmark found, MatFormBench (May 2026), scores formulation algorithms on synthetic samples, not on paint knowledge, and a GitHub search for coatings formulation turned up only small single-author optimizers with no test set.
Built with what exists
Open sources for the answers, such as Journal of Coatings Technology papers posted free by the American Coatings Association, open papers in PubMed Central and suppliers' technical data sheets; a strict scoring rule that counts a question as passed only when a model gets it right on every repeat (see the Note "All twenty times"); a model that scores many multiple-choice answers in one pass, such as Gemini Decision 1, to grade at scale (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").
First step
Write 30 questions from three open papers, have a second person answer them without seeing the key, and keep only those on which both agree.
Done looks like
300 questions written by at least two people with formulation experience, each linked to its source; every model asked each question five times; a published share of questions answered correctly on all five tries, with 50 answers checked by hand to confirm the automatic grading.