BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Finance and banking / Debt collection

Disputes and proof of debt

This is the work of answering a person who says a debt is wrong, not theirs or already paid, and of showing the records that prove what is owed.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1974 to 2021.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1974

    Right to see the agreement

    The UK's Consumer Credit Act 1974 lets a borrower on running-account credit, such as a credit card, ask in writing for a copy of the signed agreement and a statement of the account, for a fee now set at £1. Under section 78, a lender that fails to supply them "is not entitled, while the default continues, to enforce the agreement."

    legislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    UK Parliament

  2. 1977

    Thirty days to dispute

    Section 809 of the US Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, enacted on 20 September 1977, requires a collector to tell a person that they have 30 days to dispute a debt. If the person disputes it in writing within that time, the collector must stop collecting the disputed part until it mails them verification of the debt or a copy of a court judgment.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US Congress

  3. 2008

    Objection without reasons

    The European order for payment, an EU procedure for cross-border money claims, has applied since 12 December 2008. The court checks the creditor's application form, which "may take the form of an automated procedure", and issues the order without hearing the debtor. The debtor can then lodge a statement of opposition within 30 days "without having to specify the reasons", and the claim moves to an ordinary civil court, where the creditor must prove it.

    eur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council of the EU, Regulation (EC) No 1896/2006

  4. 2009

    Rebuilt copies are enough

    By 2009 claims management companies had brought hundreds of claims in English courts arguing that credit card debts could not be enforced because the banks could not produce the signed agreement under section 78. In Carey v HSBC, decided on 23 December 2009, Judge Waksman QC held that a lender can meet the duty with "a reconstituted version of the executed agreement", built from its own records, as long as the copy is honest and accurate.

    LessonA right to proof makes a lender show what was agreed; it does not cancel a debt because an old paper is lost.

    caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk

    Credit

    His Honour Judge Waksman QC, Manchester Mercantile Court

  5. 2013

    Complaints counted in public

    The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) began taking debt collection complaints in 2013; the first one in its public database is dated 10 July 2013. Its public database holds 39,032 debt collection complaints received in 2014 and 283,193 received in 2025, and in both years about 41% fell under the issue "attempts to collect debt not owed". The CFPB's own annual reports count more: about 207,800 received in 2024, against 155,893 in the database. Companies closed 73% of the 2025 complaints "with explanation" and 447 with money paid back.

    consumerfinance.govconsumerfinance.govfiles.consumerfinance.gov

    Credit

    Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

  6. 2021

    A standard dispute form

    The CFPB's Regulation F, in force from 30 November 2021, sets what a US collector's first notice, the validation notice, must show: the amount owed on a fixed "itemization date", the interest, fees, payments and credits since then, and the date the dispute period ends. Its tear-off response section has boxes that read "This is not my debt." and "The amount is wrong.", and a collector that uses the CFPB's model form gets a safe harbor, meaning it is treated as meeting these disclosure rules. The CFPB had tested draft notices on consumers in focus groups and interviews run by the research firm Fors Marsh Group from 2014.

    law.cornell.edufederalregister.govfiles.consumerfinance.gov

    Credit

    Consumer Financial Protection Bureau; Fors Marsh Group

Watch for

  1. Machine-made complaints

    The CFPB says a growing share of complaints are not written by the person affected. Its annual report of 31 March 2026 counted 6.6 million complaints in 2025, up from about 3.2 million in 2024, and named credit repair firms and "emerging technologies such as large language models and AI agents" as enabling "duplicative and spurious" submissions. On 24 June 2026 it announced two-factor sign-in and other checks, and on 14 August 2026 it stopped publishing complaint narratives. The National Consumer Law Center, an advocacy group, criticized the new requirements, as reported by the law firm Ballard Spahr. A self-published count by the fraud consultant Frank McKenna (August 2026) found that 43% of all published narratives matched another word for word, but gave no figure for debt collection.

    Achieved whenAn independent party publishes a count of copied or machine-written debt collection complaints, with code that others can rerun.

    infobytes.orrick.comconsumerfinancemonitor.comconsumerfinancemonitor.comfrankonfraud.com

    Claimed by

    Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    An open template count

    A count, with code anyone can rerun, of how many US debt collection complaints were copied from templates. Take the debt collection narratives from the CFPB's archive (December 2011 to 14 August 2026), find exact and near-identical texts, and group them into template families by year and complaint issue. Then hand-label a random sample to separate a person who used a free template letter, which is lawful and common, from bulk filing by a third party. Work only with the public, anonymized texts and report totals, never single complaints.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Disputes matched to proof

    A public test set of invented debt files and dispute letters, for checking software that handles disputes. Each case pairs a made-up account history (original creditor, itemization date, payments, sale to a debt buyer) with a dispute in a consumer's own words: not mine, wrong amount, already paid, identity theft, or a request for the original creditor's name. Gold labels say which Regulation F dispute box the letter matches, which records answer it, and whether the file holds them. Tools are scored on naming the dispute, spotting the missing record, and drafting a reply that cites only what is in the file. Use only invented names and accounts.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An open template count

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A count, with code anyone can rerun, of how many US debt collection complaints were copied from templates. Take the debt collection narratives from the CFPB's archive (December 2011 to 14 August 2026), find exact and near-identical texts, and group them into template families by year and complaint issue. Then hand-label a random sample to separate a person who used a free template letter, which is lawful and common, from bulk filing by a third party. Work only with the public, anonymized texts and report totals, never single complaints.

Why it is still open

The CFPB blames "duplicative and spurious" filings but has published no count. Frank McKenna's August 2026 analysis found 43% of all published narratives were word-for-word copies and released a list of templates, but gave no debt collection figure and did not release its code. The CFPB stopped publishing narratives on 14 August 2026, so its archive is now the last public copy. Published research on these complaints classifies them by topic or predicts the outcome (Wang, Zhu and Chen, June 2026) and does not count copies.

frankonfraud.comconsumerfinance.govarxiv.org

Built with what exists

The CFPB archive's ZIP exports; Python with the open-source datasketch library for MinHash, a fast way to find near-identical texts; a general AI model for a first pass of the sample labels, such as Claude Fable 5.2 (see the Note "Three working devices") or Mistral Large 4 run on one's own machines (see the Note "A trillion open parameters").

  1. First step

    Download the August 2026 export from the archive, keep the rows whose product is debt collection, and count exact duplicates by hashing each narrative.

  2. Done looks like

    Published code and counts, by year and by complaint issue, for every debt collection narrative in the archive; a sample of 1,000 narratives labeled by two people, with their rate of agreement; and a second person who reruns the code and gets the same counts.

Open 02 · the brief

Disputes matched to proof

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set of invented debt files and dispute letters, for checking software that handles disputes. Each case pairs a made-up account history (original creditor, itemization date, payments, sale to a debt buyer) with a dispute in a consumer's own words: not mine, wrong amount, already paid, identity theft, or a request for the original creditor's name. Gold labels say which Regulation F dispute box the letter matches, which records answer it, and whether the file holds them. Tools are scored on naming the dispute, spotting the missing record, and drafting a reply that cites only what is in the file. Use only invented names and accounts.

Why it is still open

Disputes are the largest single issue in US collection complaints: 115,681 of the 283,193 debt collection complaints in 2025 were "attempts to collect debt not owed", and companies closed 73% of all 2025 debt collection complaints "with explanation". Published work on CFPB complaints classifies or scores the complaint text alone, without the account file (Wang, Zhu and Chen, June 2026; Chai, Sun and Staddon, July 2026). The CFPB's 2016 notice research tested what consumers understood, not how firms answer. This research found no public test set that pairs disputes with the records needed to answer them.

consumerfinance.govarxiv.orgarxiv.orgfiles.consumerfinance.gov

Built with what exists

The validation notice fields and dispute prompts in 12 CFR 1006.34 as the template; an AI model to write varied letters, plain, misspelled and in Spanish; optical character recognition (OCR), software that reads scanned and handwritten pages; and Claude Fable 5.2 (see the Note "Three working devices") as one of the tools under test.

law.cornell.edu

  1. First step

    Write 50 cases by hand from the Regulation F model notice, ten for each dispute type, and have a second person label them blind.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 cases under an open license, each checked by a second person; a scoring script; and published scores for at least three tools on dispute type (accuracy), missing records (share found) and replies that cite only records in the file.