Industries / Health / Healthcare / Direct primary care
Visits and access
The work of making a doctor reachable: how many patients each doctor takes on, how long and how soon visits happen, and who lives near enough, and can pay, to join.
5
Milestones achieved, from 2003 to 2024.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2003
Too little time for prevention
Duke researchers added up the minutes needed to give every service the US Preventive Services Task Force recommended, at the recommended frequency, to a panel of 2,500 patients with the age and sex mix of the US population. It came to 1,773 hours a year, or 7.4 hours of every working day, when family doctors spend about 2,055 hours a year on all patient care. Halving the panel would bring prevention down to about 4 hours a day, which the authors judged impractical.
Lessonthe size of a doctor's patient list, not effort, caps how much recommended care gets done, and that arithmetic is the case membership practices make for small lists.
Credit
Kimberly Yarnall, Kathryn Pollak, Truls Østbye, Katrina Krause and J. Lloyd Michener (Duke University Medical Center)
2020
Doctors report small lists
In a survey for the Society of Actuaries, about 200 direct primary care physicians told Milliman, an actuarial firm, that their panels averaged 445 patients against a target of 628, and that practices with full panels took 21 months on average to fill them. They reported that members got an appointment within a day (the median answer), waited about 4 minutes in the office and spent 38 minutes with the clinician; 99% included phone or text consultations and same-day appointments in the membership fee, and 58% included home visits. A 2023 study of 8.1 million US primary care visits, timed from electronic health record stamps, notes that the average visit lasts 18 minutes, and found that each extra minute went with 0.11 percentage points fewer inappropriate antibiotic prescriptions for colds and other upper respiratory infections.
Lessonthe membership figures are the doctors' own reports; no outside party has yet measured them from schedules or records.
Credit
Fritz Busch, Dustin Grzeskowiak and Erik Huth (Milliman), for the Society of Actuaries; Hannah Neprash and colleagues (JAMA Health Forum) for the visit study
2022
27 hours a day needed
A team led from the University of Chicago rebuilt the estimate with 2020 guidelines for a hypothetical adult panel of 2,500 drawn from national survey data. One doctor working alone would need 26.7 hours a day: 14.1 for prevention, 7.2 for chronic disease, 2.2 for acute care and 3.2 for notes and the electronic inbox. With tasks shared across a team, the figure fell to 9.3 hours. Even a 1,500-patient panel needed 16 hours a day without a team. The authors wrote that direct primary care models "may reflect this opportunity" to shrink panels, but that the membership fees needed may limit their spread and that smaller panels would worsen the shortage of primary care doctors. An earlier model put a reasonable panel for a team at 1,387 to 1,947 patients, depending on how much work nurses and other staff took on.
Lessona small list fits the guidelines into a working day, but every patient a membership doctor does not take on needs another doctor.
Credit
Justin Porter, Cynthia Boyd, M. Reza Skandari and Neda Laiteerapong (Journal of General Internal Medicine); J. Altschuler, D. Margolius, T. Bodenheimer and K. Grumbach (Annals of Family Medicine) for the 2012 team model
2022
Clinic for the uninsured closes
The University of Houston College of Medicine opened a direct primary care clinic for uninsured adults in November 2021, with a $60 monthly fee, in a county where 22.4% of residents had no insurance in 2019. It saw 322 patients at 772 appointments; 37.3% spoke Spanish, and the census tracts they lived in were more socially vulnerable than tracts with no patients (median social vulnerability index 0.60 against 0.47). It closed in November 2022 after memberships fell. Its own researchers named too few members to break even, a fee that may have been too high for its patients, inflation, COVID-19 and a failure to win employer contracts.
Lessonpeople from poorer neighbourhoods joined, but individual fees alone did not cover the cost of a clinic for them.
Credit
Winston Liaw and colleagues, University of Houston Tilman J. Fertitta Family College of Medicine (Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, 2024)
2024
Practices and shortage areas
Drexel University researchers placed the 2,125 practices listed in October 2023 on DPC Frontier's Mapper, a volunteer directory, against the federal Health Professional Shortage Areas, places the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) designates as short of primary care. 44% of the practices were in a shortage area, against 47% of primary care doctors in the national provider file. Of those in shortage areas, fewer membership practices were in the highest-need ones (14% against 20%) and more were in rural or partly rural ones (47% against 38%). They published their code and warned that the volunteer list may undercount, especially practices that sell to employers.
Lessonbeing in a shortage area is not the same as serving it; the authors found no data on the incomes of the practices' patients.
Credit
Neal Goldstein and Paul Yerkes (Annals of Family Medicine)
Watch for
Texts in place of visits
Physicians at Zest Pediatrics, a pediatric membership network in Cleveland, surveyed their own member families in April 2023. Of 155 families, 59 answered (38%): all had texted their doctor, 93% had sent photos, 88% had phoned and 22% had used video. Pricing the avoided office, urgent care and emergency visits from a nearby children's hospital's price list, they put the saving at no less than $1,171 a year per family. The authors note that they did not count the visits avoided.
Achieved whenan outside group counts in-person visits avoided from records or claims, across several practices, against a comparison group.
Claimed by
Austin Lee and colleagues at Zest Pediatrics (Cureus), June 2025
Patients rate access highly
Hint Health, whose software runs memberships and billing for many practices, says 1,534 patients at 12 direct primary care clinics in eight states, surveyed from June 2024 to August 2025 with the Person-Centered Primary Care Measure (a published 11-question patient survey), gave their practices an overall score of 89% and a contact and access score of 97%. The clinics were recruited from Hint's own customers.
Achieved whenan independent party reports the same measure for membership and other practices, with how clinics were chosen and the response rates.
Claimed by
Hint Health, February and April 2026
Open
01
Drive time to a practice
A public county-by-county table and map of how many people live within a 15-, 30- and 60-minute drive of a direct primary care practice that is open, set beside the same figures for all primary care doctors and for shortage areas, and split by county median income.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Days to a first visit
An openly declared survey of at least 500 direct primary care practices, by email or contact form, asking whether each is taking new adult members and, if so, the earliest date a new member could have a first visit, run twice six months apart and set beside AMN Healthcare's figures for ordinary family medicine offices in the same 15 metro areas. The researchers say who they are and why they ask; no one poses as a patient, and no health information is given or collected.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Drive time to a practice
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public county-by-county table and map of how many people live within a 15-, 30- and 60-minute drive of a direct primary care practice that is open, set beside the same figures for all primary care doctors and for shortage areas, and split by county median income.
Why it is still open
Studies so far place practices on maps but do not measure travel or check the listings. Goldstein and Yerkes compared 2,125 Mapper listings with shortage areas in 2023, and a September 2025 preprint by Juan Carabeo-Nieva and Oscar Lugo Capera matched scraped listings to ZIP codes and the USDA's rural-urban codes; neither computed drive times or checked whether a listed practice was open. The Mapper is filled in by the practices themselves.
Built with what exists
DPC Frontier Mapper listings, used with the owner's permission; the CMS National Plan and Provider Enumeration System file for primary care doctors; HRSA shortage-area files; Census county populations and incomes; OpenStreetMap roads with an open routing engine such as OSRM (project-osrm.org).
First step
Ask DPC Frontier for an export and permission to publish derived figures, and meanwhile compute 30-minute drive areas for one state's listings with OSRM.
Done looks like
Drive-time shares for every US county, published with code; a hand check of a random 300 listings (open, address right) with the error rate stated.
Open 02 · the brief
Days to a first visit
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An openly declared survey of at least 500 direct primary care practices, by email or contact form, asking whether each is taking new adult members and, if so, the earliest date a new member could have a first visit, run twice six months apart and set beside AMN Healthcare's figures for ordinary family medicine offices in the same 15 metro areas. The researchers say who they are and why they ask; no one poses as a patient, and no health information is given or collected.
Why it is still open
The only access figures for these practices are doctors' survey answers about their existing members, such as the median of within a day in the 2020 Society of Actuaries survey. AMN Healthcare's surveys, which have timed new-patient appointments at family medicine offices in 15 metro areas since 2009, found an average wait of 23.5 days for a new patient's physical in 2025, from 4 days in Miami and New York to 69 in Boston, but they do not single out membership practices. No measure of how long a new member waits was found.
Built with what exists
DPC Frontier Mapper listings for the sample; a mail-merge tool and a five-question web form; an AI model to read free-text replies into dates and yes-or-no answers, every one checked by hand; Python for the tallies.
First step
Write the five-question form, send it to 20 practices in one metro, and record how many answer and how long they take.
Done looks like
Replies from at least 300 practices, with the response rate stated; for each metro and overall, the share taking new members and the median and range of days to a first visit; the questionnaire, the sample frame and the anonymized replies published.