Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Religious organizations
Giving and finance
Giving and finance is how congregations and faith bodies raise money, from offerings and zakat to church taxes and endowments, and how they count it, invest it and report it.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1919 to 2022.
3
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
3
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1919
Churches tax through the state
Article 137(6) of the Weimar Constitution of 11 August 1919, which Article 140 of Germany's Basic Law makes part of today's constitution, lets religious societies that are public-law corporations levy taxes based on the civil tax lists, under the law of each state (Land). In Berlin the church tax is 9% of a member's income tax. Employers withhold it along with wage tax, and the Protestant, Roman Catholic and Old Catholic churches run joint church-tax offices inside Berlin's tax offices. Since 1 January 2015 banks and insurers have withheld it automatically on capital income: each year they ask the Federal Central Tax Office (BZSt) whether each customer belongs to a church that levies the tax, and a customer can block that query and pay through their tax return instead. Leaving ends the liability. In Berlin a person declares it at the local court, which tells the registration office, and the German Bishops' Conference counted 307,117 people leaving the Catholic Church in 2025, after 321,659 in 2024.
Lessonwhen gifts are collected as a tax, a church's income depends on its register of members, and each formal exit ends one person's payments.
gesetze-im-internet.deservice.berlin.deservice.berlin.debistummainz.de
Credit
the German Constitution of 1919, carried into the Basic Law; the states' church-tax laws; Bundeszentralamt für Steuern; German Bishops' Conference
1979
Self-regulation instead of filing
A 1969 amendment to the US tax code (Public Law 91-172) excused churches, their integrated auxiliaries and conventions or associations of churches from filing the annual information return, now Form 990, that most tax-exempt groups file. In 1977 Senator Mark Hatfield asked evangelical groups to be more open about their money, and in 1979 they founded the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability (ECFA), an accreditor whose members agree to its financial standards; Christianity Today reported in 2019 that it had nearly 2,400 members. Senator Chuck Grassley wrote to six media-based ministries in November 2007, and his staff review, released on 6 January 2011, found that four gave incomplete information or none. He asked ECFA to lead a response in place of new law, and in December 2012 its Commission on Accountability and Policy for Religious Organizations issued a 91-page report with 43 recommendations and no mandates. Securities law still applies: in February 2023 the SEC found that the investment manager of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Ensign Peak Advisors, had from 1997 through 2019 failed to file the holdings reports (Forms 13F) that large investment managers must file, and had created thirteen shell companies to file in their names; Ensign Peak paid a $4 million penalty and the church $1 million.
Lessonan exemption from tax filing does not exempt a faith body's investments from the disclosure rules that bind every large investor.
law.cornell.edufinance.senate.govchristianitytoday.comchristianitytoday.comsec.gov
Credit
US Congress; ECFA; Senate Finance Committee staff under Senator Grassley; US Securities and Exchange Commission
1980
Banks deduct zakat at source
Zakat is the obligatory alms of Islam. Under Pakistan's Zakat and Ushr Ordinance, 1980, banks deduct it once a year, on the first day of Ramadan, from savings, profit-and-loss sharing and similar accounts, and pay it into the Central Zakat Account (CZ-08) at the State Bank of Pakistan. By Allied Bank's account, the deduction is 2.5% of the whole eligible balance. It applies only when the balance reaches the nisab, the minimum that the Administrator General Zakat sets each year: Rs 179,689 for the deduction of March 2025 and Rs 503,529 for February 2026, by the notices that the Ministry of Poverty Alleviation and Social Safety sent to the State Bank. People who pay zakat another way can file a notarized declaration, Form CZ-50, at least 30 days before the deduction date.
Lessoncompulsory deduction at source depends on a threshold published every year and a legal route out for people who pay another way.
Credit
Government of Pakistan; Administrator General Zakat; State Bank of Pakistan; banks acting as collecting agents
1985
Taxpayers choose a recipient
After Italy and the Holy See revised their Concordat in 1984, Law 222 of 20 May 1985 set aside, from 1990, eight per thousand (0.8%) of personal income tax (IRPEF) for either the state's social and humanitarian purposes or the Catholic Church, as each taxpayer chooses on the annual return. Other bodies joined through agreements (intese) with the state; for income of 2022, paid out in 2026, the Finance Department's recipients include the Waldensian and Methodist churches, the Lutheran church, the Union of Italian Jewish Communities, the Italian Buddhist Union and the Italian Hindu Union. Only 40.20% of 42,026,960 taxpayers made a valid choice, and the shares of those who did not are divided in proportion to the choices made, except for bodies that waive them. Of the valid choices, 67.27% named the Catholic Church through its bishops' conference (CEI), whose advance came to €1,062,957,279; 26.80% named the state and 2.94% the Waldensian church. In 2014 the Court of Audit (Corte dei conti) found that this rule roughly tripled the largest recipient's income, about €300 million by stated choice and €700 million from taxpayers' silence, and that controls on how the money was used were scarce.
Lessonthe default for people who make no choice can move more money than the choices themselves.
Credit
Italian Parliament and the Holy See; Ministry of Economy and Finance, Department of Finance; Corte dei conti, Deliberation 16/2014
2013
Vatican bank opens its books
The Institute for the Works of Religion (IOR), known as the Vatican bank, published its first annual report in October 2013, covering 2012, and hired the US firm Promontory Financial Group to review the accounts of its roughly 19,000 customers. Its thirteenth report, in June 2025, gave 2024 accounts under international accounting standards: more than 12,000 clients in more than 110 countries and a clean opinion from the auditor Mazars Italia. Moneyval, the Council of Europe's anti-money-laundering evaluator, found in 2021 that results in Vatican courts were "modest", with two convictions for self-laundering. On 16 December 2023, after 86 hearings, the Vatican Tribunal gave its first-instance judgment on ten defendants and four companies over a building at 60 Sloane Avenue in London, finding the illicit use of $200.5 million, about one-third of the funds then available to the Secretariat of State.
Lessonpublishing one institution's accounts did not govern how another office of the same body invested its money.
Credit
IOR; Promontory Financial Group; Mazars Italia; Moneyval; Vatican Tribunal
2020
Endowment cash buys state sukuk
A waqf is a permanent Islamic endowment whose returns serve a fixed purpose, and a sukuk is a certificate that works much like a bond while following Islamic rules. On 10 March 2020 Indonesia's Ministry of Finance issued the first Cash Waqf Linked Sukuk, series SW001, by private placement to Badan Wakaf Indonesia (BWI), the national waqf board, with a face value of Rp50,849,000,000. The five-year sukuk could not be traded and was sold at a discount, so BWI paid Rp48,306,550,000; the ministry paid coupons to BWI, and the waqf money was to come back in full at maturity. The returns paid for a retina and glaucoma center at the Achmad Wardi Eye Hospital in Serang, Banten, built by BWI and the charity Dompet Dhuafa on waqf land; it opened on 21 October 2020 with a target of free surgery for 2,513 poor patients over five years. A retail series, SWR001, followed.
Lessonplacing endowment cash in a government instrument keeps the principal intact while its yield pays for a named project.
Credit
Ministry of Finance of Indonesia; Badan Wakaf Indonesia with Dompet Dhuafa; study by Najim Nur Fauziah and colleagues, IIUM Institute of Islamic Banking and Finance
2022
Japan curbs donation pressure
Japan's Act on Preventing Unjust Solicitation of Donations by Corporations (Act No. 105 of 16 December 2022) covers any corporation, association or foundation that asks for donations. It bars asking a donor to borrow money, or to sell the home they live in or business assets they depend on, in order to give. Donors can cancel gifts obtained by the tactics it bans, and people owed regular support payments by a donor can use those rights to protect their support. In October 2023 Japan's education ministry asked a court to dissolve the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification as a religious corporation. Tokyo District Court ordered dissolution in March 2025, the first such order based on illegal acts under the Civil Code, finding by Jiji Press's report that 1,559 people had been unlawfully solicited for about ¥20.4 billion over roughly 40 years. Tokyo High Court upheld the order on 4 March 2026, ending the group's tax benefits as a religious corporation, and the Supreme Court rejected a special appeal in June 2026.
LessonJapan's courts treated long-running unlawful solicitation of donations as harm serious enough to end a group's status as a religious corporation.
japaneselawtranslation.go.jpenglish.adnkronos.comenglish.adnkronos.com
Credit
National Diet of Japan; Tokyo District Court; Tokyo High Court; Supreme Court of Japan
Watch for
AI questions about giving data
On 10 December 2025 Pushpay, a US company that sells giving and management software to churches, launched AI features across its products. One, "AI for Giving Data", lets church finance staff ask plain-language questions, such as how this quarter's giving compares with the last or how giving by channel has moved over two years, and get charts back. The company says it delivers insights "in seconds", saves ministry teams hours each month and keeps user permissions in place.
Achieved whenan independent party, such as an auditor or a research group, checks a sample of the tool's answers against the underlying ledgers and publishes accuracy and time-saved figures.
Claimed by
Pushpay, December 2025
Vatican investments, shared control
A motu proprio is a papal decree issued on the pope's own initiative. In Coniuncta cura, signed on 29 September 2025 and published on 6 October 2025, Pope Leo XIV repealed an instruction of 23 August 2022 on managing the Holy See's financial assets and liquidity, and required all Holy See investment to follow the rules of its Investment Committee and the approved investment policy. The Administration of the Patrimony of the Apostolic See (APSA) is as a rule to invest through the IOR, but may use financial intermediaries in other countries when the competent bodies judge that more efficient or convenient. The decree says it adopts in full the recommendations of the Council for the Economy.
Achieved whenan outside reviewer, such as Moneyval in a follow-up report or the external auditor of the Holy See's accounts, reports how investments were made and controlled under the new rules.
Claimed by
Pope Leo XIV, October 2025
Machine counting of temple offerings
A hundi is the offering box at a Hindu temple, and the parakamani is the counting of its contents. In a case about alleged theft during the parakamani at Tirumala, the Andhra Pradesh High Court directed Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD), the board that runs the temple, to submit a plan for immediate reforms within two weeks and a rough draft of permanent reforms within eight weeks. The court suggested technology, computerized records and AI to sort the contents, separate and grade currencies of different countries and denominations, pick out coins, precious metals and stones, and support surveillance. LiveLaw reported the directions on 22 December 2025.
Achieved whenTTD runs automated counting in the parakamani and the court, an auditor or another outside party reports how it performed.
Claimed by
Andhra Pradesh High Court (Justice Gannamaneni Ramakrishna Prasad), December 2025
Open
01
Religious charity accounts data set
An open, yearly data set and notebook, built from the Charity Commission for England and Wales's daily register download, of every registered charity whose entry lists "Religious Activities" under what it does. For each year it gives income and spending and, for charities with income over £500,000, the income-by-source lines they file in Part B of the annual return. Beside the data, it states what the data cannot show.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Zakat answers checked per authority
A public test set of made-up household cases (cash savings, gold, salary, business stock, debts), each with the zakat due according to three named authorities' own published calculators: Pusat Pungutan Zakat-MAIWP in Kuala Lumpur, BAZNAS in Indonesia and the National Zakat Foundation in the UK. AI assistants' answers are then scored against each authority separately. The test measures agreement with each authority's published method; it does not decide which school of law is right.
The briefCredit · unclaimed03
Gift Aid test set
A public set of synthetic donation records for a made-up congregation over one UK tax year, with made-up donors and Gift Aid declarations, covering envelopes, standing orders, card taps and cash collections. Gift Aid lets a charity reclaim the basic-rate tax a donor has paid on a gift. Each record carries the correct Gift Aid and Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme (GASDS) outcome under HMRC's published rules, so church finance software and AI assistants can be tested against it.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Religious charity accounts data set
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open, yearly data set and notebook, built from the Charity Commission for England and Wales's daily register download, of every registered charity whose entry lists "Religious Activities" under what it does. For each year it gives income and spending and, for charities with income over £500,000, the income-by-source lines they file in Part B of the annual return. Beside the data, it states what the data cannot show.
Why it is still open
NCVO's UK Civil Society Almanac, the main series on UK charity finances, excludes "sacramental religious bodies or places of worship". New Philanthropy Capital's 2016 study, Faith matters, counted 49,881 faith-based charities with £16.3 billion of income, but it was a single snapshot, not an open series. Church charities with income of £100,000 or less are excepted from registering and filing returns until 31 March 2031.
Built with what exists
The Commission's register download, including its charity_classification and charity_annual_return_partb files; Python with pandas or DuckDB; pdfplumber to read a check sample of filed accounts; Meta Muse Ember to pull income lines from those accounts (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat").
First step
Download the charity, charity_classification and charity_annual_return_partb files and count charities tagged "Religious Activities" by income band.
Done looks like
Every annual-return year from 2019 to the latest is covered; a hand check of 100 randomly chosen charities against their filed accounts agrees on total income for at least 98 of them; a published count of known gaps, such as excepted churches and late or missing returns.
Open 02 · the brief
Zakat answers checked per authority
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test set of made-up household cases (cash savings, gold, salary, business stock, debts), each with the zakat due according to three named authorities' own published calculators: Pusat Pungutan Zakat-MAIWP in Kuala Lumpur, BAZNAS in Indonesia and the National Zakat Foundation in the UK. AI assistants' answers are then scored against each authority separately. The test measures agreement with each authority's published method; it does not decide which school of law is right.
Why it is still open
The closest work, a study in Al-Mimbar published on 9 January 2026, tested five AI systems (Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Grok) on three scenarios by qualitative analysis across the four Sunni schools of law, and did not publish a reusable test set tied to named authorities' calculators. Thresholds also move every year: PPZ-MAIWP lists a 2026 nisab of RM33,996, and BAZNAS sets income zakat at 2.5% against a threshold of 85 grams of gold a year.
Built with what exists
The three public calculators; Browser Use 1.0 to enter each case and record results with dates (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Python for scoring; the Gemini Decisions API to grade many fixed-answer checks on each assistant's reply in one pass (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").
First step
Run 20 cases through the three calculators by hand and save the inputs, outputs and dates.
Done looks like
At least 150 cases, each with a dated result from all three calculators; at least five assistants scored, with an answer within 1% of an authority's figure counted as a match and match rates published per authority; a rerun after each authority's yearly nisab update.
Open 03 · the brief
Gift Aid test set
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public set of synthetic donation records for a made-up congregation over one UK tax year, with made-up donors and Gift Aid declarations, covering envelopes, standing orders, card taps and cash collections. Gift Aid lets a charity reclaim the basic-rate tax a donor has paid on a gift. Each record carries the correct Gift Aid and Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme (GASDS) outcome under HMRC's published rules, so church finance software and AI assistants can be tested against it.
Why it is still open
HMRC research found that 8% of the value of donations had Gift Aid incorrectly added by ineligible donors, a tax gap of up to £0.18 billion. HMRC's Local Test Service checks a claim file against the repayment schema and business rules, and HMRC states, "We do not provide an end to end test service". A search found no public synthetic test set of donation records with expected claim outcomes.
assets.publishing.service.gov.ukassets.publishing.service.gov.uk
Built with what exists
Python with the Faker library for made-up donors; HMRC's GASDS guidance, with its top-ups on cash or contactless gifts of £30 or less and its matching rule of 10 times Gift Aid donations; HMRC's Local Test Service to validate output files; Claude to review each expected outcome against the rule it cites (see the Note "Seven more flagged").
First step
Write 30 cases by hand from HMRC's GASDS guidance page, each with its expected top-up amount.
Done looks like
At least 1,000 records and 40 distinct rule cases, each expected outcome tied to a cited line of HMRC guidance; two independent implementations agree on the total claim to the penny; results published for at least three tools.