BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services

Advertising and marketing

The advertising and marketing industry makes ads, buys the space and time to show them, and measures what they did, so that sellers can get their products in front of buyers.

1841

Volney B. Palmer began an advertising agency in Philadelphia, working as a middleman between newspaper publishers and advertisers across the country. Duke University's Hartman Center calls it "the first American advertising agency," and the Smithsonian's finding aid for the N. W. Ayer records calls it "the first advertising agency founded in the United States.".

library.duke.edusirismm.si.edu

41

Milestones achieved across 6 domains.

12

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

12

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

In one minute

Where it started

Sellers have announced their goods for as long as there has been trade, and printed notices go back to William Caxton's in the 1470s. The business of placing ads for others began in the 1800s with agents who bought newspaper space and resold it, such as Volney Palmer in Philadelphia from 1841. Over the next century agencies took on writing and drawing the ads, an auditor began checking the circulation that publishers claimed (1914), and meters began recording which station a radio was tuned to (1942).

Where it stands

WPP Media, a media-buying group, forecast in June 2026 that ad revenue worldwide would grow 8.9% in 2026 to about $1.3 trillion, not counting US political ads, and counted the three largest sellers outside China, Alphabet, Meta and Amazon, as taking 57.6% of the market. Ads on search engines, social networks and much of the web are sold one showing at a time in automated auctions, and in an industry survey nearly two in three buyers of video ads said they use generative AI to make them. Controlled experiments at eBay and Facebook found that counting the sales that follow an ad overstates what the ad caused.

What is open

Many open jobs are checks that nobody runs in public: whether ads under chatbot answers change what the chatbot recommends, what share of social media ads are scams, whether billboard audience figures match a count of passing traffic, and how often AI inbox previews misstate an offer. Others are tools the trade buys privately but nobody has published and scored, such as a list of sites built only to show ads, or spoken descriptions of ads for blind viewers. Browser agents, low-cost AI models that read text and images, and open-source detection models put most of these within reach of a small team.

Domains

AchievedWatch forOpen

Other narrower industries

Public relationsGraphic and web designPromotional productsLead generationBillboards

Advances to build with

1 research note

Open in advertising and marketing

3 of 12 open deliverables

Open · Making the ads

Match rulings to real ads

A public dataset that links each ASA ruling to a record of the ad as it actually ran, with the ruling's outcome (upheld or not upheld), the code rules it cites and the advertiser's sector. Tools that check ads before they run could then be tested on real ads, not on descriptions of them.

Built with what exists

the ASA's published rulings; public ad libraries such as the Google Ads Transparency Center and the Meta Ad Library, and archived copies of web pages; a browser agent such as Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over") to search them slowly and within each site's rules; a low-cost extraction model such as Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat") to pull the advertiser, date, outcome and cited rules from each ruling.

Credit · unclaimed

Open · Buying ad space

Open test for MFA sites

A public, labeled set of websites and an open classifier that judges whether each is a made-for-advertising (MFA) site, one built mainly to show ads to visitors bought cheaply elsewhere, with its accuracy published.

Built with what exists

Playwright or Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over") to load each page and record its ads, refreshes and page weight; a vision-language model to measure how much of the screen the ads take; a model that returns probabilities for yes-or-no checklists, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); Python. It uses only what a visitor's browser can see, since traffic sources are not public.

Credit · unclaimed

Open · Search and social ads

Test whether ads sway chatbots

A controlled test of whether ads change what ChatGPT recommends. The same shopping prompts are run many times on two groups of Free accounts: one that sees ads and one that has opted out of ads, an option OpenAI offered at launch in exchange for fewer free messages a day. For each advertiser that appears under an answer, the test counts how often the answer text itself names that advertiser in each group.

Built with what exists

Free ChatGPT accounts, with OpenAI's ad opt-out (or Plus accounts, which carry no ads, as a second comparison group); the public prompt list and ad archive from the Lurie et al. audit; volunteers who paste prompts by hand, as SparkToro's 600 volunteers did in 2026, or a browser automation tool such as Playwright or Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over") if OpenAI's terms allow it; a small, low-cost AI model to pull brand names out of answers (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python or R for the statistics.

Credit · unclaimed