BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Electric transmission and distribution / Transformers and switchgear

Testing

Testing is the work of proving, in the factory and in special laboratories, that a new transformer or breaker meets its rating before it goes into service: that its windings survive the forces of a short circuit, that its insulation holds, and that it matches its design.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1978 to 2017.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1978

    Frequency response finds damage

    E. P. Dick and C. C. Erven described testing a transformer by sending a low-voltage signal through a winding across a range of frequencies and comparing the response with an earlier one. Frequency response analysis (FRA) grew out of low-voltage impulse tests, and the University Transformer Research Alliance, a group of university labs, wrote in 2023 that it detects moved windings, shorted turns and partly collapsed windings with far greater sensitivity than impedance or capacitance measurements. A trace taken when the transformer is new becomes the reference for every later check.

    doi.orghrcak.srce.hr

    Credit

    E. P. Dick and C. C. Erven

  2. 2012

    A standard way to measure

    After work by CIGRE working group A2.26, IEC 60076-18, published in 2012, set standard test connections and reporting for FRA, and IEEE's guide C57.149 of the same year recommends a minimum set of connections for each type of transformer. Neither gives a pass or fail rule: the 2023 review says assessing results still needs skilled people because no reliable criterion exists in IEC or IEEE standards, and that IEC 60076-18 is being revised.

    Lessonstandardizing a measurement does not standardize the verdict.

    hrcak.srce.hr

    Credit

    IEC; IEEE; CIGRE working group A2.26

  3. 2016

    Short-circuit tests at 765 kV

    In a short-circuit test a laboratory drives fault current through a finished transformer to show that its windings and supports survive the forces. KEMA Laboratories in Arnhem, the Netherlands, short-circuit tested 765 kV transformers in 2016, which René Smeets of KEMA calls the first test at that level, and can test units up to 1,000 MVA (million volt-amperes, a measure of size) three-phase and 800 kV. CESI, which now owns KEMA Labs, says the Arnhem laboratory runs six short-circuit generators of 2,100 MVA each.

    hrcak.srce.hrcesi.it

    Credit

    KEMA Laboratories

  4. 2017

    One in five fails

    Smeets counted 320 short-circuit test attempts on 278 transformers above 25 MVA at KEMA from 1996 to 2016: 70 attempts, or 22%, failed at the first try, and 33% of the 99 units rated 200 MVA or more failed. The usual fault was a deformed winding, other major laboratories report failure rates of 20 to 30%, and Smeets notes that more buyers now ask for tests on critical units.

    Lessondesign calculations alone do not prove that a large transformer will survive a short circuit.

    hrcak.srce.hr

    Credit

    René Smeets, KEMA Laboratories

Watch for

  1. AI reads FRA traces

    Engineers at POWERGRID in India describe software that cleans and lines up FRA traces from different test sets and sorts them with machine learning, trained on 2,670 traces from 225 transformers and shunt reactors, to replace subjective human reading. The paper's abstract gives no accuracy on traces held back from training.

    Achieved whensomeone outside POWERGRID scores the method on traces it was not trained on and publishes the error rates.

    indianjournals.com

    Claimed by

    Deo Nath Jha and co-authors, POWERGRID, Power Engineer Journal, June 2025

Open

  1. 01

    A blind test for FRA

    A public set of labeled FRA traces, healthy and damaged, with a held-back test set, and a scoreboard of how well each reading method sorts them.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Check test reports by machine

    A tool that reads a maker's factory test report for a transformer, usually a PDF, and flags every value outside the limits of IEC 60076-1 or the buyer's specification, every arithmetic slip and every figure that does not match the nameplate, citing the page it found each one on.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A blind test for FRA

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of labeled FRA traces, healthy and damaged, with a held-back test set, and a scoreboard of how well each reading method sorts them.

Why it is still open

The 2023 review says FRA results still need skilled people to assess, because IEC and IEEE give no reliable pass or fail criterion. Tools exist, such as the University of Stuttgart's free web application, which flags a possible failure when its Winding Assessment Factor falls below -5 above 2 kHz, and POWERGRID's classifier, but each was built and scored on its makers' own data, and a search for a public, labeled set of traces found none.

hrcak.srce.hrdiagnostic.ieh.uni-stuttgart.deindianjournals.com

Built with what exists

Circuit models of windings made of inductors and capacitors, run in an open simulator such as ngspice, to make traces of healthy and damaged windings; low-voltage FRA sweeps on small, de-energized dry-type transformers whose windings are shifted by known amounts, as a university lab did with a 50 kVA unit in a 2024 study; the Stuttgart tool and open machine-learning libraries such as scikit-learn as entrants.

diagnostyka.net.pl

  1. First step

    Simulate 100 traces of a simple winding model with axial shifts from 0 to 10% and score the Stuttgart tool on them.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 labeled traces, simulated and measured, published under an open license with 100 held back for testing, and at least three methods scored on the held-back set, with a second team reproducing the scores.

Open 02 · the brief

Check test reports by machine

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A tool that reads a maker's factory test report for a transformer, usually a PDF, and flags every value outside the limits of IEC 60076-1 or the buyer's specification, every arithmetic slip and every figure that does not match the nameplate, citing the page it found each one on.

Why it is still open

Test reports are still put together by hand in spreadsheets and word processors, which the authors of a November 2025 paper call error-prone and easy to manipulate; their tool builds reports from a laboratory's own measurements and does not check reports that a buyer receives.

ijraset.com

Built with what exists

Language models that read tables in PDFs and cite where each value came from (see the Notes "Seven more flagged" and "Findings that cite notes"); a rule file written from the tolerance clause of IEC 60076-1; Python.

  1. First step

    Write 20 synthetic test reports for 10 MVA transformers, plant 40 errors, and score one model on them.

  2. Done looks like

    On 100 reports with 200 planted errors, the tool finds at least 95% of them and raises no more than one false flag per report on average, with the reports, the errors and the scores published.