BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Medical billing

Patient bills

Working out what the patient owes, telling them before care where that can be done, and settling the bill they receive afterwards.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1973 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1973

    Japan caps what patients pay

    Japan's health ministry sets one national fee schedule that every provider, public or private, must charge, and revises it every two years; most adults pay 30% of the scheduled fee. In 1973 the government introduced caps on out-of-pocket payments. Under today's high-cost medical expense benefit, a standard wage earner pays at most JPY 80,100 (about USD 529) a month, plus 1% of costs above JPY 267,000. Out-of-pocket payments were 12.2% of Japan's health spending in 2023, against an average of 19.3% for high-income countries, by the Commonwealth Fund's 2026 country profile.

    commonwealthfund.org

    Credit

    Government of Japan; Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare

  2. 2003

    Singapore publishes bill sizes

    On 29 September 2003 Singapore's Ministry of Health and the Consumers Association of Singapore launched public hospital bill-size data, so that people could compare what an elective procedure such as knee surgery cost at different hospitals. It started with 28 common conditions and procedures at public hospitals, showed the 50th and 90th percentile bill for each so that patients could budget, and was to be updated monthly. Private hospitals were asked to submit their data by the end of that year.

    moh.gov.sg

    Credit

    Ministry of Health, Singapore; Consumers Association of Singapore (CASE)

  3. 2013

    Hospital list prices made public

    A hospital's chargemaster is its list of prices, called charges, for every item and service. Insurers mostly pay lower negotiated rates, but uninsured patients are often asked to pay full charges. On 8 May 2013 the US health department published hospitals' average charges for the 100 most common Medicare inpatient stays; for joint replacement they ran from $5,300 at a hospital in Ada, Oklahoma, to $223,000 at one in Monterey Park, California. Using Medicare cost reports, Ge Bai and Gerard Anderson then found that the 50 US hospitals with the highest markups charged about ten times their Medicare-allowable costs in 2012, against a national average of 3.4 times.

    cms.govebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS); Ge Bai and Gerard F. Anderson (Health Affairs, 2015)

  4. 2015

    New York arbitrates surprise bills

    A surprise bill comes from an out-of-network doctor the patient did not choose, for example in an emergency or at an in-network hospital. From April 2015 New York's law let patients in state-regulated plans pay only their in-network share and sent the payment dispute to "baseball-style" arbitration, in which the arbiter picks either the insurer's or the provider's final offer. State guidance told arbiters to consider the 80th percentile of billed charges. Through 2018, decisions averaged 8% above that level, by the state's own data; Loren Adler of the USC-Brookings Schaeffer Initiative concluded the process was "substantially increasing what New Yorkers pay", while the state estimated savings to consumers of over $400 million without published support.

    Lessonan arbitration standard tied to billed charges, which providers set themselves, pulled payments up.

    brookings.edu

    Credit

    New York State Legislature; New York Department of Financial Services; Loren Adler

  5. 2021

    Hospitals must post prices

    From 1 January 2021 every US hospital must publish a machine-readable file of its standard charges, including the rates it has negotiated with each insurer, and a consumer-friendly display of shoppable services, those a patient can schedule in advance. In a stratified random sample of 100 hospitals, the Office of Inspector General (OIG) of the US health department found 63 complying and estimated that 46% of the 5,879 hospitals covered did not (report A-07-22-06108, November 2024). Callers posing as patients found the price a hospital quoted by phone matched its posted cash price exactly at 3 of 22 hospitals for a vaginal birth and 9 of 47 for a brain MRI scan, in a study of 60 hospitals in 2022.

    Lessona posted file did not make the price patients were quoted the same as the one published.

    cms.govoig.hhs.govebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    CMS; OIG; Merina Thomas, Peter Cram and colleagues (JAMA Internal Medicine, 2023)

  6. 2022

    Surprise bills banned nationwide

    The US No Surprises Act took effect on 1 January 2022. It protects patients from most surprise out-of-network bills and sends the provider's and plan's payment dispute to a federal independent dispute resolution (IDR) process, baseball-style arbitration by certified private entities, through a portal opened on 15 April 2022. In the first five and a half months parties filed 90,078 disputes, more than the government had estimated for a full year, and 69% of the disputes closed in that time were found ineligible. By 30 September 2026, 7,798,616 disputes had been filed, 390,602 of them in September 2026 alone.

    Lessonthe process was built for a small fraction of the disputes that came, and sorting eligible from ineligible cases became the main cause of delay.

    cms.govcms.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor and the Treasury

  7. 2024

    Debt relief tested at random

    Medical debt is a bill a patient could not pay, often sold to a collector. Economists worked with the charity RIP Medical Debt, now Undue Medical Debt, to run two randomized experiments that bought and cancelled medical debts with a face value of $169 million for 83,401 people between 2018 and 2020. They found no effect on survey measures of mental and physical health, use of health care or financial wellbeing, a modest gain in access to credit only where the debt would otherwise have stayed on credit reports, and a moderate fall in payment of existing medical bills.

    Lessoncancelling debt long after the bill, once it has been sold, did not bring the gains in health and finances that studies of indebted patients had suggested.

    nber.org

    Credit

    Raymond Kluender, Neale Mahoney, Francis Wong and Wesley Yin (NBER Working Paper 32315, 2024)

Watch for

  1. Fees published by doctor's name

    Australia's Medical Costs Finder website, launched in 2019 at a cost of A$24 million, relied on specialists to volunteer their fees, and about 88 had done so by the end of 2025, by the count of Yuting Zhang, Charles Kemp and Stephen Duckett. A law passed in September 2026 lets the government publish named specialists' fees from the Medicare billing data it already collects, with a low, typical and high estimate of the patient's out-of-pocket cost, backed by A$7 million.

    Achieved whenthe site shows fees for most practicing specialists and an independent study reports whether out-of-pocket costs or patient complaints about unexpected bills changed.

    findanexpert.unimelb.edu.aumedicalrepublic.com.au

    Claimed by

    the Australian Government (health minister Mark Butler), September 2026

  2. Hospital price files in dollars

    CMS finalized on 21 November 2025 that from 1 January 2026, enforced from 1 April 2026, a hospital whose negotiated rate is a percentage or formula must also post the median, 10th and 90th percentile amounts actually allowed, in dollars, calculated from its electronic remittance records, the payment statements insurers send. Hospitals must also attest that the file is accurate. CMS says this will ensure "pricing information is easily comparable across hospitals". A first look by KFF in October 2026, using data gathered by Turquoise Health, found that the new allowed-amount fields "often contain no information" and that hospitals record similar arrangements in different free-text fields.

    Achieved whenan independent analysis of a national sample finds that most negotiated rates for common inpatient stays can be compared in dollars without reading free text.

    cms.govhealthsystemtracker.org

    Claimed by

    CMS, November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Planted errors in invented bills

    A public set of 500 invented itemized hospital and doctor bills, each with an invented explanation of benefits (the insurer's statement of what it paid and what the patient owes), in which a labeled share carries planted errors: duplicate lines, pairs of services billed separately that Medicare's edits say belong together (unbundling), quantities above Medicare's limits per day, charges dated after discharge, an out-of-network charge the No Surprises Act forbids, and a balance above the patient's in-network share. Two certified coders agree each label. Run patient-facing bill checkers and general AI models on every bill and publish how many planted errors each catches and how many false alarms it raises.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Price-file formulas made readable

    A public set of 1,000 free-text "algorithm" and "notes" entries copied from hospitals' public price files, each coded by two analysts into a fixed structure: contract method, base dollar amount, percentage of charges, per-day rate, stop-loss threshold (the bill size above which a different rate applies) and carve-outs. Then score AI models on turning the text into that structure and on computing the payment for 300 invented hospital stays.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Planted errors in invented bills

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of 500 invented itemized hospital and doctor bills, each with an invented explanation of benefits (the insurer's statement of what it paid and what the patient owes), in which a labeled share carries planted errors: duplicate lines, pairs of services billed separately that Medicare's edits say belong together (unbundling), quantities above Medicare's limits per day, charges dated after discharge, an out-of-network charge the No Surprises Act forbids, and a balance above the patient's in-network share. Two certified coders agree each label. Run patient-facing bill checkers and general AI models on every bill and publish how many planted errors each catches and how many false alarms it raises.

Why it is still open

A search in November 2026 found no public test set of medical bills. The closest work, a September 2026 preprint by Jan Hölter and colleagues, tested four open-weight models on 36 curated cases against an invented fee catalog, found no consistent advantage over a simple baseline and called for real catalogs and independent annotation. Consumer tools publish comparisons without shared cases: CoveredUSA's 2026 post ranks its own bill checker above ChatGPT and Perplexity with no test data, while the Healthcare Financial Management Association reported in February 2026 that patients are already using such tools to dispute bills.

coveredusa.orghfma.orgarxiv.org

Built with what exists

Medicare's National Correct Coding Initiative edit files, procedure-to-procedure pairs and medically unlikely edits, published each quarter; Medicare's national payment amount file for realistic prices; Synthea, MITRE's open-source generator of made-up patient records, for the invented stays; general AI models and open-weight models run locally (see the Note "A trillion open parameters"); a web agent to operate checkers that have only a web form (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"). CPT procedure codes are copyrighted by the American Medical Association, so the public release either carries an AMA license or uses public HCPCS Level II codes and hospital revenue codes only.

cms.govcms.govgithub.com

  1. First step

    Write 20 invented bills for one common hospital stay, plant one error type in each of 10, and run two free checkers and one general model on them.

  2. Done looks like

    500 bills, at least 150 with planted errors across six or more error types, the coders' agreement reported, at least five tools or models scored with a catch rate and a false-alarm rate for each error type, all published with a DOI.

Open 02 · the brief

Price-file formulas made readable

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of 1,000 free-text "algorithm" and "notes" entries copied from hospitals' public price files, each coded by two analysts into a fixed structure: contract method, base dollar amount, percentage of charges, per-day rate, stop-loss threshold (the bill size above which a different rate applies) and carve-outs. Then score AI models on turning the text into that structure and on computing the payment for 300 invented hospital stays.

Why it is still open

KFF's October 2026 review says these free-text entries are readable one at a time but "difficult for any kind of systematic analysis", and that hospitals put similar terms in different fields. A Carnegie Mellon poster at AMIA in 2025 built an AI question-answering tool on price data, with 62% accuracy on its own queries, but did not extract formulas. Payerset sells an AI assistant on the same data to health systems. A search in November 2026 found no public labeled set.

workshopamia2025.github.iofiercehealthcare.comhealthsystemtracker.org

Built with what exists

hospitals' machine-readable files, public by law; CMS's file schema and validator on GitHub; AI models with structured output; Python to price the invented stays.

github.com

  1. First step

    Pull the algorithm entries for hip and knee replacement (MS-DRG 470) from 20 hospitals' files and code the first 100 by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    1,000 entries from at least 200 hospitals in 20 or more states, agreement between the two analysts reported, at least three models scored on field accuracy and on computing each invented stay's payment to within 1%, with the code published.