BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Oil and gas extraction / Oilfield services / Well plugging and abandonment

Plugging

Plugging is setting cement or another lasting seal inside a well, and where needed behind its steel casing, so that oil, gas and salt water can never travel up it again.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1950s to 2021.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1950s

    Cement plugs become usual

    For about the first century of US drilling, wells were rarely sealed with care. Crews that obeyed the early plugging laws might shove a tree trunk or a bowling ball down the hole, and cement plugs became common only in the 1950s, National Geographic reported in 2022, drawing on Ron Bishop of SUNY Oneonta.

    Lessona law that asks for a plug without saying what it must be made of gets whatever is to hand.

    nationalgeographic.com

    Credit

    no single inventor; account by Ron Bishop, SUNY Oneonta

  2. 2006

    Shale used as a seal

    Some clay-rich shales slowly squeeze into the gap between a well's casing and the rock around it until they close it, which the trade calls creeping shale. Operators on the Norwegian shelf have used such shale in place of cement behind casing since 2006, once logs and a pressure test show a continuous seal, usually at least 30 m long. Norsk Hydro had logged and tested creeping shale before 2005; the 2013 revision of NORSOK D-010, Norway's well integrity standard, set requirements for it, which the 2004 revision had not; BP Norge used it to plug Valhall wells in 2015 and Equinor to plug Huldra field wells in 2016. All of this is from a November 2025 review carried out by Reflekt AS for Havtil, Norway's offshore safety regulator.

    LessonConocoPhillips does not use it at Ekofisk, because modern wells built with liners and oil-based mud trap fluid that stops the shale from creeping.

    havtil.nohavtil.no

    Credit

    Norsk Hydro; Statoil (now Equinor); BP Norge (now Aker BP)

  3. 2016

    Clay plugs win approval

    Bentonite is a clay that swells when wet; dropped into a well as dry chips or bars and then hydrated, it can form a plug. Brian Towler of the University of Queensland and colleagues, two of them from the gas company QGC, reviewed field trials of bentonite plugs in Texas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Wyoming and Queensland and reported all of them successful, though some wells were dropped as unsuitable. They report that California, Texas and Oklahoma had changed their rules to allow bentonite, that Wyoming allowed it only as the bottom plug in coal-bed methane wells, and that Queensland allowed a trial under a clause for experimental materials.

    Lessonin most places a new plug material needs a rule change before it can be used.

    api.crossref.org

    Credit

    Brian Towler and colleagues, University of Queensland and QGC

  4. 2016

    Ekofisk wells plugged faster

    Under NORSOK D-010, every zone that holds oil or gas needs a primary and a secondary barrier, and the well needs a plug near the seabed, each across the full width of the hole; Ekofisk wells take up to five plugs. Each trip of tools into a well takes 8 to 18 hours, so ConocoPhillips combined tasks on each trip and replaced a separate run to tag (strike) the top of each plug with records of the cement volumes used and samples of its strength. In 2016 each well was plugged in about 20 to 25 days instead of the 58 expected, according to the Norwegian Petroleum Museum, citing the company. The eight fields of the Greater Ekofisk Area have had 660 production wells drilled.

    Lessonmuch of the time in plugging goes on running tools in and out, not on setting cement.

    ekofisk.industriminne.no

    Credit

    ConocoPhillips Norway

  5. 2021

    A new plug method audited

    Perforate, wash and cement (PWC) punches holes in the casing, jets old mud out of the space behind it and pumps cement in through the holes, so a plug can fill the whole width of the hole without section milling, the slow grinding away of a length of casing. A review carried out for Havtil found that by late 2021 ConocoPhillips had run more than 200 PWC operations since starting to qualify the method in 2010, Aker BP more than 40 in about seven years, and Equinor 29. Aker BP drilled out and logged about half of its early plugs to check them and planned to keep checking at least 10%; Equinor still drilled out and logged every plug.

    Lessoneach company had qualified the method only for the casing sizes and conditions it had tested, so every new use needs its own track record of checked plugs.

    havtil.no

    Credit

    BP Norge, which did the original work; ConocoPhillips, Aker BP and Equinor, which qualified it; review by Reflekt AS for Havtil

Watch for

  1. Metal plugs on island wells

    BiSN says its plugs of bismuth alloy, a metal melted in place by a chemical heater that expands as it sets, sealed more than a dozen legacy wells on Thevenard Island, some over 30 years old, for Chevron, and were used in the phased decommissioning of hundreds of inactive wells on Barrow Island, a Class A nature reserve off Western Australia. It describes the work as an "alternative means of compliance" with the state's rules, and says Western Australia's Department of Mines, Petroleum and Exploration gave the submission its 2025 Golden Gecko Award for environmental excellence.

    Achieved whenChevron or the regulator publishes how many wells were sealed with bismuth and the results of pressure tests or monitoring afterwards.

    bisn.com

    Claimed by

    BiSN, December 2025

  2. New rules for shale seals

    Havtil says the NORSOK D-010 acceptance table for creeping shale is being revised, with an updated table due in 2026, and expects Revision 6 of the standard to say which rock layers may be used and how they must be qualified. Its 2025 review found that one of four operators had qualified creeping shale under a formal technology qualification practice and the other three used the standard's minimum criteria.

    Achieved whenStandards Norway publishes Revision 6 with the revised table.

    havtil.no

    Claimed by

    Havtil, November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Map Norway's sealing shales

    A public map and table of the shale layers that can serve as creeping-shale barriers on the Norwegian shelf, starting with the Hordaland Group: the depth and thickness of each layer in every released wellbore from the regulator's open data, with every published case of a shale qualified as a barrier (field, layer, depth, how it was verified) linked to its source page.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    An independent PWC track record

    An open table of every published result for plugs set behind casing by perforate, wash and cement: well or field, casing size, tool type (cup or jet), whether the plug was drilled out and logged, what the log showed, and the source page, with the share of rows that come from the tool's maker shown.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Map Norway's sealing shales

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public map and table of the shale layers that can serve as creeping-shale barriers on the Norwegian shelf, starting with the Hordaland Group: the depth and thickness of each layer in every released wellbore from the regulator's open data, with every published case of a shale qualified as a barrier (field, layer, depth, how it was verified) linked to its source page.

Why it is still open

Havtil's 2025 review found the four operators it interviewed using different approaches, says most such layers run across field and licence boundaries, and names the showing of "geologically similar layers" as key to sharing a track record; formation choice is still to be set out in Revision 6 of the standard. Equinor has mapped the clay content of the Hordaland "green clay" from mineral analyses of drill cuttings in a large number of North Sea wells, GEO ExPro reported in 2021, but the results are not published as data. Companies such as Physiq offer methods for finding suitable shales as a service, and no public list of qualified layers was found in this session's searches.

geoexpro.comhavtil.no

Built with what exists

The Norwegian Offshore Directorate's FactMaps open data service (its formation tops table holds 1,782 Hordaland Group tops, by this session's count); published papers and Havtil seminar presentations for qualified cases; a language model that extracts each case with the sentence it came from (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); QGIS; Python.

  1. First step

    Download the Hordaland Group tops from the FactMaps service and plot them with the fields the Havtil review names: Valhall, Huldra, the Balder area and Ekofisk.

  2. Done looks like

    Every released wellbore with a Hordaland Group top mapped with depth and thickness; at least 20 published shale-barrier cases each tied to a field or wellbore and a source page; a second person rechecking the cases and agreeing on at least 90%; map, table and code published under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

An independent PWC track record

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table of every published result for plugs set behind casing by perforate, wash and cement: well or field, casing size, tool type (cup or jet), whether the plug was drilled out and logged, what the log showed, and the source page, with the share of rows that come from the tool's maker shown.

Why it is still open

The 2021 review for Havtil counts operations by company but gives no plug-by-plug results, and says each company builds its own track record; Equinor drills out every plug for lack of one. The one published review of PWC field deployments, in SPE Journal in April 2025, was written by staff of HydraWell, the tool's maker.

havtil.noapi.crossref.org

Built with what exists

SPE papers on PWC, many listed in an appendix to the 2021 review; Havtil's plugging seminar presentations; a language model that extracts each plug with the sentence it came from (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); two human checkers; Python.

  1. First step

    List the papers in the 2021 review's appendix and mark which ones report drill-out and logging results.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 100 plugs from at least 15 sources in the table, each row linked to a page; pass rates by tool type and casing size; a second person rechecking 20 rows with no more than one disagreement.