BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Cathodic protection and corrosion control

Coatings

Coatings are the layers of tar, tape, epoxy or plastic on buried and submerged steel that keep water off it, so that cathodic protection only has to protect the steel where the coating has holes.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1930s to 2010.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1930s

    Hot tar over the trench

    From 1930 to 1950, by the account of KTA, a US coatings inspection firm, nearly all buried pipe was coated with hot coal tar or asphalt worked into a tar-soaked felt and wrapped in kraft paper, or with petroleum wax reinforced with fiber mesh, mostly applied over the trench. PHMSA, the US pipeline safety regulator, says these early tape wraps and coal tars tended to disbond, or separate from the steel, and that operators found coatings alone could not give complete protection, so they added cathodic protection.

    LessonCoatings alone did not stop buried pipe from corroding.

    kta.comprimis.phmsa.dot.gov

    Credit

    pipeline builders and operators of the period; no single inventor is named in the sources

  2. 1960

    Epoxy powder fused on

    Fusion-bonded epoxy (FBE) is an epoxy powder sprayed onto hot pipe, where it melts, flows and cures into a hard layer. A 3M technical brief, citing Alan Kehr's 2003 NACE book on FBE, says the first FBE-coated line pipe went into service in 1960. Canada's National Energy Board wrote in 1996 that mill-applied FBE arrived there in the early 1970s and had become the most common coating, and PHMSA calls FBE the most widely used pipe coating today.

    puc.sd.govprimis.phmsa.dot.gov

    Credit

    not named in the sources opened; 3M, an FBE maker, gives the date

  3. 1995

    Polyethylene's European record

    J. G. Haimbl and J. Geiser reported that two-layer and three-layer polyethylene coatings had been used in Continental Europe for more than 30 years, while FBE prevailed in the US and UK. The three-layer system, as Mannesmann describes it, is an epoxy primer, an adhesive and a thick polyethylene jacket. Surveys of Ruhrgas pipelines found fewer and smaller coating defects on polyethylene-coated pipe than on bitumen-coated pipe, and most defects at field joints, the welds coated on site. The authors found disbonded polyethylene in a few cases but no corrosion or cracking under it, and noted that better coatings make protection from AC interference by nearby power lines harder and more costly.

    LessonWith a good factory coating, the weak point moves to the joint coated in the field.

    osti.govmannesmann.com

    Credit

    J. G. Haimbl and J. Geiser; Ruhrgas (pipeline surveys)

  4. 1996

    Tape coatings and cracking

    A public inquiry by Canada's National Energy Board found that stress corrosion cracking, cracks grown by stress in a corrosive setting, had caused 22 pipeline failures in Canada since 1977, 12 of them ruptures, mostly since 1985 on lines coated with polyethylene tape and laid between 1968 and 1973. Polyethylene tape carried 73% of the failures from near-neutral pH cracking. The tape tents over the raised seam weld and comes loose at its overlaps, and because it is a good insulator it shields the steel from the protective current; loose asphalt and coal tar soak up water and let the current through. No cracking had been reported on pipe coated with extruded polyethylene or FBE.

    LessonA coating that insulates well can block the protective current once it comes loose.

    publications.gc.ca

    Credit

    National Energy Board (inquiry MH-2-95)

  5. 2010

    Lab disbondment matched to field

    DNV Columbus, working for PHMSA, compared laboratory cathodic disbondment tests, in which current is driven into a deliberate hole to see how far the coating lifts, with coatings from pipe taken out of service and examined in the ditch, and set out a standard lab procedure. On FBE and coal tar enamel, areas of cathodic disbondment also had low adhesion. The strongly alkaline conditions thought to drive disbondment appeared only right next to the hole, with near-neutral pH a short distance away, and disbondment often spread beyond the starting hole.

    primis.phmsa.dot.gov

    Credit

    Sean Brossia, DNV Columbus (report for PHMSA)

Watch for

  1. Too much current lifts coatings

    In PHMSA-funded tests, a team from the University of Akron, Marquette University and Rutgers University held FBE, liquid epoxy and polyethylene tape panels with a 3.2 mm hole at −0.775, −1.5 and −2.923 V against a calomel reference, from normal protection to heavy overprotection. FBE barely disbonded over 30 days at the normal level, and both epoxies lifted more as the potential went more negative; the tape showed no clear trend in disbonded area, but corrosion products at the hole grew.

    Achieved whenthe final report gives a model of coating life against protection level and another lab repeats the trend.

    primis.phmsa.dot.gov

    Claimed by

    Qixin Zhou, Qindan Huang and Hao Wang, annual report of 30 September 2025; the project runs to 29 September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A shared shielding test cell

    An open design for a test cell that holds a coated steel panel with a loose flap of coating over a hole, leaving a gap of set width and depth between coating and steel, with small reference electrodes and pH probes at points along the gap while a low-voltage supply applies cathodic protection. Publish the drawings, the protocol and 30-day results for four coatings, FBE, polyethylene tape, three-layer polyethylene and a heat-shrink sleeve, and invite other labs to repeat it.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Field joints, tested by outsiders

    A blind outside comparison of commercial field-joint coatings, the coatings put on by hand over the welds between factory-coated pipes: about eight products, such as two-layer and three-layer heat-shrink sleeves, liquid epoxy, polyurethane, and viscoelastic and butyl tapes, each applied to blasted pipe offcuts by its maker's instructions and put through a 28-day cathodic disbondment test at room temperature and at 65 °C. Someone who does not know which product is which measures the disbonded radius on every sample.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A shared shielding test cell

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open design for a test cell that holds a coated steel panel with a loose flap of coating over a hole, leaving a gap of set width and depth between coating and steel, with small reference electrodes and pH probes at points along the gap while a low-voltage supply applies cathodic protection. Publish the drawings, the protocol and 30-day results for four coatings, FBE, polyethylene tape, three-layer polyethylene and a heat-shrink sleeve, and invite other labs to repeat it.

Why it is still open

A 2024 review by Abdelkader Meroufel, Andrew Gordon and Dominique Thierry of RISE, Sweden, says results on cathodic protection under disbonded coating "are difficult to compare due to the variation in the experimental set-up". The common tests measure disbondment, not shielding: ASTM's G8 compares how far coatings lift and warns that the same disbondment on two coatings "may not represent equivalent loss of corrosion protection". Saudi Aramco patented a test cell in 2022 (US 11,467,083) that measures how much protective current passes through a free film of coating, not under a loose flap, and DNV's 2010 procedure for PHMSA standardized the study of what causes disbondment, not of current under the flap.

link.springer.comstore.astm.orgimage-ppubs.uspto.govprimis.phmsa.dot.gov

Built with what exists

An acrylic or 3D-printed cell; coated steel panels and plastic shims to set the gap; silver/silver chloride micro reference electrodes and micro pH electrodes; a potentiostat or a bench supply with a series resistor; salt water and a simulated soil solution; a data logger.

  1. First step

    Build one cell from a coated test panel and a 0.5 mm shim and log the potential at three depths for a week.

  2. Done looks like

    Three labs run the same four coatings in the same cell and publish potential and pH at four depths into the gap after 30 days, with the spread between labs stated for each reading.

Open 02 · the brief

Field joints, tested by outsiders

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A blind outside comparison of commercial field-joint coatings, the coatings put on by hand over the welds between factory-coated pipes: about eight products, such as two-layer and three-layer heat-shrink sleeves, liquid epoxy, polyurethane, and viscoelastic and butyl tapes, each applied to blasted pipe offcuts by its maker's instructions and put through a 28-day cathodic disbondment test at room temperature and at 65 °C. Someone who does not know which product is which measures the disbonded radius on every sample.

Why it is still open

Field joints are where the defects gather. Haimbl and Geiser found most coating defects on Ruhrgas's polyethylene-coated lines at field joints, and the 2024 RISE review cites an industry survey (Tan and colleagues) in which 90% of corrosion damage occurred under coatings that shield the current or under heat-shrink sleeves. The nearest outside comparison found is Richard Norsworthy's 1999 rating of tape and sleeve coating types by their properties, not a test of named products. The PHMSA-funded Akron work compares FBE, liquid epoxy and tape, not field-joint products.

osti.govlink.springer.comosti.govprimis.phmsa.dot.gov

Built with what exists

Grit-blasted pipe offcuts; the products bought through normal suppliers; a bench DC supply or potentiostat and a reference electrode; 3% salt water; a thermostatic water bath; calipers and a camera; a published test method such as ASTM G8 as the protocol.

  1. First step

    Buy three sleeve products and run one 28-day room-temperature test on two samples of each.

  2. Done looks like

    Eight products with three samples each at two temperatures, the disbonded radius in millimeters for every sample, measured blind, with all photos and raw data online.