Industries / Health / Healthcare / Direct primary care
Employer plans
Employers, public bodies and insurers that pay the membership for the people they cover, usually alongside an insurance plan for hospital and specialist care.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1934 to 2022.
3
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
3
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1934
Five cents a day
Sidney Garfield ran a small hospital in the Mojave Desert for the roughly 5,000 workers building the Colorado River Aqueduct, and was close to failing because insurers paid his claims late or in part. Harold Hatch of Industrial Indemnity Exchange, the contractors' insurer, proposed paying him 17.5% of its workers' compensation premium in advance, which came to 5 cents a day for each worker, and workers could add 5 cents a day for care off the job. At the Grand Coulee Dam, from 1938 to 1940, the plan was extended to workers' families; it grew into Kaiser Permanente. The Ross-Loos Medical Group had already prepaid care for 12,000 employees of the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and their families from 1929.
Lessona fixed sum per person, paid in advance by the employer's side, kept a practice open where payment claim by claim had not.
Credit
Sidney Garfield; Harold Hatch (Industrial Indemnity Exchange); Henry J. Kaiser
2015
A county pays the fee
In April 2015 Union County, North Carolina, with about 1,000 employees, added a direct primary care option run by Paladina Health at a clinic near county offices, the first county in the state to do so. It paid the fee with the $750 a year it had put into each employee's health reimbursement account. The John Locke Foundation, a North Carolina policy group that promotes the model, reported from county figures that claims for the 44% of employees who chose it ran over $260 a month per employee lower than for those in the county's consumer-driven plan, $1.28 million in the first year. The comparison did not adjust for the health of the people who chose each option.
Lessonthe first public savings figures compared people who chose the membership with people who did not, and a later actuarial study found that choosers were healthier to begin with.
Credit
Union County (Mark Watson, human resources director); Paladina Health
2016
A state plan adds memberships
In November 2016 New Jersey's State Health Benefits Program and School Employees' Health Benefits Program began a three-year pilot with R-Health, a direct primary care company, open to as many as 60,000 state and local government employees. Members paid no fee; doctors gave up fee-for-service payments for a monthly fee per member, typically $50 to $80, plus incentives, and could take no more than 1,000 patients each. In 2026 the state still offers direct primary care with no membership fee and no copays to employees, retirees not yet on Medicare and their dependents, through Marathon Health (formerly Everside Health); Everside and Marathon Health merged in February 2024, reaching 2.5 million eligible patients through more than 680 health centers.
Credit
New Jersey Division of Pensions and Benefits; R-Health
2017
Sponsor fails, clinic closes
Turntable Health opened in downtown Las Vegas in December 2013, charging $80 a month for same- or next-day visits and contact by phone, email or video. By April 2014 about a third of its 400 patients came through the Nevada Health CO-OP, an insurer set up under the Affordable Care Act, which paid Turntable a flat rate out of members' premiums. The co-op stopped operating on 1 January 2016, and Turntable closed on 31 January 2017; its founder, Zubin Damania, cited "the economic challenges of the Las Vegas market".
Lessona practice paid largely by one sponsor carries that sponsor's risk.
Credit
Turntable Health (Zubin Damania); Nevada Health CO-OP
2020
Actuaries test the savings
For the Society of Actuaries, Milliman studied one self-insured employer that from July 2015 let employees choose an option with a direct primary care membership, its fee paid by the employer, or a traditional PPO-style plan. Comparing 931 members with 1,105 in the traditional option over 2016 and 2017, and adjusting for age, sex and health status, the membership option went with 12.64% lower overall use of care and 40.51% fewer emergency department visits; hospital admissions were 19.90% lower, but too few to be statistically significant. The members' risk scores were 8.3% lower to begin with. Once membership fees and the deductibles waived for members were counted, the employer's plan costs were an estimated 1.3% higher, within a range from 5.2% lower to 7.8% higher.
Lessonlower use of care does not by itself lower an employer's costs once the fees are paid, and raw comparisons overstate savings because healthier people choose to join.
Credit
Fritz Busch, Dustin Grzeskowiak and Erik Huth (Milliman), for the Society of Actuaries
2022
Amazon Care shuts down
Amazon Care, a virtual and in-home primary and urgent care service with no clinics, began in 2019 as a pilot for Amazon's employees in the Seattle area and was sold to other employers across the US from 2021. On 24 August 2022 Amazon told staff it would close at the end of the year because it was "not a complete enough offering for the large enterprise customers we have been targeting". A month earlier Amazon had agreed to buy One Medical, a membership primary care company with clinics, for $3.9 billion.
Lessonlarge employers did not buy video and home visits alone as their workers' primary care.
Credit
Amazon (Neil Lindsay, Amazon Health Services)
Watch for
Employers pay most memberships
Hint Health says that, among practices on its platform (more than 2,400 clinicians and 1.2 million members), 58% of memberships in 2024 were employer-sponsored, over 7,200 employers took part, and 85% of employer sponsors were still with their practice after 12 months; its April 2026 report puts the employer share at 60%.
Achieved whenan employer survey not drawn from one vendor's customers, such as KFF's annual Employer Health Benefits Survey, reports how many employers offer direct primary care.
Claimed by
Hint Health, August 2025 and April 2026
Five years of slower costs
SALTA Direct Primary Care, a practice group in southeast Michigan, and the benefits administrator Ameriflex said on 14 October 2026 that employers paying SALTA memberships through a health reimbursement arrangement held cost growth to 0.9% a year over five years, against an expected 6.2%, with emergency visits down 31%, hospital admissions down 71% and $13.84 million saved. Medical Economics reported that the release does not say who ran the analysis, how many employers or employees took part, which years it covered or where the expected trend came from.
Achieved whenan outside actuary publishes the analysis with enrollment counts, years and adjustment for health status.
Claimed by
SALTA and Ameriflex, October 2026
Modeled savings for hybrid plan
Milliman, paid by the company, simulated employer groups using Healthcare2U's DPCadvantage, a hybrid service employers buy per employee with in-person and telehealth visits. After the program fee it estimated net savings of $3 to $24 per patient per month, 0.6% to 3.4% of employer-paid claims, depending on the group's risk; for members with none of the conditions the program targets, employer costs were $6 to $17 a month higher.
Achieved whenobserved claims from employers using the program, compared with similar employees outside it and adjusted for health status, are published.
Claimed by
Milliman for Healthcare2U, September 2026
Open
01
A ledger of employer results
A public table of every published employer or public-sector result for direct primary care since 2015, each coded for who ran the analysis and who paid for it, how many people and which years, whether the comparison group was the same employer's non-members, whether results were adjusted for health status, whether membership fees and waived cost-sharing were counted, and the headline figure.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A selection test bench
Open code that builds synthetic employer populations in which healthier people are more likely to choose a membership option, plants a known effect on emergency visits and costs, and then runs the methods used in published studies (a raw comparison, a comparison adjusted by risk score, a before-and-after comparison against non-members) to show how far each lands from the planted answer.
The briefCredit · unclaimed03
An open break-even calculator
A free, open calculator that reproduces the funding framework in section 7 of the Society of Actuaries report (baseline claims, a selection factor, expected savings by type of service, the membership fee and plan design changes) and returns the fee at which a membership option breaks even for a given employer, with every assumption shown.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
A ledger of employer results
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of every published employer or public-sector result for direct primary care since 2015, each coded for who ran the analysis and who paid for it, how many people and which years, whether the comparison group was the same employer's non-members, whether results were adjusted for health status, whether membership fees and waived cost-sharing were counted, and the headline figure.
Why it is still open
The latest independent review of the evidence is the literature review in the 2020 Society of Actuaries report, which notes critics' view that reported savings may be "aberrant, based on small study sizes, or are driven by patient selection". No systematic review of the model's costs was found since. New claims keep arriving without methods: Medical Economics found in October 2026 that the SALTA release did not say who ran the analysis or how many employees took part. Only 26% of practices with employer contracts were asked for data by those employers, by the AAFP's 2026 survey.
Built with what exists
Public releases, case studies and reports (Union County, the Society of Actuaries case, SALTA, Healthcare2U and others found by search); a shared spreadsheet; an AI model to pull candidate fields from each document, checked by two human coders.
First step
Code the five employer results named in this section and publish the coding sheet for comment.
Done looks like
At least 25 results coded by two people, with their agreement reported; every row linked to an archived copy of its source; a summary count of how many results are adjusted for health status and net of fees.
Open 02 · the brief
A selection test bench
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
Open code that builds synthetic employer populations in which healthier people are more likely to choose a membership option, plants a known effect on emergency visits and costs, and then runs the methods used in published studies (a raw comparison, a comparison adjusted by risk score, a before-and-after comparison against non-members) to show how far each lands from the planted answer.
Why it is still open
The Society of Actuaries study adjusted for health with Milliman's own proprietary risk scores and found the members 8.3% healthier at the start; Union County's and SALTA's figures compare raw costs. No public tool shows how much of a raw gap selection alone can produce.
Built with what exists
Synthea, an open simulator that generates synthetic patients with encounters and claims files (github.com/synthetichealth/synthea); hccpy, an open Python implementation of the Hierarchical Condition Categories used in Medicare risk scores (github.com/yubin-park/hccpy); Python or R.
First step
Generate 10,000 synthetic adults with Synthea and choose who enrolls so that the members' risk score is 8.3% lower, as in the 2020 case.
Done looks like
1,000 simulated employers for each scenario, and for each method its average error and how often its 95% interval contains the planted effect, published with the code.
Open 03 · the brief
An open break-even calculator
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A free, open calculator that reproduces the funding framework in section 7 of the Society of Actuaries report (baseline claims, a selection factor, expected savings by type of service, the membership fee and plan design changes) and returns the fee at which a membership option breaks even for a given employer, with every assumption shown.
Why it is still open
The framework exists only as tables in a PDF. The Purchaser Business Group on Health's public calculators for primary care access multiply default visit counts by default prices ($200 a primary care visit, $2,000 an emergency visit) and have no selection factor or membership fee schedule.
Built with what exists
The report's worked example as the test case; a spreadsheet or a small web app; public cost benchmarks where an employer has no claims data.
First step
Re-key the worked-example tables from section 7 into a spreadsheet and check that the totals match.
Done looks like
Every figure in the report's worked example reproduced to the dollar, automated tests for each step, and a published guide.