BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Finance and banking / Wealth management

Rules for advisers

This is the set of laws, duties and supervision that decide who may advise others on their money, what advisers owe their clients, how they may be paid, and which records and advertising they must keep honest.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1963 to 2024.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1963

    Advisers owe a fiduciary duty

    In 1940 the US Congress passed the Investment Advisers Act, which made it unlawful for an adviser to deceive a client. On 9 December 1963, in SEC v. Capital Gains Research Bureau, the US Supreme Court read the Act as a recognition of "the delicate fiduciary nature of an investment advisory relationship"; a fiduciary is someone bound by law to put the client's interest first. The adviser in the case bought a stock, recommended it to clients for the long term, then sold his own shares at a profit after the price rose, a practice called scalping; the Court held that he had to disclose it, and that the SEC did not have to prove he meant to harm anyone or that anyone lost money.

    LessonA general anti-fraud law can carry a full duty of loyalty, which a regulator can enforce without a separate statute.

    tile.loc.gov

    Credit

    Justice Goldberg, writing for the Court; the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which brought the case

  2. 2012

    Commission pay is banned

    Within about a year several countries stopped product makers from paying advisers for selling their products. Most rules of the UK's Retail Distribution Review, launched in 2006, took effect at the end of 2012: they removed the commission advisers received from providers, so clients pay an agreed adviser charge, and raised minimum qualifications. Australia's Future of Financial Advice reforms became mandatory on 1 July 2013, banning "conflicted remuneration", meaning commissions and volume-based payments, and creating a duty to act in the client's best interests; the Netherlands brought in a ban in 2013 that also covered execution-only sales, where a firm takes orders but gives no advice; and India's SEBI (Investment Advisers) Regulations took effect on 21 April 2013, and SEBI says an individual registered adviser "cannot provide any distribution services". A board member of the Dutch regulator AFM, Theodor Kockelkoren, said in 2014 that execution-only fees had fallen from about 0.75% to no more than 0.25%, saving €300 million a year, and in the UK the regulator's consultants found in 2014 "little evidence that the availability of advice has reduced significantly", while the FCA later counted 35,000 advisers in 2012 and 36,400 in 2019.

    LessonOnce commissions no longer hide the cost of advice, clients see its price, and the question becomes who can afford it.

    fca.org.ukfca.org.ukasic.gov.auafm.nlsebi.gov.insebi.gov.in

    Credit

    the UK FSA and FCA; the Australian Parliament and ASIC; the Dutch AFM; SEBI

  3. 2018

    A fiduciary rule falls

    In April 2016 the US Department of Labor (DOL) issued a rule that would have made many brokers and insurance sellers who advise on retirement accounts into fiduciaries. On 15 March 2018 the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals vacated, or struck down, the rule by 2 votes to 1, in suits led by the US Chamber of Commerce; Judge Edith Jones wrote for the majority and Chief Judge Carl Stewart dissented. The DOL tried again with a Retirement Security Rule on 25 April 2024, which two Texas federal courts stayed, suspending it before it took effect, on 25 and 26 July 2024; after courts vacated it, the DOL restored its 1975 "five-part test" for who counts as a fiduciary, effective 20 April 2026.

    LessonIn US retirement advice a fiduciary duty set by agency rule has twice been undone in court, and a test from 1975 still decides who is a fiduciary.

    ca5.uscourts.govgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit; federal district courts in Texas; the DOL

  4. 2019

    Best interest for brokers

    On 5 June 2019 the SEC adopted Regulation Best Interest, under which a broker-dealer, a firm usually paid per transaction, must act in a retail customer's best interest when recommending a security or an investment strategy and may not put its own interests ahead of the customer's. The SEC said the standard "cannot be satisfied through disclosure alone". The same package created Form CRS, a short "relationship summary" for clients, and set out the SEC's reading of advisers' fiduciary duty; firms had until 30 June 2020 to comply.

    LessonTelling a client about a conflict of interest no longer meets the standard by itself.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    the SEC

  5. 2019

    Fees for no service

    On 1 February 2019 Commissioner Kenneth Hayne gave the final report of Australia's Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry to the Governor-General. It found that "fees for no service", ongoing advice fees charged when no advice was given, had been "endemic in the financial advice industry", and recommended that clients renew ongoing fee arrangements in writing every year and that older commissions still allowed under the 2013 ban be repealed. By 31 December 2022 six institutions (AMP, ANZ, CBA, Macquarie, NAB and Westpac) had paid or offered A$4.7 billion in compensation for fees for no service and non-compliant advice, by ASIC's count, and ASIC's register showed adviser numbers falling from 28,522 on 29 December 2018 to 16,049 on 1 December 2022, and a Treasury review found the education and training requirements "a leading contributor" to the fall. In February 2025 the UK FCA reported on 22 large firms over seven years: the reviews clients paid for were delivered in about 83% of cases, clients declined or did not respond in 15%, and in fewer than 2% the firm had not tried.

    LessonEvery ongoing fee needs a routine check that the service behind it was delivered.

    treasury.gov.autreasury.gov.auasic.gov.autreasury.gov.aufca.org.uk

    Credit

    Kenneth Hayne; ASIC; the Australian Treasury; the UK FCA

  6. 2021

    Work texts must be kept

    US securities law requires firms to keep their business communications. On 17 December 2021 J.P. Morgan Securities admitted that from at least January 2018 to November 2020 its staff, senior supervisors among them, discussed business by text message, WhatsApp and personal email without keeping the records, and paid a $125 million SEC penalty. On 27 September 2022 the SEC charged 16 more firms over such "off-channel" messages, sent through apps a firm does not capture, for more than $1.1 billion combined, and by the end of its 2024 fiscal year it said the effort had charged more than 100 firms for more than $2 billion in penalties. On 14 April 2025 the Commission, under new leadership, refused requests from 16 firms that settled between September 2023 and September 2024 to soften their terms, calling it "settlor's remorse"; Commissioner Hester Peirce dissented.

    LessonA firm must archive business talk on every app its staff use, including apps on personal phones.

    sec.govsec.govsec.govsec.gov

    Credit

    the SEC Division of Enforcement

  7. 2024

    False claims about AI

    On 18 March 2024 the SEC settled charges against two investment advisers, Delphia (USA) and Global Predictions, which had said they used artificial intelligence in ways they did not, a practice the SEC called "AI washing". Both were also charged under the SEC's marketing rule, which bans adviser advertising that contains an untrue statement of material fact; among other things, Global Predictions had falsely called itself the "first regulated AI financial advisor". Delphia paid $225,000 and Global Predictions $175,000.

    LessonExisting advertising rules already cover claims about new technology.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    the SEC

Watch for

  1. EU retail rules stall

    On 24 May 2023 the European Commission proposed a Retail Investment Strategy that included a ban on inducements, payments from product makers to sellers, for execution-only sales. Parliament and Council negotiators agreed a deal on 18 December 2025 that dropped that ban but added, in the Commission's words, "stricter safeguards and transparency where inducements are allowed", a value-for-money test for products, and responsibility for marketing, including marketing spread by paid influencers. On 12 November 2026 the European Parliament rejected the main Omnibus Directive by 300 votes to 286, with 23 abstentions, while approving the separate PRIIPs regulation on product information, so a new round of amendments and a second plenary vote are needed.

    Achieved whenThe Omnibus Directive is adopted by Parliament and Council and published in the Official Journal of the EU.

    ireland.representation.ec.europa.eueuropa.euarthurcox.comabbl.lu

    Claimed by

    the European Commission and the Parliament and Council negotiators, December 2025

  2. UK ongoing reviews loosen

    On 25 March 2026 the FCA proposed letting firms move "from a fixed annual suitability review to periodic reviews based on clients' needs"; a suitability review checks that an investment still fits the client. Advice would still be paid by agreed adviser charges, not provider commission, and the FCA opened a discussion on the future of trail commission, the older commission some providers still pay. The consultation closed on 22 May 2026.

    Achieved whenThe FCA publishes final rules in a policy statement and they take effect.

    fca.org.uk

    Claimed by

    the UK FCA, March 2026

  3. US pay-to-play repeal

    On 3 September 2026 the SEC proposed repealing its 2010 "pay-to-play" rule, which bars an adviser from being paid by a government client, such as a public pension fund, for two years after the adviser makes a political contribution to certain officials or candidates. The SEC said the rule has had "significant unintended consequences" and that its rules on fraud and fiduciary duty would still apply.

    Achieved whenThe SEC votes a final repeal and it takes effect.

    sec.gov

    Claimed by

    the SEC, under Chairman Paul S. Atkins, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Test set for adviser ads

    A public, labeled set of adviser advertising statements, plus a script that scores any review tool against it. The faulty examples are statements quoted in SEC settled orders under the marketing rule, each tagged with the clause the order cites, such as hypothetical performance shown without the required policies, unsupported claims, or testimonials missing disclosures. The set also holds matching clean statements and faulty statements written for the test, and firm names are removed from every item.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    One lookup across registers

    An open tool that takes a firm or adviser name and checks it in several regulators' public registers at once: the SEC's investment adviser data, the UK FCA Financial Services Register and ASIC's Financial Advisers Dataset, plus IOSCO's I-SCAN list of warnings about unauthorized firms. It returns each match with a link back to the register and the date that register was last updated, and reports only what the registers say, with no judgment of any firm.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Test set for adviser ads

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, labeled set of adviser advertising statements, plus a script that scores any review tool against it. The faulty examples are statements quoted in SEC settled orders under the marketing rule, each tagged with the clause the order cites, such as hypothetical performance shown without the required policies, unsupported claims, or testimonials missing disclosures. The set also holds matching clean statements and faulty statements written for the test, and firm names are removed from every item.

Why it is still open

The SEC keeps finding these faults: it charged nine advisers on 11 September 2023, for $850,000 in combined penalties, and nine more on 9 September 2024, for $1,240,000, in what it calls an "ongoing sweep". The one regulation-based benchmark found, FinGuard-Bench (May 2026), which its authors call "to our knowledge the first benchmark for financial regulatory compliance detection", is built from Chinese regulators' documents and tests chatbot conversations, not advertisements. This research found no public labeled set of US or UK adviser advertising.

sec.govsec.govarxiv.org

Built with what exists

The SEC's public enforcement orders; Browser Use 1.0 to collect them (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Claude Fable 5.2 to pull out each quoted statement and the rule paragraph cited (see the Note "Three working devices"); Gemini Decision 1 to run fixed-answer labels over many items in one pass (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); a reviewer that names the rule behind each flag, after the Cursor agent SDK example (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"). Models that read long legal orders and quote from them accurately make the collection practical.

  1. First step

    Download the 2023 and 2024 sweep releases, their orders and the orders of 18 March 2024, and copy each quoted advertising statement and its cited rule into a spreadsheet.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 300 items, about half from orders and half written for the test, each with a source link and a rule clause; two people who label a 50-item sample independently and agree at a Cohen's kappa, a standard measure of agreement beyond chance, of 0.8 or higher; and a published table that scores at least two tools on catch rate and false-alarm rate for each clause, reported as rates only.

Open 02 · the brief

One lookup across registers

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open tool that takes a firm or adviser name and checks it in several regulators' public registers at once: the SEC's investment adviser data, the UK FCA Financial Services Register and ASIC's Financial Advisers Dataset, plus IOSCO's I-SCAN list of warnings about unauthorized firms. It returns each match with a link back to the register and the date that register was last updated, and reports only what the registers say, with no judgment of any firm.

Why it is still open

IOSCO's I-SCAN puts regulators' warnings in one place but has no matching lookup for authorized firms, and IOSCO tells investors not to assume a firm is authorized because it has no warning, and to "always check with your domestic regulator". Each register is still searched separately, and this research found only single-country tools.

iosco.org

Built with what exists

The SEC's downloadable Investment Adviser Information Reports; the FCA Register API, which the FCA says is "currently free of charge"; ASIC's Financial Advisers Dataset on data.gov.au; Browser Use 1.0 for registers with no download (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a low-cost model for the repeated name matching, such as Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), or a small model fine-tuned on one GPU (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune").

  1. First step

    Download the latest SEC adviser report and the ASIC dataset, request an FCA API key, and build the 1,200-name test list.

  2. Done looks like

    A test list of 1,000 real entries sampled from at least three registers plus 200 invented names, on which the tool returns the correct entry for at least 95% of the real ones and wrongly matches no more than 2% of the invented ones, with match rates reported per register alongside each register's refresh date.