BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Commercial and residential construction / Steel erection

Safety at height

This is the work of keeping erectors, the ironworkers who connect, bolt and deck a frame, from falling while it still has no floors or walls.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1907 to 2019.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1907

    Crews split after Quebec

    Kahnawake Mohawk men, from a reserve near Montreal, had worked high steel since the 1880s, when the Dominion Bridge Company built a bridge from the reserve across the St. Lawrence. By 1907 there were 70 Kahnawake bridge workers, almost half of them on the Quebec Bridge, and when it fell on 29 August 1907, 33 of them died. The women of the community then declared that never again would a large group of Mohawk men work together on the same job, and Kahnawake ironworkers spread out to jobs across North America, New York's towers among them. (The collapse itself is told on the engineering and architecture page.)

    LessonSpreading a crew across jobs limits what one collapse can take from a community.

    canadashistory.casonicmemorial.org

    Credit

    the women of Kahnawake

  2. 1937

    A net under the span

    While the roadway structure of the Golden Gate Bridge was built, Chief Engineer Joseph Strauss had a net of 3/8 in (10 mm) manila rope with a 6 in (15 cm) mesh hung under it from tower to tower, reaching 10 ft (3 m) outside the trusses; it cost $130,000. The bridge district says it saved 19 men, who called themselves the Halfway-to-Hell Club, and that Strauss fired anyone caught stunting. On 17 February 1937 a section of scaffold fell through the net and ten men died; eleven died on the project in all.

    LessonA net sized for falling people does not stop a falling platform.

    goldengate.org

    Credit

    Joseph Strauss

  3. 2001

    Erectors get their own rule

    OSHA had kept steel erection out of its general fall rules and, at the industry's request, had its new rule negotiated by a committee of ironworkers, erectors, builders and regulators, SENRAC, set up on 11 May 1994. The rule, published on 18 January 2001 and in force from 18 January 2002, requires fall protection above 15 ft (4.6 m) instead of the general construction trigger of 6 ft. Connectors, who set each piece as the crane brings it, and deckers in a controlled decking zone may work without tying off up to two stories or 30 ft (9.1 m), and connectors must wear the gear to tie off above 15 ft. It also changes the steel itself: every column needs at least four anchor rods, perimeter columns must stand 48 in (1.2 m) above the floor with holes for safety cables, cables go up as soon as a floor is decked, and shear studs may not be shop-welded to beam tops where erectors walk. OSHA estimated 35 steel erection deaths a year from 1994–98 national data and expected full compliance with the old and new rules to prevent 30 of them.

    osha.govosha.gov

    Credit

    OSHA; the Steel Erection Negotiated Rulemaking Advisory Committee, chaired by Philip J. Harter

  4. 2006

    A slip rule withdrawn

    The 2001 rule also said that from 18 July 2006 erectors could not walk on painted or coated steel unless the coating reached a wet slip resistance of 0.50 on an English XL tribometer, a slip-testing machine, or an equal reading on another. A steel industry coalition and a flooring group challenged it in court, and OSHA settled in 2003. On 18 January 2006 OSHA revoked the provision: the two ASTM test methods it named had no statement of how well they repeat, ASTM was likely to withdraw them, and so employers could not comply.

    LessonA rule that names a number needs a test that gives the same number twice.

    osha.gov

    Credit

    OSHA

  5. 2006

    British default erection methods

    The Steel Construction Institute describes Britain's "default solutions" for erecting steel and lists the BCSA codes of practice for low-rise (2004) and multi-story (2006) buildings as guidance. On single-story frames erectors reach the connections from mobile elevating work platforms (MEWPs, or cherry pickers); on multi-story frames they work from the metal decking or precast planks already placed on the floor below, with nets and edge barriers when the deck goes in.

    steelconstruction.info

    Credit

    BCSA; Steel Construction Institute

  6. 2009

    Falls still lead the deaths

    James Beavers, John Randolph Moore and William Schriver of the University of Tennessee read 166 OSHA case files of steel erection deaths from 2000 to 2005. Falls caused 125 of them, being struck or crushed by objects 40, and electrocution one. The death rate tended to fall over those years, and the authors concluded that employers following the fall protection rules and training workers to spot unsafe conditions could save lives.

    LessonA rule on heights cuts deaths only where employers follow it, by the authors' reading. 0733-9364(2009)135:3(227)).

    doi.org

    Credit

    Beavers, Moore and Schriver

  7. 2019

    Japan requires full harnesses

    From 1 February 2019 Japan's labor rules renamed the "safety belt" as fall-arrest equipment and stopped counting waist belts used for work positioning. A full-body harness, which holds the body at the shoulders, waist and thighs, became the rule; a single-lanyard waist belt is still allowed below 6.75 m, where a harness wearer could hit the ground before the fall is stopped. Workers using a harness 2 m or more up where no work floor can be built must take a special course of 4.5 hours in class and 1.5 hours of practice, and old belts could be used only until 1 January 2022. The health ministry gave as its reasons that waist belts can injure internal organs and squeeze the chest when they stop a fall, and that international standards use full harnesses.

    mhlw.go.jp

    Credit

    Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare

Watch for

  1. Cameras judge hook height

    Researchers at Chongqing University trained a detector on 2,700 drone photos from 17 building sites with tall formwork (the temporary supports for wet concrete) and report a detection score (mAP50, where 1 is perfect) of 0.939 for protective gear, harnesses and hooks. A geometric rule then sorted each hook as correctly anchored high, wrongly anchored low, or unclipped or too far away, with 90.82% accuracy on 305 cases from the field.

    Achieved whenanother group repeats the anchoring result on photos it collects itself, steel erection sites included.

    doi.org

    Claimed by

    Gang Yao, Lang Liu, Yang Yang and Xiaodong Cai, in the journal Sensors, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A slip test that repeats

    A study, run in several laboratories at floor level, of how slippery coated structural steel and steel deck are when wet and dry, measured on the same plates with three kinds of slip tester, with each method's repeatability and reproducibility worked out by ASTM E691, the standard way to compute a test's precision. Walking trials on a beam lying on the floor, with walkers in a ceiling harness of the kind gait labs use, link the readings to how steadily people walk.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Check models for erection rules

    An open-source checker that reads a building's steel model as an IFC file (the open exchange format for building models) and flags every place it breaks a component rule of OSHA's 2001 steel erection standard: columns with fewer than four anchor rods; perimeter columns that stop less than 48 in (1.2 m) above the finished floor or lack cable holes at 42–45 in (107–114 cm); double connections, where two beams share bolts through a column or girder, with no seat to hold the first beam; joists in bays of 40 ft (12.2 m) or more without bolt holes; and shear studs shop-welded to beam tops. Each flag cites its paragraph.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A slip test that repeats

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A study, run in several laboratories at floor level, of how slippery coated structural steel and steel deck are when wet and dry, measured on the same plates with three kinds of slip tester, with each method's repeatability and reproducibility worked out by ASTM E691, the standard way to compute a test's precision. Walking trials on a beam lying on the floor, with walkers in a ceiling harness of the kind gait labs use, link the readings to how steadily people walk.

Why it is still open

OSHA dropped its coated-steel slip rule in 2006 because no test method had a precision statement, and the current rule sets no slip requirement for coated steel or deck. In 2018 Hyunsoo Kim and colleagues wrote that there is still "no accepted or validated standard" for measuring the slipperiness of coated steel beams; their study used eight surfaces and 16 walkers in one lab. A 1995 study for CPWR by William English and William Marletta, which fed the rule, also came from a single team. ASTM's F2508 practice now certifies walkway tribometers against reference surfaces, and a 2020 paper in the Journal of Testing and Evaluation measured the variability of three common walkway tribometers, but neither covers coated steel.

osha.govstore.astm.orgstore.astm.orgpure.psu.eduelcosh.org

Built with what exists

Steel plates coated by fabricators and coating makers (shop primers, zinc-rich and epoxy paints, hot-dip galvanizing, bare mill scale) and offcuts of galvanized and painted deck; a dynamic tribometer of the kind used for the ANSI B101.3 method, a pendulum tester and a variable-incidence tribometer; the ASTM E691 calculation; wearable motion sensors to measure gait stability as Kim and colleagues did.

  1. First step

    Gather eight coated plates and measure them on two devices in one lab, twice a week apart, to see how far the readings drift.

  2. Done looks like

    At least five labs, eight surfaces, wet and dry, five readings per surface per device; published repeatability and reproducibility limits for each device; and walking trials of at least 16 people showing how well each device's readings track gait stability.

Open 02 · the brief

Check models for erection rules

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open-source checker that reads a building's steel model as an IFC file (the open exchange format for building models) and flags every place it breaks a component rule of OSHA's 2001 steel erection standard: columns with fewer than four anchor rods; perimeter columns that stop less than 48 in (1.2 m) above the finished floor or lack cable holes at 42–45 in (107–114 cm); double connections, where two beams share bolts through a column or girder, with no seat to hold the first beam; joists in bays of 40 ft (12.2 m) or more without bolt holes; and shear studs shop-welded to beam tops. Each flag cites its paragraph.

Why it is still open

These provisions are checked by people reading drawings, and they were the reason employers asked OSHA in 2001 to delay the rule. The published BIM safety checkers found deal with falls at slab edges and floor openings (Sijie Zhang, Jochen Teizer, Charles Eastman and others at Georgia Tech) or attach an OSHA checklist to one two-story frame with a new connection type (Tolulope Oyeyipo and colleagues, 2025). Madireddy and colleagues (2025) had large language models write Revit checks for room sizes, materials and object placement, not steel erection rules. No checker for these component rules was found, on the web or on GitHub.

osha.govirbnet.dedoi.orgarxiv.org

Built with what exists

IfcOpenShell, an open Python library for IFC files; IFC exports from Tekla Structures or Revit, where anchor rods and bolts are modeled; the rule text at osha.gov; an AI coding agent that turns each paragraph into a test and runs it on known cases before reporting (see the Note "Checked without being asked").

  1. First step

    Export one small steel frame to IFC and write the four-anchor-rod check, counting the anchor rods at each column base.

  2. Done looks like

    Checks for at least eight rules, run on at least ten real steel models whose owners allow it, plus copies with 50 seeded errors; a published count of errors caught, missed and falsely flagged against a hand check by a structural engineer.