Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Think tanks
Events and convening
Think tanks run public conferences and private meetings where officials, scholars and others from different countries and sides can talk.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1927 to 2020.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1927
One rule for frank talk
In 1927 Chatham House, the Royal Institute of International Affairs in London, set a rule for its meetings: "participants are free to use the information received, but neither the identity nor the affiliation of the speaker(s), nor that of any other participant, may be revealed." The wording was refined in 1992 and again in 2002, and Chatham House has translated it into seven other languages. Groups far outside foreign affairs, such as the UK's Continuity Forum for business-continuity managers, now hold meetings under the same rule.
Credit
Chatham House (Royal Institute of International Affairs)
1957
Scientists talk across the divide
Answering the Russell–Einstein Manifesto of 1955, which warned of nuclear war, scientists met in July 1957 at Pugwash, Nova Scotia, in their personal capacities rather than as delegates of their governments. Pugwash says its founders "became pioneers of a new kind of transnational, 'track 2' dialogue", meaning unofficial talks that run alongside official diplomacy, and that it has organized more than 400 meetings. Pugwash and its founder Joseph Rotblat were jointly awarded the 1995 Nobel Peace Prize.
Credit
Joseph Rotblat and Bertrand Russell; Cyrus Eaton, the industrialist who paid for and hosted the first meeting
1967
A back channel stalls
At a Pugwash meeting in Paris in June 1967, the French biologist Herbert Marcovich offered to go to Hanoi. With Raymond Aubrac he met North Vietnam's leaders Ho Chi Minh and Pham Van Dong in July and then carried messages between Hanoi and Henry Kissinger, then a Harvard professor and part-time consultant to the US government, in a channel code-named Pennsylvania. Kissinger's own account, sent in October 1967 and printed in the State Department's official history, records that the channel ended without talks. Robert McNamara, US Secretary of Defense at the time, later credited it with laying groundwork for the negotiations that ended the war.
LessonAn unofficial meeting can carry messages between governments, but it cannot by itself make them agree.
Credit
Herbert Marcovich, Raymond Aubrac and Henry Kissinger; Office of the Historian, US Department of State (the record)
2002
A think tank hosts ministers
The International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS), a London think tank, first convened the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore in 2002 as a yearly meeting of defense ministers, with Singapore's government as host. It issues no joint statement: ministers give speeches and take questions in public, and meet each other privately on the side. At the 2023 meeting IISS counted 54 nations, 34 government ministers and 121 bilateral meetings, and China's defense minister first attended in 2011. Graeme Dobell of the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, who has attended since 2002, writes that it was part of the push for ASEAN defense ministers to hold their first joint meeting in 2006.
Credit
John Chipman, IISS; the government of Singapore
2004
A president meets the club
Russia's Valdai Discussion Club, founded in 2004 and named after Lake Valdai, where it first met, brings Russian and foreign experts together once a year. Its founders include the Council on Foreign and Defence Policy, the Russian International Affairs Council, MGIMO University of the Russian foreign ministry, and the Higher School of Economics. The club says President Vladimir Putin has met its participants every year since it began, and the Kremlin's own website records him at its 23rd annual meeting on 1 October 2026.
Credit
Valdai Discussion Club and its founders
2016
A ministry co-hosts a dialogue
India's Ministry of External Affairs and the Observer Research Foundation (ORF), a New Delhi think tank, held the first Raisina Dialogue on 1 to 3 March 2016. Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj opened it as "a new initiative taken jointly" by the two, and ORF counted more than 100 speakers from over 35 countries. A separate body, the Raisina Platforms and Ideas Forum, now runs the Dialogue and spin-off meetings in Tokyo, the Mediterranean, the Middle East and Australia.
Credit
Observer Research Foundation; Ministry of External Affairs, India
2020
Events stop, then move online
In a survey of think tank staff worldwide that On Think Tanks, a research and advisory group on the sector, ran from 7 April to 25 May 2020, more than 60% of respondents said they had canceled all events and all travel because of COVID-19. Respondents wrote that webinars had reached new audiences and that well-known speakers were easier to book because they too were working from home.
Credit
On Think Tanks
Watch for
Deals made on the sidelines
On 30 May 2026, on the sidelines of the 23rd Shangri-La Dialogue, 17 countries, among them Australia, France, the Philippines, Singapore, Sweden and the United Kingdom, launched GUIDE (Guiding Principles for Underwater Infrastructure Defence Exchanges), a set of shared principles for defense cooperation on protecting undersea cables and pipelines. Singapore's defense ministry says other countries may join.
Achieved whenA member country other than Singapore reports a joint exercise, exchange or shared standard carried out under GUIDE.
Claimed by
Singapore Ministry of Defence, May 2026
Open
01
Notes that keep the rule
A note-taking tool that turns the recording of a meeting held under the Chatham House Rule into a summary that keeps what was said but drops names, job titles, employers and any detail that points to one person, and a public test of how often readers can still tell who said what. Use scripted mock meetings with volunteers or paid actors who have agreed to take part, never recordings of real private meetings.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A record of sideline promises
A public table of the commitments announced at think-tank-run dialogues such as the Shangri-La Dialogue and the Raisina Dialogue: who announced what, on what date, whether it can be checked, and what has happened since, each with a source.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Notes that keep the rule
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A note-taking tool that turns the recording of a meeting held under the Chatham House Rule into a summary that keeps what was said but drops names, job titles, employers and any detail that points to one person, and a public test of how often readers can still tell who said what. Use scripted mock meetings with volunteers or paid actors who have agreed to take part, never recordings of real private meetings.
Why it is still open
AI note-takers now record and summarize meetings and label speakers. A November 2026 commentary on the rule warned that "the identity and affiliation of the speaker is easily ascertained by the AI summary." This research found advice on consent and data retention for such tools, but no published test of whether an AI summary can keep the rule.
Built with what exists
A speech-to-text model that labels speakers, such as ElevenLabs Scribe v3 (see the Note "Fewer word errors"); an AI model such as Claude or Gemini, told to follow the rule, to write the summary; a scoring sheet for human readers.
First step
Write and record three mock roundtables with volunteers, run them through two note-taking tools, and count how many points in each summary can be traced to a named person or employer.
Done looks like
30 scripted roundtables of 6 to 10 speakers each, every speaker with a made-up public profile; 20 readers given those profiles try to match each point in a summary to a speaker; the tool's summaries keep correct matches within 5 percentage points of chance while keeping at least 90% of the points two human note-takers list. Scripts, recordings, summaries and scores published.
Open 02 · the brief
A record of sideline promises
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of the commitments announced at think-tank-run dialogues such as the Shangri-La Dialogue and the Raisina Dialogue: who announced what, on what date, whether it can be checked, and what has happened since, each with a source.
Why it is still open
The National Committee on American Foreign Policy built such a table for the official US–China Strategic and Economic Dialogue, listing each commitment, whether it could be checked from open sources, and the progress made. This research found no similar record for announcements made at meetings run by think tanks, where new frameworks such as GUIDE are launched.
Built with what exists
Speech transcripts and press releases from the organizers and from governments; a web agent such as Browser Use to collect them (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); an AI model to pull out each commitment; a shared spreadsheet for two human reviewers.
First step
List the announcements in the 2026 Shangri-La Dialogue plenary speeches and check the first ten against later government statements.
Done looks like
Every commitment announced in plenary speeches at the Shangri-La Dialogue from 2022 to 2026 logged and classed by two reviewers as done, under way, not done or not checkable, with at least 85% agreement between them; the table published with a source for every entry and updated after the next meeting.