BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Heavy civil / Paving

Concrete paving

Concrete paving places portland cement concrete in slabs, shapes and finishes the surface, and cuts joints so that the slabs crack where the builder chooses.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1891 to 2013.

0

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1891

    Concrete beside a courthouse

    George W. Bartholomew, who ran the Buckeye Portland Cement Company, laid an 8 ft (2.4 m) strip of concrete along Main Street in Bellefontaine, Ohio, in 1891, where horses were tied outside the Logan County courthouse. After two years of wear the city had him pave the four streets around the courthouse in the summer of 1893. He gave the cement free and had to post a $5,000 bond that the surface would last five years. Court Avenue is still in service; its National Register nomination says the streets went 65 years before their first major maintenance, in 1956. FHWA lists earlier concrete paving: an alley in Connersville, Indiana, in 1890, and a pavement in Inverness, Scotland, in 1865.

    Lessonwhich street was first depends on what counts as a street.

    hmdb.orgnrmca.orgfhwa.dot.gov

    Credit

    George W. Bartholomew; Logan County Engineer James Wonders, who directed the placing

  2. 1909

    A mile of concrete highway

    The Wayne County Road Commission in Michigan paved one mile of Woodward Avenue, between Six and Seven Mile Roads in Detroit, with concrete and opened it on July 4, 1909. FHWA says credit for the first concrete surface on a rural US public road "is generally conceded to Wayne County", whose commissioners first visited Windsor, Ontario, the first North American city to pave streets widely with concrete. The Michigan Department of Transportation calls it "the first full mile of concrete ever built".

    fhwa.dot.govmichigan.gov

    Credit

    Edward N. Hines and the Wayne County Road Commission

  3. 1949

    Paving without side forms

    Concrete roads had been cast between steel side forms set out by hand ahead of the paver. A slipform paver carries short forms along with it, so the concrete must be stiff enough to hold its edge as soon as the machine moves on. James W. Johnson, laboratory chief of the Iowa State Highway Commission, designed one; its first models paved one lane at a time in 1949, leaving a gap at the centre line to be filled separately. An Iowa contractor built its own version, the Quad City Paver, in 1955, and within a few years slabs 40 ft (12 m) wide were being slipformed.

    publications.iowa.govconcretepavements.org

    Credit

    James W. Johnson, Iowa State Highway Commission

  4. 2000

    Joints judged by data

    FHWA's Long-Term Pavement Performance (LTPP) program tracks how real highway sections wear. Its first decade of analysis, summarized by FHWA in June 2000, found that the right joint spacing depends on climate: colder and wetter places can use longer slabs, warmer and drier places need shorter ones. On jointed plain concrete, sealed joints performed better than unsealed ones, which held significantly more debris and spalled more at the joint edges. Continuously reinforced pavements, which have no sawn joints and use steel bars to hold their cracks tight, performed well with 0.51% to 0.75% steel.

    fhwa.dot.gov

    Credit

    FHWA's LTPP program and the state highway agencies whose roads it monitors

  5. 2013

    A box for slipform mixes

    A concrete can pass the standard slump test and still sag at the edges or show voids after a slipform paver vibrates it. Marllon Cook, Ashkan Ghaeezadeh, Tyler Ley and Bruce Russell of Oklahoma State University created the Box Test for the Oklahoma DOT in a 2013 report. Concrete in a 1 ft³ (0.03 m³) box is vibrated for 6 seconds, the sides are removed, and each face is ranked from 1 to 4 for surface voids and checked for edge slump. It is now AASHTO TP 137 and one of the tests of the Performance Engineered Mixtures (PEM) program; an Iowa State University guide sheet asks for edge slump under 0.25 in (6 mm) and a rank of 2 or better, meaning under 30% surface voids.

    shareok.orgintrans.iastate.edu

    Credit

    Marllon Cook, Ashkan Ghaeezadeh, Tyler Ley and Bruce Russell, Oklahoma State University

Open

  1. 01

    Box Test ranks from photos

    A photo method that gives each face of a Box Test its 1 to 4 surface-void rank and measures its edge slump, so that labs stop rating by eye against a printed illustration.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Joint faulting from a phone

    A phone app that estimates faulting, the step that forms at a joint when one concrete slab settles below the next, from the phone's motion sensors while it rides in a dashboard mount at normal speed, checked against profiler measurements.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Box Test ranks from photos

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A photo method that gives each face of a Box Test its 1 to 4 surface-void rank and measures its edge slump, so that labs stop rating by eye against a printed illustration.

Why it is still open

The test is scored by comparing each face with a picture scale of four ranks. The nearest automated work found, at the University of Pittsburgh, measures air voids in hardened specimens from a lab slipform simulator against the ASTM C457 microscope method, not Box Test faces; other image methods count surface voids on tunnel linings and polished sections. Crossref and web searches for image-based Box Test rating found nothing.

intrans.iastate.eduxiangdongyan.github.io

Built with what exists

A Box Test kit (the 1 ft³ form, clamps and a controlled-speed vibrator at 12,500 vibrations per minute); a phone on a fixed stand with a printed scale target in the frame; Segment Anything, Meta's open model for outlining objects in images; AI models that read images, such as Claude Fable 5.2 (see the Note "Three working devices"), scored against the human raters.

  1. First step

    Cast and photograph ten boxes from two mixes in a concrete lab, and have three people rank them independently.

  2. Done looks like

    200 photographed faces from at least 20 mixes, each ranked by three trained technicians working separately. Published: the photo method's agreement with the technicians' majority rank, set beside the technicians' agreement with each other, and edge slump within 1/16 in (1.6 mm) of a straightedge reading on 50 boxes.

Open 02 · the brief

Joint faulting from a phone

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A phone app that estimates faulting, the step that forms at a joint when one concrete slab settles below the next, from the phone's motion sensors while it rides in a dashboard mount at normal speed, checked against profiler measurements.

Why it is still open

Agencies measure faulting with a hand gauge, the Georgia Faultmeter, which needs traffic control, or with high-speed inertial profilers, vans that measure the road surface with lasers and accelerometers; FHWA's 2015 LTPP report built an automated method on profiler data to replace the manual surveys. Phone work has measured roughness, the International Roughness Index (IRI), and flagged bumps and potholes, but found that both the phone model and the vehicle change the result; a study from India saw sharp acceleration peaks at the joints of a concrete road without measuring their height. No study found reports faulting in millimetres.

fhwa.dot.govideals.illinois.edu

Built with what exists

A sensor-logging phone app such as phyphox; Python; ProVAL, the profile analysis program whose AASHTO R 36 faulting method FHWA tested, for reference values; public profile and faulting data for jointed concrete test sections from FHWA's LTPP InfoPave site, or a state agency's network survey data.

  1. First step

    Download the profile data for one LTPP jointed concrete section near you, log one drive over it from the passenger seat, and check whether the joint spikes line up with the joints in the profile.

  2. Done looks like

    Estimates on 20 jointed concrete sections that have recent profiler faulting data, from three phone models in two vehicles, with joint detection rate and mean absolute error in millimetres published beside the profiler values. Data are logged from the passenger seat at legal speed, and nobody stops on or walks onto the road.