BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Cathodic protection and corrosion control

Monitoring

Monitoring is the routine checking that protection is working: reading the voltage between the steel and the soil at test points, checking the rectifiers that supply protective current, and judging the readings against a criterion.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1933 to 2022.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1933

    A number for protection

    Protection is judged by the voltage between buried steel and the soil around it, read against a reference electrode, a probe of copper in copper sulfate solution pressed into the ground. Robert J. Kuhn proposed in 1933, in the proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute, that steel is protected once that reading reaches about −0.85 volts. T. P. Hoar in 1937 and R. B. Mears and R. H. Brown in 1938 offered theoretical explanations of the figure. In 2024 Ueli Angst of ETH Zurich, a Swiss university, said the criterion is still used in standards and is "an empirical criterion," a rule found by experience rather than derived from theory.

    protectioncathodique.netchemeurope.com

    Credit

    Robert J. Kuhn

  2. 1951

    Lab tests back the number

    At the US National Bureau of Standards, W. J. Schwerdtfeger and O. N. McDorman measured steel in 20 air-free soils ranging from pH 2.9 to 9.6, then held steel electrodes at their chosen protective voltage for 50 days in five corrosive soils. The protected electrodes lost negligible weight while unprotected ones in the same soils corroded severely, which they said agreed with the −0.85 volt practice. They attached a condition: the reading must be free of the IR drop, the extra voltage that the protective current itself creates in the soil between the probe and the steel. They also wrote that the basis for applying −0.85 volts to all soils "has never been stated."

    LessonA reading taken while the current flows can look protective when the steel is not, which is why later standards judge the voltage with the IR drop removed.

    nvlpubs.nist.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    W. J. Schwerdtfeger and O. N. McDorman, National Bureau of Standards

  3. 1971

    Federal rules require testing

    On 30 June 1971 the US Department of Transportation's Office of Pipeline Safety added corrosion control to the federal gas pipeline safety standards, requirements that its interim rules had not contained. Gas pipelines buried after 31 July 1971 needed a coating and a cathodic protection system working within one year of construction. Every protected pipeline had to be tested at least once each calendar year, at intervals of no more than 15 months, against criteria set out in an appendix, with enough test stations (posts wired to the pipe) to take the readings. Older bare or poorly coated lines had to be protected by 1 August 1976 wherever active corrosion was found.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    Office of Pipeline Safety, US Department of Transportation

  4. 2012

    A good reading nearby

    On 11 December 2012 a 20-inch Columbia Gas Transmission pipeline ruptured about 106 feet (32 m) from Interstate 77 at Sissonville, West Virginia. The fire destroyed three houses and the highway was closed for 19 hours; no one was killed. The US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found external corrosion where deteriorated coating and rocky backfill had left the pipe without effective protection, and the line had not been inspected or tested after 1988. Readings at the nearest test station, about 100 feet (30 m) from the rupture, had been satisfactory every year from 2003 to 2012, yet more than 30 square feet of the pipe was heavily corroded. Columbia's integrity manager told investigators that coating holes and weak protection "may not be detected if the area is electrically shielded from cathodic protection current."

    LessonA test station shows the protection where it stands, not along the pipe between stations.

    ntsb.gov

    Credit

    NTSB, report PAR-14/01

  5. 2021

    Rectifiers read from afar

    A rectifier turns mains power into the direct current that drives a protection system, and US rules require each one on a gas pipeline to be checked six times a year. In January 2021 the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) wrote into the rule that the check may be made by remote measurement, which its enforcement guidance had already allowed, provided each remotely read rectifier is also visited in person once a calendar year from 2022. Operators had used remote units for years where sites were hard to reach: a network of 39,000 km described at a corrosion conference in 2000 had more than 1,300 rectifier sites, over 40 of them reachable only by helicopter.

    govinfo.govdoi.org

    Credit

    PHMSA; Owen Sneath (2000 paper)

  6. 2022

    Criteria from 1971 kept

    In August 2022 PHMSA tightened monitoring rules for US gas transmission lines, in force from 24 May 2023. A low reading at a yearly test station now requires a close interval survey, readings about every 5 feet (1.5 m) in both directions, and repairs have deadlines. PHMSA also proposed to update the appendix of protection criteria, which it said had not changed since 1971. It withdrew that part after its Gas Pipeline Advisory Committee voted 10 to 0 to support the rest only without it, and after commenters warned of conflict with NACE SP0169, the industry standard that the US rules for liquid pipelines already adopt.

    LessonUS gas transmission lines are still judged by a 1971 appendix, while liquid lines follow the industry standard.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    PHMSA; Gas Pipeline Advisory Committee

Watch for

  1. Remote checks for liquid lines

    PHMSA proposed to let operators of hazardous liquid and carbon dioxide pipelines check rectifiers, diodes and critical interference bonds remotely, as gas operators may, provided each device is inspected in person at least once a year. The American Petroleum Institute and the Liquid Energy Pipeline Association had asked for the change in May 2025. PHMSA also asked whether its guidance that remote devices be "periodically calibrated or checked for accuracy" would be clearer than a yearly visit. Comments closed on 23 June 2026.

    Achieved whena final rule amending 49 CFR 195.573(c) is published.

    federalregister.gov

    Claimed by

    PHMSA, April 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Bench-test remote monitors

    A bench rig, at low voltage and connected to no pipeline, that feeds the same signals to several remote monitoring units at once: a direct current through a soil box holding a steel coupon and a copper sulfate reference electrode, an interrupter that switches the current off for instant-off readings, and a small injected AC voltage. A calibrated meter logs the same points. A month of side-by-side records gives each unit's error in millivolts for on and instant-off readings, how soon after switch-off it samples, and how many scheduled reports arrive.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Read the corrosion enforcement letters

    A public table of every US federal enforcement case since 2002 that cites the external corrosion monitoring rules (49 CFR 192.465 and 192.469 for gas, 195.573 for liquids), with each finding sorted by what went wrong: a yearly test missed or late, a low reading not acted on, rectifier or bond checks missed, test stations missing, or records missing. Each row links to its letter and carries the proposed and assessed penalty.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Bench-test remote monitors

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A bench rig, at low voltage and connected to no pipeline, that feeds the same signals to several remote monitoring units at once: a direct current through a soil box holding a steel coupon and a copper sulfate reference electrode, an interrupter that switches the current off for instant-off readings, and a small injected AC voltage. A calibrated meter logs the same points. A month of side-by-side records gives each unit's error in millivolts for on and instant-off readings, how soon after switch-off it samples, and how many scheduled reports arrive.

Why it is still open

US gas operators may check rectifiers remotely, and in April 2026 PHMSA asked whether remote devices should be "periodically calibrated or checked for accuracy." The accuracy figures published are the makers' own; no recent side-by-side test of current units was found.

federalregister.gov

Built with what exists

A current-limited bench DC supply of up to 30 V; a relay timed by an Arduino or Raspberry Pi as the interrupter; shunt resistors; a soil box with a carbon steel coupon and a copper sulfate electrode; a logging bench multimeter such as the Keysight 34465A as reference; three or four commercial test-station units, such as GPT Industries' Iso-Smart; and one open-hardware logger, such as the LoRa sensor node published by Janet Vorobyeva at UC San Diego (github.com/jvorob/cpm-firmware).

  1. First step

    Build the soil box, log on and instant-off potentials with the reference meter for one week to set the baseline, and ask two makers for loan units.

  2. Done looks like

    At least four units logged for 30 days against the reference meter, with mean and worst-case error in millivolts for on and instant-off readings and the share of scheduled reports delivered, published with the raw logs.

Open 02 · the brief

Read the corrosion enforcement letters

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of every US federal enforcement case since 2002 that cites the external corrosion monitoring rules (49 CFR 192.465 and 192.469 for gas, 195.573 for liquids), with each finding sorted by what went wrong: a yearly test missed or late, a low reading not acted on, rectifier or bond checks missed, test stations missing, or records missing. Each row links to its letter and carries the proposed and assessed penalty.

Why it is still open

PHMSA's raw enforcement file lists the regulation codes cited in each case and the penalties, but not what each finding was; that text sits in the case letters, one PDF at a time. A search found no published tally of what these monitoring findings consist of.

primis.phmsa.dot.govprimis.phmsa.dot.gov

Built with what exists

PHMSA's "Enforcement Cases Initiated from 2002" tab-delimited file and its case document search (primis.phmsa.dot.gov/enforcement-data), whose letters come with text versions; Python with pandas; an AI model that extracts fields from long documents, such as Claude or Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), working from a fixed list of finding types.

  1. First step

    Download the raw file, filter for cases citing 192.465, and read 20 letters by hand to fix the list of finding types.

  2. Done looks like

    Every case in the raw file that cites those sections classified and linked to its letter, with the agreement between the model and a person reported on a random 10% sample.