Industries / Construction and property / Commercial and residential construction / Roofing
Storm damage and insurance claims
This work judges what wind and hail did to a roof, settles what the insurance policy pays to fix it, and sets the building rules, tests and grants meant to keep the next storm from doing the same.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1992 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
3
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1992
Andrew strips roofs
Hurricane Andrew struck south Florida on 24 August 1992. Thomas L. Smith, writing ten years later in Professional Roofing, the magazine of the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA), gives 25,524 homes destroyed and 101,241 damaged, and property damage of about $40 billion in 2000 dollars. He names roof coverings blown off or punctured by wind-borne debris as the leading cause of damage to building envelopes. Investigators found the wind loads in the South Florida Building Code "grossly inadequate" and its inspections inadequate. The code adopted ASCE 7-88, the national wind-load standard of the time, and was rewritten, and new test methods followed for tile and shingles; a single Florida Building Code was in force across the state from 2002, by the account of the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS).
LessonIn Smith's words, "even a small breach in a building envelope typically led to significant interior water damage".
Credit
Dade County, which rewrote the South Florida Building Code; Thomas L. Smith of NRCA, for the account of the damage
2019
Lab hail replaces steel balls
The standard impact test for roofing, UL 2218, drops a steel ball 1.25 to 2 in across from 12 to 20 ft and grades a product Class 1 to Class 4 on whether it tears, by the account of the asphalt roofing makers' magazine. Some insurers' roof payment schedules give Class 3 and 4 roofs a column of their own. In June 2019 IBHS, a research institute funded by insurers, published a test that fires laboratory-made hailstones, matched to natural hail in density and strength, at shingles bought from stores, and scores the dents, tears and granule loss. IBHS said makers pulled two low-performing products and introduced three new ones within two years. Its fourth ratings, in November 2025, covered 24 products, about 95% of the impact-resistant shingles sold in a year; most rated Good and none Excellent.
LessonIBHS said the older standards "fail to mimic the damage caused by hail", so a pass-or-fail label hid differences that lab-made hail revealed.
asphaltmagazine.comfbfs.comibhs1.wpenginepowered.comibhs.orgibhs.org
Credit
IBHS, at the research center it opened in Chester County, South Carolina, in 2010; Tanya Brown-Giammanco and Ian Giammanco
2020
FORTIFIED roofs face Sally
FORTIFIED Roof is an IBHS standard for building or re-roofing a home: the roof deck is sealed, the roof edges are locked down and impact-resistant shingles are used, and an evaluator checks the work. Alabama passed the Strengthen Alabama Homes Act in 2011 and has given grants of up to $10,000 per roof since 2015, paid for by the insurance industry; 8,660 homes had been retrofitted by May 2025, and the state counted more than 51,000 FORTIFIED homes. When Hurricane Sally struck Gulf Shores as a strong Category 2 storm in September 2020, the University of Alabama's Center for Risk and Insurance Research studied insurers' data on more than 40,000 coastal homes for the state insurance department. It found that FORTIFIED cut the frequency of losses by 55% to 74% and the average claim by 15% to 40%, leaving out claims from fallen trees.
LessonFORTIFIED homes also beat code-built homes with the same requirements but no evaluation, which the state put down to FORTIFIED's checks, though the study did not test the cause.
Credit
IBHS; the Alabama Department of Insurance; the University of Alabama Center for Risk and Insurance Research
2022
Florida rewrites roof claims
A law of May 2022 (Chapter 2022-268) made contractors' written or electronic solicitations for roof claims carry a notice that the homeowner owes the deductible and that a contractor who pays or waives it commits a third-degree felony. It let insurers add a separate roof deductible of up to 2% of the policy's dwelling limit or 50% of the roof's replacement cost, which the homeowner may decline and which does not apply to hurricanes. It also barred insurers from refusing to write or renew a policy solely because a roof is under 15 years old, and made them accept an inspection showing five or more years of life left on older roofs. A second law in December 2022 (Chapter 2022-271) banned the assignment of benefits, in which a homeowner signs the claim over to a contractor, in policies issued from 1 January 2023, and ended one-way attorney fees in property insurance suits.
Credit
Florida Legislature
2022
Ian finds shingles no better
Hurricane Ian came ashore near Punta Gorda, Florida, on 28 September 2022 as a Category 4 storm, close to where Hurricane Charley had struck in 2004. Using aerial imagery from NOAA and EagleView and street-level photos from the National Science Foundation's StEER reconnaissance teams, IBHS found detectable damage on one in two asphalt shingle roofs, about the same rate as after Charley, showing "little progress" in shingles' wind resistance in 18 years. Shingle roofs 10 or more years old had over a 75% chance of damage in gusts of 110 mph and above. Steep metal roofs had a damage rate near 12%, and tile roofs did far better than in 2004.
LessonAs after Charley, the age of a shingle roof was the best predictor of whether it was damaged.
Credit
Ian Giammanco, Emily Newby and Hank Pogorzelski, IBHS, 2023
2024
Limits on photos from above
Insurers use aerial and satellite photos to judge roof condition, including when deciding whether to renew a policy. Louisiana's Act 151 of 2024 bars an insurer from relying solely on aerial images to identify the condition behind a cancellation or non-renewal unless the images were taken within 24 months. Other states followed: by the count of Nearmap, an aerial imagery company, Colorado, Georgia and Kentucky now cap the image age at 12 months, Rhode Island at 15, and Louisiana, Indiana and Vermont at 24. Colorado's bulletin of March 2026 says visible conditions in aerial images should not alone justify adverse action, which must rest on "material degradation or functional damage, not cosmetic appearance alone".
Credit
Louisiana Legislature; state insurance regulators
2025
Roofs paid by age
A roof payment schedule pays a falling share of the cost to replace a roof damaged by wind or hail as the roof ages, with separate rates by material; Farm Bureau Financial Services' schedule, for example, has its own column for roofs rated UL Class 3 or 4. This is actual cash value (ACV) settlement: replacement cost minus an allowance for wear. ZestyAI, which sells risk models to insurers, analyzed more than 2,000 homeowners insurance filings from about 60 insurers in states with frequent catastrophes. It found that among the ten largest US home insurers, ACV roof schedules rose from 10% of policies in 2015 to 60% in 2025, and exclusions for cosmetic damage and for matching undamaged materials from 20% to 90%. ACV roof schedules appeared in 85% of the Oklahoma filings it reviewed and 82% of the Texas ones.
Credit
US home insurers; ZestyAI for the count, July 2026
Watch for
Roof age read from above
Nearmap says Roof Age Gen2 combines its own aerial imagery with permits, assessor records and climate data, and gives the year a roof was installed within one year of the true date 95% of the time, for nearly every parcel in the contiguous US. ZestyAI says it refit its roof-age model on twice the data and cross-checks permits against imagery to catch permits that were filed but not carried out. Insurers use such ages to set prices and roof payment schedules.
Achieved whenan outside party scores either model against a published set of homes whose replacement years come from records the vendors did not use.
Claimed by
Nearmap and ZestyAI, October 2025
Open
01
Hail marks with known causes
An open image set of shingle panels struck at ground level with known impact energies and photographed the way adjusters and drones photograph roofs, with every mark labeled by its cause and its measured damage (granule loss, dent, tear). Add look-alike marks that are not hail, such as blisters, scuffs, nail pops and factory flaws. Then score AI damage detectors and general image models against it.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A public roof-age answer key
A public set of at least 1,000 homes whose roof replacement year is set by two independent records, a city re-roofing permit and a visible change between dated public aerial photos, for scoring roof-age estimates from vendors and from open models.
The briefCredit · unclaimed03
Roof claim terms by insurer
A public table, one row per insurer, state and policy form, of the roof terms in homeowners policies filed with state regulators: roof payment schedules by age and material, separate roof deductibles, cosmetic-damage exclusions, matching wording and roof-age rules, with the filing number on every row.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Hail marks with known causes
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open image set of shingle panels struck at ground level with known impact energies and photographed the way adjusters and drones photograph roofs, with every mark labeled by its cause and its measured damage (granule loss, dent, tear). Add look-alike marks that are not hail, such as blisters, scuffs, nail pops and factory flaws. Then score AI damage detectors and general image models against it.
Why it is still open
IBHS strikes shingles with lab-made hail and publishes ratings, not images, and its protocol says its damage categories "are not intended for use in the adjustment of insurance claims or inspection operations". A 2017 study by Mahshad Mahdavi Hezaveh, Christopher Kanan and Carl Salvaggio trained image networks on drone photos of hail-damaged roofs, but its dataset was not found published. Searches in November 2026 found a few small hail-damage image sets on Roboflow Universe, a site for sharing labeled images, and none described as made from impacts of known size and energy.
Built with what exists
Shingle bundles from building-supply stores; plywood test decks on a sloped stand at ground level; a fenced drop frame with UL 2218-size steel balls, 1.25 to 2 in across, released by an electromagnet raised on a pulley so the operator stays on the ground; ice spheres frozen in silicone molds; calipers and a scale; a phone camera and a small drone camera; open object detectors such as YOLO and general image models.
First step
Build one 4 ft by 4 ft (1.2 m by 1.2 m) sloped test deck, shingle it with one product, and photograph the results of 50 controlled drops at two energies.
Done looks like
At least 2,000 labeled marks from 10 or more shingle products at four impact energies, plus 500 marks that are not hail; published hit rates and false-alarm rates by mark type for at least three detectors; a second labeler agreeing on a random 10% of marks.
Open 02 · the brief
A public roof-age answer key
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public set of at least 1,000 homes whose roof replacement year is set by two independent records, a city re-roofing permit and a visible change between dated public aerial photos, for scoring roof-age estimates from vendors and from open models.
Why it is still open
Vendors publish only their own accuracy figures, and their models use permits themselves. The one public set found, released by Chris Heinrich and colleagues in 2020, covers about 230 commercial and industrial buildings in Southern California, with reroof years from Los Angeles permits checked by eye; its authors named residential roofs as a direction for future work.
Built with what exists
City open-data permit records; USDA National Agriculture Imagery Program (NAIP) aerial photos, free through Google Earth Engine or Microsoft's Planetary Computer; county assessor records of the year built; an open change-detection model; Heinrich and colleagues' reroof data and code as a starting point.
First step
Download one city's re-roofing permits for 2015 to 2020 and check 50 of them against NAIP images taken before and after.
Done looks like
1,000 homes in at least three metropolitan areas, each with a permit date and a dated image pair showing the change; error distributions published for at least one open model and for any vendor that agrees to be scored; all data released openly.
Open 03 · the brief
Roof claim terms by insurer
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table, one row per insurer, state and policy form, of the roof terms in homeowners policies filed with state regulators: roof payment schedules by age and material, separate roof deductibles, cosmetic-damage exclusions, matching wording and roof-age rules, with the filing number on every row.
Why it is still open
ZestyAI's July 2026 analysis of more than 2,000 filings published only percentages, and the data sit in its paid platform. Nearmap's state table covers only the rules on aerial imagery. One regulator has done part of the job for one state: in April 2020 the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance published a tool describing roof coverage at the state's 20 largest home insurers, but the insurer pages tried in November 2026 returned "page not found". No public table found joins roof terms by insurer and state across states.
Built with what exists
SERFF Filing Access, the public portal through which many state regulators post insurers' rate and form filings; a browser agent that collects filings slowly and within each site's terms (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); an AI model that reads the policy forms into a table (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a person checking a sample.
First step
Pull the current homeowners form filings of five insurers in Texas and Oklahoma and code their roof terms by hand.
Done looks like
The roof terms of the 30 largest home insurers in 10 states exposed to hail or hurricanes, each row linked to its filing, a second reader agreeing on at least 95% of a random 10% of rows, published under an open license and refreshed every quarter.