BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Medical billing

Denials and appeals

What happens when a payer refuses or cuts a bill, and how hospitals, doctors and patients contest that decision.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2010 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2010

    A right to outside review

    The US Affordable Care Act gave people in health plans created after 23 March 2010 the right to contest a refusal twice: first with the plan itself (an internal appeal), then with an independent decision-maker outside the plan (external review), whatever the type of insurance or the state. Rules issued in July 2010 by three federal departments set one process for both steps. A state could keep its own external review process if it met the model law of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

    cms.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; the Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor and the Treasury

  2. 2019

    Germany caps hospital bill audits

    In Germany a sickness fund, the name for a statutory health insurer, can send a hospital bill to the Medical Service, a body of medical reviewers, and a failed check cuts the payment. The MDK Reform Act, passed by the Bundestag in November 2019, made the Medical Service a public body separate from the funds and capped the share of each hospital's bills that may be audited. From 2021 the cap follows the hospital's record: where 60% or more of audited bills pass, only 5% may be checked. A hospital now pays a penalty of at least €300 for each bill the audit corrects; before, only a fund paid €300, when a bill it had challenged passed. Parliament set the 2020 cap at 12.5%, by Deutsches Ärzteblatt's report.

    Lessontying how often a payer may audit to how often the bills pass gives both sides a reason to get the bill right the first time.

    aerzteblatt.de

    Credit

    German Bundestag; Federal Ministry of Health

  3. 2023

    Court order clears Medicare backlog

    A hospital that disputes a Medicare payment denial can take it to an administrative law judge, who by law has 90 days to decide. The American Hospital Association and three hospitals sued when appeals waited far longer. On 1 November 2018 a federal court ordered the health department to cut the backlog, then projected at 426,594 appeals, to set targets. By 31 March 2023 the department reported 663 appeals past the 90-day limit, a fall of 99.84%.

    Lessonthe deadline in the statute did not hold until a court set reduction targets and required regular reports.

    aha.org

    Credit

    American Hospital Association and the hospital plaintiffs; US District Court for the District of Columbia; Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals

  4. 2023

    Denials in 1.2 seconds

    Reporters at ProPublica and The Capitol Forum found, from internal documents and former staff, that the US insurer Cigna used a system called PXDX, short for procedure-to-diagnosis. It let the company's doctors reject claims in batches when a treatment did not match a list of accepted diagnoses, without opening the patient's file. Over two months in 2022, Cigna doctors denied over 300,000 requests this way, at an average of 1.2 seconds each, and one company document estimated that only 5% of people would appeal. Cigna called the reporting "biased and incomplete".

    Lessona rule that a doctor must sign each medical denial does not ensure that the doctor reads the case.

    propublica.org

    Credit

    Patrick Rucker (The Capitol Forum), Maya Miller and David Armstrong (ProPublica)

  5. 2024

    Senate counts post-acute denials

    Post-acute care is nursing-home, rehabilitation or home care after a hospital stay. A US Senate subcommittee obtained more than 280,000 pages of documents from UnitedHealthcare, Humana and CVS, which together cover nearly 60% of people in Medicare Advantage, the private plans that run Medicare benefits. Its majority staff report of 17 October 2024 found that UnitedHealthcare's denial rate for requests for post-acute care rose from 10.9% in 2020 to 22.7% in 2022, while the company was automating the review process. In 2022 UnitedHealthcare and CVS denied such requests at about three times their overall rates, and Humana at over 16 times.

    hsgac.senate.gov

    Credit

    US Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, majority staff under Senator Richard Blumenthal

  6. 2025

    Half of outside reviews overturn

    Independent medical review is the US name for external review of a medical denial by doctors who do not work for the insurer. A study of such reviews in four US states over 2019 to 2023 found that almost one-half of the health plan denials that reached this stage were overturned. For genetic tests for cancer the share was one-third, and it varied by state, cancer and test. The study was first published in December 2025.

    ebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    G. A. Lin, J. M. Coffman, M. P. Douglas and K. A. Phillips (Health Affairs, 2026)

  7. 2026

    One in five claims denied

    US law requires insurers that sell plans on HealthCare.gov, the federal insurance marketplace, to report how many claims they deny. KFF, a health policy research group, analyzed the figures for 2024 as published by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Insurers received about 496 million claims and denied 19% of those from in-network providers, about 85 million; the rate ran from 3% to 36% by insurer. Consumers appealed fewer than 1% of denied claims, and insurers upheld 66% of the denials that were appealed. The most common denial reason reported was "Other", at 36%.

    Lessona right to appeal that fewer than one in a hundred people use does little to correct wrong denials.

    kff.org

    Credit

    KFF, using CMS Transparency in Coverage data

Watch for

  1. Paid AI appeal letters

    Claimable, a US company founded in 2023, sells appeal letters drafted by AI from clinical studies, policy text and the patient's own account, for a flat fee of $39.95 plus shipping. Its website states that "80% of Claimable appeals succeed, with most resolved in 10 days or less". It supports a fixed list of treatments, more than 85 by its own count.

    Achieved whenan outside party, such as a state insurance regulator or a university group, follows a defined set of its appeals to their outcomes, counting the ones that failed or were never decided, and compares them with similar appeals written without the tool.

    getclaimable.com

    Claimed by

    Claimable, on its website as read in November 2026

  2. Free AI appeal letters

    Counterforce Health offers a free tool that writes appeal letters with AI for patients, doctors and caregivers. Its website shows "10K+ Appeals" and "75% of appeals get approved", without saying how the figure was measured or whether it describes the tool's own appeals.

    Achieved whenthe organization or an outside reviewer publishes counts of appeals sent, approved, refused and unanswered, with the method, and a second party checks them.

    counterforcehealth.org

    Claimed by

    Counterforce Health, on its website as read in November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Appeal tools on invented denials

    A public test of the tools patients use to write appeals. Write 100 invented denial cases, each with a made-up patient summary, a made-up denial letter and the insurer's real, public coverage policy for that treatment. Run each case through the free appeal tools and at least two general AI models. Have two clinicians and one person with appeals experience score every letter: whether each cited study exists and says what the letter claims, whether each quoted policy clause exists, and whether deadlines and the right to external review are stated correctly. No letter is sent to an insurer.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Denial rates beyond HealthCare.gov

    One public table of claim denials and appeals by insurer for the US states that run their own insurance marketplaces, put together from what each state's regulator publishes and laid out in the same columns as the federal file, so that insurers can be compared across states.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Appeal tools on invented denials

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of the tools patients use to write appeals. Write 100 invented denial cases, each with a made-up patient summary, a made-up denial letter and the insurer's real, public coverage policy for that treatment. Run each case through the free appeal tools and at least two general AI models. Have two clinicians and one person with appeals experience score every letter: whether each cited study exists and says what the letter claims, whether each quoted policy clause exists, and whether deadlines and the right to external review are stated correctly. No letter is sent to an insurer.

Why it is still open

Published tests are small and none covers the tools patients are offered. A 2026 pilot in Academic Radiology scored 48 letters for 12 simulated radiology cases and found that 80% of the references produced by offline models were fabricated, as reported by Radiology Business. A March 2026 preprint scored prior authorization letters, not appeals, from three general models on 45 invented scenarios. An August 2026 preprint tested only its authors' own system on 1,000 synthetic cases. Claimable and Counterforce Health publish success rates but no test.

radiologybusiness.com

Built with what exists

Fight Health Insurance, a free appeal tool whose code is public on GitHub; Counterforce Health's free generator; general AI models; insurers' public medical policies and the Medicare Coverage Database; the Crossref and Europe PMC interfaces to check that each cited paper exists; a web agent such as Browser Use to operate tools that have only a web page (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over").

github.com

  1. First step

    Write 10 invented cases from one insurer's public policy for one treatment, run them through two tools, and check every reference by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    The 100 cases and every generated letter are published, with a rate of fabricated references, wrong policy quotes and wrong deadlines for each tool, the agreement between raters, and instructions that let someone rerun the same cases on a new tool.

Open 02 · the brief

Denial rates beyond HealthCare.gov

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

One public table of claim denials and appeals by insurer for the US states that run their own insurance marketplaces, put together from what each state's regulator publishes and laid out in the same columns as the federal file, so that insurers can be compared across states.

Why it is still open

KFF notes that federal reporting has so far been limited to plans sold on HealthCare.gov and leaves out plans on state-run marketplaces and employer plans. Some states publish their own figures: Pennsylvania's insurance department reported that insurers on its marketplace denied 14.8% of 20.7 million claims in 2024. A search in November 2026 found such reports one state at a time and no combined table.

kff.org

Built with what exists

The CMS Transparency in Coverage public use file for the column layout; state insurance department reports, such as Pennsylvania's annual Transparency in Coverage report; an open-source PDF table reader such as pdfplumber, or an AI model that reads tables, with every figure checked against the page; public-records requests where a state publishes nothing.

pa.gov

  1. First step

    Put Pennsylvania's latest report into the federal file's columns and note which fields cannot be filled.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 10 state-run marketplaces covered for two plan years, each figure linked to the regulator's document, a list of the states that publish nothing, and the table and code posted for reuse.