BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Public transit

Fares and ticketing

This is the work of setting prices, collecting them, and checking that riders have paid.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1873 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1873

    A glass box for fares

    Tom L. Johnson of Louisville, Kentucky, patented a streetcar fare box in which coins or metal tickets slid down plates behind glass, lit by a lamp, so the driver could see them; a company detective could then compare the fares on the plate with the number of passengers. By 1886 an advertisement in the Street Railway Journal offered "Tom L. Johnson's Improved Fare Box" and claimed it was in "general use in cities throughout the U.S."

    patents.google.comcommons.wikimedia.org

    Credit

    Tom L. Johnson; Wales Manufacturing Company of Syracuse, New York, the maker named in the advertisement

  2. 1997

    One card, many operators

    Hong Kong's Octopus card began service on 1 September 1997 on the trains, buses and one ferry route of five transport companies. It works when held within 10 cm of a reader, and riders keep and recharge it, where the paper stored-value tickets it replaced were kept by the gate after their last ride, by a paper put to the transport panel of Hong Kong's Provisional Legislative Council in October 1997. In September 2016 Octopus Cards Limited counted over 14 million transactions a day and over 32 million cards in circulation.

    legco.gov.hkoctopus.com.hk

    Credit

    MTR Corporation, Kowloon-Canton Railway Corporation, Kowloon Motor Bus, Citybus and Hongkong & Yaumati Ferry, through their joint company Creative Star, now Octopus Cards Limited

  3. 2012

    Bank cards pay the fare

    On 13 December 2012 Transport for London (TfL) let riders pay for a bus trip by touching a contactless bank card on the reader, with nothing bought in advance. Daily and weekly caps mean a rider never pays more than the matching 7-day ticket. On the first day 2,061 people made 2,586 trips this way; by December 2022 about 70% of pay-as-you-go bus trips in London were paid by bank card or phone, and TfL says New York, Chicago and Sydney have since built systems on London's model.

    LessonTfL called the first day's numbers impressive "given how few of the cards were in general circulation"; a fare system run on riders' own bank cards grows only as fast as those cards spread.

    tfl-newsroom.prgloo.com

    Credit

    TfL, with the banking industry, Visa and Mastercard

  4. 2013

    Free rides for residents

    On 1 January 2013 Tallinn, Estonia, a city of about 420,000 people, made its buses, trams and trolleybuses free for registered residents. A survey of 1,500 households before and almost a year after found trips by public transport up 14%, car trips down 10% and walking trips down 40%, while total car kilometers rose 31% because people drove farther.

    LessonWhere fares were already low, free fares drew more people off their feet than out of their cars.

    rd.springer.com

    Credit

    the City of Tallinn; measured by Oded Cats, Yusak Susilo and Triin Reimal of TU Delft, KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Ramboll

  5. 2023

    A national monthly ticket

    From 1 May 2023 Germany's Deutschland-Ticket let holders ride all local and regional buses and trains in the country for 49 euros a month. Researchers at the MCC institute, working for the Ariadne project, compared phone and car movement data with eight other European countries and found that in its first year it raised train trips over 30 km by 30.4% and cut car kilometers by 7.6%. A Technical University of Munich (TUM) team that tracked 506 users by app in 2023 found that only about a fifth of new subscribers cut their car use.

    pik-potsdam.detum.de

    Credit

    Germany's state transport ministers, who set the price and in September 2024 raised it to 58 euros; MCC and TUM for the outside measures

Watch for

  1. Free buses across New York

    New York City's mayor, Zohran Mamdani, campaigned on making the city's buses "fast and free" and has called for fares to end on all of them. The city's Independent Budget Office (IBO) puts the cost from 2027 at just over 1.1 billion US dollars a year. A plan for faster buses released in July 2026 by the mayor, the governor and the MTA, the state agency that runs the buses, left fares out. In the MTA's own evaluation of a fare-free pilot on five routes from September 2023 to August 2024, weekday riders rose 30% and weekend riders 38%, mostly from existing riders, while time spent at stops on the pilot routes rose 7.0%, against 1.0% systemwide.

    Achieved whenfares are removed on all New York City buses and an outside body, such as the IBO, publishes a year of ridership and cost figures.

    ibo.nyc.govmta.infopoliticsny.com

    Claimed by

    Zohran Mamdani, restated in July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Fare capping as open data

    A proposed addition to GTFS Fares v2, the open format in which agencies publish their fares, that can describe fare caps, such as London's daily and weekly caps or Toronto's monthly cap after 47 paid trips. Add sample feeds for at least five capped systems and an open calculator that reads a feed and works out what a list of trips costs.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Fare tables read by machine

    A tool that reads an agency's published fare tables, from web pages and PDFs, writes them as GTFS Fares v2 files, and checks each price it wrote against the source.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Fare capping as open data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A proposed addition to GTFS Fares v2, the open format in which agencies publish their fares, that can describe fare caps, such as London's daily and weekly caps or Toronto's monthly cap after 47 paid trips. Add sample feeds for at least five capped systems and an open calculator that reads a feed and works out what a list of trips costs.

Why it is still open

The GTFS project lists fare capping among the concepts Fares v2 "plans to represent", and the parts adopted between 2022 and 2023 (the base, fare media, fares that vary by time, and networks) do not include it. The capping calculators found on GitHub each cover one city, such as one for Toronto's TTC built in October 2026.

gtfs.orggithub.com

Built with what exists

The GTFS reference and MobilityData's open GTFS validator; Python; each agency's published fare rules; a general AI model to draft test cases from the rule pages, checked by a person.

  1. First step

    Write the capping rules of two systems, such as London and Toronto, as plain test cases (trips in, amount charged out), and try to express them with the Fares v2 files that exist today to find where they fall short.

  2. Done looks like

    Feeds for at least five capped systems that pass the validator, and a calculator that gets the right total on at least 50 test cases taken from the agencies' own rules and examples, with the proposal posted for discussion on the GTFS project's GitHub and all code public.

Open 02 · the brief

Fare tables read by machine

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A tool that reads an agency's published fare tables, from web pages and PDFs, writes them as GTFS Fares v2 files, and checks each price it wrote against the source.

Why it is still open

The GTFS project's adoption tracker lists seven organizations that produce Fares v2 data (Interline, Maryland Department of Transportation, Cal-ITP, Trillium Solutions, ITO World, MBTA and PVTA) and two apps that use it (Transit and Apple Maps). The tools found on GitHub validate Fares v2 files or convert older fare files; this research found none that reads fare tables into Fares v2 with a measured error rate.

gtfs.org

Built with what exists

A vision-language model to read tables in PDFs; a web agent to find each agency's fare pages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); MobilityData's GTFS validator; Python.

  1. First step

    Write Fares v2 files by hand for three small agencies as an answer key, then run a model on the same fare pages and count the differences.

  2. Done looks like

    Fares v2 files for 50 agencies that pass the validator, with every price in 10 of them checked by hand against the source and the share of wrong prices published.