Industries / Health / Healthcare / Chiropractic
Imaging
Imaging is the use of X-rays, and by referral MRI and CT scans, to look for serious disease, to judge whether manipulation is safe, and in some techniques to measure the alignment of the spine.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1910 to 2021.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1910
X-rays enter chiropractic
B.J. Palmer, who in 1906 had taken over the Palmer School of Chiropractic in Davenport, Iowa, from his father D.D. Palmer, bought an X-ray machine in 1910 to show subluxations, the small misalignments of spinal bones that chiropractors then held to cause disease. Local newspapers were promoting the school's machine by May 1910, and the historians Kenneth Young, Barclay Bakkum and Lawrence Siordia call him the first chiropractor to use X-rays. Several historians link the purchase to a sudden exodus of staff and students; Joy Loban, the school's first spinographer, left and co-founded the rival Universal Chiropractic College, though the record of his reasons is conflicting.
Lessonby the authors' account, X-rays taken to find subluxations left a lasting split between chiropractors who image to find disease and those who image to guide adjustments.
Credit
B.J. Palmer, Palmer School of Chiropractic
2000
Medicare drops the X-ray rule
US law had defined the chiropractic care Medicare pays for as manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation "demonstrated by X-ray to exist". Section 4513 of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 struck those words for services from 1 January 2000, and Medicare's manual now accepts a physical examination instead, though Medicare still pays nothing for X-rays a chiropractor orders or takes. The federal workers' compensation law kept its 1974 wording, so a chiropractor treating an injured US federal employee must still show the subluxation by X-ray; three authors in the Journal of Chiropractic Humanities called this wasteful and a source of needless radiation in 2020.
Lessona payment rule can require imaging that clinical guidelines advise against, and removing it in one program does not remove it in another.
Credit
US Congress; Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
2008
Chiropractors write imaging rules
A. E. Bussières, J. A. Taylor and C. Peterson published evidence-based guidelines for when chiropractors and other primary care clinicians should image the adult spine, built on more than 385 citations and on the European Commission's referral guidelines. About 45 international experts in a Delphi panel, a method of repeated anonymous rounds of rating, reached more than 85% agreement on all 55 recommendations. When 160 Swiss chiropractors were then randomly given a radiology workshop on the guidelines or not, their answers on when to image did not differ 14 to 16 weeks later; only a subgroup given an online reminder did better, and adherence was about 50% at the start.
Lessona lecture alone did not change imaging decisions; a reminder at the moment of choice helped.
Credit
A. E. Bussières, J. A. Taylor and C. Peterson
2009
Claims show X-rays falling
C. Ammendolia and colleagues counted X-rays in chiropractic claims to Ontario's public health insurance plan (OHIP) and its workers' compensation board (WSIB) from 1994–95 to 2000–01. The share of OHIP claimants given lumbar spine X-rays fell from 4.54% to 3.25%, and full-spine X-rays from 3.87% to 3.04%; for WSIB claimants, lumbar X-rays fell from 6.49% to 3.30%. By the authors' account, chiropractors see one-third of the people in Ontario who seek care for low back pain.
Credit
C. Ammendolia, P. Côté, S. Hogg-Johnson and C. Bombardier, University Health Network, Toronto
2018
The routine X-ray dispute
A review by Hazel Jenkins and colleagues at Macquarie University concluded that spinal X-rays are supported only for injury, inflammatory spinal arthritis and worsening deformities such as adolescent scoliosis, and should not be taken routinely in chiropractic, because of radiation, overdiagnosis and the further tests and treatments that follow. The same year P. A. Oakley, J. M. Cuttler and D. E. Harrison argued in Dose-Response that X-rays are essential, that a plain film's dose is about 100 times below the threshold for harm, and that guidelines should encourage routine use. Harrison is listed with CBP Non-Profit, named for Chiropractic BioPhysics (CBP), a technique that uses X-rays to plan and measure posture correction.
Credit
H. J. Jenkins, A. S. Downie, C. S. Moore and S. D. French; P. A. Oakley, J. M. Cuttler and D. E. Harrison
2021
A regulator limits routine X-rays
British Columbia's chiropractic regulator commissioned a rapid review, in which Melissa Corso, Pierre Côté and colleagues at Ontario Tech University found no study showing that routine or repeat spinal X-rays, taken without red flags (warning signs of serious disease), improve patients' outcomes, and recommended against them. On 4 February 2021 the College of Chiropractors of British Columbia changed its conduct rules to allow such X-rays only where serious disease is suspected. A dozen or more chiropractors petitioned the province's Supreme Court in March 2021, and authors from the International Chiropractors Association called the review flawed because it rested on 9 papers, the newest from 2005. Its successor, the College of Complementary Health Professionals of BC, replaced the rule on 1 April 2026 with a standard that bars initial, routine or repeat X-rays without clinical indication and requires informed consent.
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govcanadianlawyermag.compmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govcchpbc.cacchpbc.ca
Credit
College of Chiropractors of British Columbia; Melissa Corso, Pierre Côté and colleagues
Watch for
X-rays put to a trial
In a pilot trial in Sydney, chiropractors randomly assigned 20 adults with a new episode of spinal pain, whose need for X-rays was uncertain, to spinal X-rays or none. 30% of the X-ray group went without imaging and 20% of the other group got it, and the authors judge that a full trial could be run if recruitment and crossover are fixed. They say no randomized trial had tested whether X-rays change outcomes in chiropractic care.
Achieved whena full-size randomized trial reports pain and disability with and without X-rays in chiropractic care.
Claimed by
H. J. Jenkins, M. Hancock, S. D. French and colleagues, July 2026
Open
01
Outside test of X-ray AI
A public test of software that marks side-view neck X-rays for chiropractic posture analysis. PostureRay's neural network and at least one open-source landmark model are run on X-rays from the open Cervical Spine X-ray Atlas (CSXA), and their C2–C7 Cobb angle, the curve of the neck, and C2–C7 sagittal vertical axis, the forward shift of the head, are compared with the dataset's expert marks and with two chiropractors marking the same films blind.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Count films in posture reports
A public table of how many X-rays each patient received in every published CBP case report and case series, with the views taken, the months between films and an estimated radiation dose per patient.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Outside test of X-ray AI
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test of software that marks side-view neck X-rays for chiropractic posture analysis. PostureRay's neural network and at least one open-source landmark model are run on X-rays from the open Cervical Spine X-ray Atlas (CSXA), and their C2–C7 Cobb angle, the curve of the neck, and C2–C7 sagittal vertical axis, the forward shift of the head, are compared with the dataset's expert marks and with two chiropractors marking the same films blind.
Why it is still open
The only published check of PostureRay's neural network, on 254 neck X-rays, was written by authors from PostureCo, which sells the software, and CBP Non-Profit, with one expert's marks as the reference; it reports root-mean-square errors of 0.37 to 2.89 against that expert. A 2023 study by the Institute for Spinal Health and Performance, a practice in Georgia, tested the program's manual line-drawing tool on drawn rectangles, not on X-rays. A Europe PMC search for "PostureRay" in November 2026 returned these two studies and about a dozen case reports from 2024 to 2026 that use such measurements to report posture change, and no outside test of the neural network on X-rays.
Built with what exists
CSXA, 4,963 neck X-rays with 23 marked points each, open on Science Data Bank, with its measurement code on GitHub; PostureRay, under a licence or by arrangement with PostureCo; an open keypoint model trained on part of CSXA; Python for Bland–Altman agreement statistics.
First step
Download CSXA, run its released code on 100 images, and check the computed C2–C7 Cobb angles against hand measurements in ImageJ.
Done looks like
At least 500 CSXA images held out from any training; mean error and 95% limits of agreement for each tool against the CSXA marks and against both human markers, for C2–C7 Cobb angle and sagittal vertical axis, reported separately for lordotic, straight, sigmoid and kyphotic necks; code and per-image results published.
Open 02 · the brief
Count films in posture reports
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of how many X-rays each patient received in every published CBP case report and case series, with the views taken, the months between films and an estimated radiation dose per patient.
Why it is still open
The dispute over repeat X-rays turns on dose and benefit. CBP's authors say a plain film's dose is about 100 times below the threshold for harm, while Corso's rapid review found no evidence that repeat films help patients. A 2022 scoping review by Readford, Hayes and Reed found no mechanism for reporting how often chiropractors use spinal X-rays. Europe PMC lists more than a dozen CBP case reports from 2024 to 2026 alone that follow patients with repeat X-rays; searches for counts of repeat radiographs and their dose in chiropractic, in November 2026, found critiques but no count.
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Built with what exists
the Europe PMC REST API to collect every case report that names Chiropractic BioPhysics; an AI model to pull out film counts and dates, such as the open-weight Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters"); PCXMC, the Monte Carlo dose program used in a 2025 full-spine phantom study, or a published table of typical doses per view; a person to check each extracted row against the paper.
First step
Pull the 2024–2026 CBP case reports from Europe PMC and count the X-ray views in ten of them by hand.
Done looks like
Every CBP case report and series in Europe PMC up to 2026 entered; a second person checks 20% of rows with at least 95% agreement on film counts; median and range of films and estimated dose per patient published, with every dose assumption stated.