BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Think tanks

Reaching policymakers

Think tanks try to get their work used: they draft laws, write plans for incoming governments, answer consultations, and send their own staff into government.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1921 to 2019.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1921

    Drafting a budget law

    William F. Willoughby of the Institute for Government Research, founded in Washington in 1916 and merged into the Brookings Institution in 1927, drafted the legislation that became the Budget and Accounting Act of 1921, by Brookings' account. The Act created the first US Bureau of the Budget.

    brookings.edu

    Credit

    William F. Willoughby, Institute for Government Research

  2. 1965

    A parliament funds its advisers

    Germany's Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik (SWP), the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, was set up by private initiative in 1962. Since January 1965, when the Bundestag unanimously backed an independent research center, it has been funded by the federal government, and it advises the German government and parliament on foreign and security policy.

    swp-berlin.orgswp-berlin.org

    Credit

    SWP; the German Bundestag

  3. 1981

    Handbook for a new president

    Before Ronald Reagan took office, the Heritage Foundation prepared Mandate for Leadership, a policy guide for his administration whose editor, Charles Heatherly, spent a year supervising 250 contributors. Education Week reported in September 1981 that Heatherly and two of the book's education authors had become Education Department officials, and that the department had already acted on several of its recommendations, such as withdrawing proposed rules on bilingual education. Heritage has published new editions for later transitions.

    LessonA plan's authors can carry it into government themselves.

    edweek.orgmandateforleadership.org

    Credit

    Heritage Foundation; Charles Heatherly (editor)

  4. 2008

    A second transition handbook

    In November 2008 the Center for American Progress (CAP) Action Fund and the New Democracy Project released Change for America, a transition manual for the incoming Obama administration with chapters by 67 policymakers, scholars and former officials. CAP's president, John Podesta, was then on leave to lead Obama's transition. James G. McGann, in The Fifth Estate (Brookings Institution Press, 2016), describes US think tanks as a source of staff when power changes hands, naming the American Enterprise Institute for George W. Bush and CAP for Barack Obama, and calls them "governments-in-waiting".

    americanprogressaction.orgthenation.combrookings.edubrookings.edu

    Credit

    Center for American Progress Action Fund and New Democracy Project; Mark Green and Michele Jolin (editors)

  5. 2015

    China plans its think tanks

    On 20 January 2015 the general offices of China's Communist Party Central Committee and State Council issued an opinion on building "new kinds of think tanks with Chinese characteristics". It set a goal of 50 to 100 high-end think tanks, named the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences as a national one, told government bodies to commission research from think tanks through tenders and procurement, and called for "orderly circulation of talent" between Party and government organs and think tanks, with think-tank experts given concurrent posts in government.

    digichina.stanford.edu

    Credit

    General Office of the CPC Central Committee and General Office of the State Council; English translation by Rogier Creemers, published by DigiChina at Stanford

  6. 2019

    Copied bills, counted

    A two-year investigation by USA TODAY, The Arizona Republic and the Center for Public Integrity used software to compare nearly 1 million bills from all 50 US states and Congress with known "model" bills written by outside groups, including think tanks. It found at least 10,000 bills almost entirely copied from model legislation over eight years, and more than 2,100 of them became law. The models came from groups on the right and the left, among them the American Legislative Exchange Council, the Goldwater Institute and the State Innovation Exchange.

    LessonMatching exact text finds copied bills but misses bills that take an idea and put it in new words, as the reporters noted.

    usatoday.com

    Credit

    USA TODAY, The Arizona Republic and the Center for Public Integrity

  7. 2019

    Citations in policy, counted

    The Overton database, released in 2019, collects policy documents from governments, think tanks, intergovernmental bodies and charities and records which research papers and other policy documents they cite, so a think tank can see where its reports are used. By December 2021 it indexed documents from more than 30,000 sources, by its makers' count. Researchers outside the company have used it, for example to measure how much climate research is cited in climate policy.

    arxiv.orgarxiv.org

    Credit

    Overton; Martin Szomszor and Euan Adie (2022 description)

Watch for

  1. Counting a plan's uptake

    The Center for Progressive Reform reported in October 2025 that 251 of the 532 domestic regulatory actions recommended in Project 2025, whose policy book is the latest edition of the Heritage Foundation's Mandate for Leadership, had been fully or partly carried out, 47% of the total, up from 28% in April. The Center, which opposes the plan, keeps its tracker with the group Governing for Impact and counts actions by other agencies or by Congress that reach the same goal.

    Achieved whenA group with no stake in the plan publishes a count with matching rules others can rerun, and reaches a similar share.

    progressivereform.orgmandateforleadership.org

    Claimed by

    Center for Progressive Reform and Governing for Impact, October 2025

  2. Consultation answers read by AI

    Public consultations are one of the ways think tanks put evidence before governments. The UK government says its AI tool Consult sorted more than 50,000 responses to the Independent Water Commission's review into themes in about 2 hours, at a cost of £240, and agreed with one or both of two expert groups almost 83% of the time, while the two groups agreed with each other 55% of the time. Its own evaluation on 87,738 answers to a Department for Work and Pensions consultation gave an F1 score, a measure of how closely two sets of labels match, of 0.816 against single human reviewers.

    Achieved whenA body outside the team that built it, such as the National Audit Office or a university, tests Consult on a live consultation and confirms the accuracy.

    gov.ukassets.publishing.service.gov.uk

    Claimed by

    UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology and its Incubator for AI, August and October 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Match ideas, not words

    An open test set and tool that link recommendations in think-tank reports to later laws, regulations and executive actions when the wording differs, so that influence is counted the same way for every side. Take recommendations from an equal number of think tanks across the political range, in at least two countries.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Where advisers come from

    A public dataset of the jobs UK special advisers, the political appointees who advise ministers, held just before joining government, sorted by sector and naming any think tank, for every government and party since 2017.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Match ideas, not words

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open test set and tool that link recommendations in think-tank reports to later laws, regulations and executive actions when the wording differs, so that influence is counted the same way for every side. Take recommendations from an equal number of think tanks across the political range, in at least two countries.

Why it is still open

The 2019 model-bill investigation matched exact text and said it missed bills that adapt an idea in new words. Open code from the University of Chicago's Data Science for Social Good program, released in 2015 and 2016 to trace policy ideas from think tanks and lobbyists through state bills, also works from shared wording. The largest count of one plan's uptake, the Project 2025 tracker, is kept by a group that opposes the plan. This research found no open, multi-country test set for matching recommendations to policy by meaning.

usatoday.comgithub.comprogressivereform.org

Built with what exists

An AI model that reads long documents, such as Claude (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); the open-source sentence-transformers library to shortlist likely matches; official text from govinfo.gov, legislation.gov.uk and similar sites; two human coders for every pair.

  1. First step

    Take 50 recommendations each from two think tanks on opposite sides in one country, find matching laws by hand, and see how many of the same matches an AI model finds.

  2. Done looks like

    1,000 recommendations from 20 think tanks in two countries, each labeled by two coders as adopted, partly adopted or not adopted, with the matching document; the tool agrees with the coders on at least 85% of cases, reported separately for each think tank; data and code published.

Open 02 · the brief

Where advisers come from

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public dataset of the jobs UK special advisers, the political appointees who advise ministers, held just before joining government, sorted by sector and naming any think tank, for every government and party since 2017.

Why it is still open

The government's published lists give each adviser's name, minister and pay band, not past jobs. Researchers from the University of Exeter and KU Leuven coded the earlier careers of 521 advisers who served from 1997 to 2017, but grouped think tanks with other "policy advocacy" work (74 advisers), and Civil Service World found that 19% of the 65 advisers who started in 2010 had worked for a think tank. This research found no open, sourced dataset that names the think tanks advisers came from since 2017.

ckan.publishing.service.gov.uknews-archive.exeter.ac.ukcivilserviceworld.com

Built with what exists

The government's lists; public biographies, think-tank staff pages, press releases and news reports, gathered with a web agent such as Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); an AI model that sorts each prior job into a sector from a fixed list (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); two human checkers.

  1. First step

    Download the latest list and find the previous job of 50 advisers, with a source for each.

  2. Done looks like

    Every special adviser on the published lists from 2017 to 2026, with a sourced prior job for at least 90% of them; the think-tank share given per party and per government; a 10% sample checked by a second person with at least 90% agreement.