Industries / Health / Health insurers and PBMs
Prior authorization
A payer's agreement, before a test, operation, hospital stay or other treatment is given, that the plan will pay for it, and the review of whether care already under way is still needed, known as utilization review.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1972 to 2026.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1972
Doctors review Medicare stays
The Social Security Amendments of 1972 created Professional Standards Review Organizations (PSROs): local, not-for-profit groups of doctors, covering 195 areas from 1977, paid to check that care for Medicare and Medicaid patients was necessary, met local standards and was given "in the most economical manner". Their main work was reviewing hospital stays. Evaluations in the late 1970s by the Congressional Budget Office, the Government Accountability Office and the Medicare agency disagreed, and the Institute of Medicine later judged that the program "probably saved as many resources as it consumed". A 1982 law replaced PSROs with Peer Review Organizations, the forerunners of today's Quality Improvement Organizations.
LessonThe Institute of Medicine wrote that using the same reviewers both to contain costs and to protect quality "will almost surely short-change the latter" unless quality is deliberately protected.
Credit
US Congress; the Institute of Medicine's 1990 review
1996
Birth stays set by law
The US Newborns' and Mothers' Health Protection Act of 1996 bars the group health plans and insurers it covers from limiting a hospital stay for childbirth to less than 48 hours after a vaginal delivery or 96 hours after a caesarean. A shorter stay is allowed when the attending provider, in consultation with the mother, decides on an earlier discharge, and a health plan, insurance company or HMO cannot be the attending provider. For births, the discharge decision moved from the plan's reviewers to the clinician and the mother.
Credit
US Congress
2024
Medicare's rules bind private plans
A CMS rule of 5 April 2023, CMS-4201-F, in force from 1 January 2024, requires Medicare Advantage plans, the private plans that run Medicare benefits, to follow traditional Medicare's national and local coverage decisions, and to use criteria of their own only where Medicare's are not fully set, and then to publish them. Prior authorization may be used only to confirm a diagnosis or that care is medically necessary; an approval must last for the whole course of treatment; a new plan must give a person in treatment 90 days before asking for approval again; and every plan must have a utilization management committee that reviews its rules each year.
Credit
CMS
2024
One hour for cashless approval
In India most hospital stays paid by private insurance are "cashless": the hospital asks the insurer to approve the stay, and the insurer pays the hospital directly. A master circular on health insurance from the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI), dated 29 May 2024, which replaced 55 earlier circulars, requires insurers "to decide on cashless authorization requests immediately and within one hour and final authorization on discharge from hospital within three hours". If the discharge approval takes longer than three hours, the insurer must pay any extra hospital charges from its shareholders' funds.
Credit
IRDAI
2026
53 million requests counted
KFF, an independent health policy research group, counted from insurers' reports to CMS nearly 53 million prior authorization requests to Medicare Advantage plans in 2024, 1.7 per member, against just over 625,000 in traditional Medicare. The plans fully or partly denied 4.1 million (7.7%). Only 11.5% of the denials were appealed, and 80.7% of the appeals were fully or partly overturned.
Credit
Jeannie Fuglesten Biniek, Nolan Sroczynski, Meredith Freed and Tricia Neuman, KFF, January 2026
Watch for
A 30% cut at UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare said in May 2026 that it aimed to remove 30% of its prior authorization requirements by the end of 2026, and on 1 September 2026 listed about 1,700 codes that would no longer need approval from 1 October across its commercial, Medicaid, Medicare Advantage and individual plans.
Achieved whenan outside party compares UnitedHealthcare's posted code lists from before and after the change and finds the 30% cut, and the prior authorization figures it must post for 2027 show fewer requests.
Claimed by
UnitedHealthcare, May and September 2026
Open
01
Approval lists, before and after
A dated public archive of the prior authorization code lists that the 20 largest US insurers post for their commercial, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid plans, captured every quarter from a baseline before 1 January 2026, with each list turned into billing codes and compared over time. For each insurer it shows which codes left the list or joined it, and whether the change matches what the insurer and its trade group have claimed.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Plan criteria, found or missing
A named, repeated check of whether each Medicare Advantage organization publishes the internal coverage criteria it uses for prior authorization, as CMS has required since 2024, for 25 common services, and of where it applies criteria of its own to a service for which Medicare's national or local coverage decision already sets the rules. Each finding links to the page where the criteria are, or says where they should be and were not.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Approval lists, before and after
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A dated public archive of the prior authorization code lists that the 20 largest US insurers post for their commercial, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid plans, captured every quarter from a baseline before 1 January 2026, with each list turned into billing codes and compared over time. For each insurer it shows which codes left the list or joined it, and whether the change matches what the insurer and its trade group have claimed.
Why it is still open
AHIP, the insurers' trade group, said in 2026 that plans had cut prior authorizations by 11%, or 6.5 million requests, since their June 2025 pledge, but it did not say which services were dropped or how insurers differed, and the federal "public dashboards" promised in 2025 did not exist by July 2026. The closest published work, by Aya Zaari Jabri and colleagues at Stanford, counted the services needing approval in four insurers' commercial manuals at one point in time, from 3,048 at Humana to 842 at Aetna, not their change over time.
Built with what exists
insurers' public provider manuals and code lists, and earlier copies saved by the Internet Archive; a web agent such as Browser Use to find and save each list every quarter (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); pdfplumber to read PDF tables; AI models to sort codes into service groups, checked by hand, as the Stanford team did; Python.
First step
Save UnitedHealthcare's commercial prior authorization list from before and after 1 October 2026 and count the codes that left it.
Done looks like
for 20 insurers, a baseline list dated before 1 January 2026 and at least four quarterly snapshots, the change in code counts by insurer and line of business, a hand check of 200 changed codes, and the totals set beside AHIP's 11% and UnitedHealthcare's 30% claims.
Open 02 · the brief
Plan criteria, found or missing
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A named, repeated check of whether each Medicare Advantage organization publishes the internal coverage criteria it uses for prior authorization, as CMS has required since 2024, for 25 common services, and of where it applies criteria of its own to a service for which Medicare's national or local coverage decision already sets the rules. Each finding links to the page where the criteria are, or says where they should be and were not.
Why it is still open
The Government Accountability Office (GAO) could not find the public criteria that three of nine selected Medicare Advantage organizations used for five behavioral health services in 2024, but named none of them; CMS said it would review plans' internal criteria for selected services each year. A search in November 2026 found no public, plan-by-plan check.
Built with what exists
CMS's Medicare Coverage Database of national and local coverage decisions; Medicare Advantage organizations' websites; a web agent such as Browser Use to search each site the same way (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a spreadsheet; two reviewers for every "not found".
First step
Take GAO's five behavioral health services and check the ten largest organizations' websites.
Done looks like
for every Medicare Advantage organization with at least 100,000 members and for 25 services, a dated finding (criteria found, not found, or not used), the address of the page, and a flag where own criteria are used for a service with a national or local coverage decision; each organization offered the chance to reply before publication; the check rerun twice a year.