BRENNEN

Industries / Consumer goods / Textiles and apparel / Footwear

Uppers

Making the upper, the part of the shoe above the sole, means cutting its pieces from leather, synthetic sheet or fabric, by hand knife, by a steel die pressed through the material (the trade calls this clicking) or by a computer-guided knife or laser, and then sewing the pieces together (closing), or else forming the upper in one piece by knitting, fusing, printing or spraying.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1852 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1852

    Machines stitch uppers

    Women had bound and stitched shoe uppers by hand, often at home as a sideline. Edith Abbott's 1909 history of women in the shoe trade says that "in 1852 the first machine for stitching shoe uppers was used in Lynn", Massachusetts: a "Singer patent" machine run by a woman, after which stitching shops opened across the city. Fred A. Gannon's 1911 history credits a Lynn shoemaker, John Brooks Nichols, with rebuilding a Singer machine until its stitches in leather "compared favorably with the stitches of the shoe binders".

    LessonWomen who sewed uppers now had to work long, regular days in a factory, and the 1860 census counted fewer women in shoemaking than the 1850 census did, both in number and as a share of workers, which Abbott and the census both put down to the sewing machine.

    en.wikisource.orgen.wikisource.orgen.wikisource.orgfiddlebase.com

    Credit

    I. M. Singer & Co. for the machine; John Brooks Nichols for adapting it, by Gannon's account

  2. 1980

    Computers steer the needle

    USM launched its Automatic Fitting Stitcher in about 1980, a machine in which a microprocessor steered decorative stitching on uppers in "zigs, zags, and swirls". In March 1981 The Christian Science Monitor called USM the world leader in shoe-manufacturing automation and reported that it had sold more than 1,000 of the machines in under a year, a third of them abroad, over half for cowboy boots and many for jogging shoes. The Monitor also said, without naming a source, that the machine had raised productivity sixteenfold and cut the training of new workers from six months to one week. SATRA, the footwear research and testing body, wrote in 2022 that computer-controlled stitching machines are used in many shoe factories and are "very good for stitching decorative fashion flashes, embroidery or logos onto components".

    LessonSATRA notes that these machines let factories use less skilled labour.

    proof.csmonitor.comsatra.com

    Credit

    USM

  3. 2010

    Layers fused, not sewn

    Nike introduced Hyperfuse in 2010 on its basketball shoes: three synthetic layers fused together by heat and pressure into an upper with almost no sewn seams, by Complex's 2013 account.

    complex.com

    Credit

    Nike

  4. 2012

    Uppers knitted to shape

    In February 2012 Nike unveiled the Flyknit Racer, whose upper comes off the knitting machine already at size, so almost nothing is cut away, as the Victoria and Albert Museum, which holds a sample, describes it. adidas launched its own knitted shoe, the adizero Primeknit, at the London Olympics in July 2012 in a run of 2,012 pairs, Reuters reported. Nike says Flyknit "produces 60 percent less waste than traditional cut-and-sew methods"; that is Nike's own figure, and no outside measurement was found. Nike won a temporary injunction against Primeknit in Germany in August 2012, and a Nuremberg court ruled for adidas that November. In the US, adidas challenged Nike's knitted-upper patent (US 7,347,011) at the patent office's review board, which found Nike's four replacement claims unpatentable in 2014 and, after Nike appealed, again in September 2018, on the grounds of a 1994 patent on cutting uppers with less waste and two 1939 patents on knitting a helmet to shape "without requiring cutting".

    LessonThe idea of knitting a part to its final shape so that nothing is cut away was already in patents from 1939.

    collections.vam.ac.ukabout.nike.comcnbc.comsgieurope.comptablitigationblog.commintz.com

    Credit

    Nike; adidas

  5. 2018

    A printed textile upper

    Nike made the upper of its Zoom Vaporfly Elite Flyprint from a fabric 3D-printed out of TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane, a stretchy plastic) filament, and Eliud Kipchoge won the London Marathon in the shoe on 22 April 2018. MaterialDistrict reported it as "said to be the world's first trainer with a 3D printed upper", a maker's claim rather than a finding. Popular Science reported that the upper was 11 g, or 6%, lighter than the original Zoom Vaporfly Elite, and that the first run was 100 pairs at $600 each.

    materialdistrict.compopsci.com

    Credit

    Nike

  6. 2024

    An upper sprayed by robot

    On, the Swiss running brand, makes the upper of its Cloudboom Strike LS with a process it calls LightSpray: a robot arm sprays one continuous synthetic filament onto a last and builds a one-piece upper with no laces in about three minutes, and the upper is then joined to the midsole by heat bonding instead of glue. Hellen Obiri won the 2024 Boston Marathon in the shoe, and in July 2024 it was listed for sale at $330. On says the method cuts the carbon emissions of making an upper by up to 75%, its own figure.

    gearpatrol.commarathonhandbook.com

    Credit

    On

Watch for

  1. Sprayed uppers at volume

    On says it opened its second LightSpray factory, near Busan, South Korea, with 32 fully automated robots, and that they will raise its global LightSpray production capacity 30-fold in 2026. The first plant, in Zurich, opened with four robots in July 2025.

    Achieved whensomeone outside On, such as its auditors in an annual report or an analyst who counts output, confirms 2026 LightSpray volume at about 30 times the 2025 level.

    press.on-running.comjust-style.com

    Claimed by

    On, February 2026

  2. A robot laces a shoe

    ByteDance's Seed research team says its GR-RL method raised a two-armed robot's success at threading a lace through a shoe's eyelets from 45.7% to 83.3%. GR-RL refines a robot model trained on demonstrations through reinforcement learning, which is learning by trial and reward on the real robot. The team calls the result "the industry's first demonstration of a robot continuously lacing an entire shoe". These are ByteDance's own test results.

    Achieved whena lab outside ByteDance repeats the result on shoes of its own choosing, or a shoe factory reports robots lacing shoes on a production line at a measured rate.

    seed.bytedance.com

    Claimed by

    ByteDance Seed, December 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Robot sews a curved seam

    A cell in which two low-cost robot arms hold two cut upper parts, such as an outer upper and a heel liner, and steer them under the needle of a post-bed sewing machine (one that sews on top of a raised column, so shaped parts can wrap around it) along a curved seam, with no clamp frame or jig, keeping the stitch line a set distance from the edge.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Weigh the knit waste claim

    An outside, weighed comparison of the waste from making the same simple upper two ways, knitted to shape and cut from roll fabric and sewn: 20 pairs each way in two sizes, with every offcut, yarn end, trimmed edge and rejected part weighed, reported as grams of waste per pair and as a share of the material bought.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Open photos of upper seams

    A public set of at least 2,000 close-up photos of seams on shoe uppers, each marked by two trained inspectors for skipped stitches, broken thread, a wandering stitch line, uneven stitch length and puckering, with the stitch margin (the distance from stitch line to edge) measured in millimetres, released with a baseline model and the rate at which the two inspectors agree.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Robot sews a curved seam

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A cell in which two low-cost robot arms hold two cut upper parts, such as an outer upper and a heel liner, and steer them under the needle of a post-bed sewing machine (one that sews on top of a raised column, so shaped parts can wrap around it) along a curved seam, with no clamp frame or jig, keeping the stitch line a set distance from the edge.

Why it is still open

Nike's patent filed in May 2019 (granted 2022) says upper parts "are then stitched together utilizing a manual stitching machine" by a skilled worker; Nike's own answer clamps the parts in a jig that an X-Y stitching machine moves along a stored pattern. An EU project of 1997–98 titled "3D shoe upper stitching robot" set out to build a robot that feeds shoe parts into a stitching machine and reports no results. The most recent robot-sewing paper found, by Jin, Kosuge and colleagues in July 2026, sews stretchable fabric in a straight line. Searches for robot arms feeding shoe uppers through a post-bed machine and for learned robot sewing of shoe uppers found no published result.

patents.google.comcordis.europa.euarxiv.org

Built with what exists

Two pairs of SO-101 arms, the open arm design used with Hugging Face's LeRobot software, in which a person moves a leader arm and a follower arm copies it, and LeRobot to record the steered demonstrations and train on them (see the Note "No download"); NVIDIA's GR00T 2 model, which learns a task from five demonstrations by NVIDIA's own test (see the Note "Five demonstrations per task"); a light-duty post-bed machine with a servo motor set to slow speed and a finger guard; pre-cut synthetic upper parts; an overhead camera with OpenCV to measure the stitch line.

huggingface.co

  1. First step

    Film a closer sewing 20 collar seams on a post-bed machine, and cut 100 practice pairs of parts from synthetic sheet.

  2. Done looks like

    20 filmed attempts at a 15 cm curved seam, with a published tally of seams finished with no person stepping in, the time per seam, and the distance from stitch line to edge measured every 5 mm against a target such as 1.5 mm, beside 20 seams by a skilled closer on the same parts.

Open 02 · the brief

Weigh the knit waste claim

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An outside, weighed comparison of the waste from making the same simple upper two ways, knitted to shape and cut from roll fabric and sewn: 20 pairs each way in two sizes, with every offcut, yarn end, trimmed edge and rejected part weighed, reported as grams of waste per pair and as a share of the material bought.

Why it is still open

Nike says Flyknit makes 60% less waste than cut-and-sew but publishes no method. Trade figures for cutting waste come second-hand: a 2019 paper by FDRA, the US footwear trade association, cites a UNIDO leather panel study that with inefficient markers (the cutting layouts) 10–25% of fabric and 15–35% of leather or PU is wasted in cutting uppers and linings. A search for an independent measurement of knitted against cut-and-sew upper waste found only company figures, patents and reviews.

about.nike.comfdra.org

Built with what exists

A Kniterate, a compact digital knitting machine whose maker lists shoe uppers among what it can knit, or an industrial flat-knitting machine in a university knitting lab; a laser cutter or hand knife; Deepnest, free nesting software that lays out the cut parts; a lab scale reading to 0.1 g; a spreadsheet.

kniterate.comdeepnest.io

  1. First step

    Draw a one-piece upper pattern, knit five on a Kniterate at a makerspace or school that has one, and cut five from roll fabric.

  2. Done looks like

    20 pairs made each way in two sizes, every kind of waste weighed and photographed, with the data and patterns published and set beside Nike's 60% claim.

Open 03 · the brief

Open photos of upper seams

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of at least 2,000 close-up photos of seams on shoe uppers, each marked by two trained inspectors for skipped stitches, broken thread, a wandering stitch line, uneven stitch length and puckering, with the stitch margin (the distance from stitch line to edge) measured in millimetres, released with a baseline model and the rate at which the two inspectors agree.

Why it is still open

The one stitch-defect study opened here, by Nguyen Quoc Toan of Hongik University in Seoul in 2022, says "the limited availability of data on defective sewing stitches imagery" made training hard, so the author collected 900 images himself, all of garment stitches. A search for a public dataset of stitching defects on shoe uppers found only a few small collections, mostly of garment seams.

journal.iberamia.org

Built with what exists

A camera with a macro lens and ring light on a stand; Label Studio for marking; Ultralytics YOLO and Meta's Segment Anything as baselines; Gemini Decision 1 as a second baseline, since it returns probabilities for up to 1,000 fixed-answer questions in one request and so can sort each photo into defect classes (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); Python and OpenCV to measure the margin.

  1. First step

    Buy 30 pairs of secondhand shoes of different makes and photograph every seam on their uppers under one light.

  2. Done looks like

    2,000 seam photos from at least 100 pairs of at least 20 brands, released under CC BY 4.0, with the inspectors' agreement and each baseline's precision and recall for each defect, and the margin measurements checked against a caliper on 100 seams.