BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Public transit

Accessibility

This is the work of making stops, stations, vehicles and information usable by riders who use wheelchairs, cannot see or hear well, or cannot climb stairs.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1967 to 2017.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1967

    Paving read underfoot

    Seiichi Miyake's tactile blocks, paving with raised dots and bars that a blind person can feel underfoot or with a cane, were first laid on a street near the Okayama School for the Blind in Okayama City, Japan, on 18 March 1967, by Google's account. Their use spread, and about ten years later they were made mandatory, with sound guides, on the Japanese National Railways. They are now found at crossings and on railway platforms around the world.

    doodles.googleaop.org.uk

    Credit

    Seiichi Miyake

  2. 1978

    Riders block the buses

    On 5 and 6 July 1978 a group of wheelchair users, later known as the Gang of 19, blocked buses at Broadway and Colfax Avenue in Denver, after the Regional Transportation District (RTD) had ordered 250 buses without wheelchair lifts. RTD then fitted lifts to a third of its fleet, and it says that seven years after the protest it became the first metropolitan agency in the US to run wheelchair-accessible service on all its local buses.

    rtd-denver.com

    Credit

    the Rev. Wade Blank and Atlantis, the community for disabled people he founded; the Gang of 19

  3. 1988

    A bus that kneels

    MAN's NL202 city bus, shown as three prototypes in late 1988, had a floor 340 mm lower than its standard city bus and a front-door sill 315 mm above the road. An optional kneeling feature lowered the front a further 80 mm, to 235 mm, "to enable handicapped passengers and wheelchair users to board without using a lift", Commercial Motor reported in December 1988. Two prototypes were to go on trial with operators in Munich and Berlin, with 20 pre-production buses to follow in 1989.

    archive.commercialmotor.com

    Credit

    MAN

  4. 1990

    Lifts and rides by law

    Under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and the US Department of Transportation's rules, any new bus or other vehicle that a public operator of fixed routes seeks to buy or lease after 25 August 1990 must be usable by people who use wheelchairs. The operator must also run paratransit, a separate ride service for riders who cannot use the fixed routes, that reaches anywhere within three-quarters of a mile of a bus route, takes bookings the day before, charges no more than twice the full fare, and does not limit service through large numbers of refused or missed trips.

    law.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    the US Congress; the US Department of Transportation

  5. 2017

    Five percent of trips

    In its July 2017 report Access Denied, TransitCenter counted that a rider who needs an elevator could make only 5% of the station-to-station trips on New York's subway open to a rider who can use stairs: 11,990 of 222,312. From MTA data it also found an average of 25 elevator outages a day between July 2014 and June 2015, each lasting 5 hours 33 minutes on average, while the MTA reported about 96% elevator uptime.

    LessonA high uptime figure for elevators can hide how few trips riders who depend on them can make.

    transitcenter.org

    Credit

    TransitCenter and the Access Denied campaign

Watch for

  1. Ticket machines under EU law

    The European Accessibility Act covers ticket machines placed on the EU market after 28 June 2025, and for city, suburban and regional transport it applies to interactive self-service terminals in stations, though not to machines built into vehicles. Member states may let machines already in use stay until the end of their useful life, up to 20 years after they entered use.

    Achieved whena national market-surveillance authority publishes checks of station ticket machines installed since June 2025 and finds that they meet the Act's requirements.

    eur-lex.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    the European Union, in rules that apply from June 2025

  2. Elevator outages, announced and rerouted

    To settle CIDNY v. MTA, a lawsuit filed in 2017 by disabled New Yorkers, the MTA agreed to show live elevator status on station screens, announce long elevator outages on platforms every 15 minutes, offer alternate accessible routes on its website, its app and a 511 phone line, and count outages during rebuilding work in its published elevator figures.

    Achieved whenthe court approves the settlement and the plaintiffs or an outside monitor report that the MTA meets its terms.

    dralegal.org

    Claimed by

    Disability Rights Advocates, for the plaintiffs, July 2026; the settlement needed the approval of Judge George B. Daniels of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York

Open

  1. 01

    A step-free reach index

    A daily figure, for several cities, of the share of station-to-station trips that a rider who cannot use stairs can make that day, computed from each system's station data and its live elevator outage feed, with every day's figure archived in public.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Count the stops announced

    A phone app that, on a volunteer's own bus rides, listens for stop announcements, turns them into text on the phone, matches each to the stop the bus is at by GPS and the route's published stop list, and keeps only a tally of stops announced and missed, not the sound.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A step-free reach index

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A daily figure, for several cities, of the share of station-to-station trips that a rider who cannot use stairs can make that day, computed from each system's station data and its live elevator outage feed, with every day's figure archived in public.

Why it is still open

TransitCenter's 5% figure for New York was a one-time count from 2017. Tools found on GitHub, such as Out of Service (September 2026), route New York riders around elevators that often fail, but this research found no repeated figure that compares systems.

transitcenter.orggithub.com

Built with what exists

GTFS station data, including the pathways file that maps routes inside a station; the MTA's live elevator outage feed and the outage feeds of other systems that publish one; r5py or OpenTripPlanner for routing; Python; GitHub Actions to run it each day.

  1. First step

    Compute today's New York figure from the MTA's list of accessible stations and its current outages, and compare it with the same count when no elevator is out.

  2. Done looks like

    A public table of the daily figure for at least three systems over 90 days, with code public, and TransitCenter's 2017 count of 11,990 possible trips reproduced from that year's list of accessible stations.

Open 02 · the brief

Count the stops announced

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A phone app that, on a volunteer's own bus rides, listens for stop announcements, turns them into text on the phone, matches each to the stop the bus is at by GPS and the route's published stop list, and keeps only a tally of stops announced and missed, not the sound.

Why it is still open

US rules require stop announcements at least at transfer points, major intersections and destinations, and on request. Federal reviews from 2000 to 2002, made by people riding and listening, found rates from 27% of listed stops announced, at Pittsburgh's Port Authority, to 87% of Pace drivers making at least some announcements, and one found that an agency's own monitoring overstated how many drivers made them. This research found no published audit that uses speech recognition.

ilru.org

Built with what exists

An open speech-recognition model that runs on a phone, such as OpenAI's Whisper (the Note "Fewer word errors" covers a newer cloud model, ElevenLabs' Scribe v3, that could serve as a check); GTFS stop lists; the phone's GPS; Python.

  1. First step

    Ride one route five times, log each announcement by hand, and test speech recognition on the phone in a setup that keeps no audio, after checking the local law on recording in public.

  2. Done looks like

    On 50 rides where a person also logs each announcement by hand, the app agrees with the person on at least 95% of stops, with the tallies and code published.