BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Commercial and residential construction / Electrical contracting

Estimating

Estimating is pricing a job before the bid: counting the fixtures, devices, wire and conduit on the drawings, turning the counts into labor hours and material costs, and adding overhead and profit.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1923 to 2007.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1923

    Labor hours from a book

    A labor unit is the time one worker needs to install one item, such as a receptacle or 100 feet of conduit. An estimator multiplies the counts from the drawings by these units to get a job's labor hours. The National Electrical Contractors Association (NECA), the US contractors' trade group, publishes a Manual of Labor Units that a 2026 trade report says has been used "since 1923"; its units "are based on accumulated industry experience", and the 2025–2027 edition came with an online database in September 2026. In 2007 the magazine Electrical Construction & Maintenance called it "the industry standard for electrical construction estimators and project managers" for over 80 years.

    constructionowners.comecmweb.com

    Credit

    National Electrical Contractors Association

  2. 1979

    Estimates move to computers

    McCormick Systems, now based in Chandler, Arizona, says it "was created to speed up the bidding process" in 1979, and it sells estimating software for electrical, plumbing and mechanical contractors. IEC Insights, the magazine of the Independent Electrical Contractors association, names Jack McCormick as the founder and calls the company "one of the pioneers of computerized estimating software for the construction industry".

    mccormicksys.cominsights.ieci.org

    Credit

    Jack McCormick, McCormick Systems

  3. 1999

    Changes slow the whole job

    A change order is a priced change to a signed contract. Awad Hanna, Jeffrey Russell, Erik Nordheim and Matthew Bruggink of the University of Wisconsin–Madison studied electrical projects and built a regression model that estimates how much labor efficiency a project loses to change orders, using the change-order hours as a share of the original estimate and other factors. On further projects it was off by 5% on average, by the authors' account. In 2005 Osama Moselhi, Ihab Assem and Khaled El-Rayes extended such a model to account for when the changes arrive, using 33 cases from Canada and the US.

    LessonA change costs more than the hours of the changed work, because it lowers the efficiency of the whole project.

    doi.orgdoi.org

    Credit

    Awad Hanna and colleagues (University of Wisconsin–Madison); Moselhi, Assem and El-Rayes

  4. 2007

    Labor units become data

    NECA and Trade Service, a company that supplies electrical material prices to estimating software, announced in March 2007 that the Manual of Labor Units would be delivered as a live database feed matched to Trade Service's priced items. Contractors could then import labor units and prices together into their estimating and accounting systems.

    ecmweb.com

    Credit

    NECA; Trade Service

Watch for

  1. AI counts symbols and conduit

    Trimble says the AI in its estimating software for mechanical, electrical and plumbing (MEP) contractors, including Accubid Anywhere, sets drawing scales, counts receptacles, switches and light fixtures, and routes conduit to measure its length, including rises and drops. It says the tools have detected more than 3 million symbols, cut manual symbol recognition time by over 50%, and cut pre-takeoff and takeoff time by up to 60% for contractors using them in 2026. It gives no accuracy rate and no outside test, and estimators still check the output.

    Achieved whenAn outside party publishes the tool's counts and conduit lengths against a careful hand takeoff on named drawing sets, with error rates by item.

    aecmag.com

    Claimed by

    Trimble, July 2026

  2. Symbol counts on UK plans

    Dhruv Dosi, Rohit Meena, Param Rajpura and Yogesh Kumar Meena built DELP, a set of 45 electrical layout plans from UK house builders with 2,450 marked symbols in 34 classes, such as sockets, switches, lights, meters and radiators. Their YOLOv8 detector scored 82.5% mAP@50, a common detector score from 0 to 100%, and their free web tool, SkeySpot, counts the symbols and multiplies them by rates the user enters. The code and model weights are on GitHub.

    Achieved whenAnother group reproduces the score, or tests the tool on plans from other builders and countries.

    arxiv.orggithub.com

    Claimed by

    Dosi and colleagues, August 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Time the labor units

    An open table of measured install times for common electrical tasks, timed on unpowered practice rigs at an apprenticeship school. Examples are mounting a box, making up a switch or receptacle, bending and fitting a length of conduit, and pulling wire through a fixed run. Each task is filmed, timed from a set start to a set stop, and repeated by workers of different experience, and the medians are set beside published labor units.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Estimates checked against actual hours

    An open, anonymized record of finished electrical jobs: the estimated labor hours by task, the hours actually booked to each cost code, and the change-order hours. Use it to test labor-unit books and to rerun the 1999 change-order model of Hanna and colleagues on recent work.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Time the labor units

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table of measured install times for common electrical tasks, timed on unpowered practice rigs at an apprenticeship school. Examples are mounting a box, making up a switch or receptacle, bending and fitting a length of conduit, and pulling wire through a fixed run. Each task is filmed, timed from a set start to a set stop, and repeated by workers of different experience, and the medians are set beside published labor units.

Why it is still open

The labor units estimators use are sold in books and databases, such as NECA's Manual of Labor Units, whose units are "based on accumulated industry experience" rather than on published timings. The nearest public measurement, a work-sampling study that watched four electricians a day on each of eight Norwegian projects (Hajikazemi, Andersen and Langlo, 2017), found 61.1% of their time was direct value-added work, but it recorded kinds of activity, not the time per item installed. Talos Dataworks' free Hugging Face sample (November 2026) films one electrician installing a conduit run and subpanel, with sensor gloves, but times no tasks. This research found no open table of measured times for electrical tasks.

constructionowners.comdoi.orghuggingface.co

Built with what exists

Training-center practice booths with no power connected; phone cameras; open video tools or a spreadsheet to mark start and stop times; the school's own task sheets.

  1. First step

    With one apprenticeship instructor, time 20 apprentices bending and fitting the same conduit offset on a practice rig.

  2. Done looks like

    25 tasks, each timed on at least 20 attempts by at least 10 people, published under an open license with the median, the spread and each worker's years of experience, and a second school timing 5 of the tasks the same way, with both results published.

Open 02 · the brief

Estimates checked against actual hours

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, anonymized record of finished electrical jobs: the estimated labor hours by task, the hours actually booked to each cost code, and the change-order hours. Use it to test labor-unit books and to rerun the 1999 change-order model of Hanna and colleagues on recent work.

Why it is still open

The 1999 model and its 5% validation error rest on 1990s contractor project data that was not released. Level, a finance firm for contractors, publishes totals for 315,393 jobs at 1,391 companies across trades, of which 40% ran over their budgeted labor hours, but not by trade or task and not the job records. This research found no public set of estimated against actual hours on electrical jobs, and no published retest of the model.

doi.orglevelcfo.com

Built with what exists

Job-cost reports exported as spreadsheets from contractors' accounting software; Python to strip names and map cost codes to task types; the model's variables as published in the paper.

  1. First step

    Ask one contractor, or a local NECA chapter, for the estimate and final job-cost report of five finished jobs, and agree in writing on what must be removed before publishing.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 closed jobs from at least three contractors published, a table of estimate error by task type, and the 1999 model's average error on these jobs reported next to its claimed 5%.