Industries / Construction and property / Heavy civil / Tunneling
Ventilation and safety
Ventilation and safety keep people alive underground: fresh air in and fumes, dust and gas out while a tunnel is built, and smoke control, escape routes and rescue once it is in use.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1890 to 2023.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1890
A chamber for the bends
Tunnels under rivers were dug in compressed air, pumped into the workings to hold back the water, and workers who came out too quickly suffered decompression sickness, "the bends", which could kill or cripple them. Ernest Moir, engineer for the contractor S. Pearson and Son on the Hudson River tunnel in New York, built a medical lock, a chamber in which a sick worker is put back under pressure and brought out slowly. Grace's Guide says it was first used in 1890 and cut the yearly death rate among the workforce from 25% to 1%; the physiologist Leonard Hill wrote in 1912 that Moir, having proved it worked, made it essential equipment of all compressed-air works.
Credit
Ernest William Moir
1927
Fans for the motor age
The Holland Tunnel, opened in 1927 under the Hudson River between New York and New Jersey, was the first tunnel designed for cars and trucks, in ASCE's words. Car exhaust had to be removed from its 1.6 miles (2.6 km), and the engineer Ole Singstad designed a ventilation system in which 84 fans in four buildings change the air every 90 seconds. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which runs it, calls it the first mechanically ventilated underwater vehicular tunnel; ASCE and the mechanical engineers' society ASME named it a landmark in 1984.
Credit
Clifford Holland, Milton Freeman and Ole Singstad, the project's three chief engineers
1971
Gas in a water tunnel
On 24 June 1971 methane exploded 5.3 miles (8.5 km) inside a 5.5-mile water tunnel being bored at Sylmar, California, for the Metropolitan Water District, killing 17 workers; one survived. The night before, a smaller methane explosion had hurt four men, and the Los Angeles Fire Department's battalion chief found that the crew tested for gas only from time to time and told supervisors to test continuously. Crews had read about 1% methane while the boring machine was idle, but when it cut into an earthquake fault the gas came in puffs. The water district says the disaster led to the toughest mining and tunnel rules in the US. California now classifies every tunnel, before bidding, as nongassy, potentially gassy, gassy or extrahazardous from the owner's geological reports.
Lessongas that arrives in puffs from a fault slips past spot checks, so a tunnel near gas needs continuous monitoring.
Credit
Los Angeles Fire Department (rescue); California's Division of Occupational Safety and Health (classification rules)
1999
A truck fire kills 39
On 24 March 1999 a heavy goods vehicle carrying margarine and flour caught fire in the middle of the 11.6 km Mont Blanc road tunnel between France and Italy, and 39 people died. PIARC, the World Road Association, found that Italian operators kept a ventilation duct blowing fresh air instead of switching it to extract smoke, believing this would protect people on their side, while on the French side the emergency procedure blew fresh air at full capacity and pushed the smoke faster toward the French portal. Two people died of heat inside a pressurized shelter. Fires in the Tauern tunnel in May 1999 (12 dead) and the Gotthard road tunnel in October 2001 (11 dead) followed.
Lessona truck with "non-dangerous" goods can make a huge fire, and a shelter must open onto an escape route that is not the burning tunnel itself.
Credit
PIARC (analysis)
2004
Europe sets tunnel minimums
After the Alpine fires, transport ministers of Austria, France, Germany, Italy and Switzerland agreed in Zurich in November 2001 to align their rules, and on 29 April 2004 the European Union adopted Directive 2004/54/EC on minimum safety requirements for road tunnels longer than 500 m on the trans-European network. Where emergency exits are provided they must be no more than 500 m apart; tunnels longer than 1,000 m carrying more than 2,000 vehicles per lane need mechanical ventilation; existing tunnels had to be refurbished by 30 April 2014, with up to five years more for some countries.
Credit
European Parliament and Council of the European Union
2022
Electric cars burned in tunnel
In 2018 Austria's government commissioned research on what battery-electric vehicle fires mean for tunnel safety, and researchers from Graz University of Technology and Montanuniversität Leoben burned battery-electric and conventional cars in five full-scale tests in a road tunnel. They describe them as the first fire tests of battery-electric vehicles under real road tunnel conditions, and in December 2022 they published the measured air temperatures, air speeds and heat release rates as open data, for others to check simulations against.
Credit
P. Sturm, P. Fößleitner and colleagues; funded by Austria's transport ministry and ASFINAG, the motorway operator
2023
Forty-one trapped, no escape
Early on 12 November 2023 a section about 200 m inside the 4.5 km Silkyara road tunnel in Uttarakhand, India, collapsed and trapped 41 workers; all were brought out on 28 November after 17 days, the Associated Press reported. The BBC reported that an escape passage approved for the tunnel in 2018 had not been built, and that a consultant had warned in August that the ground was harder than the tender documents predicted. On 22 November the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) said it would audit all 29 national-highway tunnels under construction, about 79 km in all.
Lessonan escape route on the drawings protects nobody until it is built.
Credit
rescue teams of the Indian government and the state of Uttarakhand
Watch for
Fewer people at the face
Japan's road and construction ministry, MLIT, citing labor ministry data, says about nine in ten accidents in mountain tunneling happen at the face, the rock surface being dug, with the largest shares while steel supports are set (41%) and explosives are charged (36%). MLIT says it contracted four trial tunnels in fiscal 2025 whose builders proposed automated or remote setting of steel supports, will order five more in fiscal 2026 for a different task, and aims to make automation of some tasks standard over about five years.
Achieved whenMLIT publishes its field surveys of the trial tunnels showing fewer workers at the face than its standard crew, and the technical standards that follow.
Claimed by
MLIT, March and May 2026
Open
01
Escape routes, tunnel by tunnel
A public table of the road tunnels under construction on India's national highways, starting with the 29 that NHAI said it would audit in November 2023, giving for each its length, how it is dug, and whether an escape tunnel, refuge chamber or escape pipe is designed, built and kept up to the face, each with a dated public source.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A shared test for fumes
An open benchmark for re-entry time, the wait after a blast before people may go back to the face because carbon monoxide (CO), nitrogen dioxide and dust have fallen below exposure limits. Collect published field measurements of fume concentration over time after tunnel blasts, with the tunnel section, explosive mass, duct airflow and duct position for each, and score the simple formulas and open models used to plan ventilation against them.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Escape routes, tunnel by tunnel
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of the road tunnels under construction on India's national highways, starting with the 29 that NHAI said it would audit in November 2023, giving for each its length, how it is dug, and whether an escape tunnel, refuge chamber or escape pipe is designed, built and kept up to the face, each with a dated public source.
Why it is still open
NHAI said on 22 November 2023 that experts from the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation and others would inspect the 29 tunnels and report within seven days. No findings for individual tunnels were found in this session, and in December 2023 the Deccan Herald asked where the promised audit was. At Silkyara the escape passage existed on paper only.
Built with what exists
NHAI and NHIDCL tender documents and press releases; answers given in India's parliament; contractors' published progress reports; a web agent to gather the documents (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a reviewer model that checks each entry against its source for a person to confirm (see the Note "Seven more flagged").
First step
Name the 29 tunnels from NHAI's state-by-state count and parliamentary answers, and record what one public document says about escape provisions in five of them.
Done looks like
All 29 tunnels named, each with at least one dated public source on its escape provision, a second person checking 10 entries, and the table updated every six months.
Open 02 · the brief
A shared test for fumes
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open benchmark for re-entry time, the wait after a blast before people may go back to the face because carbon monoxide (CO), nitrogen dioxide and dust have fallen below exposure limits. Collect published field measurements of fume concentration over time after tunnel blasts, with the tunnel section, explosive mass, duct airflow and duct position for each, and score the simple formulas and open models used to plan ventilation against them.
Why it is still open
Each study checks its model against its own tunnel. Menéndez and colleagues (2022) compared 3D simulations with CO measured in one railway tunnel in northern Spain; in their simulations CO took 480 s to fall below its limit with fresh air forced to the face, and 155 s with a mixed system that also extracts air, a 67% cut. No pooled set of measurements across tunnels was found, so nobody can say which planning method errs least.
Built with what exists
WebPlotDigitizer to read concentration curves from published figures; Python for a simple one-dimensional dilution model; Hobyah (github.com/ECB2020/Hobyah), an open program for airflow in tunnel networks; OpenFOAM for three-dimensional checks.
First step
Digitize the CO curves from the Spanish railway tunnel paper and reproduce its one-dimensional model's re-entry time.
Done looks like
Curves from at least 30 blasts in at least six tunnels, published as open data, with each method's error in predicted re-entry time, in minutes, for CO and nitrogen dioxide.