BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / IoT and industrial automation / SCADA integration

Alarms

Alarms on a SCADA system tell a control room, or a person on call at home, that something at a distant site needs attention.

4

Milestones achieved, from 2010 to 2017.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2010

    Alarm practice for pipelines

    The American Petroleum Institute published the first edition of RP 1167, "Pipeline SCADA Alarm Management," in 2010, a recommended practice written for pipeline control rooms. It covers how an operator defines alarms, writes an alarm philosophy (the rules for what deserves an alarm), documents alarms, controls changes to them and audits the system, and it leaves the exact method to each operator.

    catalogue.normdocs.ru

    Credit

    American Petroleum Institute

  2. 2014

    Pump alarms must reach someone

    Recommended Standards for Wastewater Facilities, the design rules that ten US states and later Ontario have published since 1951, require in their 2014 edition an alarm system with backup power at every sewage pumping station, set off by power failure, high water, pump failure or unauthorized entry. The alarm must reach a municipal facility staffed 24 hours a day. Where there is none and the station cannot hold 24 hours of flow, it goes to the office in working hours and to the home of the person in charge out of hours.

    health.state.mn.us

    Credit

    Great Lakes–Upper Mississippi River Board of State and Provincial Public Health and Environmental Managers

  3. 2015

    Alarms off during an upset

    On 19 May 2015 Plains All American's Line 901, a 24-inch crude oil pipeline, ruptured near Refugio State Beach in Santa Barbara County, California, and spilled more than 123,000 gallons, about 21,000 of them into the ocean. By the SCADA record in the company's control room in Midland, Texas, the release began at about 10:55 a.m. and the pressure at Las Flores pump station fell by about 500 psi two minutes later, but the controller did not order the pump stopped until 11:29 a.m. A pump elsewhere on the line had shut down unexpectedly at the same time, and an operator dealing with it had the alarms that would have given earlier notice turned off, PHMSA's final report found; an outside caller told the control room of the spill.

    LessonAlarms silenced to quiet one problem also hide the next one.

    independent.comjuliabrownley.house.gov

    Credit

    PHMSA (investigation); Plains All American (operator)

  4. 2017

    Counting lost control tools

    An energy management system (EMS) is the software, built on SCADA, from which grid operators watch and control the network. NERC's EMS working group published a reference document in December 2017, revised in March 2020, drawn from 521 events between October 2013 and April 2019 in which North American control rooms lost EMS functions for 30 minutes or more. In NERC's follow-up count of 220 such events in 2018–2020, loss of SCADA was the second most common failure, 77 events or 35%, and in several Canadian events in 2019 and 2020 "improper alarm configurations" delayed the moment operators learned a tool had failed. Since 1 April 2019 standard EOP-004-4 has required a report whenever a staffed control centre loses all monitoring or control for 30 minutes or more.

    LessonAn alarm system also needs an alarm for the moment part of it stops working.

    nerc.com

    Credit

    North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC)

Watch for

  1. AI reads grid alarm floods

    The National Laboratory of the Rockies, formerly NREL, says its SCADA Enhanced Alarm Intelligence Tool (SEA-IT), part of its eGridGPT work, reads the alarm database, uses AI agents and Model Context Protocol (MCP) connections to run grid simulations, and offers operators yes-or-no actions, such as re-running a power flow, with the matching procedure. Its slides name floods of "1,000 alarms / hour" among the problems it targets, and the lab's May 2024 report called eGridGPT "the first research effort" to apply large language models in the grid control room.

    Achieved whena utility trial or operator study, measured by someone outside the lab, reports how often its explanations and proposed actions were right.

    osti.govosti.gov

    Claimed by

    Ben Kroposki and Seong Choi, National Laboratory of the Rockies, June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Call-out delays, measured

    A month-long public test of how long SCADA alarm call-outs take to reach an on-call person, and how many never arrive, by text message, voice call, email and app notification, on at least three mobile networks.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A grid alarm flood set

    A public set of simulated SCADA alarm and event streams from cascading outages on public synthetic grids, each labelled with its first cause and the right operator response, for testing alarm processors and AI assistants such as SEA-IT.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Call-out delays, measured

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A month-long public test of how long SCADA alarm call-outs take to reach an on-call person, and how many never arrive, by text message, voice call, email and app notification, on at least three mobile networks.

Why it is still open

Unattended sites depend on these call-outs: the wastewater design standards above require them, and Fresno, California, ran alarm paging software for a groundwater system of about 260 wells, which it replaced in a 2023 upgrade. Searches found vendor articles quoting delivery times of a few seconds without test data. The only regular public measurement found is the yearly test by Singapore's regulator IMDA of ordinary text messages, which reports the share delivered within 15 seconds, 15 minutes and 12 hours on each mobile network (36,150 test messages in 2019), not voice calls, email or app alerts sent by alarm software.

agendas.fresno.govimda.gov.sg

Built with what exists

An open SCADA package that sends alarms, such as FUXA; a cellular modem and a messaging service such as Twilio; phones on three carriers; a script that time-stamps each send and receipt.

  1. First step

    Send 100 timed test texts from one modem to two phones on different carriers and log the arrival times.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 test alarms on each path over 30 days, with median and 99th-percentile delay and the share lost published for each path and carrier, plus a repeat during a busy period such as New Year's Eve.

Open 02 · the brief

A grid alarm flood set

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of simulated SCADA alarm and event streams from cascading outages on public synthetic grids, each labelled with its first cause and the right operator response, for testing alarm processors and AI assistants such as SEA-IT.

Why it is still open

Public alarm flood sets exist for process plants, such as Ning Chen and Wenkai Hu's set from a simulated vinyl acetate plant on IEEE DataPort, and PowerGraph gives cascading grid failures as graphs for machine learning, but not as the stream of alarms an operator sees. Searches found no public grid alarm stream with labelled causes.

ieee-dataport.orgarxiv.org

Built with what exists

pandapower, an open-source Python grid modelling tool; the synthetic grids published by Texas A&M University; written alarm rules for breaker trips, overloads and voltage limits; an AI model to draft cause labels, checked by people.

  1. First step

    Trip one line on a 200-bus synthetic grid in pandapower, let overloaded lines trip in turn, and write out the resulting alarm list.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 200 events on two synthetic grids, each with a time-stamped alarm stream and a first-cause label checked by two power system engineers, published with baseline scores for one rule-based method and one AI model.