BRENNEN

Industries / Frontier science / Cloud seeding

Aircraft and ground generators

The machines that put seeding material where the cloud can use it: burners on the ground, flares on aircraft, rockets and shells, and now drones.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1961 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1961

    Silver iodide in a flare

    In 1957 Lohr Burkardt, William Finnegan and Rex Smith of the US Naval Ordnance Test Station at China Lake, California, found that a pyrotechnic mix containing silver iodate burns to give off fine silver iodide smoke, and patented it. In September 1961 the station's "Cyclops" units, dropped from aircraft, carried the method into Hurricane Esther for the Weather Bureau. Flares are now the standard airborne method: Ice Crystal Engineering of Kindred, North Dakota, sells ejectable silver iodide flares (20 g of agent, about 37 seconds' burn) and burn-in-place flares (75 to 150 g, about 4 minutes) and says they are used in 24 countries.

    documents2.theblackvault.comiceflares.com

    Credit

    Naval Ordnance Test Station, China Lake

  2. 1980

    A crash grounds a program

    On 2 March 1980 a Desert Research Institute seeding plane crashed, killing researchers Peter Wagner, William Gaskell, John Latham and Gordon Wicks. The institute, which had seeded from aircraft since the 1960s, moved to ground generators, which burn silver iodide dissolved in acetone at mountain sites and let the smoke rise into passing storms.

    Lessonseeding aircraft must fly into icing storms, and ground generators trade some reach for safety and cost.

    dri.edu

    Credit

    Desert Research Institute, Nevada

  3. 1991

    Valley plumes stay low

    For Utah's Division of Water Resources, NOAA and the Bureau of Reclamation, research aircraft tracked silver iodide and a tracer gas released from valley-floor and canyon-mouth generators in Utah's operational program. On four of five flights the plume stayed in the lower atmosphere and never crossed the target mountains. Utah's southern and central program still ran about 70 manually operated generators, for 3,594 generator-hours, in the 2022 to 2023 winter.

    Lessona generator only helps if its smoke reaches cold cloud, and where it sits decides that.

    journalofweathermodification.scholasticahq.comwater.utah.gov

    Credit

    Arlin Super (Bureau of Reclamation) and Arlen Huggins (Desert Research Institute)

  4. 2003

    Remote generators on ridges

    Idaho Power began seeding the Payette River basin in 2003 with remote-controlled ground generators at high elevation plus aircraft burning flares. Its generators burn a solution of about 2 percent silver iodide in 97 percent acetone. The company extended the program to the upper Snake River in 2008 and the Wood and Boise River basins in 2015.

    idahopower.com

    Credit

    Idaho Power Company

  5. 2012

    Rockets and guns at scale

    China seeds clouds with rockets and anti-aircraft shells as well as planes. The China Meteorological Administration reported nearly 559,000 operations from 2002 to 2012, using more than 900,000 rockets and 8.85 million shells, with more than 7,034 rocket launchers, more than 50 planes and nearly 6,902 guns. One standard rocket, the ZBZ-HJ-7, is 82 mm across, carries 48 burning pellets of 6.2 g of silver iodide each, and comes down on a parachute that has been used more than 50,000 times.

    bjreview.comamt.copernicus.org

    Credit

    China Meteorological Administration

  6. 2016

    A drone burns seeding flares

    On 29 April 2016 a Drone America Savant, a fixed-wing drone with a 3.6 m wingspan, flew for about 18 minutes at 400 feet (122 m) over Hawthorne, Nevada, and burned two silver iodide flares. The director of the FAA-designated Nevada drone test site called it a first in the US national airspace.

    eurekalert.org

    Credit

    Desert Research Institute, Drone America and AviSight

  7. 2025

    Drones seed a season

    For October 2025 to April 2026, Rainmaker Technology filed a federal report for drone seeding over seven target areas in Utah covering 2,589 square miles (6,705 km²). Each drone carries a dispenser that releases 3.5 g of dry silver iodide powder a minute for up to 30 minutes, at up to 15,000 feet. Rainmaker bought the Utah operator North American Weather Consultants and replaced its ground and aircraft methods with drones.

    library.oarcloud.noaa.govdeseret.com

    Credit

    Rainmaker Technology Corporation

Watch for

  1. Flares on small drones

    Rainmaker asked the FAA on 2 July 2025 (docket FAA-2025-1630) for relief from the rule that bars small drones from carrying hazardous materials, so its 50-pound (22.7 kg) Elijah quadcopters can carry burn-in-place and ejectable flares. The Air Line Pilots Association called it "an extreme safety risk". As of August 2026 no decision had been published.

    Achieved whenthe FAA grants the exemption and publishes its conditions.

    dronexl.codronexl.co

    Claimed by

    Rainmaker Technology, July 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Map where flare casings land

    An open model that predicts where spent ejectable flare casings and seeding-rocket parachute debris come down, from release height, wind profiles and published hardware specifications, with drop-zone maps for standard seeding cases.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Score every generator site

    A public scorecard that rates each known ground generator site by how many hours, in past winters, its smoke could have reached supercooled cloud over the target mountains, using the criteria researchers already use: temperature, supercooled liquid water, and a Froude number (a measure of whether air flows over a mountain or around it) high enough to carry air over the crest.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Map where flare casings land

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open model that predicts where spent ejectable flare casings and seeding-rocket parachute debris come down, from release height, wind profiles and published hardware specifications, with drop-zone maps for standard seeding cases.

Why it is still open

The Air Line Pilots Association told the FAA that Rainmaker's July 2025 petition to carry flares on drones lacked trajectory modeling for ejectable casings. Rainmaker answered that its safety data is non-public. No public drift model for seeding debris was found.

dronexl.co

Built with what exists

Published hardware data (Ice Crystal Engineering's ICE-EJ flare in an aluminium casing; the 82 mm, 10.8 kg ZBZ-HJ-7 rocket with its parachute), NOAA's hourly 3 km HRRR wind analyses, archived on AWS since 2014, and Python.

  1. First step

    Ask Ice Crystal Engineering for the ICE-EJ casing's mass and size, and compute its fall path through one archived HRRR wind profile over Utah's Bear River basin.

  2. Done looks like

    Code and drop-zone maps published for at least three hardware types on 20 archived winter storm days each, with the spread of landing points stated in kilometres for each case.

Open 02 · the brief

Score every generator site

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public scorecard that rates each known ground generator site by how many hours, in past winters, its smoke could have reached supercooled cloud over the target mountains, using the criteria researchers already use: temperature, supercooled liquid water, and a Froude number (a measure of whether air flows over a mountain or around it) high enough to carry air over the crest.

Why it is still open

Aircraft tracking in Utah showed valley plumes often stay low, yet Utah's southern and central program still ran about 70 manually operated generators in 2022 to 2023. Mazzetti and colleagues (2021) mapped seedability on a 4 km grid without scoring actual sites, and the open recast-wxmod code (2026) models plume lofting one case at a time. NCAR's 2015 study for Colorado's Central Colorado Mountains program traced six-hour paths from 10 of its 27 generators for one storm, saw low generators' smoke funneled along valleys, called its modelling "proof of concept", and asked for many more simulations before generator locations were changed. No site-by-site scorecard was found.

journalofweathermodification.scholasticahq.comwater.utah.govckanprod.data-commons.k8s.ucar.eduradiometrics.com

Built with what exists

Generator coordinates printed in state program reports (Utah's annual reports list them), NOAA's hourly HRRR analyses on AWS, recast-wxmod or NCAR's WRF-WxMod for spot checks, and Python.

  1. First step

    Copy the generator coordinates from Utah's 2022 to 2023 southern and central program report and count, from that winter's HRRR analyses, the hours each site met the criteria; compare the total with the program's 3,594 logged generator-hours.

  2. Done looks like

    Scores for at least 150 named generator sites in at least three states over ten winters, published with code, with each site's score compared with Mazzetti's seedability value at the same point.