BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Auto dealerships

Sales

Sales is the work of selling cars to the public, under the contracts and laws that govern how carmakers deal with their dealers and how dealers deal with buyers.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1956 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1956

    Dealers can sue their maker

    A franchise is the contract that lets a dealer sell a carmaker's brand. The US Automobile Dealers' Day in Court Act, signed on 8 August 1956, lets a dealer sue a carmaker in federal court for damages if the maker fails "to act in good faith" in carrying out the franchise, or in ending or not renewing it. The maker may answer that the dealer did not act in good faith either.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US Congress

  2. 1958

    A price on the window

    The Automobile Information Disclosure Act of 7 July 1958 requires every maker to fix a label to the window of each new car before it reaches the dealer. The label gives the make, model and identification number, where the car was assembled, the dealer it goes to, the maker's suggested retail price, the price of each fitted option and the delivery charge, with their total. A 2005 amendment added the government's crash-test star ratings.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US Congress

  3. 1990

    One price, no haggling

    General Motors' Saturn brand put its first cars on sale in 1990 with a fixed price and no bargaining. Its retailers each held a large territory with several stores in the same market, so no Saturn store was undercutting another on the same car. After a planned sale of the brand to Penske Automotive Group collapsed in September 2009, GM stopped making Saturns and gave its dealers until the end of 2010 to wind down.

    LessonA fixed price holds when the stores in a market do not compete with each other on the same car.

    cbsnews.comnpr.org

    Credit

    General Motors (Saturn); reported by CBS MoneyWatch and NPR

  4. 2002

    Europe opens dealer contracts

    In the European Union, carmakers' dealer contracts have run under special competition rules since 1985. The European Commission's 2000 review found those rules had left dealers "too dependent on car manufacturers" and buyers finding it hard to buy a car in whichever member state sold it cheapest. Its Regulation 1400/2002, in force from 1 October 2002, let dealers sell more than one brand in the same showroom, with makers allowed only to ask for brand-specific display areas, let them sell to buyers anywhere in the EU, and banned clauses tying a dealer to one location from October 2005.

    ec.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission; Competition Commissioner Mario Monti

  5. 2020

    A ban with a workaround

    Michigan law bars a carmaker from selling or servicing cars directly. Tesla applied for Michigan dealer licenses in November 2015, was refused, and sued in September 2016. In a settlement filed on 22 January 2020 the state agreed that a Tesla-owned subsidiary may run service centers there, and that Tesla may run galleries that give test drives, discuss prices and take orders, as long as legal title to each car passes outside Michigan. The ban stayed on the books.

    LessonA franchise law can stand while the state agrees how a maker may work around it.

    michigan.gov

    Credit

    Tesla; Michigan's Secretary of State and Attorney General

  6. 2025

    China's dealer network shrinks

    China's franchised dealers mostly run 4S stores, named for the four jobs they do under one roof: sales, spare parts, service and survey. On 23 September 2024 the China Automobile Dealers Association (CADA) sent the government an emergency report: in the first eight months of 2024 dealers had lost CNY 138 billion (US$19.7 billion), and in August retail prices were nearly 23% below what dealers paid the makers. CADA counted 4,961 stores leaving makers' networks in 2025 and 1,800 more in the first half of 2026, and only 23.5% of dealers made a profit in 2025, down from 39.3% in 2024.

    LessonA store that sells new cars below cost lives on the maker's rebates and on service work, and closes when rebates come late or are cut.

    yicaiglobal.comeu.36kr.com

    Credit

    CADA; reported by Yicai and 36Kr

  7. 2026

    California revives the CARS Rule

    The US Federal Trade Commission's Combating Auto Retail Scams (CARS) Rule, published on 4 January 2024, banned sixteen kinds of misrepresentation by dealers, required them to give the full "offering price" in their first reply to a shopper, banned add-ons that give the buyer no benefit and required express consent before any charge. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals vacated it on 27 January 2025, two judges to one, because the FTC had skipped an advance notice of proposed rulemaking that its own rules require, and declined to address the challenges to the rule's substance. California's SB 766, signed in October 2025, wrote the rule's main provisions into state law, added a three-day right to cancel the purchase of a used car priced at $50,000 or less, and took effect on 1 October 2026.

    LessonA federal rule struck down over procedure can come back as state law.

    ca5.uscourts.govsd24.senate.ca.govdmv.ca.gov

    Credit

    FTC; California Senator Ben Allen

Watch for

  1. Selling around the dealers

    Volkswagen plans to sell its new Scout brand directly to buyers through Scout Motors, an affiliate, rather than through its franchised dealers. The California New Car Dealers Association sued, arguing a 2023 state law bars makers from competing with their own dealers "indirectly through an affiliate"; on 22 October 2026 a federal judge refused for a second time to end the case, and 14 California Volkswagen dealers have filed protests with the state's New Motor Vehicle Board.

    Achieved whenScout delivers cars bought directly from it to buyers in a state with a franchise law, under a final court ruling or settlement that allows it.

    cbtnews.com

    Claimed by

    Volkswagen Group of America and Scout Motors, in court filings through 2026

  2. AI agents shop for prices

    CarEdge, which sells a car-buying service, says its AI agents asked 100 dealers by email and text for an out-the-door price (the full price with all fees and add-ons) in May 2026: 92 replied within 24 hours, 62 gave some price, and 33 gave the full breakdown asked for, and many quotes did not match the dealer's online price. It says it has scored nearly 12,000 dealers in its own Dealer Transparency Index.

    Achieved whenCarEdge publishes its method and raw replies, or a party with no stake in car buying repeats the test and gets similar results.

    digitaldealer.com

    Claimed by

    CarEdge (Zach Shefska, its chief executive), May 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Price on request, measured

    An open, repeatable test of whether dealers give the full price of a car they advertise when asked in writing, which California's CARS Act now requires. Ask 200 California dealers and 200 dealers in Arizona and Nevada, matched by brand, for the out-the-door price of one car each lists on its own website, and score every reply against the advertised price.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Direct-sales law, state by state

    An open table, for all 50 US states and the District of Columbia, of whether and how a carmaker may sell and service cars without a franchised dealer: the statute, any exception, and every court ruling, settlement or agency decision that changes how it is applied, each with its citation and the date it was last checked.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Price on request, measured

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, repeatable test of whether dealers give the full price of a car they advertise when asked in writing, which California's CARS Act now requires. Ask 200 California dealers and 200 dealers in Arizona and Nevada, matched by brand, for the out-the-door price of one car each lists on its own website, and score every reply against the advertised price.

Why it is still open

The only large test found, CarEdge's 100-dealer run, comes from a company that sells a car-buying service, and its method and replies are not public. California's law took effect on 1 October 2026, and no public comparison of dealers under it with dealers outside it turned up in this research.

digitaldealer.comsd24.senate.ca.gov

Built with what exists

A browser agent to read each listing, such as Browser Use 1.0 (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); an email account; Python; a fixed scoring sheet; review by a university ethics board before any dealer is contacted.

  1. First step

    Write the scoring sheet and try it on 20 dealers' listings without sending any messages.

  2. Done looks like

    Replies from at least 300 of the 400 dealers, each scored on six fixed points (full price given, fees listed, add-ons marked optional, price matches the listing, time to answer, person or autoresponder), with the transcripts (dealer names removed) and code published, and the California results set against the other two states'.

Open 02 · the brief

Direct-sales law, state by state

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table, for all 50 US states and the District of Columbia, of whether and how a carmaker may sell and service cars without a franchised dealer: the statute, any exception, and every court ruling, settlement or agency decision that changes how it is applied, each with its citation and the date it was last checked.

Why it is still open

Counts of the states that ban direct sales disagree, because each source sorts the states its own way. Bloomberg Law counted twelve states that ban the sale of new electric cars by anyone but a franchised dealer and 16 more that restrict it (25 March 2025); a 2020–2021 report of the National Conference of State Legislatures, as cited by PBS Wisconsin, counted 17 states that bar direct sales and 18 that allow them; Wikipedia's map sorts the states into four groups. None of them gives, for each state, the statute, its exceptions and the rulings and settlements that change how it applies. Michigan's ban stayed on the books after its 2020 settlement with Tesla, and Scout Motors' plan in California turns on how a court reads the words "indirectly through an affiliate."

news.bloomberglaw.compbswisconsin.orgen.wikipedia.orgmichigan.govcbtnews.com

Built with what exists

State codes from the legislatures' own sites; court dockets from CourtListener; an AI model that answers fixed yes-or-no questions about each statute, such as Google's Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"), with every answer checked by a person.

  1. First step

    Fill in the rows for Michigan and California from the two sources above to fix the table's layout.

  2. Done looks like

    51 rows, each with statute citations and any ruling or settlement, and a random 10 rows checked by two law students or lawyers with no disagreement left unresolved, updated at least every three months.