BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Religious organizations

Buildings

Faith bodies own, repair, heat and protect places of worship and the buildings around them, and decide what happens to the ones they can no longer keep.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1905 to 2025.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1905

    Places of worship go public

    France's law of 9 December 1905 separated churches and state. The Republic stopped paying for any religion, but places of worship that the state, departments or communes owned at the separation stayed public, and the law left them free of charge to the associations that run worship; a law of 2 January 1907 kept them available to worshippers and clergy even where no such association was formed. Public owners may pay to maintain and conserve these buildings, while the associations may receive no other public subsidy. The ban on subsidy also covered new buildings, so councils turned to long leases: in 2003 the council of Montreuil-sous-Bois approved a 99-year lease of 1,693 m² of council land for a mosque at a symbolic €1 a year, and on 19 July 2011 the Conseil d'État, France's highest administrative court, upheld such leases as a deliberate exception to the 1905 ban.

    Lessonownership decides who pays for the roof, and a ban on public money for new places of worship needed a separate legal route for communities building now.

    conseil-etat.fr

    Credit

    French Parliament (laws of 1905 and 1907); Conseil d'État (five decisions of 19 July 2011)

  2. 1969

    A fund for closed churches

    The Church of England's Pastoral Measure 1968, approved by Parliament, set up the Redundant Churches Fund in 1969 to keep closed Anglican churches of historic or architectural value. It took its first church, St Peter's at Edlington in South Yorkshire, in 1971 and was renamed the Churches Conservation Trust in 1994; by its own count it cared for 147 churches by 1979, 320 by 1999 and more than 350 today. In the year to 31 March 2025 its income of £12.0 million included £2,997,002 of government grant, by the Charity Commission's register. The trust takes only a small share of closures: a Church Buildings Council study by Guy Braithwaite (February 2020) counted 1,974 Anglican closures from 1969 to 2018, and of 272 closed churches disposed of from 2004 to 2018, 207 went to another use, 47 were demolished and 18 passed to the trust.

    Lessonpreservation by a national trust is the exception, and most closed churches survive only by finding a new use.

    visitchurches.org.ukregister-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.ukhrballiance.org.uk

    Credit

    Church of England and Parliament (Pastoral Measure 1968); Churches Conservation Trust; Church Buildings Council

  3. 2005

    Paying for security

    The US Nonprofit Security Grant Program, run by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), began in 2005 with $25 million to help nonprofits at risk of terrorist attack, religious institutions among them, pay for physical security. It funds work such as hardening buildings, access control, cameras, cybersecurity and training, and by the Congressional Research Service's count its yearly funding reached $454 million in fiscal 2024 and $275 million in fiscal 2025. Britain's Home Office set up a scheme for places of worship in England and Wales in 2016; in its 2019-20 round 49 sites received funding, 27 mosques, 13 churches, 5 gurdwaras and 4 Hindu temples, with a central contractor installing locks, lighting and CCTV, while Jewish sites had a separate grant administered by the Community Security Trust (CST). The scheme, now the Protective Security for Faith Communities Scheme, sits beside separate schemes for Jewish and Muslim communities, and it does not pay for upkeep after the funded period.

    Lessongovernments now pay for one-off security works at places of worship, but keeping those measures working stays with the congregation.

    everycrsreport.comgov.ukgov.uk

    Credit

    US Congress and FEMA; UK Home Office; Congressional Research Service

  4. 2018

    Dutch towns plan every church

    The Dutch national heritage agency, the Rijksdienst voor het Cultureel Erfgoed (RCE), started the Toekomst Religieus Erfgoed (future of religious heritage) program in 2018 with municipalities, provinces, church bodies and heritage groups. Its main tool is the kerkenvisie, or "church vision": a town-wide plan, made with building owners and residents, that sets which places of worship stay in religious use and which take on another use. Between 2019 and 2021 the national government paid 240 municipalities €25,000 to €75,000 each, scaled to how many church buildings they had, €9.2 million in all for towns holding 5,399 church buildings, and by the program's count about 70% of Dutch municipalities now have a kerkenvisie. Its count finds about 7,100 places of worship in the Netherlands, about 5,000 of them still in religious use, with 298 going out of use from 2021 to 2025, about 60 a year. On 11 November 2026 the program was renewed for 2026 to 2029 at €1 million a year.

    Lessonin the RCE's words, a town with a kerkenvisie is not faced with a fait accompli each time a church closes.

    toekomstreligieuserfgoed.nlbinnenlandsbestuur.nltoekomstreligieuserfgoed.nl

    Credit

    RCE and the Ministry of Education, Culture and Science, with partners including the municipalities' association VNG, the provinces' IPO and the churches' CIO-K

  5. 2019

    Notre-Dame burns

    On 15 April 2019 fire brought down the spire of Notre-Dame de Paris, a cathedral owned by the French state, and destroyed its centuries-old roof timbers. The Cour des comptes, France's public audit court, reported in September 2020 that ownership of the site was split between the state and the City of Paris and that responsibility for safety was shared in a complex way. It found that the failure to anticipate the expiry, in early 2019, of the agreement organizing fire safety between the state's heritage architect, the cathedral's rector and the Centre des monuments nationaux showed too little attention to the issue, and it faulted the ministry for opening no administrative inquiry. In October 2019 the Ministry of Culture, owner of 89 places of worship including 87 cathedrals, reviewed their safety systems and launched a €2 million "cathedral safety" plan. A public body created on 1 December 2019 ran the restoration, paid for by a national appeal that passed €843 million, and the cathedral reopened on 7 December 2024 with an automatic water-mist system in its roof frame; by the ministry's account, the court's third report, in September 2025, found budget and deadlines kept.

    Lessonwhen ownership, worship and visitor management sit with different bodies, a basic fire-safety agreement can run out without anyone preparing for it.

    ccomptes.frculture.gouv.frparis.frculture.gouv.fr

    Credit

    Cour des comptes; French Ministry of Culture; Rebâtir Notre-Dame de Paris, the public restoration body

  6. 2020

    Net zero by 2030 slips

    In February 2020 the Church of England's General Synod voted for the whole church to reach net zero carbon by 2030, and in July 2022 it endorsed a routemap that binds no part of the church. Churches report their energy bills through an online Energy Footprint Tool. In the church's footprint for 2024, usable data came from 63% of church buildings, up from 54.2% a year earlier; churches alone emitted an estimated 80,501 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent, and all its buildings, including schools and clergy housing, plus work travel, 365,996 tonnes. In 2022 it also changed the rules of its faculty system, the church's own consent process for building work, which under England's "ecclesiastical exemption" takes the place of council consent for listed buildings, so that decisions must have due regard to net zero guidance. A revised routemap put to Synod in July 2026, using forecasts by the consultancy Arup, expects a cut of about 29% from the 2023 level by 2030, about half of it from a cleaner electricity grid, and found only 7% of dioceses, the districts a bishop oversees, reporting that a rule against new oil boilers was being enforced. A Methodist Church report the same year also said it would not be net zero by 2030.

    Lessona church-wide target set before the estate was fully measured, and without binding local rules, can fall far short.

    churchofengland.orgchurchofengland.orglawandreligionuk.comlegislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    General Synod and the Church of England Net Zero Carbon Programme; Arup; the Methodist Church

  7. 2025

    Repair refunds capped, then ended

    From 2001 the UK's Listed Places of Worship Grant Scheme refunded the VAT, a 20% sales tax, paid on repairs to listed places of worship of any faith. An evaluation for the culture department by Harlow Consulting counted about £300 million paid in more than 70,000 grants from 2014 to 2024, with a median grant of £1,764, and judged the scheme good value for money. In January 2025 the government cut the budget to £23 million and capped claims at £25,000 per place of worship a year from 1 April 2025, expecting 94% of claims to be unaffected. On 22 January 2026 it confirmed that the scheme would end, so repairs carry the full 20% VAT from 1 April 2026, and replaced it with the £92 million, four-year Places of Worship Renewal Fund for England only. That fund opened on 20 May 2026 with competitive grants of £10,000 to £1 million and priority for the most deprived areas.

    Lessonthe new fund's smallest grant is more than five times the old scheme's median refund, so the many small repairs the refund covered fall below its floor.

    gov.uklawandreligionuk.combristol.anglican.orgfind-government-grants.service.gov.uk

    Credit

    UK Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS); Harlow Consulting; Historic England

Watch for

  1. A diocese halves its churches

    The Catholic diocese of Fulda in Germany says it will cut its roughly 400 churches to about 200 by 2035. Its property plan sorts its buildings into three funding classes: the diocese keeps helping to pay for half of them (classes A and B), while the other half (class C) gets no more diocesan money and must find other funding to stay in use. The German bishops' guidance of 2003 calls demolition of a church the last resort, and by the German Bishops' Conference press office's count, 611 Catholic churches in Germany ended all liturgical use from 2000, of which 201 were sold.

    Achieved whenthe diocese publishes which churches fall in each class, and a later count by the diocese or a state heritage office shows how many class C churches closed, were sold or found other funding.

    hessenschau.dede.euronews.combistum-osnabrueck.de

    Claimed by

    Diocese of Fulda, February 2026

  2. Hagia Sophia's domes strengthened

    Turkey's Ministry of Culture and Tourism is strengthening the domes of Hagia Sophia in Istanbul, now a working mosque, against earthquakes while worship and visits continue. Members of the scientific committee overseeing the work say numerical models showed that the main dome must be strengthened together with its semi-domes; a temporary steel roof over the main dome is complete, and a steel platform is going in to reinforce the eastern semi-dome, which a committee architect called the most vulnerable part of the building. A committee member said many stages should be finished in 2027.

    Achieved whenthe strengthening is finished and an engineering or heritage body outside the ministry publishes its assessment of the completed work.

    hurriyetdailynews.com

    Claimed by

    Ministry of Culture and Tourism and its scientific committee, September 2026

  3. AI that spots church cracks

    Researchers at the University of Genoa, the Bruno Kessler Foundation and Sapienza University of Rome trained an image model to flag cracks in photos of church interiors, to support damage surveys after earthquakes. Trained only on concrete images, it scored 98% accuracy on concrete but much worse on churches; retrained on photos from churches in Liguria, it reached 93.87% precision (the share of flagged image squares that really held cracks) and 88.45% recall (the share of cracked squares it found) on frescoed vaults. The authors note that it classifies small image squares, not whole defects.

    Achieved whena team outside the authors' group tests it on other churches and matches its findings, defect by defect, against damage surveys made by engineers on site.

    cris.fbk.eu

    Claimed by

    Matteo Bozzano, Mohamedelmustafa Omer Eid, Serena Cattari and Bianca Federici, in Applied Geomatics, May 2026

Open

  1. 01

    An all-faith closure table

    An open table of every listed place of worship in one English city region, then all of England, of every faith and denomination. Each row is one building from the National Heritage List for England with its listing grade, its faith or denomination, whether it is still used for worship, the year it closed if it did, and what it became: another congregation, homes, community use, ruin or demolished. Each fact links to a public record, such as the Church of England's Church Heritage Record, closure schemes, council planning decisions on change of use, the General Register Office list of registered places of worship or OpenStreetMap. Buildings only: no people, attendance or membership data.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Heating estimates from public data

    An open model that estimates the yearly heating energy (kWh) and carbon of each place of worship in England, of any faith, from public data alone: footprint and height from OpenStreetMap and Environment Agency LIDAR, age and construction from listing text, local temperatures turned into heating degree days (a measure of how much heating a year's weather calls for), and whether the site is near the gas grid. It gives each building an estimate with an error band.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Photo surveys checked against architects

    A tested method to find roof, stone and rainwater defects, such as slipped slates, open joints, cracks, plant growth and blocked gutters, in drone or pole-camera photos of historic places of worship, scored defect by defect against the approved consultant's own condition report on the same building from the same season. Publish the protocol, labeled images and scores. Publish condition findings only, never access or security details, and work only with the owner's permission.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An all-faith closure table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table of every listed place of worship in one English city region, then all of England, of every faith and denomination. Each row is one building from the National Heritage List for England with its listing grade, its faith or denomination, whether it is still used for worship, the year it closed if it did, and what it became: another congregation, homes, community use, ruin or demolished. Each fact links to a public record, such as the Church of England's Church Heritage Record, closure schemes, council planning decisions on change of use, the General Register Office list of registered places of worship or OpenStreetMap. Buildings only: no people, attendance or membership data.

Why it is still open

Church Action on Poverty, mapping closures in five Christian denominations in Greater Manchester from 2010 to 2020, found that a complete set of data "was not publicly available for all the denominations" and built its own from directories, year books and news reports. The General Register Office list cannot stand in, because there is no obligation to de-register, so many closed buildings stay on it. The Church Heritage Record marks closed Anglican churches only. The Netherlands shows it can be done: its national count, now merged into the volunteer database Reliwiki, supports figures on closure and reuse.

church-poverty.org.ukwiki.openstreetmap.orgheritage.churchofengland.orgtoekomstreligieuserfgoed.nl

Built with what exists

The Planning Data platform's listed-building data set, Historic England data under the Open Government Licence as CSV or GeoJSON; the General Register Office register on data.gov.uk; the Church Heritage Record; council planning portals read with Browser Use 1.0 (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); decision notices and closure schemes parsed with Meta Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python (pandas, GeoPandas) and QGIS for the joins.

planning.data.gov.uk

  1. First step

    Download the listed-building CSV for one city region, filter entries whose names include church, chapel, meeting house, synagogue, mosque, temple or gurdwara, and publish the count with a hand-checked sample of 50 rows.

  2. Done looks like

    For one city region, every listed place of worship has a status and a cited public source; an independent hand check of 100 random rows finds at least 95% correct; the Anglican rows agree with the Church Heritage Record's closed-church flags; and the same method, run nationally for Anglican closures, reproduces the Church Buildings Council's outcome counts for 2004 to 2018 (207 to another use, 47 demolished, 18 to the Churches Conservation Trust) within 10%.

Open 02 · the brief

Heating estimates from public data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open model that estimates the yearly heating energy (kWh) and carbon of each place of worship in England, of any faith, from public data alone: footprint and height from OpenStreetMap and Environment Agency LIDAR, age and construction from listing text, local temperatures turned into heating degree days (a measure of how much heating a year's weather calls for), and whether the site is near the gas grid. It gives each building an estimate with an error band.

Why it is still open

Places of worship are exempt from Energy Performance Certificates in England and Wales, so they have no public energy rating. The Church of England's footprint for 2024 had usable data from 63% of its churches and filled the gaps with internal estimates based on location, building size and occupancy, for Anglican buildings only. In the US, the Energy Information Administration publishes averages for religious worship buildings, 35.3 thousand Btu per square foot a year with 45% of it for space heating, not estimates building by building.

gov.ukchurchofengland.orgeia.gov

Built with what exists

Python with scikit-learn or LightGBM; OpenStreetMap building footprints; Environment Agency LIDAR heights; Met Office HadUK-Grid temperature data; the Planning Data listed-building data set; published case studies with meter readings from the Church of England, the Methodist Church and Historic England as training and test data, pulled from PDFs with Meta Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); the EIA's CBECS survey data as a cross-check.

  1. First step

    Gather 50 published case studies that state a place of worship's yearly gas, oil or electricity use and its floor area into one open spreadsheet.

  2. Done looks like

    On at least 50 places of worship with published yearly meter readings, held out from training, the median error is under 30%; and the model's total for Church of England churches falls within 10% of the church's published 2024 estimate of 80,501 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent.

Open 03 · the brief

Photo surveys checked against architects

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A tested method to find roof, stone and rainwater defects, such as slipped slates, open joints, cracks, plant growth and blocked gutters, in drone or pole-camera photos of historic places of worship, scored defect by defect against the approved consultant's own condition report on the same building from the same season. Publish the protocol, labeled images and scores. Publish condition findings only, never access or security details, and work only with the owner's permission.

Why it is still open

Church of England churches must have a condition inspection by an approved consultant at least once every five years, the quinquennial inspection, and roofs and rainwater goods were the works most often paid for under the government's repair refund scheme. Conservation writers argued in 2015 that drone photos can feed these inspections, and the makers of a digital twin of St Peter's Basilica said in November 2024 that its images had found cracks and missing mosaic pieces, but neither published a measured comparison with an inspection. The closest study, from Genoa in May 2026, scores small image squares for cracks inside churches.

gov.ukbuildingconservation.comirishexaminer.comcris.fbk.eu

Built with what exists

OpenDroneMap or COLMAP for photogrammetry, which builds 3D models from overlapping photos; Liquid AI LFM3 open-weight vision models, fine-tuned on one GPU (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune"); QGIS for defect maps; photos taken from the ground or a pole, or supplied by a drone operator who holds the needed permissions.

  1. First step

    Ask one parish or diocesan advisory committee for a recent quinquennial report and permission to photograph that building, and log the report's listed defects as the first test set.

  2. Done looks like

    On at least 10 buildings, the method finds at least 80% of the external defects listed in the inspection reports, and at least 80% of what it flags is confirmed by an architect not involved in the project, with location and type matched for each defect.