BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Religious organizations

Safeguarding

Safeguarding is the work of protecting children and vulnerable adults in a faith body's care: written policies, checks on staff and volunteers, rules for reporting abuse, independent reviews and redress, meaning payment, counseling and acknowledgement for those harmed.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2001 to 2022.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2001

    Nolan review for Catholic dioceses

    In September 2000 the Archbishop of Westminster asked Lord Michael Nolan to chair an independent committee to review child protection in the Catholic Church in England and Wales. Its report, A Programme for Action, published in September 2001, made 83 recommendations, including a child protection representative in every parish and a coordinator in every diocese and religious order, a national unit to issue guidance and monitor dioceses, criminal record checks, including for candidates for ordination, passing allegations to the statutory authorities "without any filtering", and keeping records for at least 100 years. The Church set up that unit, the Catholic Office for the Protection of Children and Vulnerable Adults (COPCA), in January 2002. In November 2020 the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA) found that Nolan's first aim, for the Church to be "an example of best practice", "remains an aspiration", and that its response had too often focused on protecting clergy and the Church's reputation.

    Lessonnew structures and procedures did not by themselves change whose interests came first when allegations arose.

    iicsa.org.ukiicsa.org.ukiicsa.org.uk

    Credit

    Lord Nolan's independent committee; IICSA

  2. 2002

    Dallas Charter and outside audits

    In 2002 the US Catholic bishops adopted the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People, known as the Dallas Charter, which sets procedures for abuse allegations against clergy, requires each diocese to have a review board of mostly lay members to advise the bishop, and is checked by annual audits. A study by John Jay College of Criminal Justice, commissioned through the bishops' National Review Board and published in February 2004, counted allegations against 4,392 priests from 1950 to 2002, made by 10,667 people: 4.0% of the 109,694 priests that dioceses and orders reported, or 4.3% using the count of priests by CARA, the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate at Georgetown University. The 23rd annual report, released on 27 May 2026 for July 2024 to June 2025, drew on audits by the firm StoneBridge Business Partners and a survey by CARA. It said that by the end of 2025 all 196 dioceses and eparchies (Eastern Catholic dioceses) had taken part in at least one on-site audit, the first full participation since 2002, and put allegation-related costs for the year at $483,534,316.

    Lessonan outside audit checks only the dioceses that let it in, and full participation took 23 years.

    usccb.orgevangelist.org

    Credit

    US Conference of Catholic Bishops and its National Review Board; John Jay College; StoneBridge Business Partners; CARA

  3. 2017

    Australia's Royal Commission reports

    Australia's Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, at work since 2012, delivered its 17-volume final report on 15 December 2017, bringing its recommendations to 409 in all. Of the survivors in its private sessions who named the type of institution, 58.6% said they were abused in one run by a religious organization; it heard of abuse in 1,691 religious institutions, ran 30 case studies on them, and addressed recommendations to the Anglican and Catholic churches, the Jehovah's Witness organization, Jewish institutions and all religious institutions. It set 10 Child Safe Standards for any institution and recommended making failure to report child sexual abuse a crime, with no exemption for clergy. The National Redress Scheme it proposed opened on 1 July 2018, paying up to AUD 150,000 per person (the Commission had proposed AUD 200,000) until 30 June 2027; the Catholic Church, by the Archdiocese of Sydney's account the first non-government body to join, and the Anglican Church, Uniting Church and Salvation Army committed to it. Because institutions had to opt in, a survivor's claim waited until the responsible body joined, and bodies that stayed out came to risk losing Commonwealth grants and charitable status.

    Lessona redress scheme that institutions join voluntarily needed penalties to bring the holdouts in.

    parliament.tas.gov.auamericamagazine.orgcatholicweekly.com.auewtnnews.comlawcouncil.aufindandconnect.gov.au

    Credit

    Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse; Australian Government

  4. 2018

    Counting from church files

    The MHG study, named for the universities of Mannheim, Heidelberg and Giessen whose researchers ran it, reviewed 38,156 personnel and case files from all 27 German Catholic dioceses for 1946 to 2014 and found accusations of abusing minors against 1,670 clerics, 4.4% of those whose files were read, with 3,677 children and young people affected; it called these lower-bound figures. The researchers had no access to original files: diocesan staff or law firms hired by the dioceses read them and filled in the study's forms, and the study found signs that some files had been destroyed or altered in the past. The ForuM study of Germany's Protestant churches and their welfare arm, Diakonie, presented on 25 January 2024, identified 1,259 accused and 2,225 affected people. A planned sample review of personnel files did not take place because some regional churches said they lacked the staff, so only 4,282 pastors' disciplinary files were read, and the researchers estimated that a full review might have found 9,355 affected people. ForuM recommended binding professional standards across the Protestant church, an independent ombudsman's office for those affected, and compulsory record-keeping and statistics.

    Lessonthese studies could count only what church staff pulled from church files, so each count depended on how many files they were given.

    cirkev.czevangelisch.defh-potsdam.desonntagsblatt.de

    Credit

    MHG research consortium (Mannheim, Heidelberg, Giessen); ForuM research network

  5. 2021

    Inquiry reviews 38 religious organizations

    In September 2021 IICSA, a statutory inquiry for England and Wales, published its report Child protection in religious organisations and settings, based on evidence from 38 religious organizations. It found no legal obligation on religious settings to follow government child protection guidance, "significant diversity" in whether they had adequate policies, inconsistent criminal record (DBS) checks on people working with children, and oversight that was "patchwork influence rather than mandatory standards and enforcement". It made two recommendations: that every religious organization have a child protection policy and procedures, updated with professional advice and backed by compulsory training, and that any setting that is a child's main place of education be brought under school registration. IICSA's final report in October 2022 made 20 recommendations to government, and the Crime and Policing Act 2026 (Royal Assent 29 April 2026) places a duty on anyone in regulated activity with children in England to report sexual abuse they learn of, and extends barred-list checks to supervised roles.

    Lessonguidance that no one had to follow left practice uneven, and the inquiry's answer was a required minimum rather than more guidance.

    iicsa.org.ukiicsa.org.ukgov.ukgov.uk

    Credit

    IICSA; UK Parliament

  6. 2022

    Baptist inquiry, stalled database

    The Southern Baptist Convention (SBC), a network of self-governing Baptist churches, had an outside firm, Guidepost Solutions, investigate how its Executive Committee handled abuse reports. The report, dated 15 May 2022, found that a few senior committee leaders and outside counsel controlled the response for years and were "singularly focused on avoiding liability", and that committee staff had kept a list of accused ministers since 2007, last numbering 703 names, without acting on it. It recommended an independent commission and an offender information system that churches could use voluntarily. Messengers, the churches' delegates, approved reforms including a "Ministry Check" database, but in February 2025, with no names yet published, the Executive Committee's president said it was "not a focus", citing its legality and the difficulty of insuring it.

    Lessona database of offenders run by a church body stalled over its legal risk and the cost of insuring it.

    thebaptistpaper.orgchristianitytoday.combaptiststandard.com

    Credit

    Guidepost Solutions, for the SBC's Sexual Abuse Task Force

Watch for

  1. Vatican commission's second report

    On 16 October 2025 the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, a Vatican body set up in 2014, released its second annual report on the Church's safeguarding policies and procedures: a 200-page review of 18 bishops' conferences, mainly in Africa and Europe, and two religious institutes, drawn from focus groups with 40 abuse survivors, questionnaires and data from outside bodies such as UN agencies, with six recommendations on reparations. A commission member described the report as a handbook for addressing the "global data gap" on abuse.

    Achieved whena party outside the Church checks the country findings, or a later report shows from published data that the reviewed conferences adopted the recommendations.

    ewtnnews.comtutelaminorum.va

    Claimed by

    Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, October 2025

  2. Church of England independent authority

    In February 2026 the General Synod endorsed a plan by Dame Christine Ryan, independent chair of its Safeguarding Structures Programme Board, for a single independent national charity, provisionally the Independent Safeguarding Authority. Its board would have a majority of members from outside the church, and its chief safeguarding officer's operational decisions would answer to an outside regulator rather than to the board, while diocesan safeguarding teams stay local. The lead bishop for safeguarding said the working group aimed to bring legislation back to the Synod before July 2027.

    Achieved whenthe enabling legislation passes and the authority is handling cases under an outside regulator.

    churchtimes.co.uk

    Claimed by

    Church of England General Synod, February 2026

  3. US bishops revise their Charter

    On 11 June 2026 the US Catholic bishops approved, by 176 votes to 22 with six abstentions, a revised Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People after a review begun in 2021. It adds a glossary of terms that dioceses had asked for, identifies "mandatory Church reporters" to complement reporting to civil authorities, allows electronic letters of suitability (statements of a cleric's fitness for ministry), and keeps the Charter to the abuse of minors, with a separate document on conduct with adults to follow.

    Achieved whenthe first outside audit cycle under the revised Charter reports dioceses' compliance with its new provisions.

    catholicworldreport.com

    Claimed by

    United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Score published safeguarding policies

    A public audit of the safeguarding policies that faith bodies publish online, scored against public standards: the contents IICSA's first recommendation says every religious organization's policy needs (supporting procedures, guidance on responding to disclosures, attention to the needs of victims and survivors, regular updates with professional advice, compulsory training) and the Royal Commission's 10 Child Safe Standards. An AI reader answers each question for each policy, people check a sample, and the method, the question list and aggregate results by type and size of body are published. No ranking of faiths, no scores for individuals, no list of accused people.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Common table of safeguarding figures

    A table of the aggregate safeguarding figures that national faith bodies publish each year, such as concerns reported, allegations, audits and spending on safeguarding, with each body's definitions mapped to a common set, and a list of the national bodies checked that publish no figures. Aggregate data only, no names and no ranking.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score published safeguarding policies

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public audit of the safeguarding policies that faith bodies publish online, scored against public standards: the contents IICSA's first recommendation says every religious organization's policy needs (supporting procedures, guidance on responding to disclosures, attention to the needs of victims and survivors, regular updates with professional advice, compulsory training) and the Royal Commission's 10 Child Safe Standards. An AI reader answers each question for each policy, people check a sample, and the method, the question list and aggregate results by type and size of body are published. No ranking of faiths, no scores for individuals, no list of accused people.

Why it is still open

IICSA found "significant diversity" in whether religious organizations had adequate policies. The April 2025 Northern Ireland review of the faith sector rested on a survey of places of worship, 291 usable responses from 1,004 approached, and recommended that "independent audits and performance indicators should be introduced". A Queen's University Belfast study read the public documents of four religious and belief groups in Ireland without scoring them against a standard. A search found no large-sample, scored review of published policies.

iicsa.org.ukexecutiveoffice-ni.gov.ukpureadmin.qub.ac.uk

Built with what exists

Browser Use 1.0 to find and save published policies (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); pdfplumber for text; the Gemini Decisions API to answer the fixed rubric in one pass per policy (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); Claude to recheck policies the first pass flags and quote the passage behind each answer (see the Note "Seven more flagged").

  1. First step

    Turn IICSA's first recommendation and the 10 Child Safe Standards into about 20 yes or no questions and test them by hand on 30 published policies.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 policies from national and local bodies across at least five traditions scored on every rubric item; agreement between the AI and two human coders of at least 90% on a sample of 200 policies; method, rubric and aggregate results published.

Open 02 · the brief

Common table of safeguarding figures

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A table of the aggregate safeguarding figures that national faith bodies publish each year, such as concerns reported, allegations, audits and spending on safeguarding, with each body's definitions mapped to a common set, and a list of the national bodies checked that publish no figures. Aggregate data only, no names and no ranking.

Why it is still open

Bodies publish series in their own terms, such as CARA's 20-year summary for US Catholic dioceses (January 2025) or the United Reformed Church's annual safeguarding reports, and a member of the Vatican commission called its report a handbook for the "global data gap" on abuse. A search found no compilation across bodies with common definitions.

bishop-accountability.orgurc.org.ukewtnnews.com

Built with what exists

pdfplumber and Meta Muse Ember to pull tables from long annual reports (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a spreadsheet crosswalk of definitions; a second person checking every value.

  1. First step

    List the annual safeguarding reports already public, such as the US Charter reports and the United Reformed Church's reports, and record what each one counts and how it defines a case.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 10 national bodies in at least three countries, 2015 to 2025 where published, every value linked to its page and checked by a second person, with a note on definitions for each body.