BRENNEN

Industries / Health

Health insurers and PBMs

Health insurers are the companies and funds that collect premiums or contributions from their members and pay doctors, hospitals and pharmacies for those members' care, and pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) are the companies that run the prescription drug part of that cover for them.

1260

On 28 December 1260 the Bishop of Hildesheim granted his protection to the St John's Brotherhood of the miners at the Rammelsberg mine near Goslar, Germany, the first recorded miners' guild in Germany. Members paid pennies into the brotherhood's box, which gave them support and help in sickness and at death; the Deutschlandmuseum in Berlin says the brotherhood is often viewed as the world's oldest social insurance scheme.

deutschlandmuseum.debergbaumuseum.de

38

Milestones achieved across 6 domains.

9

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

12

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

In one minute

Where it started

Health insurance began as members' funds: miners at Rammelsberg near Goslar paid into a common box from at least 1260 and drew on it when they fell sick. In the twentieth century funds and companies became the main way many countries pay for care, from Japan's national fund of 1948 that checks and pays the bills sent to employee insurers to the private insurers that processed US Medicare's claims from 1966. Pharmacy benefit managers began processing drug claims for US insurers in the late 1960s and went on to build the lists of drugs that plans cover.

Where it stands

Switzerland since 1996 and the Netherlands since 2006 have required everyone to buy a policy from private insurers that must accept every applicant, and like Germany they move money between insurers according to their members' age and illnesses; Germany's federal office paid the sickness funds about €350 billion that way in 2025. In the US 92.0% of people had health insurance for some or all of 2024, and 66.1% had private cover, by the Census Bureau's count. Private Medicare Advantage plans covered 55% of people eligible for Medicare in 2026 and made nearly 53 million prior authorization decisions in 2024, denying 7.7%, by KFF's counts.

What is open

Payers publish much of what they do, from Japan's claim checks and Medicare's drug plan files to insurers' lists of services that need approval, but few people outside test it. Most open jobs here are open tools built on invented members and public files: calculators that run one person through four countries' risk formulas, recompute Medicare drug costs against the government's own tool, or price each definition in a PBM contract, and a worked test of which insurer pays first when a person has two. Others are repeated checks of what payers have promised, such as whether insurers' cuts to prior authorization happened and how plans treat identical drugs sold at two prices.

Domains

AchievedWatch forOpen

Advances to build with

2 research notes

Open in health insurers and pbms

3 of 12 open deliverables

Open · Plans and enrollment

One patient, four risk formulas

An open calculator that takes an invented member (age, sex, region, diagnoses, prescriptions and hospital stays) and works out what four risk-equalization formulas would pay that member's insurer for a year: Germany's Morbi-RSA, the Dutch equalization under the Health Insurance Act, Switzerland's equalization, and the US HHS-HCC model for Marketplace plans. Run it on 200 invented members, from healthy 25-year-olds to people with several chronic illnesses, and publish where the formulas agree and where they differ, as a share of each country's average payment.

Built with what exists

BAS's yearly decisions on the German classification model, risk groups and weights; Gemeinsame Einrichtung KVG's documents on the Swiss equalization, including its drug-based cost groups (PCG); the equalization chapter of the Dutch Health Insurance Act and the yearly Dutch equalization rules; CMS's HHS-HCC software, which CMS now offers in Python as well as SAS; Synthea for invented medical histories; an AI coding agent checked only against hand-worked cases, as AWS checked an emulator its agents wrote (see the Note "Code no person read").

Credit · unclaimed

Open · Doctor and hospital networks

Network breadth from public files

A yearly measure, for every plan sold on HealthCare.gov, of how many local doctors and hospitals are in its network, by specialty and county, built only from public files: the provider files each insurer must publish, listed in CMS's machine-readable URL file; the national provider register (NPPES); and CMS's public data on clinicians who bill Medicare, as a count of doctors actually in practice. Publish the results each plan year with the code.

Built with what exists

CMS's Marketplace public use files, including the machine-readable URL file; NPPES; CMS's public "Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners" data; the plannet-directory-check code; Python; a web agent such as Browser Use to check a sample of listings against each insurer's own search page (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over").

Credit · unclaimed

Open · Checking and paying claims

Who pays first, worked out

A public test set of at least 400 invented households in which someone has more than one source of cover: two employer plans, a child of separated parents with or without a court decree, an active worker's plan and a retiree plan, COBRA continuation cover, Medicare with an employer plan from an employer with fewer or more than 20 employees, Medicare during the 30-month coordination period for kidney failure, Medicaid, and the medical part of car insurance. Each case gives the order in which the plans pay and the rule that decides it, under the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' (NAIC) model regulation on coordination of benefits and Medicare's secondary payer rules, worked out separately by two benefits specialists. Add an open-source rules engine that passes every case, and score AI models on the same set.

Built with what exists

NAIC Model Regulation 120; chapter 1 of CMS's Medicare Secondary Payer Manual; Python; general AI models and a model that scores fixed-answer questions, such as Google's Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); a spreadsheet for the two specialists' answers.

Credit · unclaimed