BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Heavy civil / Asphalt production

Quality testing

Quality testing designs a mix in the laboratory, setting how much binder it needs and checking that it will resist ruts and cracks, and then tests samples from the plant against that design.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1905 to 2020.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1905

    Voids counted in the mix

    Clifford Richardson, owner of the New York Testing Company, set out how to make asphalt mixes in "The Modern Asphalt Pavement" (1905). Mixes were then judged largely by eye, as in the pat-paper test, in which hot mix was tipped onto brown grocery paper and the binder's spread judged visually. Richardson also calculated voids in the mineral aggregate (VMA), the space between the stones that binder and air share. VMA became a design criterion in the Asphalt Institute's mix design manual, MS-2, only in 1962, after Norman McLeod argued for it in papers from 1956 to 1959.

    LessonA measure in print since 1905 took 57 years to become a rule.

    asphaltmagazine.comsaug.memberclicks.net

    Credit

    Clifford Richardson; Norman McLeod

  2. 1932

    Binder set by surface area

    Francis Hveem became a resident engineer for the California Division of Highways in 1927. By 1932 he had a method that set how much binder a mix needs from the surface area of its stone and sand, using factors published by the Canadian engineer L. N. Edwards in 1918, and he paired it with a stability test on his own device, the stabilometer.

    asphaltmagazine.com

    Credit

    Francis Hveem, California Division of Highways

  3. 1943

    A test for wartime airfields

    Bruce Marshall of the Mississippi highway department developed a mix design method in the 1930s and early 1940s. It compacted samples with a drop hammer instead of a hand rammer and calculated their air voids. In 1943 the US Army Corps of Engineers in Vicksburg, Mississippi, hired him, and during the Second World War the Corps used his portable method to design asphalt for airfields. State highway departments took it up after the war, and the 1974 edition of MS-2 made it the standard in practice.

    asphaltmagazine.comsaug.memberclicks.net

    Credit

    Bruce Marshall; US Army Corps of Engineers

  4. 1993

    Mixes designed by gyration

    SHRP, which ran from 1987 to 1993, planned a mix design system in three levels, two of them built on performance tests meant to predict rutting and cracking. Those tests could not be put into practice, and SHRP's performance-based mix specification was never used by state agencies. What came into use was Level 1, volumetric design: samples are compacted in a gyratory compactor, a press that kneads the sample by turning it under load, and the binder content is set from air voids, VMA and the share of voids filled with binder. It replaced the Marshall and Hveem methods as the main US method from the mid-1990s and is specified in AASHTO M 323.

    LessonThe part that was ready shipped, and performance tests waited 27 years, until AASHTO's balanced mix design practice of 2020.

    asphaltmagazine.comasphaltmagazine.com

    Credit

    SHRP; FHWA's technical working groups

  5. 1990s

    Binder burned, not dissolved

    To check how much binder a plant sample holds, laboratories used to dissolve it out with hazardous solvents. In the mid-1990s NCAT developed the ignition method, which burns the binder off a loose sample in an oven and weighs what is lost. Laboratories took it up quickly, and as AASHTO T 308 it is required or allowed by most US state transportation departments. Each mix and each oven needs its own correction factor. In 2019 NCAT reported that these factors vary widely even between ovens of the same brand, that some aggregates such as dolomite lose mass when heated, and that some agencies and contractors share factors between ovens against the standard.

    LessonA faster, cleaner test still has to be calibrated to each machine.

    eng.auburn.edu

    Credit

    NCAT, Auburn University

  6. 2017

    A one-minute cracking test

    Fujie Zhou, Soohyok Im, Lijun Sun and Tom Scullion, mostly of the Texas A&M Transportation Institute (TTI), published IDEAL-CT, a cracking test that squeezes a cylinder of mix 150 mm across and 62 mm high along its diameter at 50 mm a minute, at room temperature. It needs no cutting, gluing or notching, runs on ordinary strength-test equipment and finishes in under a minute; the authors report that its results matched cracking measured on FHWA's accelerated loading facility, two Texas highways and the MnROAD test road. ASTM published it as standard D8225 in 2019.

    LessonSuperpave's stiffer binders and volumetric checks were the answer to the rutting of the 1980s, but they carried no cracking test, and in 2024 Gerry Huber of Heritage Research Group wrote that cracking "has become THE ISSUE".

    api.openalex.orgstore.astm.orgsaug.memberclicks.net

    Credit

    Fujie Zhou and colleagues, TTI

  7. 2020

    Mixes judged by performance

    Balanced mix design (BMD) designs a mix with performance tests on suitably aged samples that address several kinds of damage, such as rutting and cracking, with allowance for traffic, climate and the mix's place in the pavement. An FHWA expert task group first defined it in 2015, and AASHTO published it as standard practice PP 105-20 in 2020. Oklahoma completed four phases over seven years, with 33 pilot and working projects, and now uses IDEAL-CT statewide alongside the Hamburg wheel-tracking test, which rolls a loaded wheel over a sample to measure rutting.

    asphaltpavement.orgetd.auburn.edu

    Credit

    FHWA's BMD task force; AASHTO; Oklahoma Department of Transportation

Watch for

  1. A robot runs the tests

    TTI built AMAZE (Asphalt Mixture Automated Testing System with Zero Intervention) for the Texas Department of Transportation, which cited trouble hiring laboratory staff and the risk of injury from hot asphalt, saws and test machines. A robot arm moves each specimen between units that measure air voids, bring it to temperature and run IDEAL-CT, a rutting test and an indirect tensile strength test. TTI reports that two runs of the robot gave almost the same air voids on seven specimens, while two experienced technicians disagreed more on two of them. Humboldt now sells the system as a new product and says it "removes human errors".

    Achieved whena state agency or a laboratory outside TTI and Humboldt publishes a side-by-side comparison with technicians on plant-produced samples, or an agency accepts its results for acceptance testing.

    static.tti.tamu.eduhumboldtmfg.com

    Claimed by

    TTI (project completed August 2023) and Humboldt (product page seen November 2026)

Open

  1. 01

    Cracking models tested across labs

    One open table of published IDEAL-CT results, each with the mix behind it (stone grading, binder grade and content, recycled content, air voids, aging), pooled from many laboratories, and a scoring rule that trains a model on some laboratories and tests it on the others.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Open air-void robot cell

    An open, documented robot cell that runs the bulk specific gravity test on room-temperature specimens (weighing a compacted sample dry, under water and surface-dry, to work out its air voids), with a public log comparing it with technicians.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Cracking models tested across labs

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

One open table of published IDEAL-CT results, each with the mix behind it (stone grading, binder grade and content, recycled content, air voids, aging), pooled from many laboratories, and a scoring rule that trains a model on some laboratories and tests it on the others.

Why it is still open

Published models are fitted and tested within one laboratory's data. Lan Ngoc Nguyen and colleagues (PLOS ONE, 2023) trained on 107 records from one laboratory in Hanoi and tested on a random split of the same records, and they say more data are needed. Small tools on GitHub, such as pysphalt for Brazilian data, follow the same pattern; this research found no pooled set from several laboratories.

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govgithub.com

Built with what exists

Python, pandas and scikit-learn; an AI document reader such as Claude to pull tables out of state agency reports and theses; ASTM D8225 to check each record's test conditions.

  1. First step

    List the state BMD reports that print CT Index values with mix details, starting with Oklahoma's, and transcribe one.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,500 IDEAL-CT records from at least 10 laboratories in at least 3 countries, each linked to its source, and published leave-one-laboratory-out scores for at least three published model types against a simple baseline.

Open 02 · the brief

Open air-void robot cell

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, documented robot cell that runs the bulk specific gravity test on room-temperature specimens (weighing a compacted sample dry, under water and surface-dry, to work out its air voids), with a public log comparing it with technicians.

Why it is still open

The one such cell found, TTI's AMAZE, is sold as a closed product, and its published comparison with technicians covers seven specimens.

static.tti.tamu.eduhumboldtmfg.com

Built with what exists

A collaborative robot arm able to lift a 150 mm compacted specimen; a laboratory balance with an under-balance hook and a room-temperature water bath; a damp-towel station for surface drying; a camera; robot learning software such as Hugging Face's open LeRobot library to teach the drying motion from recorded demonstrations, or NVIDIA's open GR00T 2 robot model, which by NVIDIA's own test succeeds 95% of the time after five demonstrations of a task (the Note "Five demonstrations per task").

  1. First step

    Film a technician running the test on 10 specimens and time each step.

  2. Done looks like

    100 specimens, each measured twice by the cell and twice by each of two technicians; the cell's two air-void readings within 0.2 percentage points of each other on at least 95 specimens, and its average within 0.3 points of the technicians' average; all data, drawings and code published.