BRENNEN

Industries / Frontier science / Cloud seeding

Rules

The laws, treaties and permits that say who may seed clouds, what they must report, and where seeding is banned.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1967 to 2026.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1967

    Texas licenses rainmakers

    After many private "rainmaking" efforts during the 1950s drought, the Texas Legislature passed the Texas Weather Modification Act in 1967. It requires a licence and a permit for each project, and an applicant must publish a notice in area newspapers for three weeks running so that residents can ask for a public hearing.

    tdlr.texas.govtdlr.texas.gov

    Credit

    Texas Legislature; run since 2003 by the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation (TDLR)

  2. 1971

    Seeders must report to NOAA

    A federal law signed on 18 December 1971, known as the Weather Modification Reporting Act of 1972, requires anyone who modifies the weather in the United States to report to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). NOAA's rules, in force since 1976, ask for an initial report at least 10 days before work starts and interim and final reports afterwards, set a fine of up to $10,000 for knowing violations, and say the records are public "to the fullest practicable extent".

    LessonThe law asks for reports but gives no federal agency the power to approve or stop a project; NOAA says it does not regulate cloud seeding.

    law.cornell.eduecfr.govlibrary.noaa.gov

    Credit

    US Congress (Public Law 92-205); NOAA

  3. 1977

    Treaty bans weather as weapon

    Starting in March 1967 the US military secretly seeded clouds over Vietnam in Operation Popeye to lengthen the monsoon and keep supply roads muddy; a closed Senate briefing in 1974 exposed it, and the record was made public on 19 May 1974. The United States and the Soviet Union then drafted the Environmental Modification Convention (ENMOD), signed in Geneva on 18 May 1977 and in force from 5 October 1978. It bans military or other hostile use of weather modification and says it "shall not hinder" peaceful use; the UN Treaty Collection lists 78 parties.

    LessonThe one binding international rule on seeding covers hostile use only, so peaceful seeding is left to national law.

    2009-2017.state.govtreaties.un.orgpopsci.com

    Credit

    Senator Claiborne Pell's subcommittee hearings; US and Soviet negotiators; the UN Conference of the Committee on Disarmament

  4. 2002

    China puts forecasters in charge

    China's State Council Decree No. 348, in force from 1 May 2002, makes local meteorological departments plan and direct all rain and snow enhancement, hail suppression, fog dispersal and frost protection, under plans approved by local governments and paid from public budgets. Crews must pass provincial exams, the names of anti-aircraft gun and rocket launcher crews go to the police, and every operation needs an airspace and time window from flight control.

    faolex.fao.org

    Credit

    State Council of China; the China Meteorological Administration

  5. 2004

    Australia writes seeding into law

    New South Wales's Snowy Mountains Cloud Seeding Trial Act 2004 let Snowy Hydro seed for snow only from ground generators, only with silver iodide, with indium oxide allowed as a tracer, and only under an environmental management plan that monitors both metals across the study area.

    journalofweathermodification.scholasticahq.com

    Credit

    NSW Parliament; Snowy Hydro Limited

  6. 2024

    States start banning seeding

    From 1 July 2024 Tennessee banned releasing any substance into the air "with the express purpose of affecting temperature, weather, or the intensity of the sunlight". From 1 July 2025 Florida repealed its old weather modification licence rules, made violations a third-degree felony with fines up to $100,000, required public airports to report monthly, and set up an online form for residents to report what they see. Louisiana passed a ban in 2025, according to a July 2026 white paper from the University of Houston Law Center.

    LessonThe same white paper reports that Florida's environment department had not received a single weather modification application in 68 years, and that the ban has produced no documented violations.

    publications.tnsosfiles.comflsenate.govlaw.uh.edu

    Credit

    Tennessee General Assembly (Public Chapter 709); Florida Legislature (Chapter 2025-157)

  7. 2026

    Auditors fault NOAA's records

    The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) reviewed NOAA's online archive of weather modification reports, which held 1,084 files in February 2025. The oldest report in it was from 1999, though the law dates from 1971; GAO estimated that 78% of initial reports had at least one error, and found that 4 of 10 states with seeding had publicly reported activity missing from NOAA's archive. NOAA agreed to write review guidance and clearer form instructions.

    LessonA reporting law without staff to check and keep the reports does not give the public the record it promises.

    files.gao.gov

    Credit

    US GAO, report GAO-26-108013, 23 February 2026

Watch for

  1. A federal ban on seeding

    The Clear Skies Act (H.R. 4403) would make knowingly modifying the weather anywhere in the United States a federal crime, with fines up to $100,000 per violation, prison terms up to 5 years, or both.

    Achieved whenboth chambers of Congress pass it and it is signed into law.

    govinfo.gov

    Claimed by

    Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, who introduced it on 15 July 2025

  2. Bans reach seeding states

    In the 2026 sessions 29 state legislatures had bills to ban weather modification or solar geoengineering, according to the University of Houston Law Center. West Virginia's HB 5513, introduced on 13 February 2026, would ban cloud seeding by name, while Wyoming's HB 12 would ban geoengineering but exempts cloud seeding. GAO counted, as of July 2025, five states with active seeding programs among those with proposed bans: Idaho, Texas, Utah, Wyoming and North Dakota.

    Achieved whena state that runs a seeding program enacts a ban that covers it.

    bills.wvlegislature.govwyoleg.govlaw.uh.edufiles.gao.gov

    Claimed by

    state legislators, 2026

  3. NOAA's archive searchable by place

    NOAA officials told GAO that work to let the public search reports by location, funded in 2024 and delayed by budget and staff cuts, would be finished in spring 2026, and NOAA agreed to GAO's three recommendations. In November 2026 the NOAA Library's list showed project name, number, dates and activity, with no search by place.

    Achieved whenNOAA's archive can be searched by place and GAO records its recommendations as carried out.

    files.gao.govlibrary.noaa.gov

    Claimed by

    NOAA, February 2026

Open

  1. 01

    What was actually released

    A public dataset of how much seeding each US project actually did: days seeded per month, hours each generator or aircraft ran, and kilograms of each agent released, taken from NOAA's interim and final activity reports (Form 17-4A) and joined to the 832 project rows Donohue and Lamb already extracted.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    World table of seeding law

    A searchable table of the rules on cloud seeding in every US state and every country with a seeding program: who may seed, what licence or permit is needed, public notice, reporting, liability cover, environmental conditions and bans, each row linked to the official text and dated.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

What was actually released

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public dataset of how much seeding each US project actually did: days seeded per month, hours each generator or aircraft ran, and kilograms of each agent released, taken from NOAA's interim and final activity reports (Form 17-4A) and joined to the 832 project rows Donohue and Lamb already extracted.

Why it is still open

Donohue and Lamb collected all 1,025 PDFs in NOAA's archive but extracted only Form 17-4, the project summary; they left out Form 17-4A, which "provides tabular data on seeding activity, including days seeded per month and agent quantities released", along with maps and operational logs. They also note that reports from 1972 to 1999 are not publicly released. GAO estimated that 21% of interim and final reports have at least one error, so the numbers need checking against state records.

nature.comfiles.gao.gov

Built with what exists

Donohue and Lamb's open code and Zenodo dataset; an AI model reading scanned PDFs with a person checking (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); state program reports from TDLR and other state agencies for cross-checks; a Freedom of Information Act request to NOAA for any 1972–1999 reports it still holds.

  1. First step

    Pull the 17-4A pages for one state's projects (Texas, five current projects) from the NOAA archive and extract them into a table this month.

  2. Done looks like

    Agent amounts and seeding days for at least 90% of the 832 projects, in one CSV with units in kilograms and days; a hand check of 200 random rows shows at least 95% of values match the PDFs; a short note listing every report where the 17-4A totals disagree with a state's own published figures.

Open 02 · the brief

World table of seeding law

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A searchable table of the rules on cloud seeding in every US state and every country with a seeding program: who may seed, what licence or permit is needed, public notice, reporting, liability cover, environmental conditions and bans, each row linked to the official text and dated.

Why it is still open

The comparisons that exist are partial or dated. Montana's legislative staff compared six western states in 2020. Law-review surveys of US state law, such as Hertz (2021), Currier (2017) and Woodruff (2024), are one-time essays written before Florida's 2025 ban, as cited by Conklin and Blount (2025), and a 2026 review of US governance by Wang and Chen describes state oversight in general terms with no state-by-state table. The University of Houston Law Center's July 2026 white paper counts 133 ban bills in 38 states since 2023 but gives no table of the rules in force. SRM360 tracks state bills to ban solar geoengineering, not seeding licences. The WMO says seeding runs in more than 50 countries, but its June 2025 statement lists no national rules.

leg.mt.govlaw.uh.edusrm360.orgwmo.intlawreview.syr.edudoi.org

Built with what exists

FAO's FAOLEX legal database, state legislature websites and the Cornell Legal Information Institute; a browsing agent such as Browser Use 1.0 to collect statute pages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a fixed schema kept in a public GitHub repository.

  1. First step

    Fill the rows for the 10 states GAO found with reported seeding and the 3 states with bans, then add China, Australia and the United Arab Emirates from FAOLEX.

  2. Done looks like

    All 50 US states and at least 30 countries covered, every row linked to an official text; 20 random rows checked by a law student or lawyer with no more than one error; an update after each year's legislative sessions.