Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Think tanks
Publishing
Think tanks publish books, journals, reports and short briefs, mostly on their own websites, and decide what gets checked before it goes out.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1884 to 2015.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1884
Ideas in pamphlets
The Fabian Society was founded in London on 4 January 1884 and explained its name in its first pamphlet. In 1889 it published Fabian Essays, with essays by George Bernard Shaw, Sidney Webb, Annie Besant and others, and its members later founded the London School of Economics and, in 1913, the New Statesman magazine. The Society calls itself Britain's oldest political think tank.
Credit
the Fabian Society
1970
Papers argued in public
Arthur Okun and George Perry of the Brookings Institution started the Brookings Papers on Economic Activity in 1970. Draft papers are presented and discussed at conferences twice a year, and the final papers are published several months later together with the invited commentators' remarks and a summary of the general discussion.
Credit
Arthur Okun and George Perry, Brookings Institution
1997
Written standards for review
RAND first set written standards for the quality and objectivity of its research in 1997 and revised them in 1999, 2003, 2009 and 2022; they come with guidance on how to review each report before it is released. Other think tanks describe similar checks: the UK's Institute of Economic Affairs says its Academic Advisory Council and honorary fellows support the peer review of its publications.
Credit
RAND Corporation; Institute of Economic Affairs
2014
A third never downloaded
World Bank economists Doemeland and Trevino tested whether the Bank's policy reports, many written to inform public debate, were read. Counting downloads and citations, they found that more than 31% were never downloaded, almost 87% were never cited, and about 13% were downloaded at least 250 times.
LessonA policy report can go unread; at the Bank, reports with help from its research department were downloaded and cited more.
Credit
Doemeland and Trevino, World Bank
2015
A library goes offline
FRIDE, a think tank founded in 1999 "to expand ideas on Europe's role in the international arena" and invited to advise the 2010 G20 summit, closed in 2015 for lack of funds, and its website and 2,600 publications went offline with it. Toby Green, co-founder of Coherent Digital and formerly head of publishing at the OECD, cited the case when Policy Commons launched in November 2020 to index policy reports, give each a persistent identifier and keep an archive copy where permitted.
LessonMost think tanks publish only on their own websites, without persistent identifiers or archive copies, so their work can vanish when they close or rebuild their sites.
Credit
Toby Green; Coherent Digital (Policy Commons)
Watch for
Papers signed by an AI
iNNOV8, a think tank in Sulaymaniyah, Iraq, launched DARA, a "Dynamic Analysis and Research Assistant" it presents as a human-supervised AI researcher. Its first paper, on AI in think tanks, carries DARA's name as author and the label "Human-Supervised, AI-Generated". iNNOV8 says DARA will propose, outline and draft papers under its researchers' guidance, that DARA's work will be kept apart from human-written work, and that the methods and, where possible, the prompts will be published.
Achieved whenSeveral DARA papers are out with their prompts and methods, and an outside review finds their sources and claims hold up as well as those in the institute's human-written papers.
Claimed by
iNNOV8, as reported by On Think Tanks, June 2026
Open
01
Reports screen readers can read
A yearly public audit of whether think tank reports work for blind and low-vision readers who use screen readers, software that reads the screen aloud. Check tagged structure, reading order, table headers, alt text (written descriptions) for charts and the declared document language, across at least 100 think tanks in five or more countries and across the political spectrum.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Count the broken links
A measure of link rot, web links that no longer work or now show different content, in think tank reports: the share of cited links that still work, by year and organization, and the share of the reports themselves still at their original web address.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Reports screen readers can read
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A yearly public audit of whether think tank reports work for blind and low-vision readers who use screen readers, software that reads the screen aloud. Check tagged structure, reading order, table headers, alt text (written descriptions) for charts and the declared document language, across at least 100 think tanks in five or more countries and across the political spectrum.
Why it is still open
The large audits found cover scholarly papers. Anukriti Kumar and Lucy Lu Wang checked 20,000 scholarly PDFs published from 2014 to 2023 and found that under 3.2% met all six of their criteria and 74.9% met none. This research found no audit of think tank reports, which are mostly self-published PDFs.
Built with what exists
veraPDF, an open-source checker for the PDF/UA accessibility standard; Code for America's open-source asap_pdf audit tool; NVDA, a free screen reader for Windows; paid testers who use screen readers every day.
First step
Run an automated checker on the five newest reports of 20 think tanks and compare its verdicts with a screen reader user's experience of five of them.
Done looks like
The latest 10 reports from each of 100 think tanks scored on the same six criteria Kumar and Wang used; screen reader users test a sample of 50; results published by organization and rerun a year later.
Open 02 · the brief
Count the broken links
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A measure of link rot, web links that no longer work or now show different content, in think tank reports: the share of cited links that still work, by year and organization, and the share of the reports themselves still at their original web address.
Why it is still open
Aaron Gertler and John Bullock showed in 2017 that most links ever published in the American Political Science Review no longer worked as intended, and more than a quarter of those published in 2013 were broken by the end of 2014; that measured a journal. Toby Green of Policy Commons wrote that policy publishers rarely use persistent identifiers, "so link rot is rife", but gave cases, not a rate. This research found no measured rate for think tank reports.
Built with what exists
A web agent or a plain crawler to collect reports (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); GROBID, an open-source tool that pulls reference lists out of PDFs; the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine to tell dead links from moved ones; Policy Commons to find reports that have left their original sites.
First step
Extract the reference lists of 100 reports from ten think tanks, half from 2010 and half from 2020, and test every link.
Done looks like
2,000 reports from 50 think tanks in at least five countries, published from 2005 to 2025; every link tested twice, a month apart; dead and changed-content rates published by year and organization, with the code.