Cloud seeding
Cloud seeding puts particles such as silver iodide or salt into clouds, from aircraft, ground burners, rockets or drones, to make more rain or snow fall or to shrink hail, and then tries to measure whether it worked.
1946
On 13 November 1946 Vincent Schaefer of the General Electric Research Laboratory dropped dry ice from an aircraft into a supercooled cloud near Mount Greylock, Massachusetts, and, in his own words, "transformed an altostratus cloud to a mass of falling ice crystals".
42
Milestones achieved across 6 domains.
11
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
12
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
In one minute
Where it started
In 1946 Vincent Schaefer and Bernard Vonnegut at General Electric found that dry ice and silver iodide turn supercooled cloud droplets, water still liquid below 0 °C, into ice crystals that can grow and fall. Within a few years utilities, farm groups and governments were paying for seeding, long before anyone could show how much it added. Early lessons came from failures: Florida's cumulus experiment failed its own confirmatory phase, hurricane seeding was dropped, and a Swiss randomized hail test found no effect.
Where it stands
Seeding is routine in China, which reported nearly 559,000 operations from 2002 to 2012, in the UAE, which flies 300 to 400 seeding flights a year, and in the western United States, where water agencies pay for it. Measurement is the weak point: randomized tests in Israel and Wyoming found small or no significant gains, and the US Government Accountability Office found in 2024 that reliable information on effectiveness is lacking, though the 2017 SNOWIE campaign in Idaho watched seeded snow form from start to finish. Some US states banned seeding in 2024 and 2025, while drone companies are expanding it.
What is open
Most open work is in records and measurement: finding seeding signatures in public radar data by machine, rerunning programs' own evaluations with controls fixed in advance, and turning NOAA's scanned activity reports into data. Others are a public "was it seeded?" lookup for flood claims, world tables of programs and laws, and a single dataset of silver measured near seeding sites. None of them needs anything released into the air.
Domains
AchievedWatch forOpen
Domain
Progress
Last achieved
Watch for
Open
Methods
How seeding is meant to work: adding particles that make ice or large drops form in a cloud that is not raining as much as it could.
7 · 1 · 2
Last achievedAirports retire fog clearing2017
Watch forNano-salt seeding powder
2
openAircraft and ground generators
The machines that put seeding material where the cloud can use it: burners on the ground, flares on aircraft, rockets and shells, and now drones.
7 · 1 · 2
Last achievedDrones seed a season2025
Watch forFlares on small drones
2
openMeasuring results
Working out whether seeding added any rain or snow, or took any hail away, against weather that varies a great deal on its own.
7 · 2 · 2
Last achievedUS auditors call benefits unproven2024
Watch forSynthetic control across the West
2
openWater agencies
The utilities, water districts and governments that decide to seed, pay for it, and answer for whether it was worth the money.
7 · 2 · 2
Last achievedArizona's canal agency steps back2026
Watch forSaudi summer seeding
2
openRules
The laws, treaties and permits that say who may seed clouds, what they must report, and where seeding is banned.
7 · 3 · 2
Last achievedAuditors fault NOAA's records2026
Watch forA federal ban on seeding
2
openPublic concerns
The fears people raise about seeding, from floods and stolen rain to silver in the soil, and how inquiries, scientists and courts have answered them.
7 · 2 · 2
Last achievedTexas flood and Rainmaker2025
Watch forSeeding agents and bee learning
2
open
Open in cloud seeding
3 of 12 open deliverables
Open · Methods
A world seedable-cloud atlas
Monthly maps, for each region where seeding programs run, of how often clouds hold supercooled liquid water at the temperatures silver iodide works (about −4 to −20 °C), built from satellite observations rather than model output, and covering programs outside the US West.
Built with what exists
CloudSat's 2B-CLDCLASS-LIDAR cloud type and phase product and its ECMWF-AUX temperature profiles (from June 2006), Python with xarray, and the published Mazzetti and Adhikari seedability values for comparison.
Open · Aircraft and ground generators
Map where flare casings land
An open model that predicts where spent ejectable flare casings and seeding-rocket parachute debris come down, from release height, wind profiles and published hardware specifications, with drop-zone maps for standard seeding cases.
Built with what exists
Published hardware data (Ice Crystal Engineering's ICE-EJ flare in an aluminium casing; the 82 mm, 10.8 kg ZBZ-HJ-7 rocket with its parachute), NOAA's hourly 3 km HRRR wind analyses, archived on AWS since 2014, and Python.
Open · Measuring results
Find seeding lines automatically
An open detector that scans public weather radar data for the lines of extra snow that seeding leaves downwind of an aircraft or drone, and reports each line's start, path and size.
Built with what exists
NEXRAD Level II data on AWS Open Data, NOAA's MRMS radar mosaics, the Py-ART radar toolkit, PyTorch for a small image model, and the flight times and tracks published in the SNOWIE papers and the Rainmaker report.