Industries / Finance and business services / Finance and banking / Energy trading
Scheduling and settlement
The back office: telling pipelines and grid operators what will flow, confirming each trade with the other side, and paying for what actually flowed.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1996 to 2019.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1996
Gas nominations standardized
A nomination is a shipper's request telling a pipeline how much gas to move, from where to where, on a given day. FERC Order 587 of July 1996 required every US interstate pipeline to follow the same standards, written by the industry's Gas Industry Standards Board (GISB), for nominations, allocation, balancing and measurement, invoicing, capacity release and electronic data exchange. It set one national timetable, with the gas day starting at 9 a.m. Central Clock Time and nominations at 11:30 a.m., and pipelines brought it in from April to June 1997.
Credit
GISB; FERC
1999
Power schedules get e-Tags
An e-Tag is an electronic record of a power deal that crosses from one grid area to another, listing where the power comes from and goes to, every area on the path, the transmission reservation and the deal's priority. NERC, North America's grid reliability body, first used electronic tagging on 22 September 1999; before that, tags went by email, fax and phone. A transfer between areas cannot start until its e-Tag is approved.
Credit
NERC; NAESB, which writes the tag specifications
2004
Confirmations matched by computer
After every deal each side sends the other a confirmation of the terms, and someone checks that the two match, a job long done by fax and by hand. The European Federation of Energy Traders (EFET, now Energy Traders Europe) wrote a standard General Agreement for power deals, whose oldest posted version is dated 20 December 2000, and the eCM standard for the messages that two firms' systems exchange to confirm and match a trade. eCM's revision history starts at version 2.1 in April 2004, and the standard answers "the urgent need for the back office to automate manual confirmation processes".
cms.energytraderseurope.orgenergytraderseurope.orgenergytraderseurope.org
Credit
EFET eCM Project Work Group
2015
Gas and power schedules aligned
More US power was coming from gas, but gas nominations were due before generators learned what they would have to run the next day. FERC Order 809 of April 2015 moved the main day-ahead gas nomination deadline from 11:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. Central Clock Time, added an intraday nomination cycle, allowed transport contracts with several parties, and told grid operators to fit their day-ahead markets to the new times. It declined to move the start of the gas day.
Credit
FERC; NAESB Wholesale Gas Quadrant
2016
Settlement matches dispatch
Settlement is working out who owes whom for the power that actually flowed. US grid operators instructed plants every five minutes but paid them on hourly averages until FERC Order 825 of June 2016 required each operator to settle its real-time market "at the same time interval it dispatches energy". On 28 November 2017 Australia's market rule-maker, the AEMC, decided to cut its settlement period from 30 minutes to 5, which took effect on 1 October 2021, and the EU's 2017 balancing guideline required a 15-minute imbalance settlement period everywhere, with exemptions allowed until 1 January 2025.
federalregister.govaemc.gov.aulegislation.gov.uklegislation.gov.uk
Credit
FERC; Australian Energy Market Commission; European Commission
2019
Cheap imbalance invites short positions
In Germany each balance responsible party, a firm answerable for a portfolio of supply and demand, must keep it level in every 15-minute period and pays the imbalance price for any gap. On three days in June 2019 the German grid ran so short that operators used their balancing reserves to the full for long periods. The regulator found that some traders had sold power they did not have, because the exchange price was predictably higher than the imbalance price they would pay. In May 2020 the Bundesnetzagentur approved an imbalance price tied to 15-minute intraday prices, and in October 2021 it fined Energi Danmark €200,000 and Optimax Energy €175,000, subject to appeal.
Lessonwhen being short is predictably cheaper than buying in the market, some firms will choose to be short, so the imbalance price has to track the market.
Credit
Bundesnetzagentur; ACER
Watch for
Final settlement in four months
Britain is moving every electricity meter onto settlement by half-hourly readings under its Market-wide Half-Hourly Settlement (MHHS) Programme. The programme plans a shorter settlement timetable to go with it, with the first settlement run seven working days after each day and the final run after four months, for settlement days from 2 July 2027, after a decision due in April 2027.
Achieved whenthe move of all meters is approved as complete and Elexon runs final settlement at four months for days from July 2027.
Claimed by
MHHS Programme and Elexon, plan as of November 2026
AI agents in post-trade
VAKT, a post-trade software firm for physical oil formed in 2018 by oil majors, traders and trade-finance providers, says eight specialised AI agents now handle nominations, documents, contracts and email. It gives "indicative figures from early deployments" of 40 to 70% fewer manual operations tasks and more than 90% fewer nomination errors, and in December 2025 it said its AI reads broker and counterparty trade summaries from email and matches them to trades in live use.
Achieved whena customer or auditor publishes measured error and workload figures, or the tools are scored on a public test set.
Claimed by
VAKT, December 2025 and November 2026
Open
01
Recompute Britain's imbalance price
Open-source code that follows Elexon's Imbalance Pricing Guide step by step, reproduces the guide's worked example, recalculates Elexon's published half-hourly imbalance prices from public data, and then works out the imbalance charge for a made-up company. Checking a bill by recalculating it yourself is called shadow settlement.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Test set of trade confirmations
About 1,000 made-up confirmations and deal recaps for power, gas, oil and LNG trades, as PDFs, scanned copies and email text, each generated from a known record. Power and gas fields follow EFET's eCM standard; cargo fields cover grade, quantity and tolerance, loading dates, pricing days and delivery terms. Some pairs carry planted mismatches in price, volume, delivery period, hub or timing, so that tools can be scored both on reading the fields and on matching the two sides.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Recompute Britain's imbalance price
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
Open-source code that follows Elexon's Imbalance Pricing Guide step by step, reproduces the guide's worked example, recalculates Elexon's published half-hourly imbalance prices from public data, and then works out the imbalance charge for a made-up company. Checking a bill by recalculating it yourself is called shadow settlement.
Why it is still open
Shadow settlement is sold as private software; one vendor describes it as a check that "verifies the accuracy of charges received". GitHub holds scripts that download or forecast British imbalance prices, and searches for shadow settlement, imbalance settlement and Elexon settlement code found none that recalculates them.
Built with what exists
the guide, version 17.0 in force from 25 August 2026, and its worked example; Elexon's free price API, which returns net imbalance volume and accepted offer and bid volumes as JSON; Python; an AI coding assistant to turn the guide's steps into tested code.
First step
Code the worked example as a test, then pull one day of prices and balancing actions.
Done looks like
the worked example matched to the penny, and recalculated prices within £0.01 per MWh of Elexon's for at least 99% of half-hours in one month, with every mismatch explained.
Open 02 · the brief
Test set of trade confirmations
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
About 1,000 made-up confirmations and deal recaps for power, gas, oil and LNG trades, as PDFs, scanned copies and email text, each generated from a known record. Power and gas fields follow EFET's eCM standard; cargo fields cover grade, quantity and tolerance, loading dates, pricing days and delivery terms. Some pairs carry planted mismatches in price, volume, delivery period, hub or timing, so that tools can be scored both on reading the fields and on matching the two sides.
Why it is still open
Vendors quote their own accuracy, such as VAKT's "over 90% out of the box" for reading trade documents, and EFET's eCM specification still describes itself as an enhancement to "the current faxed based process". Searches of GitHub, Hugging Face and arXiv for trade confirmation datasets found no labeled public test set.
Built with what exists
the public eCM 4.4 specification; Python with a PDF library and image-degrading filters; AI models such as Claude (see the Note "Seven more flagged"), GPT and Gemini, and open models such as Llama or Qwen, as the tools to score.
First step
Write the generator for one product, a monthly power forward under the EFET General Agreement, and render 50 confirmations in three formats.
Done looks like
the data and scoring script published under an open licence, with field-level precision and recall and pair-level match accuracy reported for at least three tools, and a second person who re-scores a 100-document sample within 1 percentage point.