BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Advertising and marketing / Graphic and web design

Brand identity

Brand identity is the work of designing a client's logo, colors and typefaces, and the rulebook, called brand guidelines or a graphics standards manual, that keeps them the same wherever they appear.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1876 to 2025.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1876

    UK trade mark number one

    When the Trade Marks Registration Act 1875 came into force, a British business could register its mark with the state, and on 1 January 1876 the Bass & Co red triangle label became the UK's first registered trade mark. A registered mark is property its owner can defend. The UK Intellectual Property Office says the register now protects more than 2.5 million marks, received around 200,000 applications in the past year, and still holds more than 400 marks filed before 1900.

    gov.uk

    Credit

    Bass & Co; the UK Parliament, for the 1875 Act

  2. 1907

    A company planned as one

    The Berlin electrical company AEG made the architect Peter Behrens its artistic consultant, and from 1907 to 1914 he designed its products, advertising and buildings, including the AEG Turbine Factory of 1909, by the Vitra Design Museum's account. A history page on an AEG website calls him "the inventor of corporate identity," meaning a company's whole appearance planned as a single system, and says a large company's image was "comprehensively defined and standardized for the first time." Those two claims are the company's own.

    collection.design-museum.deaeg-ie.com

    Credit

    Peter Behrens; AEG

  3. 1956

    IBM's first design program

    Thomas J. Watson Jr., who had taken over IBM from his father, set up its first Design Program and hired the graphic designer Paul Rand, who redrew the IBM logotype (a logo made only of lettering) in a typeface called City Medium. In 1972 Rand drew it in eight horizontal stripes, a version IBM says has stayed "unchanged since 1972." The Henry Ford museum dates the two logotypes 1956 to 1972 and 1972 to the present.

    ibm.comthehenryford.org

    Credit

    Thomas J. Watson Jr.; Paul Rand; IBM

  4. 1975

    NASA's worm and manual

    The New York firm Danne & Blackburn designed NASA's red lettering logotype, nicknamed the "worm," introduced in 1975 and set out in a Graphics Standards Manual of 1976. In 1992 NASA retired it, except on clothing and souvenirs, in favor of its original round insignia from the late 1950s, the "meatball." It came back in April 2020 for the first crewed SpaceX launch, Demo-2, and NASA's brand guidelines now allow it as a supplemental graphic.

    LessonA rulebook protects a mark only as long as the client's leaders follow it; NASA's administrator Jim Bridenstine said in 2020, "The NASA style guide is very clear, the worm no longer exists — but I write the style guide.".

    nasa.govnasa.govcollectspace.com

    Credit

    Richard Danne and Bruce Blackburn; NASA

  5. 2010

    Gap's logo lasts a week

    In October 2010 the clothing chain Gap replaced its decades-old logo, white letters on a navy blue box, with black letters on white and a small blue box on its website, without announcing it. Customers complained on Twitter, Facebook and blogs, and Gap first invited the public to submit designs. On 12 October, one week after the swap, it said it would keep the old logo, the Associated Press reported.

    LessonHansen said, "There may be a time to evolve our logo, but if and when that time comes, we'll handle it in a different way," and that this was not the right project to offer up to "crowd sourcing.".

    huffpost.com

    Credit

    Gap Inc.; Marka Hansen, then president of Gap North America

  6. 2025

    Cracker Barrel restores Old Timer

    On Tuesday 19 August 2025 the US restaurant chain Cracker Barrel showed a new logo with just its name on a gold background, dropping the barrel, the words "Old Country Store" and the seated man known as Uncle Herschel. The Associated Press reported that its shares fell more than 7% by the close of trading that Thursday. On 26 August the company said: "Our new logo is going away and our 'Old Timer' will remain."

    LessonFifteen years after Gap, a rebrand that removed a figure customers knew was still reversed within a week.

    ksl.comnbcmiami.com

    Credit

    Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

Watch for

  1. USPTO image search for marks

    In April 2026 the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) added a beta feature to its free trademark search: a user uploads an image and it returns registered marks with similar design elements. The law firm Akerman reports that the office "has not published detailed technical specifications for the tool's matching algorithm," and advises treating results "as a supplemental resource, not a substitute for a comprehensive clearance search."

    Achieved whenan outside party tests it on decided cases and publishes how often it finds the earlier, conflicting mark, or the USPTO publishes accuracy figures that an outside test confirms.

    akerman.com

    Claimed by

    the USPTO, April 2026, as reported by Akerman on 1 May 2026

  2. AI reviewers of brand rules

    Frontify, which sells software for keeping brand guidelines, says its Brand Check app "analyzes your assets against your guidelines and reports issues automatically," and describes an AI agent called Specs, "still in development," meant to review logo use and placement and check fonts after a rebrand. Adobe introduced Brand Intelligence on 20 April 2026, saying it "helps ensure every piece of content is on brand" by learning from reviewers' feedback, rejections and approvals. Neither company gives accuracy figures.

    Achieved whenan outside party publishes how many known rule breaks a tool catches, and how many false alarms it raises, on a test set the vendor did not choose.

    frontify.comnews.adobe.com

    Claimed by

    Frontify, page updated February 2026; Adobe, April 2026

  3. A brand file for machines

    The Ad Context Protocol (AdCP), a standard for advertising software agents, defines brand.json, a file a brand hosts on its own website that its documentation calls "the canonical source of brand identity data." It has fields for logos, colors, fonts and tone of voice, and for rules such as the minimum clear space around a logo (the empty margin it must keep) and which colors may be paired. The documentation also says: "Most brands return nothing — which means agents are guessing."

    Achieved whenbrands outside the protocol's group publish the file on their own sites, and design or brand software made outside the group reads it.

    docs.adcontextprotocol.orgdocs.adcontextprotocol.org

    Claimed by

    AdCP and AgenticAdvertising.org, documentation for schema version 3.2.8, November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A scorecard for logo search

    A public test of the free trademark image searches, the USPTO's beta and the World Intellectual Property Organization's Global Brand Database, on US cases with known outcomes. The cases are decisions of the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB, the USPTO's tribunal) from 2025 and 2026 in which the owner of an earlier mark tried to block a new one, called an opposition, and both marks include a design. For each case, upload the newer logo and record whether, and at what rank, the earlier mark appears. Publish case numbers, serial numbers, query dates and ranks, not the logo images.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Planted errors for brand checkers

    A made-up brand with a rulebook of about ten rules (palette colors, approved typefaces, minimum logo size, clear space, no stretching or recoloring the logo, minimum color contrast), written once as a PDF for people and once as data files: a design-tokens file plus brand.json-style logo rules. A script generates 500 layouts (posters, social media tiles, letterheads), each with no rule break or exactly one, logged as the answer key. Then score AI brand checkers and general image-reading AI models on it.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Brand books into data files

    A test of tools that read a brand guidelines PDF and write out its rules as data. Take 30 guidelines their owners publish openly (public bodies such as NASA publish theirs) and type an answer key for each by hand: palette color codes, typeface names, minimum logo size and clear-space rule, in Design Tokens 2025.10 and brand.json fields. Score each tool, counting values left out and values made up separately. Publish the answer keys with links to the PDFs, not copies of them.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A scorecard for logo search

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of the free trademark image searches, the USPTO's beta and the World Intellectual Property Organization's Global Brand Database, on US cases with known outcomes. The cases are decisions of the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB, the USPTO's tribunal) from 2025 and 2026 in which the owner of an earlier mark tried to block a new one, called an opposition, and both marks include a design. For each case, upload the newer logo and record whether, and at what rank, the earlier mark appears. Publish case numbers, serial numbers, query dates and ranks, not the logo images.

Why it is still open

The USPTO tool is a beta whose matching method is unpublished. The one large test of trademark offices' search tools against legal decisions, by Vandamme, Cabay and Debeir at ICAIL 2023, used 8,126 EU opposition decisions to test the EU (EUIPO) and Benelux (BOIP) offices' tools; its authors suspected the EUIPO tool had been trained on those same decisions and called for "another set of decisions." The same paper notes that the main US study covered word marks only. A 2017 dataset built from TTAB cases predates the current AI tools and tested older image-matching methods.

akerman.comorbi.uliege.bediglib.tugraz.at

Built with what exists

USPTO trademark search (free account); WIPO's Global Brand Database, free, with image search since 2019; public TTAB decisions; a spreadsheet or a short Python script for scoring. Queries run by hand or within each site's terms of use.

  1. First step

    Pick 30 TTAB final decisions from 2025 and 2026 that involve design marks, run them through the USPTO beta by hand, and publish the pilot sheet.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 200 decided cases; for each tool, the share of cases with the earlier mark in the top 10 and top 50 results and its mean rank, split by whether the board found confusion, the same measures as the 2023 EU study; a second person re-checks 10% of the queries; a repeat run three months later.

Open 02 · the brief

Planted errors for brand checkers

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A made-up brand with a rulebook of about ten rules (palette colors, approved typefaces, minimum logo size, clear space, no stretching or recoloring the logo, minimum color contrast), written once as a PDF for people and once as data files: a design-tokens file plus brand.json-style logo rules. A script generates 500 layouts (posters, social media tiles, letterheads), each with no rule break or exactly one, logged as the answer key. Then score AI brand checkers and general image-reading AI models on it.

Why it is still open

The authors of Graphic-Design-Bench, a 49-task benchmark for AI models on design work published in March 2026, write that for "checking color compliance against brand guidelines, these failure rates are not acceptable margins of error." The BrandGuide dataset of June 2026 lists automated checking of design assets against guidelines only as a future use. Frontify's reviewer is still in development and gives no accuracy figures.

arxiv.orgarxiv.orgfrontify.com

Built with what exists

Penpot, a free, open-source design tool with design tokens built in, or SVG files (a text-based vector image format) written by a Python script; the Design Tokens 2025.10 format; the brand.json schema for logo rules; vendor trials where available, such as Frontify Brand Check; Gemini Decision 1, which returns a probability for each fixed yes-or-no question such as "Is the logo below minimum size?" (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").

  1. First step

    Write the made-up brand's ten rules as a tokens file and a brand.json file, generate 50 layouts, and run one checker on them.

  2. Done looks like

    500 layouts, at least 40 per rule and at least 100 with no break; each checker's catch rate and false-alarm rate per rule, for at least three checkers; two human designers label a 100-layout subset so the tools can be compared with how often people agree; all files under an open license.

Open 03 · the brief

Brand books into data files

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A test of tools that read a brand guidelines PDF and write out its rules as data. Take 30 guidelines their owners publish openly (public bodies such as NASA publish theirs) and type an answer key for each by hand: palette color codes, typeface names, minimum logo size and clear-space rule, in Design Tokens 2025.10 and brand.json fields. Score each tool, counting values left out and values made up separately. Publish the answer keys with links to the PDFs, not copies of them.

Why it is still open

The one open-source converter found, pdf-brand-to-json, warns users to treat its output "only as suggestions" and has no test set. ExtractBench, a February 2026 benchmark for turning PDFs into structured data, uses 35 PDFs from other fields, such as financial reports. The brand.json documentation says most brands publish no machine-readable file at all.

github.comarxiv.orgdocs.adcontextprotocol.org

Built with what exists

the Design Tokens 2025.10 format; the AdCP brand.json schema; ExtractBench's scoring method; pdf-brand-to-json; an open-weights model such as Mistral Large 4, so others can rerun the same model (see the Note "A trillion open parameters").

  1. First step

    Collect 10 openly posted guidelines and type the answer keys for two of them.

  2. Done looks like

    30 guidelines and at least 600 hand-checked fields; accuracy per field, with the rates of left-out and made-up values, for at least three tools.