BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Electric transmission and distribution / Microgrids

Disconnecting and reconnecting

A microgrid has to sense when the main grid fails, cut itself loose in a fraction of a second, carry its own load, and later match the grid's voltage, frequency and phase again before it closes the breaker that rejoins them.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2011 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2011

    Sendai islands after the quake

    After the earthquake of 11 March 2011 the utility cut power to the area around Tohoku Fukushi University in Sendai for about three days. The 1 MW Sendai microgrid, built by NTT Facilities for a 2004 to 2008 demonstration funded by NEDO, Japan's energy research agency, switched to island mode. Its gas engines tripped on the grid's voltage swings and could not be restarted until about noon on 12 March, because the batteries for their own control system had run flat, so supply to the hospital and part of the nursing home stopped. Batteries and solar panels kept the highest-quality circuits (a clinic MRI and laboratory servers) running until early on 12 March, when the operator stopped the battery as its charge ran low; the DC supply kept going throughout. After the engines restarted, the operator rerouted power to four ventilator users in the nursing home, and the microgrid rejoined the grid on 14 March. IEEE Spectrum reported in October 2011 that the hospital ran "without a hitch"; NEDO's own case study says the hospital's supply stopped until the engines restarted.

    Lessonthe controls and starters of a backup plant need their own backup.

    nedo.go.jpspectrum.ieee.org

    Credit

    NTT Facilities (Keiichi Hirose); NEDO

  2. 2012

    Campuses ride out Sandy

    When Superstorm Sandy cut power across New York and New Jersey in late October 2012, Princeton University disconnected from the grid and ran its 15 MW gas-turbine combined heat and power plant, switching off administrative buildings so that the plant stayed within its limits, until grid power returned two days later. New York University's 14.4 MW plant islanded from Con Edison's network and kept its core campus powered and heated, and the city set up a command post there.

    osti.gov

    Credit

    Princeton University; NYU; ICF International and the US Department of Energy's Clean Energy Application Centers, report of March 2013

  3. 2016

    Many inverters, one island

    Newer rules make inverters ride through grid disturbances instead of tripping, which could slow their detection of an island. NREL tested three commercial home solar inverters from three makers on power hardware-in-the-loop (real inverters wired to a real-time grid simulation). Ride-through lengthened single-inverter islands, but across 244 tests with all three inverters in one island the longest lasted 632 ms, well inside the 2 second limit.

    osti.gov

    Credit

    Anderson Hoke and colleagues, NREL (report NREL/TP-5D00-66732)

  4. 2018

    Planned islands enter the standard

    The first edition of IEEE 1547, the US standard for connecting small generators to the grid, approved in June 2003, required them not to keep feeding neighbouring customers or the utility's lines once the grid had lost its supply, and it did not cover planned islands or microgrids; IEEE 1547.4 (2011) then gave guidance for designing them. The revised IEEE 1547-2018, approved on 15 February 2018, made rules for planned islands part of the main standard: scheduled and unscheduled transitions to island mode, and categories for generators that can island, black start or hold frequency on their own. Unintentional islands must still be detected and the generator stopped within 2 seconds, which the utility may extend to 5 seconds.

    osti.govosti.gov

    Credit

    IEEE Standards Coordinating Committee 21; summaries by Thomas Basso and by David Narang, Michael Ingram, Andy Hoke, Akanksha Bhat and Shazreen Meor Danial, NREL

  5. 2020

    A hydro island trips twice

    BC Hydro, the utility of British Columbia, Canada, keeps customers supplied during line outages by running a remote substation's area as an island on three privately owned run-of-river hydro plants. Its engineers described two failures in a 2020 conference paper. In one, a field electrician reported two capacitor banks as switched off when they were live, a disconnect switch not rated to break that current flashed over, and protection dropped one feeder. In the other, a wrongly programmed alarm tripped one generator, the remaining unit could not carry the load, and frequency fell to 52.9 Hz in under 500 ms before the plant disconnected.

    Lessonan island depends on telemetry and settings that nobody checks while the grid is up.

    esic.wsu.edu

    Credit

    Mukesh Nagpal and colleagues, BC Hydro; John Wheeler, New Energy Design

  6. 2024

    Gas microgrids through Beryl

    Hurricane Beryl left 2.26 million of CenterPoint Energy's nearly 3 million customers around Houston without power in July 2024. Canary Media reported that gas-fuelled microgrids kept wastewater plants, hospitals, care homes and grocery stores running; Enchanted Rock, which builds them, said 146 of its 155 Houston-area microgrids started, and some ran for more than 162 hours.

    Lessongas pipelines survive the wind and floods that bring down power lines and block diesel deliveries, Canary Media notes, but Carnegie Mellon researchers found that about 10% of US pipeline compressor stations run on electricity, so a wide outage can still cut gas to generators downstream.

    canarymedia.comengineering.cmu.edu

    Credit

    Enchanted Rock; H-E-B and other site owners

  7. 2024

    A week on sun and batteries

    Duke Energy's microgrid at Hot Springs, North Carolina, a 2 MW solar farm and a 4.4 MW lithium-ion battery that began operating in 2023, was designed to carry the whole town for 4 to 6 hours while crews fixed a routine fault. Hurricane Helene struck on 27 September 2024 and washed away the substation in nearby Marshall that fed the town. From 2 to 8 October the microgrid cut the town off from the grid and supplied it alone, downtown at all hours and the rest of the town except some overnight hours, until the grid returned; storm damage had lowered demand, which made the stretch possible. The Southern Alliance for Clean Energy reported it.

    Lessona battery sized for hours can last days when load falls or is cut back, so plans for long outages need a list of which loads to drop.

    cleanenergy.org

    Credit

    Duke Energy (Jason Handley, Distributed Energy Group)

Watch for

  1. A town on batteries alone

    San Diego Gas & Electric's Borrego Springs microgrid, installed in 2013, used diesel generators to form its island. With NREL, SDG&E upgraded a battery inverter to grid-forming, meaning it sets voltage and frequency itself as a generator would. In field tests from November 2023, on a sectioned-off circuit and inside the microgrid yard with no customers connected and the diesels off, the battery black-started and islanded the system and held frequency within 0.5% of 60 Hz. Islanding the whole community on batteries and solar was done only in simulation, and the report says conventional generators "may only be needed as a backup".

    Achieved whenthe whole Borrego Springs community runs as an island led by batteries with the diesels off, and someone outside SDG&E publishes the measured frequency and voltage.

    osti.govosti.gov

    Claimed by

    SDG&E and NREL, final report of September 2025

Open

  1. 01

    A record of microgrid outages

    A public table of every reported outage in which a microgrid tried to island: date, place, size, sources, loads carried, hours run, whether the transfer worked, and what failed. Each row links to its source.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Time home battery switchovers

    Measure how long homes with whole-home battery backup, such as Tesla Powerwall, Enphase IQ and FranklinWH aPower systems, actually go dark when the grid fails, using a plug-in voltage recorder in an ordinary wall socket at volunteers' homes during real outages.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A record of microgrid outages

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of every reported outage in which a microgrid tried to island: date, place, size, sources, loads carried, hours run, whether the transfer worked, and what failed. Each row links to its source.

Why it is still open

Outage records are kept site by site or by vendors. SDG&E's 2025 report tabulates only Borrego Springs' own islanding events to June 2021, and the Hurricane Beryl figure of 146 of 155 Houston microgrids is Enchanted Rock's own count. Searches of Zenodo and the web found single-site data sets and simulations, but no record across many sites.

osti.govcanarymedia.com

Built with what exists

Utility reports to regulators, US national laboratory reports on osti.gov, conference papers such as BC Hydro's, news archives, and an AI model for reading and extracting fields, such as Meta's Muse Ember, covered in the Note "The jobs agents repeat".

  1. First step

    Enter the 14 sites in ICF's 2013 report on combined heat and power during Sandy and other outages, plus the Sendai, BC Hydro and Hot Springs events, as the first rows, and fix the column list.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 150 events from at least five countries, each with a source link, and a second person who rechecks 30 random rows against their sources and agrees on at least 27.

Open 02 · the brief

Time home battery switchovers

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Measure how long homes with whole-home battery backup, such as Tesla Powerwall, Enphase IQ and FranklinWH aPower systems, actually go dark when the grid fails, using a plug-in voltage recorder in an ordinary wall socket at volunteers' homes during real outages.

Why it is still open

Makers state figures such as FranklinWH's "less than 16ms", while a Powerwall 2 owner on the Tesla Motors Club forum reports that at night the switch takes "more than a couple seconds". Searches found no independent measured comparison across brands.

franklinwh.comteslamotorsclub.com

Built with what exists

A plug-in recorder such as the Fluke VR1710, which plugs into a socket and logs dips and interruptions, with RMS values every quarter cycle; a shared spreadsheet; owners' app screenshots of each outage. Nobody opens a panel or touches wiring.

  1. First step

    Recruit ten owners in an outage-prone area through owner forums and agree on one recording setting for every unit.

  2. Done looks like

    50 logged outages across at least three brands, each with the measured gap in milliseconds, published beside each maker's stated figure.