BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Power generation / Wind turbines

Gearboxes and generators

The drivetrain in the nacelle, the housing at the top of the tower, turns the slow spin of the rotor into electricity, either through a gearbox that speeds it up for a small, fast generator or in a large, slow generator turned directly by the rotor.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1957 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1957

    The Danish concept

    In 1956 and 1957 Johannes Juul built a 200 kW turbine at Gedser, Denmark, for the utility SEAS. It had three blades facing into the wind, stall control (blades shaped to lose lift in strong winds, which caps the power without moving parts), and an asynchronous generator, a type that runs at almost fixed speed when wired straight to the grid. Juul also invented tip brakes that the blades' own spin released if the rotor ran too fast. The Danish Wind Industry Association's history says it ran 11 years without maintenance and was refurbished in 1975 because NASA wanted measurements from it. Paul Gipe dates its installation to 1956 and its regular service to 1959 through 1967, and writes that all commercial wind turbines trace their roots to Juul's design.

    LessonDanish turbine owners later required a fail-safe, redundant brake like Juul's tip brakes, which Gipe credits with doing more than any other rule to advance Danish wind technology.

    ele.aut.ac.irwind-works.org

    Credit

    Johannes Juul; SEAS

  2. 1993

    Turbines without a gearbox

    Enercon's E-40 put the rotor and a large ring generator on one axle instead of linking them through a gearbox, so the generator turns as slowly as the blades. Enercon dates the launch of this first gearless series, the E-40/500, to 1993 and still builds gearless turbines. The bearing maker SKF's magazine dated the E-40's introduction to 1992 and reported in May 1998 that some 1,100 were in operation.

    enercon.deevolution.skf.com

    Credit

    Aloys Wobben, Enercon

  3. 2007

    Why gearboxes failed early

    Many wind turbine gearboxes needed repair or replacement well before their design life, although they met the design standards and had passed third-party certification. In 2007 the US Department of Energy set up the Gearbox Reliability Collaborative at NREL, with GE, Siemens and Vestas, owners such as MidAmerican, Iberdrola and NextEra, and suppliers. Tests of a 750 kW drivetrain found that loads had been underestimated and that the bearings in the planetary stage did not share them well. By 2017 operators reported the mean time between gearbox failures had risen from 5 years to 8 to 12 years. The most common damage, axial cracks also called white etching cracks, can appear at 5% to 20% of a bearing's predicted life, and its causes were still debated in 2017.

    Lessonpassing the standard and certification did not prove a gearbox would last; its real loads had to be measured.

    energy.govosti.gov

    Credit

    NREL (Jonathan Keller, Yi Guo); US Department of Energy

  4. 2010

    A squeeze on magnets

    Larger turbines were turning to permanent-magnet generators, whose neodymium-iron-boron magnets can put several hundred kilograms of rare earth elements in one turbine, by the US Department of Energy's count. In its December 2010 Critical Materials Strategy the department reported that China produced at least 95% of the world's rare earths and in July 2010 had cut its export quota to 30,258 tonnes of rare earth oxides, 40% less than in 2009, after which prices jumped.

    Lessona generator design can tie a turbine maker to the output of one country's mines.

    energy.gov

    Credit

    US Department of Energy

  5. 2023

    Faults across a platform

    On 7 August 2023 Siemens Energy said that certain rotor blades and main bearings in Siemens Gamesa's 4.X and 5.X onshore turbines caused most of a rise in component failures. It booked €1.6 billion for future repairs, set up a task force, excluded certain suppliers from further deliveries, and said only a limited number of turbines carried the faulty parts.

    Lessona weak part from a supplier can spread across a whole turbine platform before failures show it.

    siemens-energy.com

    Credit

    Siemens Energy; Siemens Gamesa

Watch for

  1. Revised 5.X back on sale

    Siemens Energy says Siemens Gamesa made progress in quality improvement and relaunched the revised 5.X onshore platform, and that its orders rose again after a sales stop the year before.

    Achieved whenturbine owners or an independent party publish failure rates for the revised blades and main bearings after at least a year in service.

    siemens-energy.com

    Claimed by

    Siemens Energy, November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Outline white etching cracks automatically

    An open set of microscope images of failed wind gearbox bearings, cut, polished and etched, with the white etching cracks and the white areas around them outlined by hand, and a vision model that outlines them and measures their length and depth, so studies of many failed bearings can be compared.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Magnets, turbine by turbine

    A public table of the magnet mass that makers themselves declare for each permanent-magnet turbine model, taken from their life cycle assessments and product declarations, and a test of how far the per-megawatt averages used in national estimates miss each model's declared figure.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Outline white etching cracks automatically

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open set of microscope images of failed wind gearbox bearings, cut, polished and etched, with the white etching cracks and the white areas around them outlined by hand, and a vision model that outlines them and measures their length and depth, so studies of many failed bearings can be compared.

Why it is still open

NREL's 2017 study calls these cracks the most common gearbox failure, says their root causes are debated, and notes they are found by polishing and etching cross sections and examining them under a microscope, which is skilled hand work. A search of Crossref in November 2026 for white etching cracks with machine learning, neural networks or segmentation found metallurgy papers that describe the cracks, such as a 2025 study of them in M50 bearing steel, but no learned outlining and no open labeled image set. The closest prior work is a rule-based image analysis of white etching areas in SAE 52100 bearing steel by Pinard and colleagues at RWTH Aachen University (Microscopy and Microanalysis, 2015), whose images are not public. A GitHub search for "white etching" and "bearing micrograph" found no repositories.

osti.govdoi.orgacademic.oup.com

Built with what exists

Micrographs from open-access papers under CC BY licenses as a starting set, then images donated by bearing makers and test labs; a labeling tool such as CVAT; segmentation models such as Meta's Segment Anything 2 or a U-Net trained on one GPU; two metallographers.

  1. First step

    Collect 50 white etching crack micrographs from CC BY papers and have one metallographer outline them to test the labeling rules.

  2. Done looks like

    500 micrographs from at least 30 failed bearings, outlined by two metallographers with their agreement reported, published openly, with the model's overlap with each expert set beside the experts' overlap with each other.

Open 02 · the brief

Magnets, turbine by turbine

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of the magnet mass that makers themselves declare for each permanent-magnet turbine model, taken from their life cycle assessments and product declarations, and a test of how far the per-megawatt averages used in national estimates miss each model's declared figure.

Why it is still open

The British Geological Survey's Met4Tech map already gives every UK wind farm's turbine model, generator type, estimated magnet and rare earth content and likely decommissioning date, but it estimates the magnets from an average for each generator type, per megawatt, taken from the EU's Joint Research Centre, not from each model's own figure. Its authors, from the British Geological Survey and the University of Exeter, put the UK's wind turbines at 2,775 tonnes of rare earth elements in 2021 on that basis and noted that generators of different designs hold different amounts. A search in November 2026 found stock estimates for the EU, the UK and China built on such averages, but no table of declared magnet mass by model. Makers do publish the figure for some models: Vestas's life cycle assessment of the V236-15 MW lists magnets as their own line in the bill of materials.

map.bgs.ac.uknora.nerc.ac.ukvestas.com

Built with what exists

Vestas's life cycle assessments and other makers' environmental product declarations; the British Geological Survey's UK layer, which already joins farms to models; a language-model agent that reads each document and cites the page each figure came from (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); one person checking every figure.

  1. First step

    Extract the magnet line from every life cycle assessment on Vestas's website and check each against the model's generator type.

  2. Done looks like

    Declared magnet mass for at least 30 permanent-magnet turbine models, each with a cited page, and the UK fleet total recomputed from those figures and set beside the survey's estimate, with the difference explained model by model.