BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Warehousing and distribution / Cold-chain logistics

Energy and refrigerants

This is the work of choosing the working fluid inside cold-chain machines, called the refrigerant, and of cutting the electricity and fuel those machines use.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1870s to 2021.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1870s

    Ammonia and carbon dioxide arrive

    The first frozen-meat ships and stores used "cold air" machines, which cool by compressing air and letting it expand. Carl von Linde took out patents for ammonia compression machines from 1870 and patented one for freezing meat in 1874, and in 1888 J. & E. Hall brought out a machine using carbon dioxide (then called carbonic acid) that a 1912 history says had "very extensive use on board ship". Ammonia has stayed: the 2022 report of the Montreal Protocol's refrigeration committee says it still holds a large share of warehouse plants in warm climates.

    archive.orgozone.unep.org

    Credit

    Carl von Linde; J. & E. Hall

  2. 1988

    Minus 18 becomes law

    Council Directive 89/108/EEC of 21 December 1988 required quick-frozen food sold in the European Community to be held at −18 °C (0 °F) or colder at all points in the product, with brief rises of no more than 3 °C allowed during transport. Its preamble says that at −18 °C "all microbiological activity likely to impair the quality of a foodstuff is suspended".

    eur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    Council of the European Communities

  3. 2011

    Fake refrigerant kills three

    Over about eight months in 2011, five compressors on refrigerated shipping containers exploded and three people were killed, by the count of the TT Club, a transport insurer. The cause was counterfeit gas sold as the refrigerant R-134a that contained methyl chloride, which reacts with aluminum parts in the compressor to form compounds that burn on contact with air. The first cases were linked to refilling done in Vietnam; US West Coast dockworkers quarantined more than 1,000 units, and by 2013 counterfeit gas had been reported in about 5% of units tested.

    LessonShipping lines, container lessors and depots began testing the gas in machines and in supply bottles before use.

    ttclub.comiifiir.org

    Credit

    TT Club (the account); International Institute of Refrigeration (its 23rd Informatory Note, by G. Cavalier and R. Lawton)

  4. 2013

    Cold-store energy measured

    The ICE-E project gathered 295 sets of energy data from cold stores in 21 countries, most of them in the European Union. Energy use per cubic meter of store per year ran from 4 to 250 kWh in chilled stores (average 55.8) and from 6 to 240 kWh in frozen stores (average 69.4), as reported by the International Institute of Refrigeration. Audits of 28 stores found possible savings of 8% to 72%, and 54% of the measures would pay for themselves in under a year.

    LessonStores doing the same job used very different amounts of energy, so each one has to be assessed on its own.

    iifiir.orgdoi.org

    Credit

    J. A. Evans and colleagues, ICE-E project

  5. 2016

    Truck units change refrigerant

    Global warming potential (GWP) is how much heat a gas traps compared with the same mass of carbon dioxide. Truck and trailer cooling units long ran on R-404A, with a GWP of 3,922. Thermo King made R-452A, with a GWP of about 2,141, its standard in Europe in 2016 and on North American trailers in January 2022, and Carrier Transicold followed in North America in October 2022, the trade site Cooling Post reported. The 2022 report of the Montreal Protocol's refrigeration committee says most new trucks and trailers in Europe and North America have moved to R-452A. It also says most shipping-container units still run on R-134a, and that a container unit using carbon dioxide is on sale but has "only a few thousand units in service".

    LessonA gas that drops into existing designs spread in a few years, while a unit that needs new parts and trained mechanics in every port did not.

    ozone.unep.orgcoolingpost.comcoolingpost.com

    Credit

    Thermo King; Carrier Transicold; Chemours (which sells R-452A as Opteon XP44)

  6. 2021

    The cold chain's footprint counted

    The International Institute of Refrigeration (IIR) estimated that 12% of the food produced worldwide in 2017 was lost for want of an adequate cold chain. It estimated that a better cold chain would avoid 55% of those losses and emit almost 50% less carbon dioxide than the present one. A 2022 report by the UN Environment Programme and the Food and Agriculture Organization put the loss at 526 million tons, enough to feed about 1 billion people, and said the food cold chain accounts for about 4% of global greenhouse gas emissions once the lost food is counted.

    LessonBy these estimates, more refrigeration done well lowers total emissions, because less food is grown only to be lost.

    iifiir.orgunep.org

    Credit

    IIR (J. Sarr, J. L. Dupont and J. Guilpart); UN Environment Programme; Food and Agriculture Organization

Watch for

  1. Minus 15 in the lab

    A preprint, a paper posted before peer review, reports nine savory frozen products stored at −18, −15, −12 and −9 °C for 18 months, from November 2022 to April 2024, with more than 20,000 quality measurements. Its authors say storing 3 °C warmer saved about 7% of freezer energy, against a theoretical 10%, and that most quality measures stayed within limits at −15 °C until the best-before date.

    Achieved whenThe paper passes peer review and a group with no frozen-food maker among its authors repeats the result on other foods.

    doi.orga.storyblok.com

    Claimed by

    Nomad Foods, Wageningen Food and Biobased Research and Campden BRI, August 2025

  2. Minus 15 in real operations

    The Move to −15 °C Coalition, set up at the COP28 climate meeting in 2023 with members that include Maersk, Lineage, DP World and IKEA, says its first real-world trials of warmer frozen storage and transport are under way. It cites earlier research suggesting 5% to 7% less energy and up to 17.7 million tonnes less carbon dioxide a year. In July 2025 the American Frozen Food Institute and the Global Cold Chain Alliance published a protocol for recording time and temperature along frozen supply chains, which they say will be assessed in trials.

    Achieved whenA trial publishes its measured energy use and product temperatures, and a food regulator accepts a set point warmer than −18 °C.

    frozenfoodeurope.comgcca.org

    Claimed by

    Move to −15 °C Coalition, July 2026

  3. A propane reefer prototype

    GIZ Proklima, a German development program, and Thermo King showed in Hamburg a prototype refrigerated shipping container, called a reefer in the trade, that runs on propane (R-290). They say first tests point to energy savings of about 15% against conventional units. The Montreal Protocol's refrigeration committee wrote in its 2022 report that no maker had a propane container unit on sale.

    Achieved whenA certified propane unit carries cargo at sea and an outside party publishes its measured energy use.

    green-cooling-initiative.orgiifiir.org

    Claimed by

    GIZ Proklima and Thermo King, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Frozen shelf life, one table

    An open table, readable by software, of published results on how long frozen foods keep at each storage temperature. Each row gives the food, its packaging, the temperature, the months until the quality limit was reached, the test used, and the source page. Anyone could then look up what a store 3 °C warmer costs a given food.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Cold-store energy from public files

    An open table of the yearly energy use of refrigerated warehouses, taken from the building-energy files that some cities publish by law. Each row gives the site, its floor area and its energy use, plus an estimate of its volume from public building-height data where a city publishes it, so that energy can be stated per cubic meter and set beside the European survey's range of 4 to 250 kWh.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Frozen shelf life, one table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table, readable by software, of published results on how long frozen foods keep at each storage temperature. Each row gives the food, its packaging, the temperature, the months until the quality limit was reached, the test used, and the source page. Anyone could then look up what a store 3 °C warmer costs a given food.

Why it is still open

The 2025 preprint by Nomad Foods, Wageningen and Campden BRI says that, despite many published studies, "quantitative knowledge is lacking" on how storage temperature and time relate to food quality, and its own data cover nine products. Older results sit in printed tables, such as the storage-life ranges in an industry storage manual, and in papers from the 1950s onward. Europe's FRISBEE project released software in 2015 that works out a food's remaining shelf life from its temperature record "based on existing or user defined kinetic data"; the paper's abstract describes a tool, not a table to download. Searches of GitHub and Hugging Face found no open dataset.

doi.orgiifiir.orggcca.org

Built with what exists

Scanned papers and reports; an AI model such as Claude Fable 5.2 to read tables and charts into rows (see the Note "Three working devices"); a second reviewer model to flag doubtful readings for a person (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a spreadsheet published on GitHub or Zenodo.

  1. First step

    Put the storage-life table from the industry manual and the supplementary data file of the 2025 preprint into one sheet with one row per food and temperature.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 rows from at least 40 sources, each with a page reference. A second person checks 100 rows at random and agrees with at least 95. A published chart compares storage life at −18 °C and −15 °C for 30 foods, with the preprint's nine products shown beside the older results.

Open 02 · the brief

Cold-store energy from public files

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table of the yearly energy use of refrigerated warehouses, taken from the building-energy files that some cities publish by law. Each row gives the site, its floor area and its energy use, plus an estimate of its volume from public building-height data where a city publishes it, so that energy can be stated per cubic meter and set beside the European survey's range of 4 to 250 kWh.

Why it is still open

The European ICE-E figures in circulation are averages and ranges from 295 data sets gathered by 2013. The US ENERGY STAR score for warehouses compares buildings by floor area and rests on 472 warehouses of all kinds from a national survey of 2012. New York City's public file for 2021 alone lists 30 properties as refrigerated warehouses, with site energy from 1.1 to 264.8 thousand British thermal units per square foot, and one of the 30 is named as a university business school, so the labels need checking. A search found no study that pools such files for cold stores.

energystar.govdata.cityofnewyork.us

Built with what exists

The open-data service behind New York City's file, and the same from other cities with disclosure laws; New York City's public building footprints, which carry roof heights; Python with the pandas library; an AI model such as Claude Fable 5.2 to check each listed site against public descriptions and flag those that are not cold stores (see the Note "Three working devices").

data.cityofnewyork.us

  1. First step

    Download New York City's file, keep the 30 rows marked refrigerated warehouse, and check each address by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 200 sites from at least six cities, each confirmed by a person as a working cold store. Published: energy per square meter and per cubic meter per year for each site, the spread, and a chart against the ICE-E range. A second person rechecks 50 sites and agrees on at least 47.