BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Auto dealerships

Trade-ins and valuation

Trade-ins and valuation is the work of putting a price on a used car: what a dealer offers for the car a buyer hands in, what it will pay for stock, and the records that show whether a car's mileage and history are true.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1926 to 2022.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1926

    A used-car price book

    Kelley Blue Book was founded in 1926 and is marking 100 years in 2026. It now publishes, by its own account, "millions of market-reflective values weekly" on KBB.com, from its Blue Book trade-in values to its Price Advisor tool, and it says both consumers and the car trade rely on them. It is part of Cox Automotive.

    mediaroom.kbb.com

    Credit

    Kelley Blue Book Co

  2. 1966

    Japan certifies car appraisers

    Japan's automobile appraisal institute (Nihon Jidōsha Satei Kyōkai) was set up on 1 June 1966, under the guidance of the economy and transport ministries, as a neutral third party. On 1 April 1979 it started a national used-car appraisal system, with shared appraisal standards and a skills test: to appraise trade-ins under the system a person must pass the institute's test and register, and about 130,000 appraisers are registered today. Its stated aims are to protect consumers and keep the used-car trade orderly.

    jaai.or.jpjaai.or.jpjaai.or.jp

    Credit

    Japan Automobile Appraisal Institute

  3. 1972

    Sellers must state the mileage

    Title IV of a US law signed on 20 October 1972 found that buyers "rely heavily on the odometer reading as an index of the condition and value of a vehicle." It banned resetting or altering odometers and required every seller to give the buyer a written statement of the mileage, or a statement that the true mileage is unknown. A 2019 rule from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) let states accept the statement electronically with electronic titles, and for model year 2010 and later cars kept the requirement for 20 years instead of 10.

    govinfo.govgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Congress, Public Law 92-513; NHTSA

  4. 2006

    Belgium logs every reading

    Before Car-Pass, an estimated 60,000 to 100,000 cars a year in Belgium had their odometers rolled back before sale. A law of 11 June 2004 led to Car-Pass, a non-profit whose board represents the car trade, motoring clubs and inspection firms. Garages, body shops, tire fitters and inspection stations send it the odometer reading after every job, and a seller of a used car must give the buyer a Car-Pass showing the car's mileage history; the first was issued on 1 December 2006. A few years later, by Car-Pass's count, fewer than 2,000 fraud cases a year were found. Imports stayed a gap, so from 1 January 2020 makers and importers must send their readings for imported cars, and four times a year for connected cars. In 2023 Car-Pass counted 1,640 highly probable fraud cases, with an average of 69,118 km taken off.

    LessonA shared record of every reading made rollbacks easy to spot at home, but cars bought abroad arrived without one.

    car-pass.becar-pass.be

    Credit

    Car-Pass; the Belgian government; FEBIAC; TRAXIO

  5. 2021

    Offers made online

    Online buyers now give a car's owner a price from the plate or VIN, the mileage and the owner's answers about condition, an offer typically good for seven days. In April 2021 CarMax agreed to buy the rest of Edmunds, saying the instant offer the two had built had put it "in the position to become the largest online buyer of used autos from consumers." In its fiscal year to February 2026 CarMax bought about 1.1 million vehicles from consumers and dealers, and its annual report says its online instant offer and MaxOffer, a seven-day offer for dealers, have "significantly driven the increase."

    sec.govsec.govmwg.aaa.com

    Credit

    CarMax; Edmunds

  6. 2022

    Used prices peak, then fall

    The Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index tracks US wholesale used-car prices, adjusted for mix, mileage and season. In January 2022 it stood at 236.3, up 45.0% from a year earlier. By December 2022 it was at 219.3, down 14.9% from a year earlier, which Cox Automotive called "the largest annualized decline in the series' history."

    LessonA trade-in priced at the peak could lose value faster within a year than in any earlier year of the index.

    coxautoinc.comcoxautoinc.com

    Credit

    Cox Automotive (Manheim)

Watch for

  1. Drive-through scans set the offer

    UVeye, which makes camera tunnels that scan a car's body, underside and tires as it drives through, and Cox Automotive's vAuto, appraisal and pricing software used by dealers, launched a joint product on 29 January 2026. They say UVeye is installed at hundreds of US dealerships, captures the car's condition "in seconds," and in early tests with vAuto dealers was used by 125 people to acquire more than 850 vehicles, so that a dealer can scan a car and "give an on-the-spot offer before the customer leaves the service lane."

    Achieved whenan outside party compares scan-based appraisals with the same cars' later inspections and repair bills and publishes the result.

    coxautoinc.com

    Claimed by

    UVeye and Cox Automotive, January 2026

  2. EU-wide odometer records

    On 24 April 2025 the European Commission proposed requiring member states to record odometer readings in national databases and exchange them across borders, so that a car's mileage history follows it from one country to another. A Parliament committee voted on it on 5 May 2026; the file was still awaiting Parliament's first-reading position in November 2026.

    Achieved whenthe directive is adopted and member states' databases are exchanging readings. ).

    transport.ec.europa.euoeil.europarl.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission, April 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Same car, many offers

    A public study of 200 cars whose owners are selling anyway. On one day, each owner asks four or five buyers for an offer (CarMax, Carvana, Kelley Blue Book Instant Cash Offer and a local dealer's appraisal), giving each the same answers about condition from a written script. Owners then report what they were actually paid after the buyer's inspection. Publish the spread of offers on the same car and how often an offer was cut at inspection.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Grading the same car twice

    A blind test of condition grades, the score from 0 to 5 that an inspector gives a used car and that online buyers bid on without seeing the car. At a volunteer dealer or auction, have 100 parked cars graded on the NAAA-recommended scale by three trained inspectors who do not see each other's work, and by at least two photo-based AI tools working from the same phone photos, then publish how often the graders agree.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Same car, many offers

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public study of 200 cars whose owners are selling anyway. On one day, each owner asks four or five buyers for an offer (CarMax, Carvana, Kelley Blue Book Instant Cash Offer and a local dealer's appraisal), giving each the same answers about condition from a written script. Owners then report what they were actually paid after the buyer's inspection. Publish the spread of offers on the same car and how often an offer was cut at inspection.

Why it is still open

Published comparisons use one car or one buyer. AAA's Via magazine recounted Car and Driver's 2021 test of a single 2019 Subaru Impreza. KeySavvy, a company that handles private sales, got Carvana offers for 100 cars and compared them with Kelley Blue Book private-party values, finding private sales paid 46% more on average; it tested one buyer against a guide price, and it has a stake in the answer. No study found here compared several buyers on the same cars and then followed the final price paid.

mwg.aaa.comkeysavvy.com

Built with what exists

The buyers' public offer forms, filled in by the owners for their own cars; a shared online form for owners to report offers and the final amount; Python with pandas for the analysis.

  1. First step

    Recruit 20 owners who plan to sell this month and write the standard condition script.

  2. Done looks like

    200 cars from at least ten US states, at least four offers each within 24 hours, the final paid price for at least 100 of them, and a published table giving each buyer's median gap from the best offer and the share of offers lowered at inspection.

Open 02 · the brief

Grading the same car twice

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A blind test of condition grades, the score from 0 to 5 that an inspector gives a used car and that online buyers bid on without seeing the car. At a volunteer dealer or auction, have 100 parked cars graded on the NAAA-recommended scale by three trained inspectors who do not see each other's work, and by at least two photo-based AI tools working from the same phone photos, then publish how often the graders agree.

Why it is still open

In 2014 a co-chair of the standards committee of the International Automotive Remarketers Alliance told Auto Remarketing that "the exact same vehicle could have different condition report scores depending on location or the auction where it was being sold," and that the score affects what a dealer will pay. The trade answered with a shared scale and Manheim's AutoGrade, an algorithm that turns an inspector's findings into a grade. This research found no published figure for how often two graders give the same car the same grade.

autoremarketing.comhelp.adesa.com

Built with what exists

The NAAA grading scale, as set out in ADESA's grading guide; a fixed walk-around photo plan on ordinary phones; a vision-language model and at least one commercial AI inspection tool run on the same photos; Python with scikit-learn for Cohen's kappa, a measure of agreement beyond chance.

  1. First step

    Ask one auction or used-car manager for a morning with 20 cars waiting for inspection and two inspectors willing to grade them separately.

  2. Done looks like

    100 cars, each with three human grades and at least two AI grades, and a published table giving, for every pair of graders, the share of cars graded within half a point of each other and the kappa, with the photos published and plates blurred.