BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Direct primary care

Memberships

Selling a family doctor's care for a fixed fee each month or year: what members pay, what the fee buys, and how many practices and members there are.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1910 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1910

    Lodges hire doctors per head

    By 1910 many American fraternal societies contracted with a general practitioner to treat their members for a flat fee per person, a system known as lodge practice. The Foresters charged members two dollars a year for a doctor's care and the Fraternal Order of Eagles one dollar, which covered the member's immediate family and home visits; on Manhattan's Lower East Side, 500 doctors had contracts with Jewish lodges alone, by the historian David Beito's account. Medical societies fought the contracts: California's state medical society had a Committee on Contract and Lodge Practice reporting by 1911, and in 1914 a writer in the Journal of the American Medical Association said there was "scarcely a city in the country" where medical societies had not issued edicts against doctors who took them.

    Lessonthe fixed fee per member is an old idea, and its first wave met organized opposition from doctors' own societies.

    independent.orgpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    fraternal societies such as the Foresters and the Eagles; history by David T. Beito

  2. 1996

    A retainer practice in Seattle

    The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) wrote in 2005 that concierge care, in which doctors charge a membership or retainer fee, is often traced to a Seattle practice founded in 1996 whose doctors each cared for no more than 100 patients, charged individuals $13,000 a year and billed no insurance. Garrison Bliss, a former partner of its founders, names it as MD² and calls it the first monthly fee practice in the US. By 2004 GAO could find 146 concierge physicians in 25 states. The 112 it surveyed charged individuals from $60 to $15,000 a year, about half of them $1,500 to $1,999, and cared for 491 patients on average, against 2,716 before they converted.

    govinfo.govblog.hint.com

    Credit

    MD², Seattle; counted by the GAO

  3. 2015

    Fees counted across the nation

    With no claims to count from, Philip Eskew and Kathleen Klink built a national list of direct primary care practices from published reports, the registries that Washington and Oregon require, and the agendas of two 2014 meetings: 141 practices with 273 locations in 39 states, 93.2% of them with four clinicians or fewer. The 116 that posted prices charged an average of $93.26 a month (median $75). Practices that called themselves direct primary care averaged $77.38, and those that met the same definition but called themselves concierge averaged $182.76. They found "a broad distribution" of practices, wrote that "data about quality are lacking", and pointed readers to Eskew's DPC Mapper as the list kept "continuously updated online".

    Lessonthe first national price figures came years before any national measure of what the care achieved.

    jabfm.org

    Credit

    Philip M. Eskew and Kathleen Klink (Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine)

  4. 2017

    A pioneer closes

    Qliance opened in Seattle in 2007, co-founded by Garrison Bliss, Erika Bliss and Norm Wu, with money from investors including Jeff Bezos and Michael Dell. By 2015 it served 35,000 patients, among them employees of Expedia and Comcast and Medicaid patients through a contract with the state's Medicaid insurer, and it said in a 2015 release, by its own figures, that its patients' claims were 20% lower. By early 2017 it had lost some large employer clients and was down to 13,000 patients, and on 15 June 2017 it closed five clinics. Its chief executive, Erika Bliss, said payers resisted rewarding the company even when it beat its quality and savings targets, and that "You can't do this for $25 [per person] per month."

    Lessona practice whose members come through a few large employer contracts can lose most of them when those contracts end.

    kffhealthnews.orgtpr.org

    Credit

    Qliance; reported by KFF Health News

  5. 2024

    A funded chain shuts

    Forward launched in 2016 as a membership practice paid in cash that took no insurance. It grew to 19 locations with more than 100 primary care clinicians, raised $657 million by TechCrunch's count and was valued at $1 billion in 2021. On 13 November 2024 it announced that it was closing its locations, cancelling appointments and shutting its app at once; its medical team stayed reachable by email until 13 December 2024, and it said it would tell patients how to get their records "in the future".

    Lessonneither size nor funding protected members; when a membership practice closes, records and continuing care become the members' problem.

    fiercehealthcare.com

    Credit

    Forward (founder Adrian Aoun); reported by Fierce Healthcare

  6. 2025

    Growth and new owners measured

    Researchers linked the largest public directory of these practices to national clinician records and counted concierge and direct primary care practices growing from 1,658 in 2018 to 3,036 in 2023, an 83.1% rise, and their clinicians from 3,935 to 7,021. The share of practices independently owned fell from 84.0% to 59.7%, while practices tied to corporations grew by 576%; the share of clinicians who were physicians fell from 67.3% to 59.7%, as more nurse practitioners and physician assistants joined, and about 60% of the clinicians also took part in Medicare. The authors call their count a lower bound, not a census.

    Lessona model that began as small independent practices was, by 2023, only 59.7% independently owned.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Jane M. Zhu, T. Marsh, D. Polsky, A. Huntington and Z. Song (Health Affairs, December 2025)

Watch for

  1. Over 3,000 practices claimed

    DPC Frontier, a site run by direct primary care advocates, says its map lists 3,286 direct primary care practices in all 50 states and Washington, DC, and the Direct Primary Care Alliance's July 2026 report cites Hint Health's estimate of about 3,600.

    Achieved whenan independent count with a published method, such as a repeat of Zhu and colleagues' 2023 count for direct primary care alone, finds more than 3,000 practices.

    mapper.dpcfrontier.comdpcnews.com

    Claimed by

    DPC Frontier and Hint Health, 2026

  2. Prices near $100 a month

    The Direct Primary Care Alliance, a nonprofit of these physicians, reports a national average price of $98.64 per member per month from 465 survey responses collected in October and November 2024, against the $77.38 found in 2015. The American Academy of Family Physicians' 2026 brief says 61% of its 167 practicing respondents charge adults $51 to $100 a month, 64% also charge an enrollment fee, and the share running pure membership practices fell from 90% in 2022 to 71%.

    Achieved whenposted prices or regulator filings from several states confirm a national average near $100.

    dpcnews.comaafp.org

    Claimed by

    DPC Alliance (July 2026) and AAFP (2026), both from self-reported surveys

Open

  1. 01

    What practices post, coded

    An open table, refreshed each quarter, of what practices say on their own websites: monthly fees by age band (child, adult, over 65, family), enrollment fees, visit or message limits, what the fee covers, and the access they promise (same- or next-day visits, a stated reply time for texts and calls, after-hours contact, home and video visits, any cap on the number of patients), each tied to a saved copy of the page. From it, report the share of practices whose fee is at or below the $150 a month for one person, or $300 for a family, that US tax law now sets for paying from a health savings account, and how often a practice's map listing disagrees with its own site.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Membership clinics abroad, counted

    A repeatable count of family-doctor clinics and services that charge a membership or annual fee in Canada, Australia and the United Kingdom, with the fee, what it buys and the public rule it sits under, from clinic websites, published fee notices and news reports, under one written method.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

What practices post, coded

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table, refreshed each quarter, of what practices say on their own websites: monthly fees by age band (child, adult, over 65, family), enrollment fees, visit or message limits, what the fee covers, and the access they promise (same- or next-day visits, a stated reply time for texts and calls, after-hours contact, home and video visits, any cap on the number of patients), each tied to a saved copy of the page. From it, report the share of practices whose fee is at or below the $150 a month for one person, or $300 for a family, that US tax law now sets for paying from a health savings account, and how often a practice's map listing disagrees with its own site.

Why it is still open

Current figures come from surveys of doctors (the DPC Alliance's 465 responses from late 2024, the AAFP's 167 practicing respondents, about 200 in the 2020 Society of Actuaries survey) or from one state's register, which reports averages and bands, not practice-level prices. The last national compilation of posted prices was Eskew and Klink's in 2015. DPC Frontier's map lists addresses, website links and a few benefit tags, such as "Videochat", but no prices. No practice-level dataset of posted prices or promises was found.

dpcnews.comaafp.orgsoa.orgmapper.dpcfrontier.comlaw.cornell.edu

Built with what exists

DPC Frontier's map as the list of practices; a crawler such as Scrapy, with archived copies of each page; an AI model that fills a fixed form from each pricing and services page, checked by two human coders; Python for agreement statistics.

  1. First step

    Write the coding sheet from the service list in the 2020 Society of Actuaries survey, and hand-code the pricing and services pages of 50 practices from the map to test the extraction step.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 practices in at least 40 states; field-level accuracy of at least 95% on 200 hand-checked pages, and agreement between the two coders (Cohen's kappa) of at least 0.8 on each access field; the share under the $150 and $300 limits by state; a second quarterly run showing which prices changed.

Open 02 · the brief

Membership clinics abroad, counted

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A repeatable count of family-doctor clinics and services that charge a membership or annual fee in Canada, Australia and the United Kingdom, with the fee, what it buys and the public rule it sits under, from clinic websites, published fee notices and news reports, under one written method.

Why it is still open

The counts found are one-offs and are ageing. A 2022 study by Dalhousie and Simon Fraser researchers found 14 clinics taking membership fees or private payment in Alberta, 24 in Ontario and 30 in Quebec between November 2019 and June 2020, as CBC reported it. Cleanbill, an Australian clinic-search company, counted 98 clinics charging a membership fee for bulk billing in April 2024. In the United Kingdom only company figures were found: Bupa began selling GP subscriptions at £16.99 and £21.66 a month in September 2024 and told members to stay registered with an NHS GP, and HealthHero says 63,000 people signed up for private GP appointments through gym memberships in the two years from January 2024.

amp.cbc.cawww1.racgp.org.aupulsetoday.co.uksportsmanagement.co.uk

Built with what exists

Provincial and state clinic lists; Google Maps listings; clinic websites saved with their dates; an AI model to read fee pages in English and French; two coders for a check sample.

  1. First step

    Rebuild the Alberta part of the 2019–2020 count from public clinic websites and compare the new list with the old figure of 14.

  2. Done looks like

    A table covering every province of Canada, every state and territory of Australia and the four UK nations, refreshed once, with each clinic's fee, evidence link and date; 10% of rows rechecked by a second person with at least 95% agreement.