BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Electric transmission and distribution / Transformers and switchgear

Insulation and oil

Insulation keeps the windings from shorting to each other and to the tank; in most large transformers it is paper and pressboard soaked in a liquid that also carries the heat away.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1932 to 2012.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1932

    Fluid that would not burn

    Mineral oil insulates and cools well but can burn, so for transformers inside buildings and crowded districts makers wanted a liquid that would not. General Electric first used askarel, a blend based on polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) made by Monsanto, in its Pyranol transformers in 1932, and Westinghouse sold its own as Inerteen, by Monsanto's maintenance guide. A 1976 report by the US National Bureau of Standards said askarels had come under criticism for suspected toxicity and long persistence in the environment, that mineral oil still filled as much as 98% of liquid-cooled power transformers, and that no replacement for askarel had gained general acceptance.

    Lessona liquid chosen to remove one hazard, fire, can leave a longer-lasting one.

    toxicdocs.orgnvlpubs.nist.gov

    Credit

    Frank M. Clark of General Electric, named by Monsanto as the inventor of transformer askarels; Monsanto

  2. 1966

    Windings cast in resin

    A cast-resin transformer seals its high-voltage windings in epoxy resin poured under vacuum, so it needs no tank of oil. Siemens Energy dates its GEAFOL cast-resin line to 1966, and ABB, whose grid business is now Hitachi Energy, launched RESIBLOC, with resin reinforced by glass fiber, in 1974. Hitachi Energy says adoption "was often driven by critical events, such as fires or accidents," and names high-rise buildings, offshore platforms, underground substations and ships among the users; Siemens Energy's Kirchheim plant has built its 150,000th GEAFOL unit.

    siemens-energy.comhitachienergy.com

    Credit

    Siemens; ABB (now Hitachi Energy)

  3. 2002

    Soybean oil checked outside

    Cooper Power Systems made Envirotemp FR3, a transformer fluid of more than 98.5% vegetable oil, a natural ester (oil made of fatty-acid esters, as plant oils are). In June 2002 the US Environmental Protection Agency's Environmental Technology Verification program published its tests of the fluid's performance, biodegradation, toxicity and composition, when about 475 transformers, rated up to 35 kV and 10 MVA, used it. By Cooper's own count, in its nomination for EPA's 2012 Presidential Green Chemistry Challenge awards, more than 450,000 transformers had been filled with it.

    archive.epa.govmath-cs.gordon.edu

    Credit

    Cooper Power Systems (now part of Eaton); US EPA (verification)..pdf)

  4. 2012

    Sulfur ruled out of oil

    Some mineral oils contained dibenzyl disulfide (DBDS), a sulfur compound that reacts with copper windings to form copper sulfide, which conducts electricity and settles in the paper between turns until the insulation breaks down. Because DBDS was the most common corrosive sulfur compound in the oil of failed power transformers, the IEC revised its specification for new mineral oil, IEC 60296, to limit DBDS to 5 mg/kg, with a corrosion test (IEC 62535) and a method for measuring DBDS (IEC 62697-1); from 2012 new oils could not contain reactive disulfides, by the account of the Nikola Tesla Electrical Engineering Institute in Belgrade.

    Lessonan oil can pass every test in its specification and still fail transformers when the specification does not test for what fails them.

    scindeks-clanci.ceon.rs

    Credit

    the IEC; account by Dejan Kolarski and colleagues (Nikola Tesla Electrical Engineering Institute)

Watch for

  1. Ester oil at 765 kV

    Hitachi Energy says it tested a 765/400 kV, 250 MVA single-phase transformer filled with natural ester in May 2025, the first at this voltage and power, and a 2026 CIGRE paper by its engineers reports that the unit passed the full set of IEC 60076 factory tests, including lightning-impulse tests up to 2,100 kV. In August 2025 CHINT said its 750 kV, 120 MVA unit, filled with Cargill's FR3, passed factory acceptance tests overseen by a State Grid testing center, and that ester extends insulation life by up to eight times compared with mineral oil.

    Achieved whena unit of this class has run in service for a year and its owner or an outside body publishes its operating record.

    hitachienergy.come-cigre.orgtransformer-technology.com

    Claimed by

    Hitachi Energy, May 2025; CHINT and Cargill, August 2025

Open

  1. 01

    An open paper-aging test

    A repeatable public test of how fast transformer paper ages in mineral oil, natural ester and synthetic ester, at several temperatures, with every raw measurement and the analysis code published, ending in a measured ratio of paper life between the fluids.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Register of high-voltage ester units

    A public list of every ester-filled transformer and reactor at 110 kV or above that has been reported anywhere, with its rating, fluid, year in service, owner and any reported fault, each field linked to its source.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An open paper-aging test

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A repeatable public test of how fast transformer paper ages in mineral oil, natural ester and synthetic ester, at several temperatures, with every raw measurement and the analysis code published, ending in a measured ratio of paper life between the fluids.

Why it is still open

Makers state large gains: CHINT says ester extends insulation life by up to eight times. Outside tests use their own vessels, temperatures and papers and report end points, not life ratios: Junko Tokunaga and colleagues found that kraft paper kept in mineral oil for 365 days at 105 °C in sealed tanks fell to a degree of polymerization (DP, the length of its cellulose chains, which shortens as paper ages) of 289 or less, against 536 in a palm fatty acid ester.

transformer-technology.comjstage.jst.go.jp

Built with what exists

A university or commercial oil-testing laboratory with ovens and sealed steel aging vessels; kraft and thermally upgraded paper; mineral oil, a natural ester and a synthetic ester; the standard viscometer method for measuring DP; a tensile tester; Python for fitting aging rates against temperature.

  1. First step

    With a university oil laboratory, age kraft paper in mineral oil and in one natural ester at 120 °C for four weeks and measure DP each week.

  2. Done looks like

    Three fluids, two papers, three temperatures between 110 and 130 °C and six time points, each run in triplicate, with raw data and code under an open license, a second lab repeating one temperature within 10% on DP, and a life ratio with its confidence range set beside the makers' claims.

Open 02 · the brief

Register of high-voltage ester units

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public list of every ester-filled transformer and reactor at 110 kV or above that has been reported anywhere, with its rating, fluid, year in service, owner and any reported fault, each field linked to its source.

Why it is still open

CIGRE's survey of service experience with ester and silicone fluids, Technical Brochure 436, dates from 2010 and costs non-members €180. Makers announce single units, such as Hitachi Energy's 765 kV transformer, with test results but no service record.

e-cigre.orghitachienergy.com

Built with what exists

The free OpenAlex and Crossref indexes of research papers; makers' press releases; utility tenders; a language model that pulls each unit's details and cites the sentence they came from (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); two human checkers.

  1. First step

    Query OpenAlex for papers on ester-filled power transformers and list the units named in the first 50 results.

  2. Done looks like

    Every unit found in papers and releases since 2000, with the search method published so others can rerun it, a second checker agreeing on 95% of fields, and the list updated every three months for a year.