Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Auto dealerships
Finance and insurance
Finance and insurance, called F&I in the trade, is the dealer's office that arranges the buyer's loan or lease, usually with an outside lender that pays the dealer for the business, and sells add-ons such as service contracts and cover for the gap between a written-off car's value and the loan.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1919 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1919
Credit at the dealership
A carmaker needs dealers to take cars in large numbers as they come off the line, and in the early 1920s a buyer had to pay cash or find a loan from a bank that did not usually lend on cars, by its successor's account. General Motors opened the General Motors Acceptance Corporation (GMAC) in New York City in 1919 "to help dealers finance and maintain their inventory and keep up with consumer demand," and it let buyers finance a car at the dealership. Lending a dealer the money for its stock until each car sells is called floor-plan financing. By 2001 GMAC had financed $1 trillion for 150 million vehicles. GMAC is now Ally Financial.
Credit
General Motors (GMAC)
1975
Lenders answer for the dealer
A dealer that sells a car on credit usually sells the loan contract on to a finance company. Under the old rule of the "holder in due course," the company that held the contract could collect in full even if the buyer had a claim against the dealer. A Federal Trade Commission rule issued in November 1975 makes it unfair for a seller to take a consumer credit contract that lacks a notice, in at least ten-point bold type, saying that "any holder of this consumer credit contract is subject to all claims and defenses which the debtor could assert against the seller," up to the amount the buyer has paid.
Credit
US Federal Trade Commission, 16 CFR 433.2
2018
Markup guidance voided
In indirect lending the dealer sends the buyer's application to several lenders. A lender quotes a "buy rate," lets the dealer charge more, and pays the dealer part of the extra interest, called dealer reserve. A March 2013 bulletin from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) warned lenders that this markup discretion could breach the Equal Credit Opportunity Act. In December 2013 the CFPB and the Justice Department ordered Ally to pay $80 million in damages and $18 million in penalties, finding that more than 235,000 Black, Hispanic, and Asian and Pacific Islander borrowers paid higher markups than similar white borrowers from April 2011 to December 2013. On 21 May 2018 Congress disapproved the bulletin under the Congressional Review Act, so that it "shall have no force or effect."
LessonGuidance can be struck down as a rule; here a December 2017 opinion from the Government Accountability Office that the bulletin counted as one opened the way.
Credit
CFPB; US Department of Justice; US Congress (Public Law 115-172)
2024
China drops the down payment
In an announcement dated 28 March 2024, the People's Bank of China and the National Financial Regulatory Administration let lenders set the maximum loan share for personal cars themselves, ending the 2017 caps of 80% of the price for conventional cars and 85% for new energy vehicles, so a buyer can now put nothing down; used cars stayed at 70%, CnEVPost reported. Banks pay dealers to promote their car loans, which lets dealers offer below-market prices to buyers who take the bank's loan, Yicai reported in April 2025. When buyers took the loan and then paid it off early, branches of ICBC and Agricultural Bank of China in Hangzhou pushed the first penalty-free payoff from two years to three and charged 8%, 5% and 3% of the loan for payoff in years one, two and three.
LessonWhere lenders pay dealers to place loans, buyers can take a loan for the discount and repay it at once, and lenders answer with penalties.
Credit
People's Bank of China; National Financial Regulatory Administration; reported by CnEVPost and Yicai
2025
Hidden commission ruled unfair
In the UK the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) banned discretionary commission, under which a dealer acting as credit broker could raise the customer's interest rate to earn more, from 28 January 2021, after its review found such models led to higher finance costs. On 1 August 2025 the Supreme Court ruled in three linked cases that car dealers arranging finance are not fiduciaries, people bound to act with single-minded loyalty to the buyer, so the buyers' claims for bribery failed. In one case, Johnson v FirstRand, it found the relationship unfair under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974: the undisclosed commission was 25% of the loan and 55% of the total charge for credit, and the papers hid a tie that gave the lender first refusal while suggesting the dealer chose from "a select panel of lenders." The commission was to be repaid with interest.
LessonThe court weighed how large the commission was and what the papers concealed, not only whether a commission was mentioned.
Credit
UK Supreme Court, [2025] UKSC 33 (Lord Reed, Lord Hodge, Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Briggs, Lord Hamblen); FCA
2025
The same loans pledged twice
Tricolor Holdings was a subprime auto retailer and finance company: it sold cars and lent to the buyers, then borrowed against those loans. According to an indictment unsealed on 17 December 2025, its executives from about 2018 to 2025 "double-pledged" loans to more than one lender and altered loan data so that near-worthless loans looked eligible. By August 2025 it had pledged about $2.2 billion of collateral against about $1.4 billion of real collateral. It filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy on 10 September 2025, owing its largest lenders more than $900 million. The former finance chief and a finance executive pleaded guilty; the founder's charges are allegations.
LessonLenders relied on loan data the borrower supplied; by the indictment's account the scheme ran for about seven years before lenders confronted the company in the summer of 2025.
Credit
US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York; FBI; FDIC Office of Inspector General
Watch for
UK motor finance compensation
The FCA's final scheme, published on 30 March 2026, covers motor finance agreements from 6 April 2007 to 1 November 2024 where the lender paid the broker, usually the dealer, a commission and the customer was not told of a discretionary commission, a high commission or an exclusive tie between lender and broker. It counts 12.1 million eligible agreements and expects lenders to pay about £7.5 billion in compensation, £9.1 billion including the cost of running it. About 90,000 cases close to Johnson's would get all the commission back with interest; the rest get the average of an estimated loss and the commission. Four parties challenged it: Consumer Voice, represented by Courmacs Legal, and the finance arms of Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz and Crédit Agricole. On 2 July 2026 the Upper Tribunal suspended parts of it, so lenders need not calculate or pay compensation until the case ends; the hearing is set for 14 to 18 December 2026 or 16 to 26 February 2027.
Achieved whenthe Tribunal rules and the FCA or the lenders publish how many agreements have been paid and how much.
Claimed by
FCA, March 2026
Open
01
Score the deal readers
A public test set of about 200 car purchase and finance documents given by people who bought cars: US buyer's orders and retail installment sale contracts, and UK hire purchase and PCP agreements, with names, addresses and account numbers blacked out. For each, a person records the ground truth: cash price, amount financed, APR, term, every add-on and its price (service contract, GAP, paint protection) and any commission or markup the papers disclose. Then score consumer "deal checker" tools and general AI models on how many fields they read correctly and how many add-ons they miss.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A public markup gauge
A quarterly table, built from the loan-level data that issuers of US auto-loan bonds file with the Securities and Exchange Commission, showing how widely interest rates vary among borrowers with the same credit score band, loan term and lender. That spread is the part of the rate that credit score and term do not explain, which is where a dealer's markup sits.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Score the deal readers
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test set of about 200 car purchase and finance documents given by people who bought cars: US buyer's orders and retail installment sale contracts, and UK hire purchase and PCP agreements, with names, addresses and account numbers blacked out. For each, a person records the ground truth: cash price, amount financed, APR, term, every add-on and its price (service contract, GAP, paint protection) and any commission or markup the papers disclose. Then score consumer "deal checker" tools and general AI models on how many fields they read correctly and how many add-ons they miss.
Why it is still open
Tools that promise this are reaching buyers. In December 2025 CarEdge's chief executive described a coming tool, its AI Car Deal Reviewer, that "analyzes purchase agreements in seconds, highlighting hidden markups, fees and financing terms," but this research found no independent test of how accurate any such tool is. The UK Supreme Court's Johnson ruling shows the need: the buyer had not read any of the documents, and the key statements were given no prominence.
Built with what exists
A phone scanner app and open text-recognition (OCR) software; an AI model that reads documents, run on the tester's own machine so the contracts never leave it, such as Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters"); an agent that fills one spreadsheet row per document (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python for scoring.
First step
Collect 20 documents from friends and relatives who agree in writing, black out the personal details, fill in the ground-truth sheet and run one model.
Done looks like
200 redacted documents from at least 30 dealers in two countries, published with their ground truth under an open license; at least three tools scored; for each, the share of fields read correctly and the share of add-ons missed.
Open 02 · the brief
A public markup gauge
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A quarterly table, built from the loan-level data that issuers of US auto-loan bonds file with the Securities and Exchange Commission, showing how widely interest rates vary among borrowers with the same credit score band, loan term and lender. That spread is the part of the rate that credit score and term do not explain, which is where a dealer's markup sits.
Why it is still open
Since the SEC's Regulation AB II took effect, each publicly registered auto-loan bond files a Form ABS-EE giving every loan's borrower credit score, original interest rate, original term and whether the loan carried a subsidy such as a cut-price rate. The CFPB's 2013 markup guidance was voided in 2018. The analyses of these filings found in this research were commercial: MSCI described its own loan-level models for investors in 2021, and sec-api.io sells the parsed archive. No free, published series of rate spreads among like borrowers turned up.
Built with what exists
The free EX-102 asset data files on SEC EDGAR; Python with lxml, pandas and DuckDB; an AI coding assistant to write the parser against the Schedule AL field list.
First step
Download one prime and one subprime trust's ABS-EE files for one month and compute the spread for a single credit band.
Done looks like
Every auto-loan trust filed since November 2016 parsed, each trust's weighted average APR reproduced within 0.05 percentage points of the figure its prospectus states, and a quarterly table of the gap between the 25th and 75th percentile APR for each lender, credit band, term and new or used car, with code and data public.