Industries / Finance and business services / Finance and banking / Energy trading
Risk
Measuring and limiting what a trader, producer or utility can lose, with futures and other hedges, clearing houses, margin and credit limits.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1983 to 2022.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1983
Crude and gas get futures
A futures contract is a standard agreement to buy or sell a set amount at a set price in a future month, with an exchange's clearing house standing behind both sides. The New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) began its WTI crude oil contract in 1983, by CFTC staff's account, and in 1990 the first natural gas futures began trading there, which EIA says let "producers, consumers, and financial traders" hedge against price swings at the Henry Hub in Louisiana.
Credit
New York Mercantile Exchange
2002
Clearing for private deals
After Enron's collapse made energy firms wary of each other's credit, NYMEX began clearing over-the-counter deals in the second quarter of 2002. Such deals are agreed privately between two firms; once submitted for clearing, the exchange's clearing house stands between them and collects margin from both. A 2007 US Senate report found that "substantial volumes of off-exchange contracts are submitted to ClearPort for clearing".
Credit
NYMEX (ClearPort)
2006
Amaranth's gas bet collapses
Amaranth Advisors, a hedge fund, was the largest trader in US natural gas. When NYMEX told it in August 2006 to cut its positions, it moved them to ICE, which then had no position limits, and by the end of August it held nearly 100,000 short September contracts, mostly on ICE. In September, as the price gap between winter and summer contracts collapsed, its margin requirements neared $3 billion, and the CFTC says the fund "lost $6 billion of its capital".
Lessonlimits on one exchange do little if the same bet can move to a market no one watches.
Credit
US Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, led by Senators Carl Levin and Norm Coleman (report of June 2007)
2018
One trader drains a fund
The Norwegian trader Einar Aas bet that the gap between Nordic and German power prices would narrow. On 10 September 2018 the gap for 2019 widened by 5.56 euros in a day, beyond the 4-euro move that Nasdaq Clearing's risk model had been calibrated for. He was declared in default on 11 September, leaving a hole of €114 million, of which €107 million came from the default fund paid in by other clearing members and €7 million from Nasdaq. Sweden's financial supervisor later fined Nasdaq Clearing SEK 300 million for faults that included how it calculated margin.
Lessononce prices move further than the margin model allows, every other member pays.
Credit
Nasdaq Clearing; Finansinspektionen
2020
Oil trades below zero
On 20 April 2020 the May contract for WTI crude settled at −$37.63 a barrel, by CFTC staff's account "the first time the WTI Contract traded at a negative price since being listed for trading 37 years ago". The contract ends in physical delivery at Cushing, Oklahoma, and by March 2020 working storage there was near capacity.
Lessona futures price stays tied to the physical market behind it, and when delivery gets hard the price can fall below zero.
Credit
CFTC staff (interim report, November 2020)
2022
Margin calls threaten utilities
As gas and power prices soared in 2022, energy companies that had hedged their sales on exchanges had to post ever more cash as margin. In September Finland proposed a €10 billion lending facility and Sweden offered 250 billion kronor in liquidity guarantees for such companies, and Finland's minister Mika Lintilä warned of "the ingredients for a kind of a Lehman Brothers of energy industry".
Lessona fully hedged firm can still run out of cash, because margin is due at once while the gain on its physical sales comes later.
Credit
the Finnish and Swedish governments
Watch for
Crypto as futures margin
The CFTC launched a pilot letting brokers accept bitcoin, ether and the USDC stablecoin as margin collateral, and issued guidance on tokenized collateral. Circle, which issues USDC, says this enables "near-real-time margin settlement". A 2026 letter from the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago judged that the new options were not yet ready to replace the large-value payment systems that clearing houses rely on.
Achieved whena broker or clearing house reports routine use for energy futures accounts, and an outside review finds that it held up under stress.
Claimed by
CFTC Acting Chairman Caroline Pham, with Circle and Coinbase, December 2025, revised in CFTC Staff Letter 26-05 of February 2026
Sunday payments for margin
The Federal Reserve says it will run its Fedwire Funds Service and National Settlement Service from Sunday to Friday "no earlier than 2028", which would allow payments, margin calls among them, on Sundays.
Achieved whenFedwire settles live Sunday payments and a clearing house collects a Sunday margin call through it.
Claimed by
Federal Reserve Board, October 2025
Open
01
Size the weekend margin gap
A study, with code anyone can rerun, of how far energy futures prices move from Friday to Monday compared with an ordinary one-day move, using the US Energy Information Administration's free daily settlement prices (crude oil 1983 to 2024, heating oil 1980 to 2024 and others). It then works out how much extra initial margin, as a share of contract value, would have covered 99% and 99.9% of weekend moves. Initial margin is the deposit a clearing house holds against each open position.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A record of clearing failures
An open, machine-readable table of margin and clearing failures in energy markets since 1993. For each event it gives the date, the market, the size of the price move against what the margin model allowed, the loss, who paid it and the regulator's report, with each value quoted from a primary source with its page.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Size the weekend margin gap
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A study, with code anyone can rerun, of how far energy futures prices move from Friday to Monday compared with an ordinary one-day move, using the US Energy Information Administration's free daily settlement prices (crude oil 1983 to 2024, heating oil 1980 to 2024 and others). It then works out how much extra initial margin, as a share of contract value, would have covered 99% and 99.9% of weekend moves. Initial margin is the deposit a clearing house holds against each open position.
Why it is still open
A 2026 Chicago Fed letter on trading and clearing every day of the week names collecting weekend margin in advance as one option, but notes that its own data "reflect current weekday trading and clearing patterns". Searches of GitHub, arXiv and Crossref found no public measure of the weekend gap for energy contracts.
Built with what exists
Python and pandas on the EIA downloads, with care at the dates when one contract month rolls into the next.
First step
Download the series and tag every gap between settlements as one day, a weekend or a holiday.
Done looks like
a published notebook and table for at least four contracts, with every weekend and holiday gap labeled, that gives identical numbers when anyone reruns it on the EIA files.
Open 02 · the brief
A record of clearing failures
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open, machine-readable table of margin and clearing failures in energy markets since 1993. For each event it gives the date, the market, the size of the price move against what the margin model allowed, the loss, who paid it and the regulator's report, with each value quoted from a primary source with its page.
Why it is still open
The facts sit in scattered reports, such as the US Senate's Amaranth investigation, CFTC staff reports, Sweden's decision on Nasdaq Clearing and Finland's budget papers. Searches of GitHub and Hugging Face for clearing default, default fund and margin crisis datasets found none.
Built with what exists
an AI model such as Claude to pull candidate values with page citations from regulators' PDFs (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a person to check every value; a public Git repository.
First step
Draft the table's fields and fill the four events whose primary sources are cited on this page: Amaranth, Nasdaq Clearing, negative WTI and the 2022 margin calls.
Done looks like
at least 20 events, with a second reviewer confirming at least 95% of values against the cited pages.