BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Finance and banking / Energy trading

Regulation

The rules and policing of energy trading: who may trade, what must be reported, and what counts as manipulation.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2005 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2005

    US bans energy manipulation

    The Energy Policy Act of 2005, signed on 8 August 2005, made it unlawful to use "any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance" in buying or selling natural gas, electricity or transmission under FERC's jurisdiction, borrowing the words of US securities law. It raised civil penalties to as much as $1 million per day per violation, and FERC's Anti-Manipulation Rule, Order No. 670, put the ban into effect on 26 January 2006.

    govinfo.govfederalregister.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; FERC

  2. 2011

    Europe's market abuse law

    REMIT, the EU Regulation on Wholesale Energy Market Integrity and Transparency, adopted on 25 October 2011, banned insider trading and market manipulation in EU wholesale gas and power markets. It counts as manipulation trades or orders that give "false or misleading signals" about supply, demand or price. It also requires trades to be reported to ACER, the EU agency of energy regulators: reporting of exchange trades and orders began on 7 October 2015, and other contracts followed on 7 April 2016.

    publications.europa.eupublications.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council; European Commission; ACER

  3. 2013

    Futures stay with the CFTC

    FERC fined Brian Hunter, a trader at the hedge fund Amaranth, $30 million for manipulating the settlement price of NYMEX natural gas futures in early 2006. On 15 March 2013 the US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit overturned the fine, holding that futures manipulation "falls within the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction" and that the 2005 Act did not change that. The CFTC had brought its own case against Hunter in July 2007.

    Lessonone trade can fall under two regulators, and the futures regulator keeps its role unless Congress clearly says otherwise.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, opinion by Judge Tatel; CFTC

  4. 2013

    Barclays fined for index pushing

    On 16 July 2013 FERC assessed civil penalties of $435 million against Barclays and $18 million in all against four of its traders, and ordered $34.9 million in profits repaid, for manipulating western US power markets from November 2006 to December 2008. FERC found that the desk set up financial swap positions and then traded physical next-day power at a loss to move the ICE daily price index on which those swaps settled. Barclays did not pay, FERC took the case to federal court, and in May 2015 the court refused to dismiss it.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    FERC Office of Enforcement; US District Court for the Eastern District of California

  5. 2015

    First REMIT manipulation fine

    On 24 November 2015 Spain's markets and competition authority, CNMC, fined Iberdrola Generación €25 million. Between 30 November and 23 December 2013 Iberdrola had raised the offer prices of its hydro plants on the Duero, Sil and Tajo rivers, so that less of their output was sold while day-ahead prices rose. The law firm Bird & Bird calls it the first decision by a national regulator to fine a breach of REMIT's ban on manipulation. Later cases include Ofgem's £24.5 million penalty, plus £12.8 million in restitution, on InterGen companies in 2020 for false notices to Britain's balancing market in 2016, and French fines of €8 million on Danske Commodities and €4 million on Equinor in January 2025 for gas capacity bookings they did not mean to use.

    twobirds.comcms.lawacer.europa.eu

    Credit

    CNMC; Ofgem; CoRDiS, the dispute and sanctions committee of France's regulator CRE

  6. 2018

    Caps on commodity positions

    From 3 January 2018 the EU's MiFID II, its main law on investment markets, required national regulators to limit the net position that one person or group can hold in commodity derivatives, to prevent market abuse and keep futures prices in line with physical prices at delivery. The start had been put back a year from 2017. In 2021 the EU narrowed the limits to farm contracts and "critical or significant" ones, saying the regime "has proved to be unfavourable for the development of new commodity markets", and made the change "to support the development of new energy contracts".

    Lessonlimits sized for large, mature markets can hold back new ones before they grow.

    publications.europa.eupublications.europa.eupublications.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council; ESMA, the EU securities regulator

  7. 2024

    Europe tightens REMIT

    Regulation (EU) 2024/1106 of 11 April 2024 amended REMIT. Firms that trade by algorithm must have risk controls and notify their national regulator and ACER; ACER gained powers to investigate cross-border cases, though fines stay with national regulators; firms from outside the EU must name a representative inside it; and the maximum fines for manipulation or insider trading must be set at no less than 15% of a firm's annual turnover.

    publications.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council; ACER

Watch for

  1. New EU reporting rules

    Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/256 replaces the 2014 rules on what trades must be reported to ACER. It entered into force on 29 April 2026, its new reporting details apply from 29 October 2027 with further parts from 29 April 2028, and market participants may need to give exchanges "the identification code of the algorithm" they trade with.

    Achieved whenreporting in the new formats is running and ACER publishes data-quality results on it.

    acer.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission and ACER, in an ACER open letter of April 2026

  2. Surveillance of trading algorithms

    ACER says its surveillance systems now "trigger and assess alerts involving algorithms", and it had "536 REMIT breach cases under review at the end of Q3 2026".

    Achieved whena national regulator publishes a sanction under REMIT's new article on algorithmic trading, or a decision that credits ACER's algorithm alerts.

    acer.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    ACER, REMIT Quarterly no. 46, November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Planted manipulation for surveillance tests

    Made-up energy order and trade records, for day-ahead and intraday power, balancing bids and capacity bookings, with labeled planted episodes and a scoring script. Each pattern is drawn from a published case: index pushing (Barclays), hoarding cross-border capacity by trading with oneself (Energi Danmark in the Nordic market), balancing bids set at the price limit and not meant to run (an Austrian case of November 2026), capacity bookings with no intent to use them (Danske Commodities and Equinor), and wash trades (FERC's 2003 Enron findings). Every record is invented.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Enforcement cases as data

    An open, machine-readable register of energy market manipulation decisions by FERC, the CFTC, Ofgem, the EU's national regulators and others. Each row gives the date, regulator, market, the scheme in plain words (such as index pushing or capacity hoarding), the rule broken, the penalty, and the paragraph of the decision that describes the scheme.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Planted manipulation for surveillance tests

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Made-up energy order and trade records, for day-ahead and intraday power, balancing bids and capacity bookings, with labeled planted episodes and a scoring script. Each pattern is drawn from a published case: index pushing (Barclays), hoarding cross-border capacity by trading with oneself (Energi Danmark in the Nordic market), balancing bids set at the price limit and not meant to run (an Austrian case of November 2026), capacity bookings with no intent to use them (Danske Commodities and Equinor), and wash trades (FERC's 2003 Enron findings). Every record is invented.

Why it is still open

No labeled benchmark of this kind for energy trading turned up. The nearest are SMLT, a set of false-data attacks on grid measurements rather than on trading; ReguSim, a general test of financial compliance for AI agents; and a cartel-detection study of two real Italian cases. Searches of arXiv and GitHub for energy market manipulation, REMIT and electricity market surveillance found only stock, crypto and social-media projects.

arxiv.orgarxiv.orgacer.europa.euacer.europa.eu

Built with what exists

Python and ABIDES, J.P. Morgan's public market simulator, or a simple custom order book; an AI model such as Claude to turn each enforcement decision into a structured pattern description that cites paragraph numbers, checked by a person.

  1. First step

    Write the pattern descriptions for the Barclays and Energi Danmark cases, then generate one made-up week with ten planted episodes.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 6 pattern types, each with at least 50 planted episodes and as many lawful look-alikes, every pattern citing its decision. Precision and recall are reported for two baseline detectors, and a third party reproduces the scores.

Open 02 · the brief

Enforcement cases as data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, machine-readable register of energy market manipulation decisions by FERC, the CFTC, Ofgem, the EU's national regulators and others. Each row gives the date, regulator, market, the scheme in plain words (such as index pushing or capacity hoarding), the rule broken, the penalty, and the paragraph of the decision that describes the scheme.

Why it is still open

ACER's overview of national REMIT sanction decisions covers the EU alone, sits in an embedded table, and lists the article breached rather than the scheme. US cases sit in FERC's docket library and court records. My search for a combined open database of FERC, CFTC and REMIT manipulation cases found none.

acer.europa.euai-analytics.org

Built with what exists

an AI model such as Claude to read each decision and propose the fields with the paragraph they came from (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a person to check every row; Python; a public Git repository.

  1. First step

    Enter the decisions cited on this page (Barclays, Iberdrola, InterGen, Energi Danmark and Optimax, Danske Commodities and Equinor), and fix the list of scheme types from them.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 100 decisions from at least five regulators, every field tied to a paragraph, and a second reviewer who checks 40 rows chosen at random and agrees with at least 38.