BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Power generation / Nuclear decommissioning

Planning and cost

Planning decides when and how a closed plant will be taken apart, either soon after shutdown or after decades of waiting for radioactivity to decay, and makes sure the money for the job exists before the work starts.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1988 to 2017.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1988

    Money set aside in advance

    On 27 June 1988 the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), the federal nuclear safety regulator, issued its decommissioning rules. Decommissioning is the work of taking a closed plant apart and cleaning the site so its license can end. The rules required every owner to show that enough money would be available at any time until the license ended, set a minimum amount by a formula in rule 10 CFR 50.75, and required a detailed plan, approved by the NRC, within two years after a plant closed. Owners now report the state of these funds to the NRC every two years.

    federalregister.govnrc.gov

    Credit

    US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

  2. 1996

    Notice instead of approval

    A revised NRC rule, in force from 28 August 1996, replaced the approved plan with a shorter public report filed within two years of closing, the post-shutdown decommissioning activities report (PSDAR). It gives the planned work, a schedule and a cost estimate. Owners could start major dismantling 90 days after filing, without waiting for NRC approval, once they had certified that the plant was shut and its fuel removed from the reactor. A license termination plan, which the NRC must approve, comes only near the end.

    federalregister.govnrc.gov

    Credit

    US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

  3. 2010

    A cleanup firm takes over

    On 1 September 2010 Exelon handed the license of the closed Zion plant in Illinois, two reactors shut in 1996 and 1997, together with its decommissioning trust fund, to ZionSolutions, a subsidiary of the waste company EnergySolutions. POWER magazine reported that it was the first time this had been done in the United States. The new owner dropped the old plan to wait in safe storage (called SAFSTOR) and began dismantling at once (called DECON); in 2014 it expected to finish in 2018, ten years earlier than planned. The NRC released most of the site for unrestricted use on 8 November 2023, leaving about 5 acres of spent fuel storage under license.

    Lessonhanding a plant and its fund to a specialist firm can cut decades from the job, though the firm's own first schedule still slipped by about five years.

    powermag.comnrc.gov

    Credit

    EnergySolutions (ZionSolutions); Exelon

  4. 2012

    Formula found short

    GAO, the US Congress's audit office, compared the NRC's funding formula with detailed site-specific cost estimates for 12 reactors. For 5 of them the formula captured 57 to 76% of the estimated cost; for the other 7 it captured 84 to 103%. GAO noted that the formula rests on information collected more than 30 years earlier.

    Lessona single formula for every plant can leave a particular plant's fund short.

    gao.gov

    Credit

    US Government Accountability Office

  5. 2017

    Magnox contract collapses

    In 2014 the UK's Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA), the public body that owns the country's older nuclear sites, awarded a 14-year contract worth up to £6.2 billion to clean up 12 sites, 10 of them Magnox power stations at or near the end of their working lives. In July 2016 the High Court found that the NDA had wrongly decided the competition. The NDA settled with the losing bidders, EnergySolutions and Bechtel, for £97.3 million, and in 2017 ended the contract with the winner, Cavendish Fluor Partnership, nine years early. The expected cost of the work had grown from £3.8 billion in the winning bid to £6.0 billion, partly because the sites held more waste and asbestos than expected. The National Audit Office put the cost to taxpayers at upwards of £122 million.

    Lessona fixed contract cannot work if the buyer does not know what is on its own sites.

    nao.org.uk

    Credit

    National Audit Office (report, 11 October 2017); Nuclear Decommissioning Authority

  6. 2017

    A public fund takes over

    On 3 July 2017 the operators of Germany's 25 nuclear plants paid €24.1 billion into KENFO, a new public foundation that invests the money to pay for storing and disposing of radioactive waste through the end of the century. The operators still take their plants apart and package the waste; once they hand the packaged waste to the federal storage company BGZ, the duty to pay for its storage and disposal passes to the state. KENFO had paid out €5.3 billion by the end of 2025.

    kenfo.degrs.de

    Credit

    German federal government; KENFO

Watch for

  1. Faster starts, fewer comments

    A rule the NRC proposed on 24 September 2026 would let owners begin major dismantling 30 days after filing their post-shutdown report instead of 90, drop the public comment period on that report, and let plants still running draw on their decommissioning funds for jobs such as disposing of large radioactive parts after 60 working days' notice, instead of asking for an exemption, which the NRC says takes 9 months on average to review. Comments closed on 9 November 2026.

    Achieved whena final rule is published in the Federal Register and takes effect.

    federalregister.gov

    Claimed by

    US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, September 2026

  2. Vermont Yankee, three years early

    NorthStar Group Services took over the closed Vermont Yankee plant from Entergy after an NRC order of October 2018; Entergy's 2014 plan had put license termination by 2073. In September 2026 NorthStar's executive chairman, Scott State, said the job was "99 percent done", that final work would finish in 2027, three years before NorthStar's 2030 deadline, and that it fits within the $602 million trust fund the company inherited. Vermont's Department of Public Service reported $35.2 million of license-termination work left at 30 November 2025.

    Achieved whenthe NRC releases the land outside the spent fuel storage area and Vermont's Department of Public Service confirms the final cost against the fund.

    vtdigger.orgnrc.govlegislature.vermont.gov

    Claimed by

    NorthStar Group Services, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Compare first estimates with outcomes

    A public table of every power reactor whose decommissioning is finished or nearly finished: the 25 that the World Nuclear Industry Status Report counted as fully decommissioned in 2026, plus the US plants handed to decommissioning firms since 2010. For each, give the first published cost estimate and finish date, the strategy chosen, and the final cost and finish date, each figure linked to the document it came from. Then publish the median gap between first estimate and outcome, in cost and in years.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Check waste forecasts against shipments

    For each US reactor that began dismantling since 2013, set the volume of low-level waste forecast in its owner's cost estimates beside the volume actually shipped for disposal, year by year. The shipped volumes come from the Department of Energy's Manifest Information Management System (MIMS), a public database of commercial low-level waste sent to US disposal sites since 1986. Then publish how far the forecasts missed and whether the misses track cost overruns, since waste disposal is one of the main costs of the job.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Compare first estimates with outcomes

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of every power reactor whose decommissioning is finished or nearly finished: the 25 that the World Nuclear Industry Status Report counted as fully decommissioned in 2026, plus the US plants handed to decommissioning firms since 2010. For each, give the first published cost estimate and finish date, the strategy chosen, and the final cost and finish date, each figure linked to the document it came from. Then publish the median gap between first estimate and outcome, in cost and in years.

Why it is still open

Invernizzi, Locatelli and Brookes at the University of Leeds (2019) gathered public cost estimates for 24 European projects, most still under way, and none in the United States, where 17 of the 25 finished reactors are. The Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), the US utilities' research body, gathered estimated and actual costs for eight US plants, seven of them finished by 2008, and published them in a 2013 paper as charts in 2008 dollars, not as a table of each plant's first estimate beside its outcome. Lordan-Perret and colleagues at the University of Basel (2022) used past US cost overruns to set a 48% contingency, but published no plant-by-plant data; the full paper is available only on request. No public table pairing first estimates with outcomes was found.

eprints.whiterose.ac.ukworldnuclearreport.orgarchivedproceedings.econference.ioedoc.unibas.ch

Built with what exists

PSDARs, funding reports and license termination letters from the NRC's public ADAMS document library; national audit reports such as the National Audit Office's and GAO's; older project reports on OSTI, such as the NRC's 1982 summary of Elk River; an AI model that reads long PDFs and pulls out figures with page references (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a spreadsheet; a second person to check.

  1. First step

    Build the rows for Elk River and Zion from the OSTI and NRC documents cited in this file, then add Vermont Yankee from Vermont's public trust reports.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 20 reactors with first and final cost and dates, every figure linked to its source page; a second person rechecks 50 figures and agrees on at least 95%; the table and the medians published under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

Check waste forecasts against shipments

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

For each US reactor that began dismantling since 2013, set the volume of low-level waste forecast in its owner's cost estimates beside the volume actually shipped for disposal, year by year. The shipped volumes come from the Department of Energy's Manifest Information Management System (MIMS), a public database of commercial low-level waste sent to US disposal sites since 1986. Then publish how far the forecasts missed and whether the misses track cost overruns, since waste disposal is one of the main costs of the job.

Why it is still open

EPRI's 2013 paper charts the total waste shipped by the eight US plants it studied against plant size, but not forecasts against shipments. MIMS reports volumes by disposal site, state, year and generator, with each generator listed by a code number rather than a plant name, so a plant-by-plant comparison is not ready-made. No study comparing forecast and shipped volumes for recent plants was found.

archivedproceedings.econference.iomims.doe.gov

Built with what exists

MIMS queries exported as spreadsheets; the cost estimates and post-shutdown reports in the NRC's ADAMS library; an AI model that reads long PDFs and pulls out figures with page references (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python with pandas.

  1. First step

    Export the MIMS shipments from Vermont for 2015 to 2025, work out which generator codes belong to Vermont Yankee, and compare the totals with the plant's latest cost estimate.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 10 reactors with forecast and shipped volumes for each year since shutdown, every forecast linked to its page and every shipped total to its MIMS query; a second person reruns five plants' queries and gets the same totals; the table published under an open license.