BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Health insurers and PBMs

Checking and paying claims

Receiving the bills that doctors, hospitals and pharmacies send, checking each one against the plan's rules and prices, settling which insurer pays first when a person has more than one, and paying.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1948 to 2021.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1948

    A fund to check claims

    Japan set up the Social Insurance Medical Fee Payment Fund in September 1948 under a law of its own, to stand between employee health insurers and the hospitals and clinics that bill them. It reviews their claims, pays them and settles the money nationally; its two stated missions are "proper review" and "prompt payment". By a 2010 count in the Journal of Epidemiology it handled about 70 million claim forms a month, one for each patient seen by each provider. A law passed on 5 December 2025 gave it the running of Japan's medical data systems as well, and on 1 October 2026 it became Japan Healthcare Payment & Digital Transformation Services (HPDX).

    hpdx.or.jphpdx.or.jppmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Japan's Diet; the Fund

  2. 1966

    Insurers process Medicare's bills

    When Medicare began paying in 1966, the US government did not process the claims itself. Private insurers did: fiscal intermediaries, which hospitals and nursing homes could choose for themselves, handled hospital (Part A) claims, and carriers handled doctors' (Part B) claims, under agreements the Social Security Administration negotiated. Section 911 of the Medicare Modernization Act of 2003 told the agency to replace them with Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs) chosen by open competition under federal purchasing rules.

    cms.govssa.gov

    Credit

    US Social Security Administration; Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans and other insurers; US Congress

  3. 1996

    Code pairs checked nationally

    In 1996 Medicare began the National Correct Coding Initiative (NCCI), a public set of claim edits: automatic checks that refuse to pay for pairs of procedure codes that should not be billed together. Before launch the edits were reviewed by the medical directors of Medicare's claims contractors and by the American Medical Association's coding committee. Edits on the largest likely quantity of a service in a day were added on 1 January 2007, state Medicaid programs had to use the same methods by 1 October 2010 under the Affordable Care Act, and the tables are republished every quarter.

    cms.gov

    Credit

    the US Health Care Financing Administration, now the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)

  4. 1997

    A system switch stalls payments

    In September 1996 Oxford Health Plans, a fast-growing New York insurer, moved most of its business onto a computer system it had built, called Pulse, but left claims on its old system, Pick, with data copied between the two. Its annual report for 1997 says the software and hardware problems that followed caused "significant delays" in paying claims and billing customers, and a backlog of complaints from doctors. Its share price fell sharply on 27 October 1997, and New York's insurance department and attorney general, the federal Medicare agency and the Securities and Exchange Commission opened inquiries. Oxford then gave up building claims processing into Pulse.

    LessonMoving the rest of a business to a new system while claims stay on the old one can hold up payments to doctors for months.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    Oxford Health Plans' own filing with the SEC

  5. 2000

    A separate agency checks claims

    In 2000 South Korea merged its many health insurance schemes into one insurer and set up the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service (HIRA) as an independent agency to review claims and assess the quality of care, so that the body that checks the bills is not the body that pays them. HIRA later took on claims review for Medical Aid, the program for people on low incomes (2005), for veterans' hospitals (2008) and for the medical part of car insurance claims (2013).

    hira.or.kr

    Credit

    the Government of South Korea; HIRA

  6. 2021

    One set of checks nationwide

    Japan's fund long had differences in review between its prefectural branches, and set up a committee in 1995 to resolve them. It published its computer-check rules in March 2018. In September 2021 it moved every branch's own computer-check rules to headquarters or abolished them and switched on a new review and payment system, and in October 2022 it concentrated review work so that it is done the same way across the country. The fund says a survey it finished in November 2021 found no significant change, such as larger doses per prescription, after it began in October 2020 to publish checks that rest on medical judgment.

    LessonWhen each office writes its own checks, the same claim can be paid in one prefecture and cut in another.

    hpdx.or.jphpdx.or.jp

    Credit

    the Fund; Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare

Watch for

  1. A shared fee calculator

    On 1 June 2026 Japan's HPDX began full operation of a common calculation module: one program, kept up to date by the payer side, that the billing software of hospitals and clinics can call to work out the fee and the patient's share, checked against HPDX's own code lists before the claim is sent. It is available first in the cloud billing software of ORCA, a company of the Japan Medical Association, and HPDX says it expects vendors and clinics to spend less reprogramming their systems at each fee revision.

    Achieved whenthe health ministry or an outside study reports how many clinics use the module and whether claim errors or vendors' revision costs fell.

    hpdx.or.jp

    Claimed by

    HPDX, June 2026

  2. Claims answered during the visit

    Optum, part of UnitedHealth Group, launched Optum Real on 21 October 2025: a system through which a provider can ask the payer about a patient's benefits and a claim while care is being given, "not two weeks after", with UnitedHealthcare as the first plan to use it. Optum says it could help avoid claim denials.

    Achieved whena provider using it or an outside researcher publishes denial rates and payment times for claims sent through Optum Real against comparable claims that were not.

    healthcaredive.com

    Claimed by

    Optum, October 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Who pays first, worked out

    A public test set of at least 400 invented households in which someone has more than one source of cover: two employer plans, a child of separated parents with or without a court decree, an active worker's plan and a retiree plan, COBRA continuation cover, Medicare with an employer plan from an employer with fewer or more than 20 employees, Medicare during the 30-month coordination period for kidney failure, Medicaid, and the medical part of car insurance. Each case gives the order in which the plans pay and the rule that decides it, under the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' (NAIC) model regulation on coordination of benefits and Medicare's secondary payer rules, worked out separately by two benefits specialists. Add an open-source rules engine that passes every case, and score AI models on the same set.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Japan's claim checks, reusable abroad

    An open, documented copy of the claim checks that Japan's HPDX publishes (which drugs suit which diagnoses, dose limits, drug pairs that must not be combined, drugs to avoid with a given disease, and procedures matched to diagnoses), with every drug mapped to the World Health Organization's ATC drug classification and every disease to ICD-10, English labels, and an open-source checker that runs the checks on a claim. Test it on synthetic claims built from HPDX's published examples, so that an insurer or claims reviewer in another country can see what each check would catch.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Who pays first, worked out

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set of at least 400 invented households in which someone has more than one source of cover: two employer plans, a child of separated parents with or without a court decree, an active worker's plan and a retiree plan, COBRA continuation cover, Medicare with an employer plan from an employer with fewer or more than 20 employees, Medicare during the 30-month coordination period for kidney failure, Medicaid, and the medical part of car insurance. Each case gives the order in which the plans pay and the rule that decides it, under the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' (NAIC) model regulation on coordination of benefits and Medicare's secondary payer rules, worked out separately by two benefits specialists. Add an open-source rules engine that passes every case, and score AI models on the same set.

Why it is still open

Insurers apply these rules to every claim from a person with two plans, and the NAIC model regulation sets out "a uniform order of benefit determination" rule by rule, but a search in November 2026 found no public set of worked cases, no open-source engine and no published test of software or AI models against them.

content.naic.org

Built with what exists

NAIC Model Regulation 120; chapter 1 of CMS's Medicare Secondary Payer Manual; Python; general AI models and a model that scores fixed-answer questions, such as Google's Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); a spreadsheet for the two specialists' answers.

cms.gov

  1. First step

    Write 40 cases, five for each of the model regulation's main order rules (such as the birthday rule for children), and have two people answer them separately.

  2. Done looks like

    400 cases covering every order rule in the model regulation and at least eight Medicare secondary payer situations, the two specialists' rate of agreement reported, the engine passing all cases, and at least four AI models scored on the order of payers, all published with a DOI.

Open 02 · the brief

Japan's claim checks, reusable abroad

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, documented copy of the claim checks that Japan's HPDX publishes (which drugs suit which diagnoses, dose limits, drug pairs that must not be combined, drugs to avoid with a given disease, and procedures matched to diagnoses), with every drug mapped to the World Health Organization's ATC drug classification and every disease to ICD-10, English labels, and an open-source checker that runs the checks on a claim. Test it on synthetic claims built from HPDX's published examples, so that an insurer or claims reviewer in another country can see what each check would catch.

Why it is still open

HPDX has published its computer-check rules in stages since March 2018 and releases the check master files as CSV files with each update, the latest dated 30 October 2026, but only in Japanese and keyed to Japanese drug and disease codes. A search in November 2026 found no English or internationally coded version.

hpdx.or.jp

Built with what exists

HPDX's check master files; the standard Japanese disease-name master kept by MEDIS-DC, which follows ICD-10; WHO's ATC index; machine translation checked by a pharmacist who reads Japanese; a low-cost model for repeated matching, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python.

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

  1. First step

    Confirm HPDX's terms for reuse, then map the drugs in its smallest file, the list of drugs contraindicated with certain diseases, to ATC codes.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 90% of the drug and dose checks mapped to ATC and ICD-10 codes, a random 500 mappings checked by two pharmacists with their agreement reported, the checker reproducing every published example, and the whole set released under an open licence with each row traced to its HPDX file and date.