BRENNEN

Industries / Frontier science / Cloud seeding

Water agencies

The utilities, water districts and governments that decide to seed, pay for it, and answer for whether it was worth the money.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1973 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1973

    Utah takes charge of seeding

    Utah has seeded since the early 1950s, and its Cloud Seeding Act of 1973 gave the state's Division of Water Resources authority over seeding projects. The state and local water users share the cost; the state paid 50% for its southern and central program in 2022–23.

    water.utah.govwater.utah.gov

    Credit

    Utah Division of Water Resources

  2. 2007

    Downstream users pay upstream

    The Central Arizona Project, which carries Colorado River water to Phoenix and Tucson, began helping pay for seeding equipment in Colorado, Utah and Wyoming in 2007. Water agencies in Arizona, California and Nevada have together sent about $1.5 million a year to this work in recent years, by KUNC's count.

    kunc.orglibrary.cap-az.com

    Credit

    Central Arizona Project, Southern Nevada Water Authority and California water agencies

  3. 2012

    Snowy trial becomes permanent

    Snowy Hydro ran a seeding trial in the Snowy Mountains of New South Wales from 2004 to 2012 under a state law that made the Natural Resources Commission supervise it. In September 2012 the government ended the trial and made seeding permanent, under an environmental plan approved by ministers and reviewed by the state Environment Protection Authority.

    Lessonan outside reviewer with legal standing let the trial become a program in public view.

    nsw.gov.au

    Credit

    Snowy Hydro and the New South Wales government

  4. 2015

    UAE funds research abroad

    The UAE Research Program for Rain Enhancement Science began in 2015 and had given $22.5 million to 14 projects in nine countries by November 2024, by its own count. The country's National Center of Meteorology says it flies 300 to 400 seeding flights a year, about 1,000 flight hours.

    en.aletihad.ae

    Credit

    UAE Research Program for Rain Enhancement Science and the National Center of Meteorology, UAE

  5. 2020

    China sets national targets

    China's State Council set goals for its weather service to seed for rain and snow over more than 5.5 million km² and to protect more than 580,000 km² from hail by 2025.

    mee.gov.cn

    Credit

    General Office of the State Council of China, document 2020 No. 47

  6. 2025

    Delhi seeds dry air

    Delhi's cabinet approved ₹3.21 crore for five trials, run by IIT Kanpur, to wash out post-Diwali smog with rain. The October 2025 flights released silver iodide and salt into clouds that Delhi's environment minister put at 15% to 20% humidity, against about 50% normally needed, and no rain fell.

    Lessonseeding can only help clouds that are already close to raining.

    business-standard.com

    Credit

    Government of Delhi and IIT Kanpur; reported by Business Standard

  7. 2026

    Arizona's canal agency steps back

    In a close vote in November 2026, the Central Arizona Project board declined to fund the next phase of Upper Colorado River seeding. Board members said the gain is hard to measure and questioned whether Arizona would see the water.

    Lessonpayers downstream want a measured result, not only a plausible one.

    kunc.org

    Credit

    Central Arizona Project board; reported by KUNC

Watch for

  1. Saudi summer seeding

    Saudi Arabia's National Center for Meteorology says its first summer seeding raised rainfall over Rumah, northeast of Riyadh. It gave no figure. Its Regional Cloud Seeding Program flew 415 seeding flights in 2023, by its own count.

    Achieved whena measured rainfall change, with its method and an unseeded comparison, is published and checked by someone outside the centre.

    saudigazette.com.saarabnews.com

    Claimed by

    National Center for Meteorology, Saudi Arabia, August 2025

  2. Colorado River deal without Arizona

    The Southern Nevada Water Authority and six California water agencies are moving to keep funding Upper Basin seeding, with each agency's share capped at $525,000 a year in 2027, rising to $750,000 a year by 2036.

    Achieved whena signed agreement and the first payments are published.

    kunc.org

    Claimed by

    KUNC, reporting the agencies' letters, November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    One price per acre-foot

    A public ledger of operational seeding programs that puts each one's yearly cost, claimed extra water and the method behind the claim on one line, so funders can compare like with like.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A world list of programs

    An open register of seeding programs outside the US: who runs each one, who pays, what it targets, and whether it has ever been tested against unseeded weather.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

One price per acre-foot

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public ledger of operational seeding programs that puts each one's yearly cost, claimed extra water and the method behind the claim on one line, so funders can compare like with like.

Why it is still open

Programs report their own figures in different years and by different methods. Idaho's water agency gives $3.9 million a year and about 1,240,000 acre-feet, or $3.22 per acre-foot (March 2023); Utah gave $2.18 per acre-foot for 2018. The GAO said in 2024 that the return on funding is unclear. A search found no study comparing cost per acre-foot across programs.

idwr.idaho.govcpr.orglegistorm.com

Built with what exists

Utah's eight 2024–25 program reports, Idaho's program documents, state evaluation reports, the Donohue and Lamb dataset of reported US seeding periods, and an AI model that reads report tables with a person checking each value (see the Note "Seven more flagged").

  1. First step

    Fill the first ten rows from Utah's eight 2024–25 reports and Idaho's 2023 figures, and note where a report gives no cost.

  2. Done looks like

    Twenty programs, each with cost, claimed water, the evaluation method (randomized, target and control, or model), and whether anyone outside the operator checked it, published as a CSV with a source for every cell.

Open 02 · the brief

A world list of programs

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open register of seeding programs outside the US: who runs each one, who pays, what it targets, and whether it has ever been tested against unseeded weather.

Why it is still open

The World Meteorological Organization kept a register of national weather modification projects from 1975. In February 2024 it wrote to member countries that the register was last updated in 2001–2002, and asked each to name a contact to help set up a new one. In February 2026 its expert team listed "a global directory of weather modification programmes" in its 2026 to 2029 workplan, and asked 11 member countries for money to carry it out. A search in November 2026 found no directory published.

extranet.wmo.intextranet.wmo.int

Built with what exists

A browsing agent to collect agency pages and reports in many languages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"), machine translation, and a spreadsheet with a person checking each entry; the 2001–2002 WMO register as the starting list.

  1. First step

    Type the 2001–2002 WMO register (WMO/TD-No. 1191) into a table as the baseline.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 countries, each with one or more programs and a source per row, and a column showing which programs in the 2001–2002 register have since stopped.